Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - using the name Madeline

286 replies

Argealanlea · 26/01/2022 10:59

First pregnancy and DH and I so far can only decide on one name for a girl - Madeline. We love it and it goes really well with our surname.

Issues are:
Madeline McCann. Is it too associated with her to use? We actually live in Ireland not U.K. so there is maybe less of an association but could still be there? For me already saying the name in my head with our surname lessens the connection so maybe it’ll be the same for all our family and friends?

Second issue - Madeline the books/movies which feature a red head Madeline. We actually have a 50% chance of having a red head. Would this be bad then to use the name and risk teasing or am I overthinking it and kids don’t read those books anymore anyway and the movie is old!

Cant decide if we’re being unreasonable to consider it - we both really like it! Sad

OP posts:
T00Ts · 26/01/2022 14:13

People will be making you feel worse on here @Argealanlea. I can’t imagine anyone flinching away in horror when you introduce your lovely new baby, because a child was abducted 15 years ago.

Yes, it was super high profile, but so were the West murders and I know a little Fred and two little Roses, so were the Soham murders but I know two Hollys and a Jessie, so was Harold Shipman killing off patients but I know a new baby Harold!

To me it is illogical to can a name you adore because someone was killed with that name once, we could probably find atrocities linked to every name of everyone’s children on here.

And your baby will have the name in her own right, and her own little path and achievements will completely override any connection someone may have (if they even have it, I and lots of other posters haven’t when we’ve met new Madeleines) in relation to the McCann case.

And if someone persisted in linking your child to that because of her name, that is frankly their odd problem and I’d suggest removing them from your life.

PAFMO · 26/01/2022 14:08

@TrufflesAndToast

I adore the name Maddy but wouldn’t dream of using it because its association with MMC is just far too strong. It’s literally the first thing 99% of people think of when they hear the name.
It literally isn't. It may have been for people closely following the case 12-13 years ago.

Do you find the names Jessica or James similarly unusable?

Gilly12345 · 26/01/2022 14:05

I personally wouldn’t use the name, it is unusual but the connection will always be there and also double whammy the red issue, sorry.

There are hundreds of names to choose from.

AryaStarkWolf · 26/01/2022 14:02

@PattyPan

I actually have worse associations for Madison *@Sunny987654* - Ashley Madison
Never heard of Ashley Madison
PattyPan · 26/01/2022 14:01

I actually have worse associations for Madison @Sunny987654 - Ashley Madison

T00Ts · 26/01/2022 14:01

@FinallyHere

My first thought was Proust , but then I'm a big fan of cakes
Moi aussi.
marmitegirl01 · 26/01/2022 13:57

My daughter is named Holly. There was another high profile case with one of the girls involved having that name around the time she was born
We have never had adverse reaction to calling her that.
You’ve picked a beautiful name

Regularsizedrudy · 26/01/2022 13:57

Madeline is mad a LINE. Madeleine is mad a LYN

dowhattyougotttado · 26/01/2022 13:56

@TrufflesAndToast

I adore the name Maddy but wouldn’t dream of using it because its association with MMC is just far too strong. It’s literally the first thing 99% of people think of when they hear the name.
It really isn't Hmm
Esmereldapawpatrol · 26/01/2022 13:54

I have school ages children and there are two Madeline (Maddie's) at school and I don't think it is weird they have used the name.

What is a bit weird is one of the Mum's is obsessed with the Madeleine McCann case and knows A LOT of facts and details.

Also I don't know of the book/film Madeline so I suspect quite a few others don't either.

Sunny987654 · 26/01/2022 13:53

Could you use Madison instead? That way you could still call her Maddy.

Chasingaftermidnight · 26/01/2022 13:53

It’s a beautiful name - really elegant and classy.

I really don’t think it’s irretrievably associated with Madeleine McCann. But even if it is, it’s not like she was a bad person who did anything wrong, or she was kidnapped because she was named Madeleine.

If you’re not happy with Madeleine how about Evelyn? (Just suggesting it because I think it’s an equally beautiful name and it sounds a bit similar!)

MadeleineForThisThread · 26/01/2022 13:49

Madeleine here, so very much qualified to comment on my name Grin

I was born in 1975 and only met one other Madeleine until I was 30. Now my daughter's best friend is a Madeleine (post-McCann) and my neighbour's daughter is a Madeleine (just pre-McCann) and occasionally I hear others calling their little daughters by the name when I'm out and about.

I wouldn't worry about the McCann link, no-one has ever mentioned it to me in connection with my name, possibly because I'm older, but I gather from the parents of the younger ones that it doesn't really come up.

Re: pronunciation, my parents always intended me to be Mad-elaine. We lived in France for a while when I was a child and everybody I knew there pronounced it as an odd mix of Mad-elaine and Mad-e-lin. Historically in Britain it was pronounced Mad-elaine, the Mad-e-lin is a more recent style and more Americanised (yes, I have done lots of research on my name through history and culture Smile )

I'm also known as Maddy, and Mads. It should really have been Maddie give that it contains an I and and E and no Y, but my mother's name has a Y and she wanted it to be like hers, so it's always been that way.

I never disliked it as a child but now as an adult I love it. It's different but not unheard of, and classically French. Go for it OP. Call her Madeleine and she's bound to be delightful Wink

Snorkmaidenn · 26/01/2022 13:46

It's a lovely name and never thought of connection until you mentioned.

Everyone has a name they don't like for some reason that they associate with a person they know .

AryaStarkWolf · 26/01/2022 13:45

@HeyGirlHeyBoy

Love it. Unlikely to be shortened to Maddie in Ireland, imo.
Why do you think it would be unlikely to be shortened to Maddie in Ireland? I don't know any real life Madeline's but Irish people shorten names too
StellaGibs · 26/01/2022 13:45

Youre overthinking it

ElftonWednesday · 26/01/2022 13:43

The cartoons were shown on Tiny Pop ten years ago, so it's not that dated.

ElftonWednesday · 26/01/2022 13:42

YANBU to use it unless your surname is McCann. It's a lovely name, though I prefer Madeleine as a spelling.

It reminds me more of the Madeleine cartoons or the cakes. All positive associations!

AIBU - using the name Madeline
AIBU - using the name Madeline
twilightermummy · 26/01/2022 13:41

My brother and I used to get up early on a Sunday to watch Madeline! We absolutely loved it. I also love red hair. I can’t imagine that many would make the connection now, it’s pretty dated.

However, I agree with another poster. I’d be far too superstitious to use the name and I think people would think of Madeleine McCann unfortunately. It was/is such a huge case.

JudgeJ · 26/01/2022 13:40

@Soubriquet

I would use it. It will probably be shortened to Maddy and no one has a problem with that
Whatever name you choose make sure you're comfortable with the abbreviations, nicknames etc associated with it, it really doesn't matter of you say 'I don't want it shortened or nicknames used', it will be once the child is away from you!
TrufflesAndToast · 26/01/2022 13:38
  • SleepingStandingUp

TrufflesAndToast
I adore the name Maddy but wouldn’t dream of using it because its association with MMC is just far too strong. It’s literally the first thing 99% of people think of when they hear the name.
That's quite some hyperbole. Just read this thread. It literally isn't.*

As I very quickly realised in my follow up post Grin

Rainallnight · 26/01/2022 13:36

I know a Madeline in Ireland and no one at all makes that connection (I am Irish)

solbunny · 26/01/2022 13:35

I wouldn't automatically think of madeleine mccan personally, but maybe that's because I have a friend named madeleine.

I did think of the lovely film Madeline which is one of my all time favourites from my childhood! However I'm in my mid twenties and none of my friends were familiar with the film when I mentioned the film to them once.

Also, if you're pronouncing it MadeLIEn rather than MadeLIN then I think that lessens the McCann association somewhat.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 26/01/2022 13:30

Love it. Unlikely to be shortened to Maddie in Ireland, imo.

themerrywifeofwindsor · 26/01/2022 13:30

Madeleine was one of the few names that DH and I could agree on. Unfortunately, our last name is McCann. Otherwise we absolutely would have used it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread