Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that if you’ve gone no contact you can’t go to funeral

496 replies

Playingdevilsadvocate · 27/01/2022 06:35

My SIL has gone NC with her DF. It’s been a couple of years now. He’s just died. I don’t know what she plans to do regards funeral yet but I feel that if she didn’t want anything to do with him in these last years of his life, she can’t go wailing at his funeral with his grieving family. They all know how she’s behaved towards him and they don’t want a bar of her. She should have thought of this moment before she cut him off! Should his widow (not her dm) have to encounter this person who caused her dh so much pain, at his funeral where she will be grieving her dh? Thoughts?

OP posts:
Etinoxaurus · 27/01/2022 10:48

@Playingdevilsadvocate
It’s none of your business.

clpsmum · 27/01/2022 10:48

I think it's none of your business

ClumsyClaret · 27/01/2022 10:46

I am no-contact with my siblings - I will not go to my mother's funeral - my Dad's dead (and that funeral was bad enough). I think your SIL should feel able to attend her father's funeral regardless of what's happened.

sweetbellyhigh · 27/01/2022 10:46

@Playingdevilsadvocate

I’ve not managed to read all comments just yet but the first page is interesting. It’s not my business to say anything of course! I just wanted to see how the opinions fell. Personally if I was NC with a parent I’d avoid it because I wouldn’t feel that I should go when I’d been awful to them in life and cut them out. Just my opinion which of course my SIL will never have to hear.
You say that but you don't know how you would actually feel because you haven't experienced it.

Sometimes it's better to listen than judge. Try to be supportive of your sil who is obviously going through a difficult time.

And don't be so sure that she has "been awful" to her parents, you cannot know what has gone on between them. Just be glad you haven't suffered estrangement or bereavement of your parents.

Wreath21 · 27/01/2022 10:46

Firstly this is not your business so stay out of it as much as possible.

Secondly (I work in the funeral industry) while a funeral is a public event which people can attend if they wish (sort of - over the past couple of years, obviously, there have been more restrictions on attendance, a friend's widower had the horrible task of having to tell several other friends that they couldn't come because there were too many people wanting to attend; more than the crematorium was allowed to admit) - mourners can ask that a particular person be denied entry, and it's certainly the case that we can refuse to tell specified people when and where a funeral is taking place if the NOK have asked is to do so.

MrsTimRiggins · 27/01/2022 10:45

I’ve come back to this thread as I’ve been mulling this over for the morning. I’m
NC with my ‘D’F. Have been since I was 14, and I’m now 28. He’s only 58 so I don’t expect he’ll die soon altho his blood pressure must be sky high from the simmering rage he carries around with him all day every day.
Would I go to his funeral? Probably not, I’m not sentimental about funerals and I feel I’ve probably reconciled the feelings I have towards him, but I sure as hell would not accept anyone telling me I had no place being there because we were NC. To a lot of people, I expect I’m the bad guy, he’s ever so charming when you meet him and he talks a very good talk about being estranged by his cruel ex wife and heartless children. All lies of course, had he not been quite so handy with his fists, and sometimes his feet (nothing like kicking a child in the face when they annoy you!) I expect we’d be on better terms.
My point is really that you never know the full story. Try not to judge.

Sicario · 27/01/2022 10:42

And I agree with previous posters who say that no-one goes NC with their family for no reason. There's always a reason.

Bananarama21 · 27/01/2022 10:42

None your business, this is her father regardless she allowed to say goodbye.

SamphiretheStickerist · 27/01/2022 10:42

No matter how or why she went NC she is still part of his grieving family.

I have no idea how my DFs other family will see DSis and I at his funeral, but we will make up our own minds as to wther we attend or not. They can deal with their emotions just as we have had to for all of our lives. That is what adults do!

Nanny0gg · 27/01/2022 10:41

@Playingdevilsadvocate

I’ve not managed to read all comments just yet but the first page is interesting. It’s not my business to say anything of course! I just wanted to see how the opinions fell. Personally if I was NC with a parent I’d avoid it because I wouldn’t feel that I should go when I’d been awful to them in life and cut them out. Just my opinion which of course my SIL will never have to hear.
NC is usually to protect yourself from a toxic individual.

Why are you assuming the parent didn't deserve it?

Sicario · 27/01/2022 10:41

I am NC with my family of origin. I never want to see any of them again. I won't be attending any funerals. Couldn't be doing with the inevitable drama.

ThanksIGotItInMorrisons · 27/01/2022 10:40

Why are you assuming your sil has been ‘awful to them and cut them out’ in life? You don’t know what awful things her father did that caused her to have to take the serious decision of nc. You clearly know nothing but are taking sides- I would suggest that perhaps she has a very good reason and at the end of the day, her dad has died. Perhaps best not to overthink it and form (possibly) incorrect or negative opinions that will form the relationship you have with your sil. Leave well alone!

PollyFlint · 27/01/2022 10:38

Her father, her choice.

rogueone · 27/01/2022 10:38

My auntie had been NC with her dad for around 25yrs. She did go to his funeral as she wanted to have closure. It also allowed a few of us to catch up who hadnt seen each other for a long time and it ended up being a good day for all. We laughed and she did share stories about her dad too.

Your SIL may be NC but she can go to the funeral and its not your place to judge

ChargingBuck · 27/01/2022 10:36

@FudgeOff, @TrickyD - you'll probably find Victoria Coren Mitchell's article interesting ...
www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2008/dec/21/celebrity-victoria-coren

Pazuzu · 27/01/2022 10:31

I'm NC with DM. Will I go to her funeral? On balance, no. She made her choices in life which caused the NC so why am I going to go and pretend to care about someone who hasn't cared about me, DW or even my DC.

I'm not going to show up to pretend and go through the motions.

A580Hojas · 27/01/2022 10:28

In the broadest terms I agree with you. If you take the extreme step of going no contact with a parent then don't go to their funeral. It is hypocritical and makes things awkward for the genuine mourners.

pointythings · 27/01/2022 10:25

This is a blanket statement you cannot make. Each NC situation is different. My DDs went NC with their father because he was an emotionally abusive alcoholic. When he died, 8 months after being removed from the family home by police, it was incredibly tough. Should they not have attended his funeral? How much additional damage would that have done?

Each situation has to be assessed on its individual merits.

ClawedButler · 27/01/2022 10:23

I think for people who have had a bad relationship with a relative, their death can actually be a huge blow. You'd think they'd be happy the bastard's dead or something, but often the death of a relative you don't like (or even actively hate) brings up all sorts of difficult memories. There's also the fact that while you are NC in life, their death means there is definitely no possible way that the situation can ever be resolved. The hope of one day maybe it could be improved has gone. That can be just as devastating as the loss of a much-loved relative, just in a different way.

NickiMinajerie · 27/01/2022 10:20

YANBU

GiveYourHeadAWobble · 27/01/2022 10:18

I’m LC with a cousin and aunt after they severely bullied me and have turned other members of the family against me. I had some unexpected good fortune which triggered it all. I won’t go to either of their funerals, and if I die first I don’t want them at mine. I’ve lost all respect for them and it will never come back.

AngelinaFibres · 27/01/2022 10:18

@IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads

Anyone can go to a funeral, they often provide closure on bad feeling and difficult circumstances and “let bygones be bygones”. They are as much for the living as the dead.
Exactly. If she attends greet her politely and move on. If she doesn't that's fine. You will be busy with stuff and will need to speak to lots of different people so you will probably barely notice that she is even there.
ShagMeRiggins · 27/01/2022 10:16

@itispersonal

I disagree with a lot of the posters.

Why does the ds deserve to get closure? If you can't be there for someone in life, you don't get to go to the funeral, it's hypocrisy.

Has it occurred to you that the father might not have been there for his daughter?

I have great distaste for the idea that only the dutiful and engaged have a right to be at a funeral. A person’s life takes many along for the ride. We have no idea what others’ experiences of an individual meant, could have meant, or means to either party. It’s crass to pronounce what is right and wrong in these circumstances.

“Be curious, not judgmental”
Walt Whitman (probably misattributed)
via Ted Lasso

ChargingBuck · 27/01/2022 10:10

@User1isnotavailable

If you cannot be bothered to stay in touch with the person in real life then why would you want to go to a funeral. To show others you actually do care? No idea really but why would you. A last finger up to the NC person and their loved ones that bothered with them? It seems quite petty to go when the most important thing is actions in real life.

Similar to some posting on social media about how wonderful someone is but barely bothering in real life. Odd.

Gordon Bennett.

NC is nothing like posting on SM.
It has nothing to do with not being bothered. Quite the reverse, usually. People don't go NC out of laziness, @User1isnotavailable.

And the feelings of a bereaved NC relative are going to be anything but petty. Their choice of whether to attend a funeral is theirs to make, not yours to express gleeful contempt for.

Binthescales · 27/01/2022 10:08

Going no contact is never a jump up out of bed, this is what I’m going to do today decision.

It is a final resort surrounded by years worth of pain and trauma, regardless of the instigator. The only individuals who will really understand are the directly affected ones, in this instance SIL and her father.

The situation with no contact often appears very black and white to outsiders - he was abusive, she was spoilt, he acted like a dick when xyz. It’s rarely so cut and dry. As the adage goes - there’s three sides to all stories - this side, that side and the truth.

SIL has felt so pained that it’s a necessity to cut contact with half of her DNA. That’s a very traumatic decision to make with lifelong impacts. Her father died without her saying goodbye. Whilst, yes, that was the intent whilst being no contact it’s still a terrible burden she will have to live with and you can guarantee not the outcome she ever wanted or envisioned for her life.

She may want to go to the funeral to solidify the fact he is dead, she may want to go for closure and to say a silent fuck you, she may want to go to apologise that they never had an opportunity to reconcile, she may want to grieve for the man he used to be. You don’t know. What you do know is that it is none of your business or concern whether she decides to attend.

Swipe left for the next trending thread