Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that my friend is being ridiculous?

357 replies

qwerty1129 · 25/01/2022 15:41

DS is 5, 6 next week and I've been with my boyfriend for over a year but he doesn't live with us yet, he stays over a few nights a week and he always puts DS to bed when he does (DS asks).

On Saturday, my friend was here and so was my boyfriend. Boyfriend went to put DS to bed and I was with my friend, he had been a while so I went upstairs and he was asleep with DS cuddled up to him so I let them sleep.

I told my friend and she said it was ‘weird’ and I shouldn't let DS get attached to boyfriend as he isn't his real dad and he sees his dad (only once a month, sometimes not at all so he sees boyfriend more often).

Aibu here or is my friend being ridiculous?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PurpleMauve · 27/01/2022 18:48

The naivety of some people is shocking. Protect your children always.

AutomaticMoon · 27/01/2022 18:35

*‘Well no, they don't.
They win if we let them molest our children. Not if we keep our children safe.’

This, a million times!

Waxonwaxoff0 · 27/01/2022 16:57

[quote Marmarind]**@CowboyJo I'm a single mum, I will never introduce a man to my child. That does not mean being single forever, it just means I won't force any relationship I have on my child as well. Keep it separate.

Good for you. For many people, their step-parents are their real parents. My cousin's birth dad isn't involved, his mum married my uncle and had their own child together, he has known the non-bio kid since he was about 2, he adopted him. Guess what? He is that non-bio child's dad in the same way he is his bio child's dad, he treats them both equally and they are a successful blended family.

Likewise, I was raised by my step-grandfather! I don't know my dad or my bio grandfather on either side, so he has always been "my real granddad" and what a shame it would have been to be deprived of these things. He is a wonderful man and has supported me and brought so much good into my life. He treated me as he would have treated his bio grandchildren.[/quote]
That's great for you. But that is not always the case, my own stepfamily situation was horrendous and culminated in me leaving home at 17 as I felt unwelcome in my own home. Not a chance am I going to take that risk with my own child.

GreyCarpet · 27/01/2022 16:47

[quote Marmarind]**@CowboyJo I'm a single mum, I will never introduce a man to my child. That does not mean being single forever, it just means I won't force any relationship I have on my child as well. Keep it separate.

Good for you. For many people, their step-parents are their real parents. My cousin's birth dad isn't involved, his mum married my uncle and had their own child together, he has known the non-bio kid since he was about 2, he adopted him. Guess what? He is that non-bio child's dad in the same way he is his bio child's dad, he treats them both equally and they are a successful blended family.

Likewise, I was raised by my step-grandfather! I don't know my dad or my bio grandfather on either side, so he has always been "my real granddad" and what a shame it would have been to be deprived of these things. He is a wonderful man and has supported me and brought so much good into my life. He treated me as he would have treated his bio grandchildren.[/quote]
I agree. My son's stepdad is the only one he's ever known. We split up when my son was 12 and he paid maintenance until he was 18 and is still his dad 5 years on. That will never change.

But we took it very slowly.

Marmarind · 27/01/2022 13:38

@CowboyJo I'm a single mum, I will never introduce a man to my child. That does not mean being single forever, it just means I won't force any relationship I have on my child as well. Keep it separate.

Good for you. For many people, their step-parents are their real parents. My cousin's birth dad isn't involved, his mum married my uncle and had their own child together, he has known the non-bio kid since he was about 2, he adopted him. Guess what? He is that non-bio child's dad in the same way he is his bio child's dad, he treats them both equally and they are a successful blended family.

Likewise, I was raised by my step-grandfather! I don't know my dad or my bio grandfather on either side, so he has always been "my real granddad" and what a shame it would have been to be deprived of these things. He is a wonderful man and has supported me and brought so much good into my life. He treated me as he would have treated his bio grandchildren.

Marmarind · 27/01/2022 13:32

Nor relatives either? Babysitters? Nannies?

No. None of those people have any need to cuddle a 5 year old in their bed.

That's unusual. My grandmother has babysat for me on the odd night and she would get into bed with DD because DD still to this day (6) likes to be cuddled and stroked to sleep after her story. She will struggle to go to sleep otherwise. It wouldn't occur to me to ban trusted family members from doing so.

Fair enough, 16 months is a bit soon for this imo, but I similarly think those saying 16 months is too soon to meet a boyfriend bizarre too.

Marmarind · 27/01/2022 13:24

it's not a blanket ban. And no-one's depriving him of snuggles. He can snuggle with his actual parents

At what point does it become ok to move in, marry, and actually be a step-parent that can do these things with the child if the child wants?

Marmarind · 27/01/2022 13:20

Stop letting men who are not your childrens father into their lives!!! Please stop.

Good men exist that can help raise children who aren't their own.

Silversprinkles · 27/01/2022 12:39

@girlmom21

It's just that if we allow the sickness of perverts to dictate everything we do in life, they win, don't they?

Well no, they don't.
They win if we let them molest our children. Not if we keep our children safe.

Once again for those of the hard of thinking persuasion
BertramLacey · 27/01/2022 08:55

There must be better approaches than a blanket ban on all contact. I'd hate to deprive my child of genuine snuggles on the basis that there are certainly some maniacs around.

It's not a blanket ban. And no-one's depriving him of snuggles. He can snuggle with his actual parents. What he shouldn't be doing is snuggling with his mum's boyfriend. This isn't a hardship. It's a way to teach him to have boundaries and a sense of his own bodily autonomy. Not only will he then be able to avoid any maniacs, he'll also be able to deal with the common or garden creeps, of which there are many. He'll have a better respect for the bodily autonomy of others as well.

Why such binary thinking? Why the assumption that ensuring appropriate behaviour from the boyfriend is somehow depriving this child of something? It's not that there are just a few maniacs and everyone else is fine. There are many points in between those two states and it helps to be able to spot what you're dealing with and put measures in place to stay safe.

rattlemehearties · 27/01/2022 07:36

I'd not freak out about it being creepy, but I would think it's not ok for your DS to bond with your boyfriend so closely after less than 2 years. If you break up he will feel bereft, he should be shielded from that by not getting too close

QuillBill · 27/01/2022 07:35

It reminds me a bit of my dad refusing to let us have pets when we were kids, on the basis that it would be too upsetting for us if a much-loved animal died.
It's not even vaguely the same. Apart from 'child doesn't get what child asked for'. It's not the same as not letting them climb a tree in case they fall out.

Adults don't go to bed with children unless they are their parents. Or at least their primary care givers. You don't blur lines like that.

"Surely if a child has been brought up to understand boundaries and communicate any doubts, a trusted friend should not be viewed as a potential threat? Snuggles like this are, or should be, among the joys of childhood."

And you don't put the responsibility of not being molested by an adult in a child. Are you saying there is no such thing as grooming? Are you saying a child should push past a man who tries to get in his bed in his own bedroom in his own home and race to tell his mother! And if he doesn't he wasn't listening when he was being taught about boundaries?

sunsshineshowerss · 27/01/2022 07:18

YABU - friend is spot on.

Completely inappropriate l, also find it odd that he prefers a man of 16 months to put him to bed instead of his mum and primary caregiver.

girlmom21 · 27/01/2022 07:15

It's just that if we allow the sickness of perverts to dictate everything we do in life, they win, don't they?

Well no, they don't.
They win if we let them molest our children. Not if we keep our children safe.

milkyaqua · 26/01/2022 23:16

We all have the stories about the woman we knew vaguely who...

Actually, I'm just trying to maintain a level of privacy over the internet.

I don't think we do all "have the stories"... Clearly all the women minimising this behaviour by the OP's boyfriend do not have any idea of the potential for this sort of thing, or the prevalence of it.

Alcemeg · 26/01/2022 21:41

@milkyaqua
Ugh, of course I know these dreadful things happen. We all have the stories about the woman we knew vaguely who... etc etc etc. It's just that if we allow the sickness of perverts to dictate everything we do in life, they win, don't they? There must be better approaches than a blanket ban on all contact. I'd hate to deprive my child of genuine snuggles on the basis that there are certainly some maniacs around.

Re kids getting attached, I can understand that a rapid succession of "daddys" isn't the best idea, but I don't understand this "ah, but you must wait xxx years before introducing them" because no one can guarantee the outcome of any relationship, can they? (Even with the original "daddy"?!) It reminds me a bit of my dad refusing to let us have pets when we were kids, on the basis that it would be too upsetting for us if a much-loved animal died. There's an argument for that being a good way for children to learn about death... and maybe, along similar lines, there is no harm in learning about how human relationships can change over time (handled maturely, obvs). Over-protection can result in a kind of sterile isolation.

I think the most useful thing we can show our kids is not to pretend that life is simple and easy, but to maintain emotional stability in the face of all the difficult and unpredictable challenges that arise.

milkyaqua · 26/01/2022 21:09

[quote Alcemeg]@milkyaqua
This was hardly a "new man" or a random stranger.[/quote]
It is new in terms of introduction to small children who may become easily attached. Usually, considerate parents wait a fair while before introducing a new partner to such children. They certainly don't have the doing bedtime rituals or curling up in bed with them.

A woman I knew vaguely had a relationship with a young, handsome, gentle-seeming and intelligent man. He molested her little children. When she threw him out and told everyone she could, no-one seemed to believe her. He then moved in with another woman in that circle, and molested her toddlers. She couldn't cope and killed herself after she found out.

This and many memories of my own informs my comment.

Alcemeg · 26/01/2022 21:00

@milkyaqua
This was hardly a "new man" or a random stranger.

milkyaqua · 26/01/2022 20:49

@Alcemeg

Surely if a child has been brought up to understand boundaries and communicate any doubts, a trusted friend should not be viewed as a potential threat? Snuggles like this are, or should be, among the joys of childhood.
Snuggles with new men in mummy's life? Snuggles with swim coaches, and sporting coaches, and teachers, also?

The fact the OP is miffed and incredulous that her friend pointed out this is not a good idea suggests this child will not have been modeled boundaries at all.

RealBecca · 26/01/2022 17:32

I wouldn't even introduce someone to my children as my boyfriend after a year. Your friends heartbisnun the right place.

betwixtlives · 26/01/2022 17:30

fucking yikes. your friend is right, listen to her

2Gen · 26/01/2022 17:26

YABU and your friend is right. I am disturbed that your bf is putting your child to bed and even more so that he was asleep in the same bed as him. Please, please put a stop to it and do the night time routine yourself. You could let your bf read your DC a story with you present but everything else should be done by you alone. Your bf might be perfectly innocent but the being in bed asleep with your DC is a red flag to me. Please put your child first and take over from today onwards!

EllaVaNight · 26/01/2022 17:14

Also your boyfriend should not be putting himself in a situation where he could be accused of abuse.

And please believe your child if they disclose anything to you.

You and your boyfriend need to get some boundaries. Please protect your child, he is relying on you to do so. He deserves protection from potential abuse.

EllaVaNight · 26/01/2022 17:12

From a child sexual abuse survivor please, please safeguard your child.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 26/01/2022 17:06

@Alcemeg

Surely if a child has been brought up to understand boundaries and communicate any doubts, a trusted friend should not be viewed as a potential threat? Snuggles like this are, or should be, among the joys of childhood.
A 5 year old does not understand these things. It's up to the adults to act appropriately.
Swipe left for the next trending thread