Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We need normal people to be running the country

143 replies

Marianne1234 · 26/01/2022 13:39

Not these Etonian freaks who have no idea what it’s like to live in the real world.

Where are they all? The lawyers, accountants, teachers. Clever professionals who have been to the state schools. Used the NHS. Lived amongst normal people. Been skint students who have struggled to pay their bills. Cared for elderly relatives. Been working mothers. Worked for a living.

Not ridiculous anachronisms like JRM or hooray Henry’s like David Cameron or national embarrassments like Boris (who was a national embarrassment before he was ever the PM).

It really is true that people who want to be in politics, should not be anywhere near it. Maybe we should conscript the normal people Grin

OP posts:
Domino20 · 26/01/2022 19:31

@Asdf12345

If I were to take five years out to be an MP for a term it would cost me substantially lifetime earnings in its impact on my career unless I found a way to leverage it financially. That is why I want to be represented by someone independently wealthy who would be harder to buy.

I do begrudgingly accept that everyone has a price, but would hope beyond a certain level of security people are much harder to buy.

That's demonstrably not been the case though has it? Regardless of personal wealth they all, without fail, seek to enrich themselves further.
DoTheMerengue · 26/01/2022 19:06

I don’t get the “Sir Kier Starmer is too posh and not a man of the people” argument.

So what are you gonna do? Vote for Boris? He hardly dragged himself up off the streets did he?

user1497207191 · 26/01/2022 19:04

@eddiemairswife

I would like to see a requirement for prospective MPs to have worked for at least five consecutive years in a job completely outside politics.
But some of them have had jobs/careers outside politics and are still useless.

Look at Rishi Sunak - only entered Parliament in 2015.
Tony Blair was a barrister before he became an MP.

Lolamento · 26/01/2022 19:00

@NiceShrubbery

Cue 47 posters saying how Keir is the Messiah and 47 other posters saying they'll keep voting Tory because yes.

Defunct systems just pump out dross. Class is irrelevant if half the electorate doesn't get a real say.

Oh like Biden was the messiah and how is that going?
Lolamento · 26/01/2022 18:58

What about Sadiq Khan? He is useless but ordinary so there you go.

D0lphine · 26/01/2022 18:56

Professional here.

Personally I don't think that the money of being an MP is worth it for the exposure, hate and ridicule women in that role receive.

I can earn far more than that being anonymous.

Lolamento · 26/01/2022 18:54

As long as they are not divisive and vindictive class haters yes please!

eddiemairswife · 26/01/2022 18:53

I would like to see a requirement for prospective MPs to have worked for at least five consecutive years in a job completely outside politics.

ListeningButNotHearing · 26/01/2022 18:53

..."Where are they all? The lawyers, accountants, teachers. Clever professionals who have been to the state schools. Used the NHS. Lived amongst normal people. Been skint students who have struggled to pay their bills. Cared for elderly relatives. Been working mothers. Worked for a living..."

You are either VERY naive or very young if you perceive these types of people (indeed anyone unless you really know them) to be 'normal' people.

StarbucksSmarterSister · 26/01/2022 18:45

The fact that he grew up in oxtead in Surrey means that he’s far more privileged than most of the country to start with

This is his family home in Oxted. Doesn't look very privileged to me.

We need normal people to be running the country
NotsoNeurotypical · 26/01/2022 18:39

Keir Starmer is too much of a fence sitter for my liking, I prefer Angela Rayner she's more outspoken and seems to have some gumption. I know people don't seem to like either of them though.

dorkfink · 26/01/2022 18:36

I think it’s because we have had hundreds if not thousands of years in the country of being indoctrinated to believe that the upper “ruling” classes know what they are doing and are somehow looking after us.

this, it's bizarre

PlanetNormal · 26/01/2022 18:33

I wonder if Starmer ever regrets accepting his Knighthood? It seems to be a millstone round his neck.

He got it in 2014, before he went into politics, for his work as Director of Public Prosecutions. Honours go with the job for senior civil servants, so it was part of his pay grade.

His problem is that people who don’t understand this think he’s ‘posh’ when he’s actually a normal bloke from a normal background who went to grammar school, worked hard and climbed the career ladder.

onlychildhamster · 26/01/2022 18:30

@GreenLunchBox was also confused by what she meant by oxted being a world away from London. The most expensive housing in the country is still in certain london neighbourhoods like kensington and bishops avenue. There are very few places outside london which are as expensive, 50 years ago or currently. And Oxted is definitely not one of them.

Bishops Avenue is largely abandoned but the few people who live there are richer than the Queen. I live ten minutes from Bishops Avenue and am extremely ordinary. So I don't understand how Keir starmer can be 'privileged' living in Oxted because Oxted may have some posh streets when I am not privileged just by living near Billionaires Row!

HoliHormonalTigerlilly · 26/01/2022 18:20

@Grapesavocado

They're in because they were voted for.

K Starmer is very ordinary.

Yep. Stop voting them in. It's fairly simple.
GreenLunchBox · 26/01/2022 18:17

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

The fact that he grew up in oxtead[sic] in Surrey means that he’s far more privileged than most of the country to start with. I grew up there too so I know it well.

🤣🤣🤣🤣

I'm intrigued now why that poster said 'Oxtead' was posh.

Boris, is that you? You don't have to lie about everything, you know 😂

PenStation · 26/01/2022 18:08

On a local level flatpack democracy is changing some places but I don’t know enough about it to say how it would translate nationally.

www.theguardian.com/politics/2015/may/22/flatpack-democracy-peoples-republic-of-frome

PenStation · 26/01/2022 18:02

I agree with the OP. And it’s not enough to have a bright leader from an ordinary background, the majority of the team need to be. The Whitehall civil servants could do with a good overhaul as well.

A reasonable level of education and a lot of motivation to learn is needed to analyze policy, understand the issues, but I wouldn’t link eligibility to particular professions.

I’m probably ideal as a candidate because I am from a poor background but have had a professional career. I’ve had tons of media experience and I’m of an age where I have enough financial security and life experience to enter politics. The trouble is that most people get into politics through their local party and none of them appeal to me. Independents seem to get nowhere at election time.

phlebasconsidered · 26/01/2022 18:02

The problem is that the sort of person who wants to become a politician is usually manifestly not in it for the people. Even back in the day it was all personal ambition.

The various requirements of rank were dropped and you did get people rising up through the ranks, like Kier Hardy and so on, but the fact remains that in either party you still need to have quite a lot of time to campaign, schmooze and even get considered for election and time is the preserve of those with money or willing helpers. So usually middle class or above, and male, even now.

I would love to represent my community but i'm flat out teaching all day and marking in the evenings and caring for kids and an elderly parent and I cannot spare even an evening to go along to party meetings and bring myself to selection. You need a lot of time and support to be able to do that.

onlychildhamster · 26/01/2022 17:47

@Silverswirl like many places in the Home Counties, the property prices in oxted are cheaper than my bit of suburban north london. Of course for a poorer person, it would be more accessible to live in north london than surrey in many cases due to availability of public transport (lower cost of commuting) and more gig economy jobs. Hence why there are more poor people in London than in Surrey- I have talked to my office cleaners and they seem mainly to live in zone 5.

However, for people working in the NHS or in the trades like Keir's parents were, it probably doesn't make a difference. It makes a big difference for someone like me who commutes to the City or even someone who works in the restaurant trade in central london.

Silverswirl · 26/01/2022 17:47

@NiceShrubbery

This is why a better democracy isn't just government by plebiscite or sortiton or whatever

Ok but they don't actually scrutinise legislation do they. if they decide they want to vote against, they get silenced. As for the presenting of arguments, they (Boris especially) just tell lies and make it up as they go along. Not a skill you need to go to Eton for.

Well it is in a way. Validated privilege which breeds arrogance which is needed to tell (and keep the stoney face pretence) of the lies and is most definitely needed to have the belief in yourself when you know that really you are just making it up
Blossomtoes · 26/01/2022 17:46

@MakeYourOwnLollies

because being cleaners, retail staff and Uber drivers doesn't fit you for reading and analysing policy, speaking on your feet, picking apart arguments and scrutinising legislation. Sure, people who have done those jobs will bring valuable lived experience to Parliament but there is education needed too.

This is why a better democracy isn't just government by plebiscite or sortiton or whatever.

Angela Rayner seems to be doing OK. Alan Johnson (former postman) was one of the best PMs we never had. What you need is intellect, there are plenty of bright people with very little education.
NiceShrubbery · 26/01/2022 17:43

This is why a better democracy isn't just government by plebiscite or sortiton or whatever

Ok but they don't actually scrutinise legislation do they. if they decide they want to vote against, they get silenced. As for the presenting of arguments, they (Boris especially) just tell lies and make it up as they go along. Not a skill you need to go to Eton for.

doadeer · 26/01/2022 17:29

I agree MPS should be paid more

doadeer · 26/01/2022 17:28

It's not just about whether you were born into money, the biggest job representatives should be well represented. Eg nurses, teachers, builders, civil servants. A lot of MPs seem to be career politicians.