Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think

84 replies

namechangemango · 26/01/2022 12:17

that this is not an appropriate use of my niece's DLA money?

My niece (16) is diagnosed autistic and has an emotional support dog. She gets DLA. She has told me that her dog had to go to the vet and my niece has billed her for it. It turns out my sister has had my niece pay for the cost of the purchase of the dog and all her toys and equiptment like her crate etc out of her under 18's trust fund, which has completely depeleted the balance and there are no plans for it to be replaced. My sister justified it to my niece that she needed the dog so it was an appropriate use of the money, Now I've read that under 18's aren't legally responsible for dogs.

Niece is also being charged for essential toiletries like face wash and clothes/shoes when they (genuinely) need replaced, travel etc. There has been words that there is going to be discussion of niece paying for her share of every other essential expense including food, and non essentials.

Her DLA amounts to a bit over 3k a year, she can't get a job at the moment due to continuing education. Sister doesn't earn much money herself.

I feel I should report this but sister would know it was me and I'm estranged from most other family (on my side) as they are toxic. Without getting into details she's been supporting me with personal issues

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 26/01/2022 15:34

Your DSis (who is clearly on a very low income) will have to account for how the DLA money has been spent. If she cannot prove it has been spent on DN, then there could be financial repercussions, which would impact DN and the family. no one in 6.5years has ever asked a single qn about how we spend DSs DLA

namechangemango · 26/01/2022 15:34

You must've overlooked it as I did say in my OP that there is going to be discussion of my niece contributing. Which includes food and bills out of her dla, and paying for all essentials including prescriptions and all non essentials.

OP posts:
Sartre · 26/01/2022 15:12

Your sister is on low income and dogs cost a lot, they’re one of the most expensive pets to own. Your niece is also a teenager so will cost a lot as all teenagers do.

I don’t think your sister is wrong using the extra money for this, if she was using it on partying then you’d have a point.

HollaHolla · 26/01/2022 15:09

I think trying to keep a family of (at least) 3, and a dog, on £20k a year must be really super tough. If they were better off, then I would say to put the cash away for her, and make sure she had money for the future; but they don't have much spare cash, by the sound of things, and the DLA going on the assistance dog sounds fair enough, as it's something to help her with her autism. I would say that asking her to contribute to other essentials probably would be a bit 'tight', but if you don't have the money elsewhere, you don't have it.
I think you'd be VU to report her.

BooksAndHooks · 26/01/2022 14:35

@2022success

I don't think you understand the way the system works OP.

Your DSis (who is clearly on a very low income) will have to account for how the DLA money has been spent. If she cannot prove it has been spent on DN, then there could be financial repercussions, which would impact DN and the family. So including the dog/toiletries etc is just a legitimate accounting strategy.

You don’t have to account for the money at all. It can be used on anything that will benefit the person. There is no routine checking of how it is spent.
newnameforthis76 · 26/01/2022 14:33

The DLA money is there to be spent on things the disabled person needs, so why would it be a problem to spend it on the care of her support dog? As for your niece buying her own toiletries, I don’t really think it’s any of your business. I think plenty of teenagers buy their own toiletries and stuff, especially if they have particular ones that they like (eg I wouldn’t expect her to buy her own handwash or bog roll, but pretty normal for a teenager to buy their own favourite scented shower gel or moisturiser).

DLA, like any other benefit, is paid because the recipient has been assessed for it and is eligible. It doesn’t come with conditions for what you can or can’t buy with it.

Not your money, not your child, not your business.

SleepingStandingUp · 26/01/2022 14:31

I have to say part of DSs DLA goes into the family pot because I can't work because of him and we need the money. Half is more directly set aside for his additional stuff although of course he'd not go without and he isn't presented with a bill each month totting up what he's cost me.
The qn I suppose is is your sister refusing to spend anything beyond the DLA on DD? Are they choosing not to earn more because they can just live off DDs DLA iyswim?

Jellycatspyjamas · 26/01/2022 14:30

DLA reflects the increased costs of having a child with disabilities, in terms of them needing additional care and support. It should be spent for their benefit, and that will mean different things for different people and might include daily living expenses particularly if the household has a low income. Caring for a child with disabilities limits the job opportunities for carers, meaning the household income is often lower so sometimes it’ll include things that you would ordinarily pay for your child.

I think paying for the dog is a reasonable use, as is buying toiletries if the carers can’t afford them any other way. What do you think it should be spent on?

SleepingStandingUp · 26/01/2022 14:27

@namechangemango

Sister and husband earn £20k a year combined in benefits/pension (early pension) the bulk of which earned by her husband
Dla for the dog seems to me is the kind of thing it meant for - the extras that help with her disability.

On that basis, I do think she ibu to charge her daughter for basics like toiletries. If nothing se she could use the CB she gets for it. If she didn't get DLA she'd still need to provide these things.

If their joint income is 20k I'm assuming she doesn't work? Does she claim carers allowance if she isn't able to work cos of DD?

TheFormidableMrsC · 26/01/2022 14:18

Sorry YABVVVU. My child receives DLA. It goes into the "pot" of income that I receive. Out of that "pot" comes everything he needs including activities, piano lessons, clubs, the endless clothes and shoes (sensory issues), toys, books so on and so forth. I think it's perfectly fine for your sister to use that money for a support dog. I mean give your head a wobble. Why would you report your own sibling? You sound awful.

gobbynorthernbird · 26/01/2022 14:13

@namechangemango

Surprised to hear I'm the one being unreasonable. Glad to know her DLA's being spent correctly after all when spent on the dog. I still don't think she should be paying for all essentials as well. Fancy living on over 3k a year?
DLA/PIP are not means tested and are not meant to be 'lived on'.
forlornlorna · 26/01/2022 14:10

WHOAH lol! My teenager spends her dla on things that help her disability. She also likes to buy toiletries and makeup. You know some nice sprays and stuff. Probably because I'm skint on carers allowance as I'm her full time carer. Do you know how much i get for being her carer? 67 poxy quid a week. So yeah she prefers her more expensive stuff where as I usually get her basics from supermarket.

I'll just sit back here in the bad parent zone

BarbaraofSeville · 26/01/2022 14:02

If all their income is £20k pa and that has to cover housing, bills, food, travel, etc etc then they're probably struggling to afford even the basics, let alone vets bills, and even toiletries, so have to use all the money that's available to the whole family, even if it's the niece's DLA and better off families would be able to let DN save the money for later in life.

wanttomarryamillionaire · 26/01/2022 14:00

The dog is exactly the sort of thing the dla is for, the other stuff not so much!

MorningStarling · 26/01/2022 13:59

This is bizarre. She's old enough to marry, have sex, leave home, join the army, but not buy her own toiletries?

CorrBlimeyGG · 26/01/2022 13:54

I'm estranged from most other family (on my side) as they are toxic.

You're not coming across well here yourself.

PinkSyCo · 26/01/2022 13:51

Dogs and their vet bills are an expensive luxury so I think it only fair that the cost of it comes out of your nieces DLA. I think it’s really tight of her parents to charge her for basic toiletries and clothing when she is only 16 and in full time education though.

2022success · 26/01/2022 13:27

I don't think you understand the way the system works OP.

Your DSis (who is clearly on a very low income) will have to account for how the DLA money has been spent. If she cannot prove it has been spent on DN, then there could be financial repercussions, which would impact DN and the family. So including the dog/toiletries etc is just a legitimate accounting strategy.

Sally872 · 26/01/2022 13:22

Living off 3k per Yr?? She is 16 what expenses other than dog, phone and toiletries does she have?

RaininSummer · 26/01/2022 12:55

3k a year isn't bad to cover a dog and toiletries though is it? She's not having to pay rent or food costs presumably.

QuiteAtALoss · 26/01/2022 12:53

Do you have other concerns, or are you jealous about the family's supposed "free" money?

I can assure you, I would pay DLA back 10-fold if my child could do things she can't as a result.of her disability. It's not free.

TheVolturi · 26/01/2022 12:53

You sound like an amazing sister 🙄. Have you got any children with additional needs yourself?

namechangemango · 26/01/2022 12:48

Surprised to hear I'm the one being unreasonable. Glad to know her DLA's being spent correctly after all when spent on the dog. I still don't think she should be paying for all essentials as well. Fancy living on over 3k a year?

OP posts:
Vapeyvapevape · 26/01/2022 12:46

Don't make their life any more difficult than I'm sure it already is.

Hankunamatata · 26/01/2022 12:41

Yabu. Loads parents use dla for everyday living for their child. It's to be spent for nieces benefit on neice which is being done - its not nieces pocket money