Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We need normal people to be running the country

143 replies

Marianne1234 · 26/01/2022 13:39

Not these Etonian freaks who have no idea what it’s like to live in the real world.

Where are they all? The lawyers, accountants, teachers. Clever professionals who have been to the state schools. Used the NHS. Lived amongst normal people. Been skint students who have struggled to pay their bills. Cared for elderly relatives. Been working mothers. Worked for a living.

Not ridiculous anachronisms like JRM or hooray Henry’s like David Cameron or national embarrassments like Boris (who was a national embarrassment before he was ever the PM).

It really is true that people who want to be in politics, should not be anywhere near it. Maybe we should conscript the normal people Grin

OP posts:
fishonabicycle · 26/01/2022 14:50

A stop to career politicians would be a good idea. And we've definitely had enough Bullingdon club alumni - even Plato said that an ideal ruler would be someone who didn't want to do it (as people generally want to be in politics for self advancement and aggrandisement.

Sartre · 26/01/2022 14:47

Also just want to add that it’s Keir, too many people misspell his name.

Sartre · 26/01/2022 14:46

Lots of Labour MP’s fit your criteria including both the leader and deputy. Angela Rayner is regularly slated for being too normal though, apparently having a NW accent isn’t very professional.

QuestionsorComments · 26/01/2022 14:45

Surely we want someone a but more than Average Joe in charge? Grin

I agree more average background would be good, but they won't be average in the years in between leaving (starting?) school and becoming PM if they're going to be any good.

Sir Kier Starmer QC was born Kier Starmer son of a nurse and a tradesman. He worked for the rest.

I don't understand why he's not doing better, he should be a dream candidate at an easy time for Labour, but they're not making it happen.

NiceShrubbery · 26/01/2022 14:43

I don’t give a shit about the background of people in politics

That's part of the problem and partly why the system is so corrupt. They then appoint and promote their cronies from those same backgrounds and form power clusters that are hard to get rid of. Diversity really matters.

OfstedOffred · 26/01/2022 14:41

Then stand for a seat in an area with relatively affordable housing

What, and uproot my whole family?

Someone has to represent the area I live in. Should it only be someone with inherited wealth to afford the housing here on an mp salary?

ilovesooty · 26/01/2022 14:40

[quote onlychildhamster]@MorningStarling Keir Rodney Starmer was born in Southwark, London, on 2 September 1962[1][2] and grew up in the small town of Oxted in Surrey.[3][4][5] He was born the second of the four children of Josephine (née Baker), a nurse, and Rodney Starmer, a toolmaker

He has a far more 'ordinary' childhood than most people I know...He was also far more successful in his career than almost anyone I know. Sounds like a good combination.

After all we should respect people for what they have done with their lives, not who their parents were.[/quote]
Yet Johnson had the nerve to describe his party as "the party of aspiration" in PMQs today. He's never had to work for anything in his life.

Blossomtoes · 26/01/2022 14:39

@OfstedOffred

The kind of politician I want would consider £80k plus expenses to be a fair recompense for a role in which they can make a difference.

Yeah well if you live in the south east and havent inherited a house, 80k doesnt go that far on a massive mortgage when you've childcare to pay

Then stand for a seat in an area with relatively affordable housing and wait until you no longer have a massive childcare bill.
QuestionsorComments · 26/01/2022 14:39

Kier Starmer is exactly what OP is asking for. A child of working class parents who did well academically and was successful enough as a lawyer to become QC and get a knighthood for services to law and criminal justice.

The trouble is once he "made it" he became one of "them", or at least that's how it seems from some posts here.

MsTSwift · 26/01/2022 14:39

Keir starmer is not from a privileged back ground. He’s like my Dh as he’s well educated and clever people assume “posh” and privileged. The reality for Dh is both his parents left school at 16 his dad had a manual job and dh went to state school. Keir starmer similar from what I vaguely remember from desert island discs anyway.

sst1234 · 26/01/2022 14:37

@Kay00

The Labour Party have many of the professional ordinary working people that you are looking for. Angela Raynor and Kier Starmer for two.
We said ordinary, not even more incompetent.
Marianne1234 · 26/01/2022 14:37

Yeah. I like Starmer. And I liked Gordon Brown.

OP posts:
Giraffesandbottoms · 26/01/2022 14:36

Nice bit of inverted snobbery on a Wednesday

HopefulProcrastinator · 26/01/2022 14:33

It's for this reason I'd love to get behind Starmer. He's from an average background at the very least even if it's not one of poverty and clearly has the intelligence and social skills to climb the greasy pole to obtain not just QC but Sir as extras to his name.

I do believe that he can appreciate the viewpoint of the more ordinary UK person than the average Conservative or even Lib Dem. However he can't seem to find a convincing voice or position so is incapable of winning people over and his refusal to acknowledge that women are the only people capable of having a cervix has done him no favours in this home

I refuse to vote Tory but I'm struggling to give Labour a vote beyond wanting to oust the Tories. I don't think that's a strong enough position in general to give Labour the majority (or as close to for alliances) as they need. They are meant to be the party of the people, but the people can't seem to trust them which is beyond mad given how Boris and cronies are abusing pretty much every privilege laid at their door.

I agree though, we need people with real experience and real ability/aptitude/intelligence. Not people spoon fed degrees because mater and pater have a few bob in the bank and could pay for it.

gsaoej · 26/01/2022 14:33

I have no ties to or knowledge of Eton but don’t think we should be berating people who went there.

Eton have so much money that they can take very bright kids for free. Social mobility is a funny thing. If you start out as “salt of the earth local kid born to WC parents” and do brilliantly - maybe you go to Eton for free, maybe Oxford or whatever and become rich - you suddenly become part of the hated elite and seemingly it’s ok for people to dismiss you as a rich bastard in an ivory tower.

I don’t give a shit about the background of people in politics. I do give a shit about their intellect though.

Grapesavocado · 26/01/2022 14:29

Sir Keir Rodney Starmer KCB QC, doesn't sound like your average Joe.

No but before he rose on merit he was ordinary which I think is the OP's ideal.

onelittlefrog · 26/01/2022 14:28

Where are they all? The lawyers, accountants, teachers. Clever professionals who have been to the state schools. Used the NHS. Lived amongst normal people. Been skint students who have struggled to pay their bills. Cared for elderly relatives. Been working mothers. Worked for a living

Well they're not in the Tory party! (But didn't we already know that?) Confused

gsaoej · 26/01/2022 14:28

Politics is simply a horrible workplace. It attracts people with bad personality traits - arrogant and narcissistic. Competence completely optional and usually lacking. All backstabbing so they can get a go at the “top job”. Grim grim grim.

Reasonable and intelligent people such as Vince Cable are the ones who ought to have been PM.

OfstedOffred · 26/01/2022 14:20

The kind of politician I want would consider £80k plus expenses to be a fair recompense for a role in which they can make a difference.

Yeah well if you live in the south east and havent inherited a house, 80k doesnt go that far on a massive mortgage when you've childcare to pay

QuestionsorComments · 26/01/2022 14:18

Yes, I understand your point BlossomToes, but where are all these "ordinary people" with the skills to do the job who aren't motivated by money?. If you've struggled from a poor background to get yourself well qualified (via a mountain of student debt) and are finally on a career path to change all that, would you take a pay cut? Would you be supportive of a partner who wanted to do that to take on a job that could be all over within 3/5 years?

It is certainly true that the people who want the power are the last people who should have it, but the best thing about democracy is the alternatives, as they say.

Also the Eton types are largely Tories. If people don't want them, it's easy, they need to vote differently.

OfstedOffred · 26/01/2022 14:17

I fit your description OP.

State educated
Working mother
Working class parents
Chartered accountant
Used/benefitted from NHS a lot

a) going to work as an mp would mean a pay cut of about 15/20%
b) I assume the hours are hellish and not ideal with a young family
c) I dont know.... I think politics is a bit of scuzzy career now. All the parties are crap and it's full of cronyism, old boys club
d) I've had a corporate career and I expect everything I've ever worked on will somehow be used to discredit or embarrass me somehow
e) it's all a big popularity contest and people would probably hate me/not vote for me, I'm too blunt, I will say it like it is and people often don't like people stating the facts if they don't agree with them

Blossomtoes · 26/01/2022 14:12

@QuestionsorComments

This is the argument for paying politicians more. The successful, driven accountants and solicitors even headteachers and SE tradesmen, who rely on their income (ie don't have family money) can earn more than the PM and a lot more than an MP.
I disagree. I don’t want politicians who are motivated by money. The kind of politician I want would consider £80k plus expenses to be a fair recompense for a role in which they can make a difference.
Walnutblossom · 26/01/2022 14:10

Where are they all? The lawyers, accountants, teachers. Clever professionals who have been to the state schools.

Why only lawyers, accountants and teachers? Why not cleaners, retail staff and Uber drivers? Or are you only allowed to run the country if you've had a "career"?

QuestionsorComments · 26/01/2022 14:09

This is the argument for paying politicians more. The successful, driven accountants and solicitors even headteachers and SE tradesmen, who rely on their income (ie don't have family money) can earn more than the PM and a lot more than an MP.

Hoppinggreen · 26/01/2022 14:07

I think it’s because we have had hundreds if not thousands of years in the country of being indoctrinated to believe that the upper “ruling” classes know what they are doing and are somehow looking after us.
If I want to be more intimidating I get posher - and it bloody works!
Too many of us hear a posh voice and the trappings of “old money” and we role over and bare our throats.
I’m not some sort of commie - never voted Labour in my life, went to Private school and earn well now but I really do agree that more ordinary people from varied backgrounds should be in charge. Unfortunately all too often they don’t see it as an option