Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - using the name Madeline

286 replies

Argealanlea · 26/01/2022 10:59

First pregnancy and DH and I so far can only decide on one name for a girl - Madeline. We love it and it goes really well with our surname.

Issues are:
Madeline McCann. Is it too associated with her to use? We actually live in Ireland not U.K. so there is maybe less of an association but could still be there? For me already saying the name in my head with our surname lessens the connection so maybe it’ll be the same for all our family and friends?

Second issue - Madeline the books/movies which feature a red head Madeline. We actually have a 50% chance of having a red head. Would this be bad then to use the name and risk teasing or am I overthinking it and kids don’t read those books anymore anyway and the movie is old!

Cant decide if we’re being unreasonable to consider it - we both really like it! Sad

OP posts:
Benjispruce5 · 26/01/2022 12:57

I didn’t even connect the name to the event until I read your full post and I am well aware of the tragedy as I have a daughter the same age. Sadly lots of tragedies involving children of all names have occurred, this one was high profile.
It’s a beautiful name.

Argealanlea · 26/01/2022 12:57

I agree with others madeleine mc cann does come to my mind but I’d be hoping like every name once you know someone with it you start associating it with them. I do think the media coverage isn’t done yet either. Already though after a few days of thinking about the name with our surname the connection has lessened for me.

Re spelling this doesn’t bother me. As someone with an Irish name I’ve always had to spell it out or say now it’s pronounced. Everyday pretty much on my year abroad but it doesn’t bother me as I like my name.

Thanks to the poster who gave the Irish spelling. Also one to consider.

And the poster who said there’s a thread in baby names. I’ll check it out. Maybe it’s coming back around if more people are considering it.

OP posts:
WhosThatBehindTheFlask · 26/01/2022 12:54

I also worked with a Paul McCarthy and tbh, after the first couple of weeks never thought of the Beattle of the same name.

In fact, when I heard the name on the TV or radio my first thought was "what's PAUL doing on the telly?!?" Grin

Dixiechickonhols · 26/01/2022 12:53

I think some names are just so linked with certain cases that people will make name association years later. Myra springs to mind too.
I personally wouldn’t but I suspect if you do chose name it would soon become Maddie anyway so not the same connection.

WhosThatBehindTheFlask · 26/01/2022 12:53

If it helps, OP, I read the title thread and my first thought was not Madeleine McCann. I opened it assuming it was a 'there is already a Medeline in my family' type of thread.

Onairjunkie · 26/01/2022 12:53

I know so many girls called Madeline/Madeleine. I didn’t ever think of McCann. If you like it, use it. It’s not that uncommon though if that’s something that bothers you.

dowhattyougotttado · 26/01/2022 12:52

I have a Madeleine, nobody ever mentions Madeleine McCann and never did when we picked the name.

Icantrememberthenameoftheartis · 26/01/2022 12:52

Someone up thread has said it’s ok so long as you’re name isn’t McCann which reminded me I went to school in the 80’s with a Ruth Ellis (same name as last woman to be hanged in UK), also a Michael Jackson.

Getyourjinglebellsinarow · 26/01/2022 12:52

Unless your last name starts with Mc then absolutely go for it, it's a lovely name and unfortunately every name has someone who has been involved in something tragic it shouldn't stop the name being used entirely.

cookiemonster2468 · 26/01/2022 12:51

I think you are overthinking it on both counts. It's a lovely name. I met someone with this name a few months ago and I didn't think of either of those references, I actually thought of the french madeleine cookies which are delicious! Grin

SleepingStandingUp · 26/01/2022 12:50

Just think how popular the name Jack is, despite him being a mass murderer. Victoria is beautiful, it isn't just associated with Victoria Climbie. Rose is lovely and Fred is gaining popularity. Their crimes were heinous. Not sure on the popularity of Jessica and Holly as names but I doubt anyone would cite those girls as reasons to avoid it. It's the same with Madeline.

Icantrememberthenameoftheartis · 26/01/2022 12:49

My DD has a Madeleine in her class(not sure on the spelling) and I’ve never made the connection with Madeleine McCann. Everyone calls her Maddie.

I wouldn’t worry if you like the name then use it.

QuentininQuarantino · 26/01/2022 12:47

I think YABU but then I have a red headed Madeline!

PrettyBluebells · 26/01/2022 12:47

I don't immediately associate it with McCann as I know others. I do know a Madison too, she gets Maddy. It's a variation on a theme.

Hellosunshiner · 26/01/2022 12:46

I know a young Madeleine and I can honestly say I only see her as Madeleine in her own right and don't think of any other Madeleines when I think of her or see her. It's a beautiful name, if you love it, use it.

mistermagpie · 26/01/2022 12:45

I loved Madeleine but we have a Mc surname so I just couldn't do it.

In your case I wouldn't worry about it. I've never heard of the books or the film you mention either so I doubt that will be a problem.

Go for it!

Saddlesore · 26/01/2022 12:44

It's a beautiful name. If someone associates it with a tragic case, that's their issue, not yours.

SnipSnipMrBurgess · 26/01/2022 12:43

I'm irish in ireland and there are two in my daughters class. One is madeline and the other is maddie. Never even thought about it tbh.

The case is obvs well known here too, but I always associate praia de rocha with the situation rather than the name. People will make their own associations.

FawnFrenchieMum · 26/01/2022 12:36

There is one in my DD class, I have never though of the McCann connection and I've never heard of the books your referring to.

RoyalCorgi · 26/01/2022 12:34

It's a lovely name, and I wouldn't worry about the Madeleine McCann connection.

However, I would perhaps stay clear of lumbering your daughter with a name that she's going to have to spend the rest of her life spelling over the phone. Smile

Alayalaya · 26/01/2022 12:34

It’s a lovely name. I know a couple of women called Maddi and nobody ever mentions McCann. Especially if you’re using a shortened version on an everyday basis nobody will notice.

dottydodah · 26/01/2022 12:30

I would think of poor Madeleine Im afraid .Ben ,Holly Jessica and Sarah are in much more common usage .Madeleine stands out for me .We have had about 15 years of coverage of this poor child ,it doesnt seem to want to end any time soon sadly . I feel dreadfully sorry for her parents ,and the fact they are constantly being made out as bad parents ,for a terrible unfortunate misjudgement on their holiday so long ago.

Incywinceyspider · 26/01/2022 12:28

The only way the connection to the McCanns will go away is if people start using the name again, so go for it. By the time she's old enough to have heard about the connection I imagine it won't be as significant anyway

WhyYesYABU · 26/01/2022 12:24

I wouldn't make the connection and think its a lovely name. I also love the book and think a red headed girl will enjoy seeing 'herself' in a book. But I have an unusual name and always longed for representation somewhere...or at least to be able to buy a 'personalised' pencil case/headband off the shelf like all the other cool 90s kids had.

ButterOllocks · 26/01/2022 12:24

Personally I would not, for 2 reasons, she will spend the rest of her life spelling it out to people, (I know this because my parents named me Jacqualine - and I've spent all my life with incorrect spellings) and because of the McCann connections .
It's a truly pretty name, but needs consideration.