Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

LGBTQ talk in schools

545 replies

JaggedStone · 26/01/2022 22:50

Named changed for this as could be outing.
We are very open with our children and explain life to them in ways they can understand and to ensure they are respectful of everyone and are always open and honest with us.
A LOT of parents have kicked up a fuss about the fact that teachers have spoken to the children today about LGBTQ but it is government mandated as compulsory so essentially the parents can not opt out of it unless they are planning to home school.
Some of the views seem quite hypocritical and some are saying they shouldn’t have these kind of talks yet.
AIBU to think that they are being unreasonable?

OP posts:
bishophaha · 27/01/2022 22:24

@Pinkrose1111

definitely should not be teaching this in primary school. They're there to learn how to read/write do numeracy, basic science etc. Not to learn who loves who and relationships. I'd have an issue with even heterosexual relationships being taught at that age. Let them be kids. Why do 5-8 year olds need to know about ANY type of relationships???
Primary is up to 11. Do you think they've not come across any people in a relationship before? Shouldn't say that their parents love each other, for example? What an odd attitude.

It's usually recommended that for kids to happily be kids, they have some idea of what love is.

SarahAndQuack · 27/01/2022 22:24

@EeeICouldRipATissue

Males and females have quite significantly different natural gaits. We are a sexually dimorphic species and have developed a very strong ability to detect the sex of other humans Maybe I was just walking like a man that day as well then whatever that means Grin
Seems legit. My DP must walk like a man too. Grin
bishophaha · 27/01/2022 22:22

I know lots of trans people pass well enough.
I think what someone looks like is irrelevant. It shouldn't be any basis for how 'trans' anyone is. Gender is an internal feeling, isn't it? It doesn't need to be expressed in any set way.

Be as masculine or feminine as you like! Being male or female has very little to do with that.

Pinkrose1111 · 27/01/2022 22:21

definitely should not be teaching this in primary school. They're there to learn how to read/write do numeracy, basic science etc. Not to learn who loves who and relationships. I'd have an issue with even heterosexual relationships being taught at that age. Let them be kids. Why do 5-8 year olds need to know about ANY type of relationships???

nolongersurprised · 27/01/2022 22:19

*the US, not marryGrin

I don’t want to marry an American lesbian

nolongersurprised · 27/01/2022 22:18

I was reading a Reddit thread recently (yes, I know) where there was a discussion about adult lesbians in marry US, where hormones are easier to come by, microdosing on testosterone. Not because they were trans, but more “non binary trans masc” and wanting to feel more like their authentic selves.

Women who take testosterone look like men to me, although their voices are distinctive. Apparently that Donald Duck voice happens when testosterone thickens the cartilage of the voice box but there’s not the concomitant lengthening of the structures that normally happens then growth hormone and testosterone work together, as in male puberty.

DH reckons he can tell though.

EeeICouldRipATissue · 27/01/2022 22:14

Males and females have quite significantly different natural gaits. We are a sexually dimorphic species and have developed a very strong ability to detect the sex of other humans
Maybe I was just walking like a man that day as well then whatever that means Grin

bishophaha · 27/01/2022 22:07

@SarahAndQuack

I will say -and then I will shut up because I should get DD to bed - the issue I have found young lesbians, and indeed not so young lesbians, bothered about is the tendency to presume if you're a bit butch you're probably trans and in denial, or you must want to be trans. I suspect it's the 2022 version of accusing lesbians of wanting to be men.
hang on, but when others on MN have said this exact thing, they're pretending? Loads of people have brought this up.
Wanderingowl · 27/01/2022 22:07

@EeeICouldRipATissue

The we can always tell crap always makes me laugh. I've been told I look like a man before when out. Which is absolutely baffling as there's nothing manly about me Grin Can only presume its because I never wear make up and I was in DH's hoody. Anyway point is people go on what you're wearing, or your make up, or whether your features are suitably feminine enough Hmm It boils down to what a woman '' should '' look like.
Not really. Studies have shown that humans can tell the sex of a person based solely on points of light showing our joints during walking. Males and females have quite significantly different natural gaits. We are a sexually dimorphic species and have developed a very strong ability to detect the sex of other humans. And yes, women tend to be better than men at it, because we have to be for our safety. There is no one single tell. There are multiple tells, through sight, sound and even smell. But it's not just simply sight, for example, we might not be able to see it when someone holds still or is in a photo. But once they start moving, there are so many ways that we can tell. Even if you don't consciously know the person is trans, you will be aware of an incongruity, of something about that person being 'off.' Your subconscious will pick up un the differences.

In fact, humans are so sexually dimorphic that even some monomorphic animals can tell the difference between men and women. Transpeople, don't 'pass.'

bishophaha · 27/01/2022 22:05

@EeeICouldRipATissue

The we can always tell crap always makes me laugh. I've been told I look like a man before when out. Which is absolutely baffling as there's nothing manly about me Grin Can only presume its because I never wear make up and I was in DH's hoody. Anyway point is people go on what you're wearing, or your make up, or whether your features are suitably feminine enough Hmm It boils down to what a woman '' should '' look like.
What do you think a man is, then? You've argued before that it's a feeling. Now you are saying it's what someone looks like.

What is it? What is a man?

bishophaha · 27/01/2022 22:02

@Helleofabore

Sarah said something like ‘you are not doing the awareness work you think youre doing’

And The other poster said ‘and you are (doing the awareness work)?’

yes, I mistook Sarah's you as being a question aimed at me, not the general 'you' of posters who would be arguing similar things that I have been arguing.

See @EeeICouldRipATissue your question has been answered.

I see I was correct in saying that you wouldn't even have the basic level of respect to respond, to even engage about what you mean when you talk about the people affected.

Helleofabore · 27/01/2022 21:49

@Ereshkigalangcleg

Yes I acknowledge there are a tiny minority of both sexes who can convincingly pass as the opposite sex, but other people's anecdata doesn't trump my own.
Grin
Helleofabore · 27/01/2022 21:47

Or, we can stop being so bloody wound up about it and remember actually it doesn’t really matter in the scheme of things and our kids will be just fine.

actually, no.

As I said up thread, in a group of 7 friends, 5 are trans. These are 14/15 yr old females. And each and every one of those 5 have significantly poor mental health. And this has not improved over the past year.

It DOES matter in the scheme of things. And some kids will be just fine. Others will need a great deal of support, which they are not getting enough of. Because in some cases, the medical professionals are not treating the mental health issues but are 'affirming only'.

And the schools need to ensure that they are providing balanced resources and toolkits.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 27/01/2022 21:45

Yes I acknowledge there are a tiny minority of both sexes who can convincingly pass as the opposite sex, but other people's anecdata doesn't trump my own.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 27/01/2022 21:43

How do you know you're not just missing the ones who do look like women?

Because I've seen thousands of these people in photos/TV/IRL and none of them do 🤷‍♀️ they mostly have a certain uncanny valley look which makes them stand out, so it's vanishingly unlikely IMO but obviously not something I can actually prove without some sort of controlled experiment.

DP doesn't have my skillz. I don't think men notice it so much.

SarahAndQuack · 27/01/2022 21:42

@Helleofabore

I know 'MIL' and 'DD' get used in a few other contexts

I have seen these commonly used on other forums. MN didn't invent them and they are not unique to MN.

They're very typical of MN, though, which is my point - that in combination with 'AIBU' and 'pearl-clutching' and the focus on GCSE grades would certainly make me think 'hmm ...'.

@EeeICouldRipATissue - YY, I well believe that.

Helleofabore · 27/01/2022 21:40

I know 'MIL' and 'DD' get used in a few other contexts

I have seen these commonly used on other forums. MN didn't invent them and they are not unique to MN.

EeeICouldRipATissue · 27/01/2022 21:40

The we can always tell crap always makes me laugh.
I've been told I look like a man before when out.
Which is absolutely baffling as there's nothing manly about me Grin
Can only presume its because I never wear make up and I was in DH's hoody.
Anyway point is people go on what you're wearing, or your make up, or whether your features are suitably feminine enough Hmm
It boils down to what a woman '' should '' look like.

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 27/01/2022 21:39

kids will be just fine.
Thanks to Keira Bell

SarahAndQuack · 27/01/2022 21:37

@Ereshkigalangcleg

I think maybe GC feminists do Grin
Interestingly, I don't know that GC feminists are any better at this than anyone else. I remember at Radfem 2012 there was a minor controversy amongst a group of women who believed they'd spotted a transwoman. She was a butch lesbian. I've also got a friend who's a transwoman, who's more than once had GC feminists try to start a discussion with her about transwomen, without realising she is one.
BoredZelda · 27/01/2022 21:37

Free reign into trans ideology doesn't tend to end well.

Oh of course, kids can’t do their own thing, and we aren’t allowed to teach them anything at school, and parents aren’t allowed to either, unless it’s the right thing apparently.

Or, we can stop being so bloody wound up about it and remember actually it doesn’t really matter in the scheme of things and our kids will be just fine.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 27/01/2022 21:34

I think maybe GC feminists do Grin

SarahAndQuack · 27/01/2022 21:34

@Ereshkigalangcleg

If it's so easy to pass as the opposite sex, why don't any MTF trans people on Twitter look remotely like women apart from clothes, makeup and hair?
How do you know you're not just missing the ones who do look like women? Grin
SarahAndQuack · 27/01/2022 21:33

@Ereshkigalangcleg

I disagree. There are a very small number of people who can successfully pass as the opposite sex. Maybe in a staged, filtered photo. Maybe in a head shot in a face mask.
Maybe we're talking cross purposes - I was talking about whether people can easily tell sex casually, without particularly thinking about it, rather than whether people can if they scrutinise. I agree with you that if people are thinking really hard about someone's sex they can probably tell most of the time. But we don't do that in daily life.
Ereshkigalangcleg · 27/01/2022 21:33

If it's so easy to pass as the opposite sex, why don't any MTF trans people on Twitter look remotely like women apart from clothes, makeup and hair?

Swipe left for the next trending thread