Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy clothes for a baby even though I’m not pregnant

565 replies

somegirlontheinter · 26/01/2022 16:28

I’m 29 and very broody. We can’t have a baby yet as we need to save money to raise them, feed them and send them to school. I have £5k in savings. We’d also really like to move up the property ladder. My SO and I need to complete postgrad exams in order to advance in our profession (£2-3k each). We do not share our disposable income and never will do.

I am so looking forward to having a baby one day. Sometimes I see baby clothes that are just so cute, I feel like I have to buy them or I’ll never see them again. I’ve spent probably £2-3k on baby clothes in the 3 years, I’d say around half on sale. My SO is upset because he feels that I’m throwing money away. He’s managed to save quite a bit already which will cover a few years of education. I feel that we are technically saving money by front loading the cost of this necessity. I think it’s such a non issue and it’s quite smart tbh. We have a shared budget of £50k for offspring and I can definitely save this by the time I’m 35 (it will take me 30 months to save £25k). Surely it only matters that I eventually save the money, not that I save it at the same rate as him.

We’ve been together since we were 18 and we’ve always agreed about money and spending. But as we age, he’s becoming very anxious and extra cautious about the cost of having a family and he can be quite stubborn e.g. a child will survive with free education as I did, they don’t definitely need savings accounts from birth etc. He’s taking it a little too seriously because many people don’t save so much before starting a family.

We’ve bickered about this quite a bit and it really winds me up. I feel like the arguments are getting worse about such a minor issue. Is he being unreasonable?

OP posts:
DePfeffoff · 26/01/2022 18:23

@somegirlontheinter

Just to clarify, I don’t even have that many items. But one item, like a dungaree set, can be £30 these days! I can always sell them if I’m infertile, I thought.
No baby needs a #30 dungaree set. It'll only get puked and weed on within a few minutes of being put on. Honestly, you need to wait till you have a baby, you'll have a much more realistic idea of what they need then.
veevee04 · 26/01/2022 18:21

Baby clothes are a waste of money my DD used to fidget in anything but a vest and sleep suit which cost pennies to buy if I have a second I won't be wasting clothes they grow out of in 3 months.

CaMePlaitPas · 26/01/2022 18:21

You could have put that 3k in an account to support them at school or something.

3k for baby clothes when they barely stay the same size for 4 weeks is absolutely insane.

Jumpalicious · 26/01/2022 18:21

@SummerHouse

DS is 12. I doubt that I have spent 3k on cloths in his lifetime.
This… op 💐
PinkSyCo · 26/01/2022 18:20

You are crazy to have spent so much money on baby clothes when you’re not even pregnant!!! I can’t believe you think you are being smart, when that money could have gone into your savings account and possibly earned interest. Half of those clothes you’ve bought will probably never get worn anyway. Have you considered that babies are different ages in different seasons and that usually lots of clothes are bought by friends and family as gifts for baby so that you have clothes coming out of your ears. Plus you’ve taken the fun of buying clothes for the baby when you actually are expecting one, though I’m guessing that the fact that you already have thousands of pounds worth is not going to stop you buying more. Confused

WonderfulYou · 26/01/2022 18:20

I’ve spent probably £2-3k on baby clothes in the 3 years

I actually think you need some therapy OP.

The maternal instinct is a natural instinct but sometimes it can become too much and almost becomes an addiction.
Just like when people are obsessed with their weight, cleaning, having things in a certain place etc - they are conditions which often need help.

I don’t ever see baby clothes as I don’t have a baby so you must be looking for these to find the special pieces.

I’m really surprised your partner has stayed with you as you’re essentially choosing your obsession over him.

I absolutely love the idea of knitting!!

WeWashEverythingExceptLaundry · 26/01/2022 18:17

There's a lot going on here.

I can't help feeling that your spending is, at least in part, some kind of rebellion against your partner's strictures and decrees re what needs to be saved up before you can think about having a child.

Whose idea was the completely separate finances? His, I take it?

DueyCheatemAndHow · 26/01/2022 18:15

God I was about to say YANBU - I bought a Winnie the Pooh book before I was pregnant.

But 2-3k??? How? This is crazy. Your baby may never fit into them

This is madness

christmaslights4 · 26/01/2022 18:14

i think it's a good idea of yours to buy some in advance so you don't have to buy them when you do actually have a baby, but i think 2-3k is a bit much just on clothes

Tullig · 26/01/2022 18:13

Are you sure you actually want to have a child? Because if you've agreed not to have one until you've both amassed a specific amount in savings, you're actively pushing that date back significantly by your spending. On the hypothetical baby who won't come into existence until you stop blowing cash on baby clothes.

In the nicest possible way, I think you should sell the clothes you've amassed, and invest the proceeds in therapy. You sound as if you have a very fixed inner narrative about your life that is no longer working for you, and that would benefit from being interrogated.

godmum56 · 26/01/2022 18:10

its not smart. Its not normal. From my professional experience, such spending is a red flag for a stress related mental health issue.... I seriously think you should look at getting help.

www.verywellmind.com/shopping-addiction-4157288

Lemonsandlemonade · 26/01/2022 18:08

If this is real YABU for lots of reasons, after 5 years of trying and a round of IVF I’m luck I got my miracle I know of many people who try for many more years etc.

Don’t take for granted that TTC and having a baby will be easy. Also will you still like the clothes in a few years of it took you that long to conceive? Fashions change. Also how do you buy things when you don’t know the sex of this hypothetical baby.

bubblesbubbles11 · 26/01/2022 18:07

I have not read the whole thread.
But I think what you are doing is crazy.

I know some new mums love to dress up their baby. But I for one (and I know many many others) found that once my newborns had arrived they pretty much lived in baby grows for ease of nappy change / laundry etc.

OP your posts read like a person who literally spends all of their life savings and then takes out a loan to spend more on a wedding to someone they don't know too well.

Clothes (and the "fairytale wedding") are often mistaking the wood for the trees.

I think your time would be better spent doing something like making friends with someone with a newborn and ask to watch them look after that newborn or maybe volunteering at a local hospital on the maternity ward or similar (if that is possible) just so you get a clear idea how much time you would really have to put your baby (once you get one, if you get one) in all the different outfits you have bought.

DaveGahansRealWife · 26/01/2022 18:06

Many would consider that bad luck to do ahead of time.

GrannyMack63 · 26/01/2022 18:04

So, setting aside the money you've spent how can you possibly know what will fit and when. You might find yourself with clothes that are out of sync with size and season. Plus unless they are all unisex then potentially 50% of them won't suit.

IncompleteSenten · 26/01/2022 18:02

Are you sure you want a child?

Spending thousand on a child you don't yet have when one of the reasons you aren't trying yet is that you need thousands seem arseways up.

You'd be £3000 nearer your goal if you hadn't wasted it on baby stuff that will NEVER be unavailable.

It seems like you are sabotaging it.

RussianSpy101 · 26/01/2022 18:02

You’re wrong about getting a good amount back for branded items that have tags on. People don’t want to pay more than a few £ for any 2nd hand stuff.

If you are saving £25k in 2.5 years and you can’t afford to have longer than a few months off work after having a child, you do not “have so much” and need to stop spending like you do.
I’m sorry you grew up poor and now feel better off, but you’re blowing your money on ridiculous things when you should be saving it for maternity leave so you don’t have to rush back to work if you do ever have children.

Lifeismeh · 26/01/2022 18:00

You. Are being. Unreasonable.

ittakes2 · 26/01/2022 17:59

If this is real you are mad. You have no idea if you will fall pregnant, and if you do what sex it will be and when you will have him/her. Babies need different clothes for different seasons too ie jumpers for a winter new born baby and light clothes for a summer new born baby.

Darbs76 · 26/01/2022 17:58

I didn’t even spend anywhere near 2-3k when I had babies. You’re being very unreasonable and he’s right

Worryworry887 · 26/01/2022 17:55

Also, are these all newborn clothes or are you buying up the sizes as well? They grow out of newborn so quickly and when they hit around 3 they start to refuse certain clothes (IME) eg my four year old will only wear certain dresses, so they probably won’t get used…but I don’t think that’s the issue here!

Sceptre86 · 26/01/2022 17:55

Yabu and a bit daft. You might not even have kids together or what if you struggle to conceive? What if you haven't bought for the right season? Even when you are pregnant there isn't much point in buying clothes too far ahead as baby might be in a size for longer than you would expect or less time so the season would be all wrong. you sound like you have some obsessive behaviour going on here or anxieties, I'd speak to your GP.

NeverChange · 26/01/2022 17:54

I do think what you are doing in a little crazy but each to their own in some regards.

There are a number of reasons this is not a good idea:-

  1. You don't have a baby yet
  2. You don't know the sex of the baby and buying neutral colours is more limiting
  3. You don't know when the baby will be born - a winter outfit for a 0-3 month old is not good if baby born in Spring
  4. You don't know the size of the baby - could be so big that starts of 6-9 months clothing
  5. Fashion dates - not a big issue but by the time the child is born, everything you have bought years in advance will look like second hand - not a problem but just highlighting it
  6. You will get a lot of hand me downs and gifts so probably don't need a lot
  7. The money could be better spend now or even for the child in the future
  8. You never know what the future holds

If you cannot stop immediately, I think you should consider a combination of the following:-

  1. Counselling
  2. A self imposed spending limit, e.g. £5 a month
  3. If you see something you like, take a picture rather than a purchase
  4. Put the equivalent cost of the outfit into a savings account for any future children

You obsessive behaviour may also be very off putting to your partner. I would be very concerned and irritated by it if I were him.

I'm sorry, I understand being broody is tough, but this is not healthy and you have to find a better way to deal with it.

MajorCarolDanvers · 26/01/2022 17:52

You are off your head spending thousands on a non existent baby.

Worryworry887 · 26/01/2022 17:51

This has got to be a joke..I have two children and doubt I’ve even spend £1k on clothes for them!

Swipe left for the next trending thread