Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

LGBTQ talk in schools

545 replies

JaggedStone · 26/01/2022 22:50

Named changed for this as could be outing.
We are very open with our children and explain life to them in ways they can understand and to ensure they are respectful of everyone and are always open and honest with us.
A LOT of parents have kicked up a fuss about the fact that teachers have spoken to the children today about LGBTQ but it is government mandated as compulsory so essentially the parents can not opt out of it unless they are planning to home school.
Some of the views seem quite hypocritical and some are saying they shouldn’t have these kind of talks yet.
AIBU to think that they are being unreasonable?

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 27/01/2022 18:37

it could well be the organisations you're thinking of also don't think it's an issue.

Stonewall have been told it is an issue. By ex-members. They have been ignored.

SarahAndQuack · 27/01/2022 18:35

@Ereshkigalangcleg

Let's know how we can tell if pressure on lesbians is an issue - the fact is that no LGBT organisation will come out and say it's ok to be exclusively same sex attracted without qualifying it. "Of course anyone has the right to say no to anyone for whatever reason". But they won't come out and say that it's ok to be a female person attracted only to other female people.

Even TRAs have tentatively tried to say that some people need a penis or vagina or whatever and they get piled on by the younger activists who have never questioned the homophobia.

But the thing here is, I know plenty of people who would just laugh and wonder why on earth you'd care? I mean serious, thoughtful people. Who would simply be bemused and say 'but surely if you don't enjoy sex with someone with a penis you'll just, erm, not have sex with them eh?' In much the same way that you might hear someone say 'oh, I can't bloody stand oral' and someone else says 'no, I never come from missionary'.

My DP, who's not on MN but whom I chat to about this stuff, was genuinely a bit bemused why anyone would care if a transwoman calls herself a lesbian - she really didn't understand why it would be an issue. And yet, she wouldn't want sex with someone with a penis.

It's not automatically an issue for a lot of people, and it could well be the organisations you're thinking of also don't think it's an issue.

Helleofabore · 27/01/2022 18:35

The question I ask Eresh is where are the support groups who are telling those males to stop and that it is totally unacceptable to abuse lesbians not accepting of them as sex partners. Plenty of opportunities, yet I have never seen stonewall make a statement. (if I have missed the statement and someone has it, please do post it)

Ereshkigalangcleg · 27/01/2022 18:35

I damn well know that one of those lesbians was just going along with it as we have discussed it. She absolutely would not admit it to the others.

And that is where we have a problem, isn't it.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 27/01/2022 18:32

There's a sense among many young people that being essentially bisexual is the only morally justifiable position.

Helleofabore · 27/01/2022 18:31

That is what I mean by echo chamber. You're setting out to design a survey so that it confirms what you believe to be true.

No, I was very clear that the questions asked needed to be able to evaluated as to whether they are answering a 'canned' answer or something they actually believe. Meaning, the questions would have to be carefully framed and repeated in certain ways.

At least, in my experience designing marketing research quant studies, that is what I would do.

We ... elll ... but you're coming at this from the presumption that they are being socialised in a certain way, aren't you?

So, you are saying that these 7 girls all believe fully that lesbians should be accepting of penises? I damn well know that one of those lesbians was just going along with it as we have discussed it. She absolutely would not admit it to the others.

Lolamento · 27/01/2022 18:31

People want their choices to be respected but only when it suits them. Why the bashing on religious people which btw I am not?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 27/01/2022 18:30

Let's know how we can tell if pressure on lesbians is an issue - the fact is that no LGBT organisation will come out and say it's ok to be exclusively same sex attracted without qualifying it. "Of course anyone has the right to say no to anyone for whatever reason". But they won't come out and say that it's ok to be a female person attracted only to other female people.

Even TRAs have tentatively tried to say that some people need a penis or vagina or whatever and they get piled on by the younger activists who have never questioned the homophobia.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 27/01/2022 18:26

It's important to bear that in mind at all times before you make sweeping statements based on your own experience. For everyone.

Helleofabore · 27/01/2022 18:26

the wider population don't use the same sets of phrases/the same structure of argument

But they do if they have seen even an article about it, watched a news interview, or read a book. As people get to know more, they take on the terms. I have even had a male friend who started discussing with me, using the same terms from reading Douglas Murray's book.

SarahAndQuack · 27/01/2022 18:25

@Ereshkigalangcleg

I really don't think they are 'all over Twitter'. I've never seen a cotton ceiling post come up in the sidebar of things that are being discussed a lot. And I spend masses of time on twitter.

We all have our filter bubble based on what the algorithms think we want to read about. You, me, everyone. It depends on who you follow.

I spend a lot of time on other social media sites too and because I am aware of this issue I see it more. As you said, we would need a huge impartial survey, and you're generally going to think your impression is more accurate and so do others think that about theirs.

For me, they are all over Twitter.

I know we all have our filter bubble - that's where we came into this discussion!
SarahAndQuack · 27/01/2022 18:25

@Helleofabore

And I think it is very important Sarah that those very young lesbians are included in any survey. But how do you reach them, and how do you cut through the socialisation that they are getting from their friends.

I know at least one of those lesbians has slept with their transgirlfriend at 14 years old while drunk.

We ... elll ... but you're coming at this from the presumption that they are being socialised in a certain way, aren't you? And that you need to 'cut through' that to get to the truth.

So you would end up writing bias into your survey.

That is what I mean by echo chamber. You're setting out to design a survey so that it confirms what you believe to be true.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 27/01/2022 18:24

I really don't think they are 'all over Twitter'. I've never seen a cotton ceiling post come up in the sidebar of things that are being discussed a lot. And I spend masses of time on twitter.

We all have our filter bubble based on what the algorithms think we want to read about. You, me, everyone. It depends on who you follow.

I spend a lot of time on other social media sites too and because I am aware of this issue I see it more. As you said, we would need a huge impartial survey, and you're generally going to think your impression is more accurate and so do others think that about theirs.

For me, they are all over Twitter.

Helleofabore · 27/01/2022 18:22

And I think it is very important Sarah that those very young lesbians are included in any survey. But how do you reach them, and how do you cut through the socialisation that they are getting from their friends.

I know at least one of those lesbians has slept with their transgirlfriend at 14 years old while drunk.

SarahAndQuack · 27/01/2022 18:20

@Helleofabore

And the only way we'd know how representative it is, would be to survey a load of lesbians.

I think this has been advocated for. I agree. However, who would do the survey? It would have to be done via interview I feel to cut through to get to the true. Then there is the issue with how to word it so it was clear yet not deemed hateful.

I am sure you can see the issue with it.

I know someone who applied for funding to do it, and didn't get it. She did a smaller survey off her own back, which didn't come back suggesting it was particularly a thing, but then, obviously, it's really hard to tell much from small surveys (and you'll have issues of bias that the people who'll respond will be the author's social network, who may have quite uniform views on the subject).

I agree, it'd be difficult in lots of ways.

Helleofabore · 27/01/2022 18:18

Sarah said something like ‘you are not doing the awareness work you think youre doing’

And The other poster said ‘and you are (doing the awareness work)?’

yes, I mistook Sarah's you as being a question aimed at me, not the general 'you' of posters who would be arguing similar things that I have been arguing.

Helleofabore · 27/01/2022 18:16

And the only way we'd know how representative it is, would be to survey a load of lesbians.

I think this has been advocated for. I agree. However, who would do the survey? It would have to be done via interview I feel to cut through to get to the true. Then there is the issue with how to word it so it was clear yet not deemed hateful.

I am sure you can see the issue with it.

GaiusHelenMohiam · 27/01/2022 18:15

There are a generation of kids who wholeheartedly believe you have to be pansexual or you’re transphobic.

I’ve had many many heated discussions with my teenagers about this.

This isn’t a niche issue. My daughter has screamed at me that some lesbians have penises and I’m a bigot for saying otherwise. DS came afoul of DH when he told him he’d be transphobic for not wanting to sleep with a TW based on the fact they were trans.

It’s is a movement that is actually aiming to erase peoples sexuality. Any LGB people buying into this shit are complicit in rolling back everything that was fought for. If we can’t name sex we can’t name sexuality.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 27/01/2022 18:13

@EeeICouldRipATissue

think you totally misunderstood "and you are?" in the post you quoted, btw So what did and you are mean then if they weren't actually asking who they were? Confused
Sarah said something like ‘you are not doing the awareness work you think youre doing’

And The other poster said ‘and you are (doing the awareness work)?’

SarahAndQuack · 27/01/2022 18:13

@Ereshkigalangcleg

am aware there is what I called a 'lunatic fringe' earlier, of trans activists who have said some pretty eye-watering things about the 'cotton ceiling'.

They're all over Twitter, I think if you spend a lot of time on there and other social media sites it would feel like a pretty hostile experience, and that's what my lesbian friends tell me (although they are GC feminists so I don't claim that they are a representative sample). It's all part of the wider misogyny which is pretty intense and all encompassing on social media. And that I do feel I can comment on, and I know a lot of women downplay and minimise misogyny and sexism in general.

I really don't think they are 'all over Twitter'. I've never seen a cotton ceiling post come up in the sidebar of things that are being discussed a lot. And I spend masses of time on twitter.

It's not that I don't believe you go on there and see them - I know some people who really make it their business to retweet this stuff as a form of awareness-raising. But, is it actually representative?

I don't find it so.

And the only way we'd know how representative it is, would be to survey a load of lesbians.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 27/01/2022 18:11

Of course often it's positive stuff too. There is a really distinctive MN way of responding when someone is talking about a man who doesn't pull his weight at home - you know, we all post to the OP telling her how much money a live-in nanny/cook/cleaner would cost, we point out how he's exploiting her labour, we debunk the 'men don't see dirt' myth.

YY I can recognise that! No is a complete sentence, that kind of thing.

Helleofabore · 27/01/2022 18:10

I am aware there is what I called a 'lunatic fringe' earlier, of trans activists who have said some pretty eye-watering things about the 'cotton ceiling'. But, I also know that it's not a hugely mainstream experience amongst lesbians I know, to have been made to feel transphobic. Who's right?

And my overhearing the group of seven young lesbians saying just that (because I am a mum and fade into the background) should be telling you that these girls are getting this perception from somewhere.

And it seems to be a regular thing on tiktok and YouTube videos which this group watch and read.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 27/01/2022 18:09

am aware there is what I called a 'lunatic fringe' earlier, of trans activists who have said some pretty eye-watering things about the 'cotton ceiling'.

They're all over Twitter, I think if you spend a lot of time on there and other social media sites it would feel like a pretty hostile experience, and that's what my lesbian friends tell me (although they are GC feminists so I don't claim that they are a representative sample). It's all part of the wider misogyny which is pretty intense and all encompassing on social media. And that I do feel I can comment on, and I know a lot of women downplay and minimise misogyny and sexism in general.

SarahAndQuack · 27/01/2022 18:08

@Helleofabore

But if that were the issue, surely there would also be passionate defences of young lesbians on threads about people's daughters coming out? And on the whole, there are not.

I wouldn't dream of posting on the LGBT board. That seems to me to be a board that should be left for that community. And if they are posting on the FWR board about what their daughter's experience, those posts get plenty of support.

There would be posters seeing threads like those I linked, and rushing on to be supportive, because they would be worried about their own daughters being discriminated against.

Again, how many are regulars on AIBU.

And it's not that I'm saying there are no supportive posts on 'general' lesbian threads, but I think the concentration of posts on trans issues is pretty telling.

Where? Only a board that was hived off from the main feminism board because so many posters claimed it was hateful and they simply did not want to see those posts? Of course they will be a concentration on trans issues there.

I know that I am not the only one who would not post on the LGBT board. If I saw a thread that I felt I have some knowledge or experience to offer about adult lesbians I would post there too.

Oh, I'm not talking about the LGBT board - it's invariably totally dead! I don't think anyone much posts there. It's a shame.

Clearly, since this thread is on AIBU and so are most of the threads I'm talking about (or on Chat), these posters are regulars there.

I don't really go on FWR much these days so no, I really am talking about threads like this one, which become enormous 'trans issues' threads, versus threads like those I linked, which are mostly not about the T, and therefore seem not to elicit the same concern for lesbians.

SarahAndQuack · 27/01/2022 18:06

@Ereshkigalangcleg

I just know the writer is a MNer because of the way she talks about trans issues. I've not been wrong yet. So I think there is an element of something like an echo chamber?

In what sense do you perceive that a random poster is a mumsnetter? As to me the tone on FWR on trans issues is very similar in other parts of the internet that are 30s/40s/50s female oriented such as GC Facebook groups, Twitter etc. Do you know what demographic the posters are from? How do you know you guessed correctly, did they confirm they post on MN/read MN? I'm not saying you don't btw, I'm fairly good at this kind of thing myself, just interested.

YY, I've got in touch and asked! Or dropped a hint and they picked it up.

It is interesting.

Of course often it's positive stuff too. There is a really distinctive MN way of responding when someone is talking about a man who doesn't pull his weight at home - you know, we all post to the OP telling her how much money a live-in nanny/cook/cleaner would cost, we point out how he's exploiting her labour, we debunk the 'men don't see dirt' myth.

I have to be a bit careful on other forums that I use, because if I go in full-on MN, I usually have to backtrack because that combination of responses may not be totally familiar to posters.

That's just an example.