Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We need normal people to be running the country

143 replies

Marianne1234 · 26/01/2022 13:39

Not these Etonian freaks who have no idea what it’s like to live in the real world.

Where are they all? The lawyers, accountants, teachers. Clever professionals who have been to the state schools. Used the NHS. Lived amongst normal people. Been skint students who have struggled to pay their bills. Cared for elderly relatives. Been working mothers. Worked for a living.

Not ridiculous anachronisms like JRM or hooray Henry’s like David Cameron or national embarrassments like Boris (who was a national embarrassment before he was ever the PM).

It really is true that people who want to be in politics, should not be anywhere near it. Maybe we should conscript the normal people Grin

OP posts:
Silverswirl · 26/01/2022 17:27

[quote onlychildhamster]@Silverswirl there are all types of people in almost every area in the UK bar places like Knightsbridge. In my area, there are ex council flats costing £300k all the way up to £30 million houses. there are children who need food banks to eat, alongside children who probably have never seen the inside of a tube train. And everyone in between. No one is necessarily 'privileged' because of the area they live in because the experiences in the same area can be very very different based on who your parents are and what your living circumstances are. Disadvantaged children in London probably have more of an advantage in the sense that their schools tend to be better (even the rough comprehensives) and they can stay at home while saving for a deposit as my DH did; but at the same time, i think truly disadvantaged children do face other problems that inhibit their success even in London (knife crime is very high and there is high unemployment amongst disadvantaged london youths).[/quote]
Oxtstead is a world away from London (but surprising close in actual distance of course) and yes I have lived and worked in multiple parts of London.
The vast vast majority of oxstead village is extremely privileged. You have to be to even consider living there.
Of course there are exceptions but I’m speaking about the vast majority.
How widely have you travelled and lived in various parts of England? I can assure you, most people’s experience of living as a ‘normal non privileged person’ or a ‘poor person’ in the poorer areas of Surrey (which oxtead is not btw) is vastly different from a ‘non privelidged’ person in say South Wales or Birmingham or the poorer parts of Manchester for example.

MakeYourOwnLollies · 26/01/2022 17:26

because being cleaners, retail staff and Uber drivers doesn't fit you for reading and analysing policy, speaking on your feet, picking apart arguments and scrutinising legislation. Sure, people who have done those jobs will bring valuable lived experience to Parliament but there is education needed too.

This is why a better democracy isn't just government by plebiscite or sortiton or whatever.

StoneofDestiny · 26/01/2022 17:25

Is that your Kebab shop advertising? 😂😂

user1497207191 · 26/01/2022 16:39

I think it's the senior civil servants who need to be "normal" and have real world exposure, i.e. qualified accountants with experience in practice/business running the Treasury, which would be permanent long term jobs. We seem to have a lot of "career" civil servants who get their jobs through the old boy's network who are elevating beyond their qualifications, experience and abilities, or graduates without experience who know nothing but their civil service bubble.

Eg, we constantly get bad decisions made by the Treasury, whether in the annual Budget, or the Covid business support schemes. Real-life accountants spot the mistakes/omissions almost immediately, but the policiticians/civil servants refuse to accept they're wrong and won't change things.

A classic was Gordon Brown's paymaster general, Dawn Primarolo, who stood in Parliament and made an announcement that she didn;t think small businesses would convert themselves into limited companies "just to save tax", following Brown's stupid tax reductions which affected only limited companies and not sole traders. In the weeks and months that followed, literally tens (if not hundreds) of thousands of sole traders converted themselves into limited companies!

Moretodo · 26/01/2022 16:32

@daimbarsatemydogsbone - reporting from the station live 😁

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 26/01/2022 16:29

The fact that he grew up in oxtead[sic] in Surrey means that he’s far more privileged than most of the country to start with. I grew up there too so I know it well.

🤣🤣🤣🤣

We need normal people to be running the country
We need normal people to be running the country
123ZYX · 26/01/2022 16:24

As an accountant (high end of 5 figure salary), with a working class background, I probably fit the OPs ideal pretty well.

There are a huge number of reasons why I wouldn't want to be an MP

  • job uncertainty - you can lose your job every five years, so you need to be confident of walking straight into a job or having the money behind you for it not to matter
  • time away from home - as a mum of a fairly young child, I wouldn't want to have to be away from him in London as often as would be needed as an MP
  • stalling my career - it would be hard to go back into my role or a similar role after 5/ 10 years away from it
  • not being part of the "old boys club" - I've had to prove myself already in my career in that sort of environment and wouldn't want to have to face it again, either to other MPs or to journalists/ the public who will judge your accent rather than your abilities, especially as a woman
Moretodo · 26/01/2022 16:19

Normal

We need normal people to be running the country
onlychildhamster · 26/01/2022 16:18

@Silverswirl there are all types of people in almost every area in the UK bar places like Knightsbridge. In my area, there are ex council flats costing £300k all the way up to £30 million houses. there are children who need food banks to eat, alongside children who probably have never seen the inside of a tube train. And everyone in between. No one is necessarily 'privileged' because of the area they live in because the experiences in the same area can be very very different based on who your parents are and what your living circumstances are. Disadvantaged children in London probably have more of an advantage in the sense that their schools tend to be better (even the rough comprehensives) and they can stay at home while saving for a deposit as my DH did; but at the same time, i think truly disadvantaged children do face other problems that inhibit their success even in London (knife crime is very high and there is high unemployment amongst disadvantaged london youths).

Moretodo · 26/01/2022 16:18

Oxted.
If you grew up there why spell it like that?
I know there area well and there is a traveller community, big social housing estate and pockets of deprivation.

He certainly wasn't privileged.

user1497207191 · 26/01/2022 16:16

@SuitcaseOfWhine

The trouble with this current PM and cabinet minsters is they move jobs on what seems like a monthly basis. I don't get how you can be an expert in transport and logistics one week and then in education the next.

That's the same regardless of party. It's always been that way. The current office holders are no better no worse than prior governments of all colours. The reality is that it's the civil servants who actually run the departments and who "feed" options to the current minister of their dept. Of course, the ministers should have some experience/qualifications in their dept in a perfect world, but if it was an absolute requirement, you'd have situations where there was only one MP with a law qualification who therefore "had to be" the attorney general or only one MP who is a qualified accountant who "had to be" the Chancellor - regardless of their actual ability and competence in ministerial office. That's just as ridiculous.

Blossomtoes · 26/01/2022 16:13

The fact that he grew up in oxtead in Surrey means that he’s far more privileged than most of the country to start with. I grew up there too so I know it well.

That’s absurd. Are you seriously suggesting that the child of a cleaner in Oxtead is more privileged than the child of a lawyer in Manchester? Catch yourself on.

user1497207191 · 26/01/2022 16:12

It's not just the politicians though, is it? What about the permanent civil servants who are the ones who "really" run the country, many of whom stay in their jobs (or move on the magic merry go round) when the political party in power changes hands.

"Normal" people probably wouldn't want the interference and intense scrutiny into their home/family/personal life. The Lib Dems had, for a very short period of time, a brilliant leader in Tim Farron, who is an exceptional and popular, hard working MP in South Cumbria - he'd have done wonders for the Lib Dems, but resigned as leader pretty quickly due to the intrusion into personal religious beliefs.

Silverswirl · 26/01/2022 16:09

[quote onlychildhamster]@MorningStarling Keir Rodney Starmer was born in Southwark, London, on 2 September 1962[1][2] and grew up in the small town of Oxted in Surrey.[3][4][5] He was born the second of the four children of Josephine (née Baker), a nurse, and Rodney Starmer, a toolmaker

He has a far more 'ordinary' childhood than most people I know...He was also far more successful in his career than almost anyone I know. Sounds like a good combination.

After all we should respect people for what they have done with their lives, not who their parents were.[/quote]
The fact that he grew up in oxtead in Surrey means that he’s far more privileged than most of the country to start with. I grew up there too so I know it well.

SuitcaseOfWhine · 26/01/2022 16:06

I mentioned this on a thread yesterday. We need normal people who have lived ordinary lives and have worked hard to get to where they have, not walked into a job through privilege, or have been too changed by the success that they have had if they have come from more humble beginnings.

The trouble with this current PM and cabinet minsters is they move jobs on what seems like a monthly basis. I don't get how you can be an expert in transport and logistics one week and then in education the next. Experts and people with lived experience working in these fields need to be in these jobs as they can understand how things will play out if a policy is changed or introduced. The constant chaos of having self-elected experts who move roles so frequently (because they are shit and shouldn't be in them in the first place) just leads to a lack of stability, leadership and stagnation, which is basically what has happened in this country for the last 10 years. It's very convenient though for this government who avoid tackling real issues in the long term. It's a reactive government, not a proactive one.

Another issue is it seems people want a celebrity as a PM, and not someone who has worked hard and understands real people just because they appear to be a bit dull. They want the annoying snazzy tie weirdo in the office to run the company instead.

DoTheMerengue · 26/01/2022 16:03

Why would any sensible, clever professional go into politics?

Despite the view that it’s a gravy train, a lot of professionals can earn far more outside politics than in.

It’s a totally thankless task, abuse, death threats, being told you’re useless and idle despite working your arse off, people who disagree with you thinking you’re scum because they’re utterly incapable of having a reasoned debate about anything.

It’s just not worth it.

fishonabicycle · 26/01/2022 16:03

Part of the problem (imho) is that since Blair, we have moved towards US style 'personality' politics. It's all about whether you 'like them', or would they be a good bloke to 'go for a drink with'. Which probably isn't the best criteria for a leader!

GreenLunchBox · 26/01/2022 16:03

@Asdf12345

If I were to take five years out to be an MP for a term it would cost me substantially lifetime earnings in its impact on my career unless I found a way to leverage it financially. That is why I want to be represented by someone independently wealthy who would be harder to buy.

I do begrudgingly accept that everyone has a price, but would hope beyond a certain level of security people are much harder to buy.

Are you serious?

Where have you been that you've not heard that Rishi 'married to the daughter of a billionaire' Sunak has just written off £4.3 billion worth of fraudulent covid bounce back loans. Yes that's BILLION. Of OUR money.

I wonder why? Could it be that their donors and cronies are involved? His wife's company benefited from a lot of covid support money.🤔

Some of these companies didn't even exist when covid started! The pandemic hasn't even ended and he's writing them off! There must be paper trails to these things so why? That's why Askew quit the other day....he was asking the same questions and getting nowhere.

So, no, an 'independently wealthy' person is not more likely to be trustworthy with money. IMO the scams are likely to be on a bigger scale, as we have seen from this episode!

QuestionsorComments · 26/01/2022 16:02

@Thirtytimesround

Our horrible media and weak privacy laws scared off all the normal people. I’d love to be an MP and have a fab CV for it but don’t fancy having my family’s personal life in the papers 🤢

The way things are set up only the most egotistical/arrogant people can stand the job.

Look what happened with Chuka Umnna. Withdrew his candidacy for Labour leadership because press harassing his gran at home or something like that. So then we got stuck with Corbyn. So then we got stuck with BJ.

OMG really. The press shouldn't be investigating birthday parties, private finances, relationships with sexual predators of those in power?

The press need to be better at this IMO, so they know they'll get caught

Thirtytimesround · 26/01/2022 15:59

Our horrible media and weak privacy laws scared off all the normal people. I’d love to be an MP and have a fab CV for it but don’t fancy having my family’s personal life in the papers 🤢

The way things are set up only the most egotistical/arrogant people can stand the job.

Look what happened with Chuka Umnna. Withdrew his candidacy for Labour leadership because press harassing his gran at home or something like that. So then we got stuck with Corbyn. So then we got stuck with BJ.

StoneofDestiny · 26/01/2022 15:55

Is this the same K Starmer who refused to prosecute Jimmy Savile when he was DPP?

No
But Jimmy Saville was your future Kings' pal (in this non democracy).

FortVictoria · 26/01/2022 15:54

We have got the child of Trump and Berlusconi - and how we laughed at them!**

@StoneofDestiny - what a brilliant description!! Wink

110APiccadilly · 26/01/2022 15:53

Power corrupts, so I'm not convinced making MPs meet some standard of "normal" would help much.

I'd quite like the HoL to be chosen randomly, like jury service, to sit for 5 years though. Everyone to have exactly the same chance of being selected. Probably wouldn't be practical (too much disruption to the lives of those selected), but it's a nice idea.

StoneofDestiny · 26/01/2022 15:49

I'm less worried about their background than their morality and ethics.

Currently we have a prolific liar in charge of our country. A philanderer. A hypocrite. A racist misogynist and a blundering idiot who is taking us all for fools.
The worst thing is that all these qualities were widely known by the Tories, the media and the public, yet he was still put in the position to inflict significant damage to the UK at home and abroad. We have got the child of Trump and Berlusconi - and how we laughed at them!