Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think

84 replies

namechangemango · 26/01/2022 12:17

that this is not an appropriate use of my niece's DLA money?

My niece (16) is diagnosed autistic and has an emotional support dog. She gets DLA. She has told me that her dog had to go to the vet and my niece has billed her for it. It turns out my sister has had my niece pay for the cost of the purchase of the dog and all her toys and equiptment like her crate etc out of her under 18's trust fund, which has completely depeleted the balance and there are no plans for it to be replaced. My sister justified it to my niece that she needed the dog so it was an appropriate use of the money, Now I've read that under 18's aren't legally responsible for dogs.

Niece is also being charged for essential toiletries like face wash and clothes/shoes when they (genuinely) need replaced, travel etc. There has been words that there is going to be discussion of niece paying for her share of every other essential expense including food, and non essentials.

Her DLA amounts to a bit over 3k a year, she can't get a job at the moment due to continuing education. Sister doesn't earn much money herself.

I feel I should report this but sister would know it was me and I'm estranged from most other family (on my side) as they are toxic. Without getting into details she's been supporting me with personal issues

OP posts:
CeleriacOfTheNight · 26/01/2022 18:51

You are being unreasonable, they are a low income family budgeting accordingly- they aren't swanning off to the Canaries on it.

You also make yourself look a bit silly when you change your story.

melj1213 · 26/01/2022 18:50

I know many people have said that the mum should be paying for toiletries, but it’s not always the case with someone who has ASD or SPD.

I do think that parents should provide or cover the cost of basic hygiene items but if the person in receipt of DLA or PIP needs specific items/brands then their DLA/PIP should be used to pay the difference.

So, for example I always buy whichever toothpaste is cheapest on offer but if DD could only use Colgate original then I would expect a DLA/PIP payment to pay the £1.50 difference between my £1 own brand and the £2.50 Colgate but I would be putting the £1 towards the cost as that is what I would otherwise pay for toothpaste.

Likewise with soap/shampoo - I'm not brand specific so will buy whatever is available but if DD wanted a specific soap/shampoo then I would buy it but she would have to pay the difference out of her pocket money.

LonginesPrime · 26/01/2022 18:49

[quote namechangemango]@melj1213

she has to pay for her share of bills including what you have said, 'Council tax, water, gas, electricity, Internet'. Literally her share of everything. It's no wonder she's been crying. People on minimum wage have more than her to live off[/quote]
Her share of council tax?

So £0 then.

namechangemango · 26/01/2022 18:47

@namechangemango

Oh stop it.
yes there are going to be discussions about it and from that point she will be made to pay for those things.

OP posts:
gettingolderandgrumpy · 26/01/2022 18:47

Op stop you’ve already said your sister doesn’t earn much so your niece getting several hundred pounds a month while your sister is struggling. She’s 16 so that money is technically your sisters until your niece is 18 . My son gets pip it goes to me for whatever I need for him I’d be bloody fuming if some nosey sod questioned what I spent it on .

TheVolturi · 26/01/2022 18:44

[quote namechangemango]@melj1213

she has to pay for her share of bills including what you have said, 'Council tax, water, gas, electricity, Internet'. Literally her share of everything. It's no wonder she's been crying. People on minimum wage have more than her to live off[/quote]
You actually said they were going to be having conversations about this, have we time travelled into the future?

namechangemango · 26/01/2022 18:41

@melj1213

she has to pay for her share of bills including what you have said, 'Council tax, water, gas, electricity, Internet'. Literally her share of everything. It's no wonder she's been crying. People on minimum wage have more than her to live off

OP posts:
Bookaholic73 · 26/01/2022 18:32

I know many people have said that the mum should be paying for toiletries, but it’s not always the case with someone who has ASD or SPD.

My son has autism, and his sensory issues mean that he is incredibly sensitive to smells & textures. So his PIP pays for his specific toiletries and toothpaste, because it’s so expensive.

The rest of the family are happy to use the cheap stuff from Aldi, whereas his costs about 4x as much. IMO, that’s a very fair use of his PIP.

SeasonFinale · 26/01/2022 18:27

You seem to be looking for reasons or excuses as to why you may be reasonable but you are not and indeed just making yourself look worse.

TheLovelinessOfDemons · 26/01/2022 18:24

Is appropriate use of DLA different from appropriate use of PIP? DS 10 has been known to ask to treat us all to McDonald's with his. Adult DS spends a large proportion of his PIP on Lego.

Svadhyaya · 26/01/2022 18:20

I don't see a problem with it. It's no different to a neurotypical 16 year old having an allowance or a Saturday job. It sounds like Dsis is trying to teach DN about budgetting.

gettingolderandgrumpy · 26/01/2022 18:18

It’s nothing to do with you op , don’t you dare report this what a mean interfering sister you are . Benefits are used for whatever they want unless they are using it to fund their heroin habit then keep out of it .

melj1213 · 26/01/2022 18:10

@namechangemango

Niece was crying to me about how she doesn't know how she'll pay for all essentials and non essentials on 3k a year. So that includes all basic food, basic clothes/shoes/coat, travel, everything. Which feels very mean, and not her responsibility. Sister has been giving her the money to manage. I'm just parroting what I've been told.
So basically she's worried about having to budget ... your DSis could just put the money into the family pot to account for your DNs expenses but instead she has given her the money and told her she has to budget her expenses out of that money.

That is not unreasonable at all, although your DN clearly needs more support to sit down and work out a budget - I earn not much more than NMW and once I have paid the rent and essential bills (Council tax, water, gas, electricity, Internet) I have not much more money than your DN to cover food/transport/clothes/socialising etc for both DD and I so a 16yr old should be more than capable of funding herself from the money she gets, she just needs to be shown how to budget.

TheFormidableMrsC · 26/01/2022 18:03

Also in your OP you said your niece was being "charged" yet now you are saying that her mum is giving her the money to manage herself so she's not being charged is she? It's not the same thing by a long shot.

TheFormidableMrsC · 26/01/2022 17:59

@namechangemango

Niece was crying to me about how she doesn't know how she'll pay for all essentials and non essentials on 3k a year. So that includes all basic food, basic clothes/shoes/coat, travel, everything. Which feels very mean, and not her responsibility. Sister has been giving her the money to manage. I'm just parroting what I've been told.
So on the back of a 16 year old telling you this, you decided that you were going to report your sister for misappropriation of the DLA. It sounds to me as if your sister is trying to teach her some responsibility, the value of money, the value of budgeting which is exactly what I'll be teaching my son when he's old enough to be responsible for his DLA.
namechangemango · 26/01/2022 17:58

Yes. Told by the 16yo

OP posts:
QuiteAtALoss · 26/01/2022 17:44

Told by the 16yo? Hmm

namechangemango · 26/01/2022 17:41

Niece was crying to me about how she doesn't know how she'll pay for all essentials and non essentials on 3k a year. So that includes all basic food, basic clothes/shoes/coat, travel, everything. Which feels very mean, and not her responsibility. Sister has been giving her the money to manage. I'm just parroting what I've been told.

OP posts:
Svadhyaya · 26/01/2022 17:36

Presumably the DLA goes into your sister's account so she isn't 'charging' niece for the toiletries as such, just paying for them out of the DLA that has been paid in (possibly because there's not enough money in there otherwise)?

XenoBitch · 26/01/2022 17:36

YABVU it is absolutely none of your business. Your niece has been assessed and awarded DLA, and that is the end of it.

TheFormidableMrsC · 26/01/2022 17:28

@namechangemango

You must've overlooked it as I did say in my OP that there is going to be discussion of my niece contributing. Which includes food and bills out of her dla, and paying for all essentials including prescriptions and all non essentials.
And what of it? This is really none of your business and you just sound jealous that they have what you perceive to be "extra money".
melj1213 · 26/01/2022 17:03

@namechangemango

You must've overlooked it as I did say in my OP that there is going to be discussion of my niece contributing. Which includes food and bills out of her dla, and paying for all essentials including prescriptions and all non essentials.
Why should your DN not contribute to the household? £3k a year is £250 a month or just over £60 a week ... what else do you think your DN should be spending her DLA on if it doesn't go towards the costs of her dog and paying for personal toiletries and expenses she is incurring, including prescription charges?

At 16 I had a part time job while I was at school and whilst I didn't pay board to my parents that money basically covered everything that was above and beyond food, bills, school supplies and basic clothes (ie school uniform and anything I needed like a warm coat and basic tshirts/jumpers/jeans/dresses but if I wanted specific brands or if I just wanted a new tshirt but all of the ones I had were still in good condition then I had to buy it myself) - so all toiletries, clothes, books, magazines, socialising etc came out of my wages and pocket money I saved up.

Presumably your DNs autism means she is unable to get a part time job so instead she has DLA to cover her "wants" ... however if the household is on a tight budget then she needs to contribute too especially if any bills are increased because if her disability - eg my nephew has a disability which means he really feels the cold so there is always a heater on 24/7 so part of his DLA goes towards the increased heating bill - if he wasn't home then my DB and SIL would have the heating off and just put on a jumper if they were a bit chilly.

BlankTimes · 26/01/2022 16:44

Even if they were better off you are not allowed to save DLA money

But no-one checks.

The only time saving it is relevant is if it puts you over the threshold for claiming other benefits that are means-tested.

I recall a case where a lady thought she was being very frugal and scrimped to save her non-means tested benefit for years, then was horrified to see all her means tested benefits stop when she was over the savings limit, it's around £16K IIRC.

BooksAndHooks · 26/01/2022 15:44

@HollaHolla

I think trying to keep a family of (at least) 3, and a dog, on £20k a year must be really super tough. If they were better off, then I would say to put the cash away for her, and make sure she had money for the future; but they don't have much spare cash, by the sound of things, and the DLA going on the assistance dog sounds fair enough, as it's something to help her with her autism. I would say that asking her to contribute to other essentials probably would be a bit 'tight', but if you don't have the money elsewhere, you don't have it. I think you'd be VU to report her.
Even if they were better off you are not allowed to save DLA money.
BooksAndHooks · 26/01/2022 15:43

@namechangemango

You must've overlooked it as I did say in my OP that there is going to be discussion of my niece contributing. Which includes food and bills out of her dla, and paying for all essentials including prescriptions and all non essentials.
Not much different to going in the family pot to allow a parent to give up work to provide care. Which is also a legitimate use. If household finances are limited because of caring responsibilities it can be used to compensate as it is to the persons advantage that the Carer is providing care rather than working more.