Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy clothes for a baby even though I’m not pregnant

565 replies

somegirlontheinter · 26/01/2022 16:28

I’m 29 and very broody. We can’t have a baby yet as we need to save money to raise them, feed them and send them to school. I have £5k in savings. We’d also really like to move up the property ladder. My SO and I need to complete postgrad exams in order to advance in our profession (£2-3k each). We do not share our disposable income and never will do.

I am so looking forward to having a baby one day. Sometimes I see baby clothes that are just so cute, I feel like I have to buy them or I’ll never see them again. I’ve spent probably £2-3k on baby clothes in the 3 years, I’d say around half on sale. My SO is upset because he feels that I’m throwing money away. He’s managed to save quite a bit already which will cover a few years of education. I feel that we are technically saving money by front loading the cost of this necessity. I think it’s such a non issue and it’s quite smart tbh. We have a shared budget of £50k for offspring and I can definitely save this by the time I’m 35 (it will take me 30 months to save £25k). Surely it only matters that I eventually save the money, not that I save it at the same rate as him.

We’ve been together since we were 18 and we’ve always agreed about money and spending. But as we age, he’s becoming very anxious and extra cautious about the cost of having a family and he can be quite stubborn e.g. a child will survive with free education as I did, they don’t definitely need savings accounts from birth etc. He’s taking it a little too seriously because many people don’t save so much before starting a family.

We’ve bickered about this quite a bit and it really winds me up. I feel like the arguments are getting worse about such a minor issue. Is he being unreasonable?

OP posts:
SnotRags · 26/01/2022 20:40

YABU buying so many baby clothes that might never get used (even if you do have a baby, a baby is not going to use thousands of pounds worth of clothes, they grow quick!) but also the mad rules you’ve set yourself around even trying for a baby. And … if you genuinely need all that money just to even have a baby then why on earth are you wasting thousands on clothes???

I think other posters are right, you need counselling

DueyCheatemAndHow · 26/01/2022 20:40

@onlychildhamster but you could spend your life thinking that? Why a year? Why not 2?

And you can't be that worried if you're spending nuts amounts on clothes!

Doesn't the fact that so many people are confused tell you that this policy of yours is unusual?

VelvetChairGirl · 26/01/2022 20:38

you have a terrible habit, stop it.

I dont think I have spent that amount in my sons entire life and he is 12, what are you thinking, maybe if you had a massive collection of dolls I might be able to understand (if you were rich).

but baby cloths for a baby you dont have, I got the cheapest shit money can buy from ASDA and Primark as they last five seconds before they get thrown up on, shitted on etc and stained forever, even baby dribble stains.

onlychildhamster · 26/01/2022 20:37

@DueyCheatemAndHow if you both lose your jobs and there is a bad recession? During bad recessions, it can be quite probable it takes a year to find work....We haven't experienced that in years but it may happen.. We do £1k per month mortgage overpayments so that probably does build up a cushion too. I wouldn't want to lose my home!

onlychildhamster · 26/01/2022 20:35

@coconuthead DH and I also don't drive so no car leases or any expensive commitments. but I would not feel comfortable having less than £20k in the bank... Even at our poorest where our food budget was literally 20 euros a week and we could not afford ikea delivery (so carried ikea furniture home on the bus), we had £10k in savings. I think we even spent a few weeks in a shared hostel as a young couple cos we couldn't find a rental flat we could afford (in our early 20s). At that time, we had a more flexible budget, so I can't imagine having less savings now that we have a 300k mortgage!
Even after buying our flat in 2019, we had maybe £12k in the bank (needed a 15% deposit) and it still felt tight, I was worried we could not afford furniture!

So if OP has a baby and a big mortgage for a family home, i guess that might be why she thinks 50k is a good amount?

DueyCheatemAndHow · 26/01/2022 20:32

I don't understand why you think you need a years mortgage cushion?

birdglasspen · 26/01/2022 20:31

But kids books instead! Far more valuable and great to have a wee library set up!

SoftSheen · 26/01/2022 20:30

If you are certain that you want children, then think about starting sooner rather than later. You sound like you are in an excellent financial position already, and waiting until you are 35 to try for your first is a bit of a gamble, fertility wise.

Babies aren't babies very long and so there is absolutely no point in spending £3k on baby clothes. And I say that as someone who was quite happy to occasionally splash out on Baby Boden etc.

ButtockUp · 26/01/2022 20:30

So you've all that money for absolutely nothing whatsoever other than to reduce your ability to stay at home with your baby/reduce your deposit .

A baby doesn't need a tenth i op f that amount of clothes and stuff.

This is seriously obsessive and you need to be careful, my dear, that your partner doesn't think the same!

Stop it!

onlychildhamster · 26/01/2022 20:28

@coconuthead DH and I have a policy that we need to have £24k in cash for 1 year of basic expenses if we lost our jobs. We have £1k mortgage etc. If childcare is £1k (I know its much more full time, but say part time hours), and you probably can't cancel it immediately if you lose your job, thats £36k you would need saved up. And the additional £14k is to account for other expenses that OP and her husband may have like a car lease and also other baby related expenses? and also for maternity lave

I mean, I don't have a goal of saving £50k to have a baby, but probably its a good idea to have enough money in savings to pay 1 year of mortgage and basic expenses + childcare as well as maternity leave. Our mortgage may be higher then to account for bigger flat, so can quite imagine needing £50k in savings by that point... I think it is quite a lot, probably more reasonable to have £35k in savings given that we need £24k as a couple!

Whatinthelord · 26/01/2022 20:25

You are majorly overthinking this.

It’s great you’re both planning ahead financially, but I think you’re being a bit OTT about how much is needed to raise a child. Clearly if you’re spending that much on clothes for a baby that doesn’t exist yet, then your fairly financially secure anyway.

I think the coming from poverty thing is interesting. I grew up poor and I’m massively strict with spending and struggle with “ waste”, my brothers the opposite though and love spending.

PurplePansy05 · 26/01/2022 20:23

I am really confused about this. Firstly, it sounds like you're in that place when you are focusing your thoughts on having kids. You need to understand if you want to postpone it, that's your choice, but it will be difficult emotionally - from personal experience. This issue stands out for me, not so much buying clothes which I think is secondary to this.

Secondly, and I don't say this lightly, I too spent a long time at university, taking follow up exams and progressing my career and then got pregnant easily in my 30s and my life seemed picture perfect. Only to have 3 miscarriages in a row and everything coming crashing down. I have my beautiful son now, and I am not saying this to scare you, OP, I am saying this for you to be aware that your wait may be unexpectedly longer than you envisage now. We just don't know these things, ever. As long as you have your eyes open, it's entirely your choice of course.

Baby clothes are not a good investment, let me tell you, my son has a big wardrobe now and I sold some of them, they never sell for anywhere near the original price, even discounted. I buy ahead too on sales, but he is already here and I know what suits him and what brands are actually my favourite too. So, in the nicest possible way, stop buying now.

Finally, you do not need £50k for maternity leave. You really don't. I believe you may be too focused on the sense of security, particularly financial, because of your background. But honestly, no one needs this kind of money for this. If you have it, you're honestly in an extremely good position.

As a professional and a mother I will tell you as well, whilst there are better and worse times career-wise for having a baby, I absolutely believe that if you have your qualifications sorted, you will get where you want to be regardless. In hindsight you'll find that your career may have slowed down a bit because of maternity leave etc. But in a grand scheme of things, you have 30+ years of working ahead of you and no one, absolutely no one will remember whether you took a break at 29 or 35 or both. It doesn't really matter. It might matter if you want to build up a good relationship with your employer to enjoy more flexibility. But in the post-pandemic world things are looking more flexible for many professionals anyway. And the same goes for your partner - who I assume doesn't need to worry about childbearing, so why can't he step up more and provide you with a comfortable environment sooner? (and frankly it sounds you have this environment already, but you don't perceive it this way). You may want to have a word with him and agree your shared priorities. I'm massively career driven, but children are a huge blessing and definitely a priority now. Think about what really matters to you now. xx

HollyBollyBooBoo · 26/01/2022 20:23

I think you need some help, this is an addiction.

DueyCheatemAndHow · 26/01/2022 20:22

It's just such a waste. You've no idea how big your baby might be. You could well have spent 1.5k on clothes that never get used at all.

It actually makes me feel a bit queasy

coconuthead · 26/01/2022 20:20

Why do you need to save £50k to have a baby?

Why do you have so many expensive baby clothes before you even have a baby?

I'm so confused!

This has to be a wind up

redandwhite1 · 26/01/2022 20:18

Spending that amount is unnecessary and if you stop you'll get to that end goal (of actually having a baby) so much quicker

Plus what are you buying as it must be all gender neutral and you really don't need that much as the moment it's born (or you find out the sex) you'll spend even more on pink
/ blue!!

BigYellowHat · 26/01/2022 20:18
  1. Your savings would go up a lot faster if you weren’t buying clothes for a non-existent baby.
  2. Don’t put it off if you want a baby as you might have fertility problems and regret it
  3. Use the £5K now to pay for your postgrad if it’s that important
  4. Who on Earth saves up for a baby (no-one!!)

YABU!!

Antsgomarching · 26/01/2022 20:15

I found when I bought in advance for DD (because of pandemic, where I am there was limited on-line shopping etc) she basically didn’t fit into the clothes that were appropriate for the weather. I ended up with loads of clothes she never wore.

Honestly I don’t think this is healthy at all. I did look at baby clothes when we were TTC but I really think you should talk to somebody about this. You are investing a lot into a future that hasn’t happened yet. It’s fantasising, and thats fine if it doesn’t affect your day to day living but it’s costing you money and causing conflict in your relationship.

onlychildhamster · 26/01/2022 20:13

Oh and like you OP, I am 29. I married at 22!

Pollypocket81 · 26/01/2022 20:13

I feel sad reading your post. I get that you're broody and possibly feeling trapped in your life choices at the moment.

Whose choice is it that you have to wait to try to conceive until you've saved a certain amount? I guess it's ultimately yours but that your not entirely happy with that choice/feel cooerced or you wouldn't have posted here.

The money spent on the clothes might have been better spent on bringing forward trying to conceive by a couple of months.

onlychildhamster · 26/01/2022 20:13

Oh OP. I am going against the grain and I feel you.

I have never bought baby clothes in my life. I have been known however to drag DH to the baby clothes section to look at baby clothes to imagine myself buying them. I have tried out prams in the pram selection of John Lewis; the nice sales girl came over and i told her I was shopping for a friend!

I have looked up primary school catchments and bought the flat in the right area for the non existent baby. Cos you know, future proofing in case we can't upgrade to a 3 bed flat and need to stay here.

I will probably have a baby around 35 like you. I find the broodiness has improved, i don't look at baby clothes as I used to 3 years ago.I still spend too much time on mumsnet though, it was because of my broodiness that I even joined. Focus your mind on goals that you need to get done before having your baby i.e. career, studies, savings. I think broodiness is an instinct, its something a lot of women feel even after they have had multiple babies. Ultimately though, its different for every woman when they want to conceive, you alone know whats right for you.

Westerman · 26/01/2022 20:12

Are you sure your partner wants children? To set a predetermined budget ahead of even trying to conceive has some sense to it, but you also need to consider your fertility, which is dropping every year. And you'll never save every single penny ahead of time that you going to need to spend on kids. Their expenses don't stop at 18.
But, in all kindness, please stop spending more money on baby clothes. It's a waste.

birdglasspen · 26/01/2022 20:07

It shouldn’t come as a surprise if you spend anytime on here that babies can be hard to come by, not everyone gets pregnant very easily. Wait till you have kids or save money incase you need treatment. I probably spent less than £50 a year at first as we were given so many presents and second hand clothes(which were as good as new as babies aren’t in them
Long!) you aren’t saving money just spending a baffling amount on clothes which will be outdated (wouldn’t concern me but you sounds pretty into clothes!) and spewed, dribbled on constantly by a baby who just wants a comfy baby gro not a mini me outfit!

Lostmyway86 · 26/01/2022 20:04

I have a 15 month old and 2.5 year old and don't think I've spent more than £200 on clothes between them their entire lives, what with hand me downs, second hand bits and presents.

That amount is seriously insane! It's great that you're budgeting but seems pretty pointless if you've spent money like that. I also think you're overthinking it a bit, babies don't cost much if you're frugal about it.

thebigpurpleone · 26/01/2022 20:01

Jesus Christ that is insane money to spend on baby clothes.