Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find this effing unbelieveable **MNHQ adding content warning for CSA**

216 replies

Imnotafemistbut · 25/01/2022 13:12

A man has raped a child and walks free from court as the judge appears to blame the child.

courtnewsuk.co.uk/rapist-walks-free-after-judge-says-12-year-old-was-sexualised/

OP posts:
VanGoghsDog · 25/01/2022 15:34

@aristotlesdeathray

Well on an app for adults it's odd to think anyone should ID their dates

So I can fully understand and agree with this ruling

What????
skodadoda · 25/01/2022 15:33

@spikesonbuildings

At first I thought this was victim blaming shite, like people come out with when they read Lolita, but having read the article it appears the Judge accepted that he genuinely did not realise her age. It says she had her own car and place to live and presented herself as an adult on the dating app. The Judge also acknowledges this girl is vulnerable. But her judgement was based on her believing he did not realise her age. She was almost 13 and some girls that age do look like adults. She is obviously a troubled child, but this does not appear to be a case of an older man knowingly taking advantage of a child.
I’m inclined to agree with this
longwayoff · 25/01/2022 15:32

I thought we'd heard the last of blaming the child for the adult's actions after Rochdale. Evidently not. 12 YEARS OLD. Ffs. And he's immature for his age? What? That balances things out?

StellaGibs · 25/01/2022 15:26

@Imnotafemistbut

I assumed that I'd be addressing adults.
How can you post this then follow with such a callous response?!
aristotlesdeathray · 25/01/2022 15:25

@Puzzledandpissedoff

Attending the sessions are a condition of his suspended sentence

I'm aware of that, aristotle, but wouldn't quite say it was pointless to wonder what'll happen if he doesn't attend them - even allowing for what's supposed to follow

You think people regularly don't follow strict conditions of suspended sentences and nothing happens to them? Confused
Puzzledandpissedoff · 25/01/2022 15:24

Attending the sessions are a condition of his suspended sentence

I'm aware of that, aristotle, but wouldn't quite say it was pointless to wonder what'll happen if he doesn't attend them - even allowing for what's supposed to follow

CorrBlimeyGG · 25/01/2022 15:15

What sort of World do we live in, that 12 year old children are deemed mature enough to pass for over 16?

That would be the real world. It has been the case for years. It's not victim blaming to remember being that age, and acknowledging our own situations and maturity.

Each case needs to be judged according to the individuals involved. There's so much wrong with the background to this case, the sentence is not one of those things.

aristotlesdeathray · 25/01/2022 15:14

@Puzzledandpissedoff

The people who have interviewed the man are all agreed that he is very immature for his age

Hence no doubt the 48 "maturity sessions" which have reportedly been arranged

Two things occur to me ... firstly what the chances are of him actually attending them, and secondly what message he'll take away from all this, beyond believing that all he has to do in future is swear "I thought she was 16"

Attending the sessions are a condition of his suspended sentence

So your view he won't attend them is a bit pointless

aristotlesdeathray · 25/01/2022 15:14

@Cantleave

So you think it's impossible that there are any 12, nearly 13 year olds out there that can pass for 16?

Bullshit

Cantleave · 25/01/2022 15:11

@ABCeasyasdohrayme

There really is no end to the blame of women and girls for our own rapes and assaults.

There is no way this man thought that a 12 year old was an adult, absolutely no way, 'immature' or not.

I agree with this, but it seems that a lot of other posters don’t, and actually think that his sentencing was appropriate! Bloody hell, talk about “victim blaming!”

What sort of World do we live in, that 12 year old children are deemed mature enough to pass for over 16?
Doesn’t help either, that the Judge was a female!

Puzzledandpissedoff · 25/01/2022 15:11

The people who have interviewed the man are all agreed that he is very immature for his age

Hence no doubt the 48 "maturity sessions" which have reportedly been arranged

Two things occur to me ... firstly what the chances are of him actually attending them, and secondly what message he'll take away from all this, beyond believing that all he has to do in future is swear "I thought she was 16"

alexdgr8 · 25/01/2022 15:10

i heard on the radio that there are organised crime gangs in romania who are grooming children aged 8, as part of a production line to bring them to uk aged 12 to work as prostitutes.
we don't know the background of this case.
maybe she was trafficked and went awol.

AlDanvers · 25/01/2022 15:10

@longwayoff

Useless judge. Wonder what's on his laptop.
That makes no sense. The defendant was looked into and no evidence of him being a paedophile was found.

What do you think they would find that would make the judge want to give him a lighter sentence?

astoundedgoat · 25/01/2022 15:05

[quote Porcupineintherough]@emuloc no they are not. How many 12 year olds with the conversational abilities of an adult do you know?[/quote]
None, but the people who have interviewed the man are all agreed that he is very immature for his age.

His own eloquence in conversation might not be much beyond that of the child herself. If they were just talking about computer games, hanging out with friends, going to the park/shopping centre there might not have been much noticeable difference that he could see.

She pretty clearly HAS been groomed and abused, though, if not (intentionally) by this man, and hopefully is now safe. His involvement is not blameless, but I think she has encountered some pretty evil men already. Hopefully the focus will now be on bringing them to justice. The poor poor child.

PippaPotter · 25/01/2022 15:03

@Imnotafemistbut I assumed that I'd be addressing adults.

What a dick thing to say. This forum is full of rape victims, women who experienced abuse as children, survivors of violence at the hands of men. Women who deserve a fucking trigger warning and don’t need to be told that they are adults so they should just deal with it. Ffs.

aristotlesdeathray · 25/01/2022 15:01

@longwayoff

Useless judge. Wonder what's on his laptop.
Confused
CorrBlimeyGG · 25/01/2022 15:01

@longwayoff What are you insinuating about the judge? Most on here agree with her rationale, are you accusing us all of having something untoward on our laptops?

Gonnagetgoing · 25/01/2022 14:59

@BellaElla99

I can believe this. My friends and I definitely looked around 16-17 when we were 12-13. We had all had sex and would always be chatted up in london by guys who were 16-22. We used to find it really fun driving around with these older boys smoking and drinking, I guess it made us feel older and we were looking for attention. We would lie about our ages to get free lifts often in return for sexual favours. My friends mum was a single mum working really long hours so we often had the flat to ourselves and would invite guys around to drink/smoke with us. It’s so sad thinking back to how we used to be but I don’t think any of the guys that we did have sex with and lie about our ages to could have been to blame. We were all tall, very well developed and unfortunately thought having sex would get us free alcohol etc and make us more grown up. Hopefully the girl will receive some support from the sexual exploitation teams and social services to help her with this but I do not feel it is victim blaming. I had lots of support from social services during this time of my life and I wouldn’t have wanted any of the men I slept with to go to prison for it.
@BellaElla99 - same we looked about 18 when we were 12-13 upwards and though I didn't lose my virginity until I was almost 15 my 2 best friends lost theirs at 12 and 13/14 respectively.

Coupled with one mother who didn't really care and the other who was out all day a lot working plus 'open house policy' it's not surprising what happened. We weren't tall just average heights but had boobs and bums etc and we wanted boyfriends.

Poor girl who did this.

Grenlei · 25/01/2022 14:57

There's no victim blaming.

As a pp said, referring to the child as sexualised is a statement of fact. The average 12 year old might be on social media, Tiktok, Insta etc. Not on Tinder actively looking for sex.

The Defendant spent 7 months in custody, given that and the prevailing circumstances a community order seems entirely appropriate. Had he been white and middle class he almost certainly would have been on bail for 7 months not on remand.

longwayoff · 25/01/2022 14:57

OK. Her laptop.

longwayoff · 25/01/2022 14:56

Useless judge. Wonder what's on his laptop.

Wreath21 · 25/01/2022 14:54

I think there is a substantial difference between acknowledging the specific circumstances in which a young man mistakenly believed the girl he met was older than she was - and had no desire or intent to abuse a child - and victim-blaming or enabling a predator. Unfortunately some newspapers love making clickbait out of complicated and unusual cases.

AlDanvers · 25/01/2022 14:48

The op of this either didn't read the story or started this for other reasons.

Because I can't see anywhere where the judge appears to blame the child at all.

AlDanvers · 25/01/2022 14:45

@Puzzledandpissedoff

How on earth did a 12 year old have a car and a 'place to live'?

Apparently she was living in a car, having been chucked out of her home, as opposed to driving it round with a licence

Glad I'm not the only one who noticed the judge is female though ...

No she didn't.

He was living in a car. He was kicked out.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 25/01/2022 14:45

The 12 year old wasnt living in a car. The accused was

Ah - apologies if I got that wrong then, but I could have sworn I read it was the girl herself (will try to find it again ...)