Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find this effing unbelieveable **MNHQ adding content warning for CSA**

216 replies

Imnotafemistbut · 25/01/2022 13:12

A man has raped a child and walks free from court as the judge appears to blame the child.

courtnewsuk.co.uk/rapist-walks-free-after-judge-says-12-year-old-was-sexualised/

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 25/01/2022 17:21

@EdenFlower

If he genuinely believed the girl was 16 and he didn't force her to have sex then I don't see how it can be classed as rape. Who asks for proof of age before before sleeping with someone.

It sounds like the young man, who was 19 at the time, might have some 'learning needs', why else would the judge deem him so immature?

Because sexual penetration with a child of that age is rape. End of. She CANNOT consent. The issue is then what sentence etc the Courts give.
Allsorts1 · 25/01/2022 17:15

He was convicted and sentenced appropriately for the crime. He was 19 at the time and the judge says:

Judge Freya Newbery said there was 'no suggestion' Mascall had 'any paedophile tendencies at all' - adding that he thought she was an adult because 'she had a car and a place to live'.

'What there is instead is a young man who is relatively ordinary, immature and possibly naïve,' she said.

Would it be better for him to be locked up and the key thrown away, to destroy another young life forever when he is at no risk of reoffending (according to the judge)?

EdenFlower · 25/01/2022 17:08

If he genuinely believed the girl was 16 and he didn't force her to have sex then I don't see how it can be classed as rape. Who asks for proof of age before before sleeping with someone.

It sounds like the young man, who was 19 at the time, might have some 'learning needs', why else would the judge deem him so immature?

WonderfulYou · 25/01/2022 17:07

Just a sad story all round, shows the importance of boys not just getting informed consent, but making sure the girls can give consent, which can be a challenge when you can get false ID for less than £20.

I agree but if she’d had a fake ID people will still question whether he knew it was fake and make out like he’s a peado still.

esloquehay · 25/01/2022 17:05

Let's hope the young man in this situation receives any support he might need, as well.

WonderfulYou · 25/01/2022 17:04

@Omicrone what part of my post is victim blaming?

He was 19 and thought she was 16. Not sure why you’re trying to imply he knew otherwise.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 25/01/2022 16:59

I could easily pass for 16 at that age .

As for her conversational skills, have you met some 19 year old boys?

I have a 19 year old , his friends range from great to talk to really sensible young men right the way down to like speaking to my 11 year old and behaviour to match!

JudgeJ · 25/01/2022 16:55

@whiteworldgettingwhiter

Are you seriously saying you can't tell the difference between a 12yo girl and an adult woman, *@ILoveAllRainbowsx*? Hmm
I have seen girls of that age from my school out in the evening and my OH has been shocked when I've told his their age. Some people on this site seem very naive though it's good to read so many confessing their own youthful mistakes.
Unsure33 · 25/01/2022 16:53

@Monkey2001

This is a tragic story, we don't know enough about the girl to understand. As a 12 year old, her side of the story needs to be kept confidential.

It is shocking that a not-very-bright student who met up with someone on Tinder, believing her to be a consenting adult could have his life wrecked because he believed her lies. It appears that he was straight with her. I have also seen 12/13 year olds who look much older than they are.

It is also shocking that a 12 year has lost her childhood and felt that it was appropriate to be on Tinder.

Just a sad story all round, shows the importance of boys not just getting informed consent, but making sure the girls can give consent, which can be a challenge when you can get false ID for less than £20.

Exactly , actually quite a terrible experience for the boy involved .

I hope the girl is getting the appropriate support. It’s a very sad case.

Nanny0gg · 25/01/2022 16:52

@Omicrone

Why has the world suddenly turned so thick, and all our human recognition skills have suddenly just switched off?

Apparently it's impossible to tell who are men and who are women, and now it's Apparently impossible to tell who are 12 year old children and who are adults?

Have you seen some 12-year -olds lately?

Instagram and TikTok have a lot to answer for.

Unsure33 · 25/01/2022 16:51

@SleepingStandingUp

Do typical 12 year olds living in supportive loving homes come across as mature as 16 year olds? No. Although my niece was 11 when I got married and in her bridesmaid dress, make up and fancy hair she'd easily pass physically.

But this child isn't a typical girl fro ma loving home. There's no mention of her situation but she's posing on Tinder pretending to be 16+ and inviting men to come to visit her for sex. There's a hell of a lot of back story that will make her act and sound older.

I think the judges sentencing is probably fair. He didn't groom her. He didn't go in Tinder looking for sex with a child. Her actions gave the impression that she was older. He hasn't been found innocent, but she's accepted that this wasn't rape with intent to rape.

I only hope that the help given to him is reflected in this poor girl getting some intervention and supoort

Yes I wonder if some of the posters objecting would feel the same if it was their 17 year old son who had met and dated her .

I promise you my niece when she was 12 or 13 could have easily passed as 17 or 18 . She was fully developed and very confident and loved all the attention .

No one meeting her in a pub would have guessed at all .

Nanny0gg · 25/01/2022 16:51

@whiteworldgettingwhiter

So the judge said: 'What I do know is that you were described by the first probation officer as presenting as immature even for your young age' to the rapist - yet she said that the victim was 'sexually suggestive'.

Lots about the rapist's 'supportive family'; nothing about the poor girl's family.

I wonder why. She has been let down.

Ridiculous victim blaming.

She had been kicked out by her parents and was living in a car (another reason he thought she was older apparently) I hate to think what kind of upbringing she had and how it can be undone.

What we don't know is what has happened to her since (hopefully now being Looked After)

JudgeJ · 25/01/2022 16:51

Anyone with sons needs to make sure they’ve asked for ID before they go anywhere because it’s literally on them to prove everything.

If she is savvy enough to convincingly fake everything else, age, car house etc etc then faking ID would be a breeze.

Nanny0gg · 25/01/2022 16:48

@Cubit

I think it sets a worrying precedent, the onus was on him to confirm she wasn't a child - he didn't.
Does every person on Tinder ask for ID when they meet up with someone?
Nanny0gg · 25/01/2022 16:47

@sillysmiles

Even if he thought she was 16. He's 20. At 20 a 16 yr old is much younger - generally still in school, not sat state exams yet. 20 - finished school, working or in trade or in 3rd level education.

So how did he not cop a 12 year old?

He was 19 at the time, the girl was on Tinder (so he wasn't looking for underage) and some 12 year-olds would pass for 16.
Monkey2001 · 25/01/2022 16:41

This is a tragic story, we don't know enough about the girl to understand. As a 12 year old, her side of the story needs to be kept confidential.

It is shocking that a not-very-bright student who met up with someone on Tinder, believing her to be a consenting adult could have his life wrecked because he believed her lies. It appears that he was straight with her. I have also seen 12/13 year olds who look much older than they are.

It is also shocking that a 12 year has lost her childhood and felt that it was appropriate to be on Tinder.

Just a sad story all round, shows the importance of boys not just getting informed consent, but making sure the girls can give consent, which can be a challenge when you can get false ID for less than £20.

SleepingStandingUp · 25/01/2022 16:39

@sillysmiles

Even if he thought she was 16. He's 20. At 20 a 16 yr old is much younger - generally still in school, not sat state exams yet. 20 - finished school, working or in trade or in 3rd level education.

So how did he not cop a 12 year old?

Immature 19 year old who wasn't at that point at uni and no indication if he was working. He was sleeping in his car though. Person who says she's 16+, it's on an adult dating website that isn't, AFAIK, known as a paedophile haven, dresses like a 16+, acts in a sexually mature way, who may be more sexually experienced than him, who has photos of her car and own place. 19 year old who's been quite babies, it's markedly immature for his age vs a 12 year old who's likely been groomed previously, who actively sought sex on an adult platform, and who knows how to pass for older. It isn't that unbelievable in the real world.

Tragically sad and I hope the victim, this young girl, is given the help and support she needs to process this and move forward

Cubit · 25/01/2022 16:38

I think it sets a worrying precedent, the onus was on him to confirm she wasn't a child - he didn't.

Whattothink65 · 25/01/2022 16:36

@Dixiechickonhols

It must be rare for almost 13 yr old to pass as 16 but not unheard of. In the Scottish case I linked it was accepted that the 12 year old passed for 16 plus. She’d been spoken to that evening by police looking for a missing girl who thought she was old enough to be out with her pal drinking vodka late at night - not a child, the taxi driver thought she was 20, judge reviewing cctv accepted she looked older, people at house party were fine she was there. Unusual but not impossible.
DH is a teacher and honestly, those kids look older than I do. It's shocking.

I tend to find a lot of the kids at 12/13 who look 18 tend to be used to hanging around with older kids and it is a big effort to appear older.

I get told I look under 16 all the time, this isn't because I'm shockingly youthful or anything, but I just have that type of face and don't wear much makeup. 12/13 year olds are extraordinary at make up.

Whattothink65 · 25/01/2022 16:33

It's awful but also sounds fair - it is exceptional. He genuinely seemed to believe she was older. Unfortunately this shows why apps and over 16 / 18 platforms need age verification.

whiteworldgettingwhiter · 25/01/2022 16:32

Are you seriously saying you can't tell the difference between a 12yo girl and an adult woman, @ILoveAllRainbowsx? Hmm

whiteworldgettingwhiter · 25/01/2022 16:31

So the judge said: 'What I do know is that you were described by the first probation officer as presenting as immature even for your young age' to the rapist - yet she said that the victim was 'sexually suggestive'.

Lots about the rapist's 'supportive family'; nothing about the poor girl's family.

I wonder why. She has been let down.

Ridiculous victim blaming.

Omicrone · 25/01/2022 16:30

Why has the world suddenly turned so thick, and all our human recognition skills have suddenly just switched off?

Apparently it's impossible to tell who are men and who are women, and now it's Apparently impossible to tell who are 12 year old children and who are adults?

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 25/01/2022 16:30

I can only go on what the Daily Mail says, but I can't see what he did that was wrong. He thought she was 16. The judge obviously believed him.

emuloc · 25/01/2022 16:29

@sillysmiles

Even if he thought she was 16. He's 20. At 20 a 16 yr old is much younger - generally still in school, not sat state exams yet. 20 - finished school, working or in trade or in 3rd level education.

So how did he not cop a 12 year old?

Have you read the whole thread? Several posters have already provided an answer to that question.