Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU Not To Support Them

91 replies

SereWontSleep · 25/01/2022 18:45

Oldest DC is almost 20. They have said they are ftm since they were about 15. At the time I thought it was just for attention. DC would flip flop of if they were ftm or if they just wanted to be with someone of the same gender.

DC moved out when they were 18 years old. Every few weeks DC would post a very passive aggressive post about being ftm on facebook. The last line was always along the lines of "Come at me. Tell me what you really think." I would never comment on these posts as I always thought facebook was not the place to hash out what I thought about it.

So on to today. DC posted on facebook that they will be going to a medical appointment to start on male hormones on Feb 10. Now, DC is almost 20. They live on thier own and make their own medical decisions.

Whether or not I agree with the transition is not something I want to debate. I have my opinion, but I still love my DC and will no matter what they decide to do.

Since DC moved out at 18; they have struggled with paying their bills. DC even had to move back in for 6 months at the begining of 2021.

For the last four months DC has not worked. Myself and my parents have been paying for food and utilites for DC and their significant other. Significant other's parents have been paying their rent.

DC messaged me last week to ask for money to pay a vet bill for their cat.

My AIBU is I have considered cutting DC off financially. The medical treatment they are wanting it private pay. My thought is is that if they can afford to have elective medical treatment done, then they should be able to pay for food and rent for themselves.

What are your thoughts?

I am not wanting to discuss whether or not I agree or disagree with DC being transgender. The only thing is if AIBU to cut DC off financially.

PS. I think I have left information out, but I"m not sure what that is. If you have questions please ask. I could use some outside advice on how to deal with this financial situation.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Beowulfa · 26/01/2022 09:26

So this person isn't adult enough to manage their own finances and be a responsible pet owner, but is making life-altering decisions about serious surgery and medication? Do their medical team know about the marijuana use (and its related mental health effects)? I suppose this isn't a medical specialisation famed for its high level of ethics.

OP, I fear you'll be made out to be the Bad Guy whatever happens.

SleepingStandingUp · 26/01/2022 09:23

DC, I've seen your post on FB re paying for the medical treatment so assume you've now sorted your fiancé's and no longer need us to buy you food. I'm happy you've managed to find a way to support yourself.

whenthedoveslie · 26/01/2022 09:15

@Meandthesky

They both need to grow up, get jobs and pay their own rent and bills

YANBU to stop funding free loaders

Agree completely!
HollowTalk · 26/01/2022 09:13

Wouldn't the cost of medically transitioning be an absolute fortune in the USA? How on earth are they thinking they can afford that? Personally I would never pay for my child to do this, mainly because I think it would just be wrong but also because I think in the future there are going to be a hell of a lot of court cases about this and I'm sure parents who pay for the operation will be first in line.

gabsdot45 · 26/01/2022 09:12

Please stop financially supporting them. My parents financially supported one of my siblings for years including helping them to buy a house and when the money ran out and they couldn't help anymore my sibling behaved terribly and there was a huge falling out. He hasn't spoken to my parents for 3 years except to argue and they're heart broken.

rookiemere · 26/01/2022 09:07

The transitioning is a red herring. The real issue is your DC and their SO are relying on everyone else to pick up their cost of living and spending their own money on dope and takeaways.

Just stop funding with immediate effect ( except for cat food obviously) . It's up to everyone else if they keep bank rolling the moochers, just let them know that you won't be doing it anymore.

Your DC may well bad mouth you on SM but so what, you're a person not a walking cheque book.

Alpinechalet · 26/01/2022 09:01

Your DC and their SO are taking everyone for a ride. You do need to start managing their expectations.

I would start a conversation saying when you are 21 we will stop funding you. As an adult you are expected to stand on your own two feet and support yourself.

After this date if they beg or plead for money for x, depending on the situation you could agree to pay direct e.g. give me the vets details and I will pay them for the cat. Do not give them cash directly. I would suggest to your parents and SOs parents that they also take this approach.

They will probably scream and shout and say hurtful things. They may possibly go NC but you need to do this for their sake. If you don’t do it now their dependency on you and others to fund their lifestyle will only grow. Ask yourself if I don’t do it at 21 what age would I do it 25, 30, 50?
Part of being a parent/grandparent is helping (making) children grow up and become independent adults. To do this you sometimes need to take a tough love approach. Hard to do in the short term but beneficial in 5he long term beneficial.

BlowDryRat · 26/01/2022 07:41

Your last post is appalling. What a brat! She doesn't need your money. Talk to your parents, explain that their financial help is actually not helping and ask them to stop too. You can't do anything about the SO parents.

Porcupineintherough · 26/01/2022 07:30

So are you asking whether you should stop supporting your dc with their bills? And what does this have to do with their choice to present themselves as a man?

You dont have to keep giving money but, if you dont, what sort of relationship are you going to have? Is there anything left? You certainly dont seem to like them much.

RedHelenB · 26/01/2022 07:20

You might not want to say it straight but basically you don't want any of your money to go towards gender reassignment surgery it's plain that's what the problem is from your OP and when you stop giving money it will be plain to your child too. So maybe rather than make excuses you need to have a conversation about it all with your dc.

KTheGrey · 25/01/2022 22:48

Also if you have younger children - are you going to contribute this generously to them as well? It's going to get quite pricey.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 25/01/2022 22:14

@Stoop

Transitioning stuff aside- there is no way I would be financially supporting two adults when they’re not even working.

Transitions stuff-
There’s no way I’d financially support my daughter in butchering her own body needlessly.

This
Mummabug18 · 25/01/2022 21:36

@PrincessPaws

The transition piece is irrelevant, the two free loading young adults would be the reason I would cut them off. If they want to live like adults, they need to work to pay for it (and if they can't work, they need to claim benefits and live within their means)
This. What is in their heads/hearts and their pants has nothing to do with them being irresponsible piss takers. I moved out at 18 with a 2 months (out of over a year) rent debt to my 'mother' vs my friend who always had her parents cover her ass, especially when her daughter was born and she just wanted to party. She always treated them like mucky rugs. There is a fine line between supported and spoiled that you need to get on the right side of or DC will never grow up.
Getyourjinglebellsinarow · 25/01/2022 21:27

Making it about their transition is the problem. You shouldn't be cutting g them off because of their medical decisions. But they're adults that need to at least be trying to support themselves financially

AmandaMirandaPanda · 25/01/2022 21:18

Based on your update at 19:26:19, there's a combined income of $2300 a month and fixed monthly expenses of $160 (assuming the $90 is bus passes for both), since rent, utils, food, and DC's mobile are all paid by family. That's a surplus of over $2000.

If all of the subsidies stop, they're still bringing in $2300 and paying out a known $1035. That leaves $1265/mo to cover food, utils, DC's mobile, and any other recurring expenses. Can it also stretch to the vet's bill and the hormones, and perhaps to a minimum monthly payment against DC's debt? DC & partner really need to make a budget and stick to it. If what they earn can't cover their fixed costs, they have to either figure out how to bring in more or how to spend less, or both. The budget can include an amount for ad hoc non-necessities like marijuana and doordash, but only if something else changes to accomodate that.

I don't know that I'd use the term "cutting (you) off" when you talk with DP about this, but do say clearly that the current situation can't contine. It's great that the couple have so many adults willing and able to help financially - they are only 20 and the economy is bad - but get them on a even keel supporting themselves, and then be there for an emergency, a loan for something they need and have asked you to consider, an occasional gift, etc. Can you get your parents on board with this too? E.g., it's not that they can't treat and even spoil their grandchild, but do it in a planned and responsible way.

I also would not mention the hormone therapy, except as one of many budgetary expenses if you end up getting into details. It sounds like that one expense was the last straw for you, but I think you'd have had a similar reaction if it had been, say, a big trip or an expensive luxury item. Keep in mind that from DC's perspective the hormones probably are a necessity rather than a luxury and may even seem like the first step to a better life including a better job. But plenty of expenses are necessities, and they still have to fit into the budget somehow.

TheWeeDonkey · 25/01/2022 21:16

The guy I know who sends the PA Facebook posts started on his GM when his mother tried to extricate herself from the situation. You mention marijuana, it's much stronger that the stuff that was around even in the 90s, enough to affect a person's personality and cause the kind of behaviour you mention.

The behaviour and incidents you described sound so familiar to me. This behaviour can't be indulged or encouraged, I'm sorry this is so hard but you need to be tough for your child's sake.

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 25/01/2022 21:15

@SereWontSleep - I am so sorry, this sounds like a horrible situation for you. I would guess that DC and/or SO believe that life has been hard for them and they are therefore entitled to special treatment. And that things that they would have a meltdown about if it was done to them should just be ok if they do it. I hope your parents will also see sense and stop enabling. It is undoubtedly hard for people with gender dysphoria (and I have no doubt that is a real thing and that people really suffer), but I also think that MH, gender dysphoria and attention issues are also used by people who have a generally entitled view of life to excuse their bad behaviour and demand preferential treatment.

SereWontSleep · 25/01/2022 21:00

I have wondered for awhile if DC would cut contact.

There was an incident right have Christmas where my mother and I were taking DC home. (DC lives 40 miles away and no public transit) DC got mad as halfway to DC home we had to turn around due to deteriorating road conditions. (Snow making it too bad to drive).

DC screamed bloody murder all the way back to my home, telling DC grandmother (my mother) to Shut up Shut up Shut up.

SO also texted me while I was driving accusing me of kidnapping DC. I saw this when I got home as I was not going to look at it while driving.

The next day when weather was better we were able to get DC home.

DC was told that there would be no more rides anywhere and don't even ask. DC didn't talk to me for a week after this. Instead DC called my parents to pay for things. I'm surprised that they did considering the yelling DC did at my mother.

My mother even appologized at getting mad at DC. I told my mother that she should not have apologized as DC should not have been screaming at everyone to shut up and to take her home immediately. Even if it meant my mother and I would get stuck in the snow or possibly get into an accident because of road conditions.

At this point I had cut down contact with DC as I wasn't going to indulge in that kind of behavior.

No with the post and the money I realize I am a mug. I am letting DC walk all over me.

I can't do that anymore as I have an 18 month DD at home that is watching what I do.

OP posts:
AffIt · 25/01/2022 20:57

@Zeewest

Assuming they are in UK why aren't they getting universal credit? That would pay the rent and some living money!!
The OP has said several times they are not in the UK and quoted figures in dollars.
Zeewest · 25/01/2022 20:56

Assuming they are in UK why aren't they getting universal credit? That would pay the rent and some living money!!

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 25/01/2022 20:56

Medical care is very expensive. But they have two completely discretionary expenditures (drugs and pets) that are not necessary. Responsible adults understand if you cannot afford something you cannot do it. They have not got it yet. The only way they will is if you withdraw support. However, you will be in the position of being the scapegoat if the others keep paying, and it will probably be blamed on transphobia. They have already shown themselves to be manipulative, so the likelihood that they will accept that they are taking the piss is vanishingly small. Sorry. I would phase out what you pay as soon as possible. And tell the others that you are doing so.

moomee12 · 25/01/2022 20:53

Why on earth do you give them money when they're spending all theirs on weed and take aways?

No wonder they're taking the piss.

QueeniesCroft · 25/01/2022 20:38

You obviously need to stop funding them, but there will (equally obviously!) be a major tantrum over that.
I think you should work out a way of wording it, so that they can't make this about you being against the transition. Given that they seem quite keen to paint themselves as a persecuted minority (from the Facebook posts picking a fight about it), that might be tricky. But regardless of identity, any able-bodied adult should be paying their own bills and buying their own food.

Brace yourself and prepare for drama, and probably for them cutting contact for a while. It will be hard on you, but the alternative is to give them everything they demand until you die, I'm afraid.

WonderfulYou · 25/01/2022 20:22

Why does DC only work PT?

Surely if they want more money they need to get a FT job.

I’m not against helping people financially but they need to learn to budget for their own good.

Tilltheend99 · 25/01/2022 20:16

They should pay their own rent and bills but I don’t think you should bring up the cost of the medical procedure regardless of if they are paying privately. It comes across as though on a subconscious level you think that cutting DC off now will prevent them going through with this transition you are not entirely sure about.

If you can afford to keep helping them out can you discuss stopping this after their procedure? It is presumably better to give them warning anyway rather than just cutting them off out of the blue as it may take a while to find new jobs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread