Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scaffolding on neighbours roof

134 replies

SuPerDoPer · 25/01/2022 10:29

I think I already know the answer to this but need clarification.

I've lived here for only 3 months and I'm having solar panels fitted. The scaffolders came yesterday and the area that they need to reach is very narrow and right next to my neighbours garage extension. The neighbours weren't in to ask so I was very clear that the scaffolders shouldn't put anything on the roof next door or encroach on their property. Next thing I know the neighbour has returned home to see 3 blokes on his roof putting scaffolding on his roof and has come round here fuming. I said I'll tell them to take it down and work round it but he seemed more angry about not being warned than what they were actually doing. I apologised profusely and he went off in a grump.

Today I bought a nice box of posh biscuits and went round again to apologise and offer the biscuits. This time his wife answered and kept me on the doorstep for almost 10 minutes telling me how upset and distraught she was and how worried she was about the scaffolding damaging the lead on her roof. I said I'll call them and ask them to come back and remove it but she said no it's done now but wanted to keep telling me how awful the experience was.

I realise I am at fault here but apart from making sure my workmen dont cause any further upset is there anything else I can do? Would you be this upset and distraught if a neighbour put scaffolding on your property? I'm not sure if I would give it a second thought after the initial surprise.

OP posts:
OhFuckBloodyHell · 25/01/2022 13:09

I’m not sure legally you’d be able to refuse - I think installing solar panels could arguably fall under the renewal part of the below from the Access to Neighbouring Land Act:

a) the maintenance, repair or renewal of any part of a building or other structure comprised in, or situated on, the dominant land

Surely that's only if OP already has solar panels that are being replaced, not adding a completely new thing to her property?

OP I'd listen to @chesirecat99 's very good advice. You could be in trouble here.

Dixiechickonhols · 25/01/2022 13:05

I think you need to be clear to neighbours you didn’t tell them to go onto their property. The workmen were specifically told not to. I’d also complain to solar company.
My mum is elderly and would be very shaken and upset by something like this. Worrying re roof damage.
I’d have been fuming and told you to move scaffolding immediately.

gamerchick · 25/01/2022 13:05

think giving them a box of biscuits, no matter how posh, was taking the piss a little. A £500 Amazon voucher or something might have been better, a gesture that really costs you something would show you were actually sorry

Creased. Grin man this shits funny.

OP don't sweat it, just make sure the scaffolding is taken down straight afterwards.

londonrach · 25/01/2022 13:05

If be furious but totally understand what happened. We had similar happen to us and I was furious that our roofers when we had told them not to went onto our neighbours roof. Can't believe work man think they can ignore what you say!!!!

PattyPan · 25/01/2022 13:03

@Strictlyfanoftenyears

Oh and solar panels are bloody ugly so I would definitely not have given you permission Wink
I’m not sure legally you’d be able to refuse - I think installing solar panels could arguably fall under the renewal part of the below from the Access to Neighbouring Land Act:

a) the maintenance, repair or renewal of any part of a building or other structure comprised in, or situated on, the dominant land

chesirecat99 · 25/01/2022 13:03

@HumpreyDowny

Really, a party wall agreement for scaffolding?! But why, nothing is being done to the wall? I had one done with a neighbour for an extension, it was a massive headache and costed thousands of £. Cant believe one would be required for installing solar panels, it'd put me right off...
OP would at least need a scaffold license, which is basically the same thing as a party wall agreement just for scaffolding on the neighbour's property. There should have been a record of the state of the roof (surveyor's report and photographs) before the scaffolding was erected and an agreement made that OP will pay for any damage.

This could cost you more than a £500 Amazon voucher, @SuPerDoPer. I would get some legal advice (there are often free clinics for people on a low income, you may have free legal advice with your home insurance or you could join Which Legal Advice, it's only about £10). At the very least, I would put a written complaint in to the scaffolding company stating that you told them not to erect scaffolding on the neighbour's property but they did it anyway, and they will be held liable for any damage caused and you will be claiming on their insurance. I would take photos of any existing damage on the roof and the exact placement of the scaffolding too, if you can.

If there is a claim for damages, it could all get very complicated as there is no record of the state of the roof before works started so your neighbour could claim for existing damage, and it will be difficult to know how any damage was caused, whether it was the scaffolders or the installers. I would probably get the scaffolding removed before the installation on Thursday to avoid that.

gamerchick · 25/01/2022 13:00

@Cissyandflora

Posh bloody biscuits? The cheek of it. You need to apologise profusely and keep pretending you knew nothing about it. And order them a proper huge hamper from fortnum and Masons. I’d be absolutely livid with you.
Heh that's a joke right? Who the fuck wants a hamper from there. Grin
Clymene · 25/01/2022 12:59

Scaffolders are bloody liars in my experience. They asked me if they could use my property as access to put scaffolding up in my neighbour's property. I said yes of course. Came home and they'd put the scaffolding up in my property. They had supporting beams on my shed roof. They cracked a paving slab and left scaffolding planks behind.

PearlclutchersInc · 25/01/2022 12:57

Some of the expectations on here beggar belief Hmm

If no damage has been done and you've profusely apologised then that's it (of course unless you're as rich as croesus.....)

Consider your relationship with the drama queens massacred though.

Dixiechickonhols · 25/01/2022 12:57

I think courtesy to let neighbours know before workmen there even if not on their property if it’s likely to be noisy, vans etc.
I can understand why they were fuming - workmen have come into their property and put scaffolding up. Things like flat roofs are not to be walked on.
The solar panels men sound like charlatans who knows what they might have damaged.
If I was your neighbour id want a reputable roofer to check roof for damage and you pay him. You can try and claim back from solar panels company. It covers you otherwise when they get a leak in 3 months and say it’s because of your workman trespassing it could become very messy.

HeyDiddleDee · 25/01/2022 12:54

It’s good that you’ve acknowledged this OP but you really need to emphasise to your neighbours that this was done without your permission and you are complaining to the scaffolders (and then do it). We had endless problems with contractors employed by a neighbour and he sent hampers and apologies and did lots of sad faces about how unprofessional the contractors were and it wasn’t what he expected and it drove me insane because HE hired them and therefore if they were unprofessional it was his problem to fix. Not to just keep apologising for after the fact.

Ponoka7 · 25/01/2022 12:53

They are just getting the message across that it isn't to happen again. You're a fairly new neighbour, so they are setting ground rules. No need for anything else to be done.

Gladioli23 · 25/01/2022 12:52

I'd be moderately irritated and a box of posh biscuits would seem like an excellent apology gift to me.

I can see why you didn't think, but agree more thought required another time.

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 25/01/2022 12:46

Oh and solar panels are bloody ugly so I would definitely not have given you permission Wink

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 25/01/2022 12:45

I actually cant believe that the neighbours were as nice as this. I would have insisted that the scaffolding was taken down. I would have been slightly cross if it had been put in my garden, but having it put on my roof, no way.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 25/01/2022 12:43

@Lockheart

£500 / an F&M hamper?! Is there something in the water today? That's absolute madness.

The neighbours are right to be annoyed - with the scaffolders. It's not OPs fault the scaffolders ignored her instructions and OP has been round to apologise on their behalf.

What more do you want, a pound of flesh?

This! I sometimes wonder if I read the same posts as other posters!
TeddyTonks · 25/01/2022 12:38

Also, its basic common courtesy to let neighbours know when you're having work done, how long it will take and any likely disruption, so in future I'd make sure you do this, tends to help keep relationships cordial.

Toddlerteaplease · 25/01/2022 12:35

I'd. E cross that you hadn't made more effort to check first. I would have no issue, if you'd asked.

DropYourSword · 25/01/2022 12:31

Would you be this upset and distraught if a neighbour put scaffolding on your property?

I wouldn't be upset or distraught, I'd just be seriously pissed off!!

TeddyTonks · 25/01/2022 12:29

You need to be very careful about doing work close to the boundary with your neighbours,in some cases a formal agreement may be needed. Unfortunately you have been very naive in thinking they wouldn't mind. If it were me, I'd be livid but I wouldn't harp on about it as I'm not an arsehole.

If I were you I'd make sure you check they have public liability insurance at an absolute minimum as you don't want to end up liable for any damage they might cause.

HumpreyDowny · 25/01/2022 12:23

Really, a party wall agreement for scaffolding?! But why, nothing is being done to the wall? I had one done with a neighbour for an extension, it was a massive headache and costed thousands of £. Cant believe one would be required for installing solar panels, it'd put me right off...

PattyPan · 25/01/2022 12:22

@Lockheart

£500 / an F&M hamper?! Is there something in the water today? That's absolute madness.

The neighbours are right to be annoyed - with the scaffolders. It's not OPs fault the scaffolders ignored her instructions and OP has been round to apologise on their behalf.

What more do you want, a pound of flesh?

I know! Putting right any damage yes, but nothing else is required imo.
SuPerDoPer · 25/01/2022 12:19

A £500 amazon voucher!

Aside from the fact that I don't shop at amazon the solar panels are being fitted as part of a government energy saving scheme because I'm on a low income. The biscuits weren't meant as compensation (obviously) but more of a gesture of apology. I'm pretty new to home ownership and have certainly learned to think more about any future building work.

Thank you for all the opinions, I knew that they had every right to feel upset but I would like to move on and not have this cloud neighbourly relations forever. I'll try and be a more thoughtful neighbour going forward.

OP posts:
sasparilla1 · 25/01/2022 12:13

My dh is a roofer, so I can give you information on what he does.

He does an on-site survey of every job and has enough of a knowledge of scaffold to let the scaffold company know what he needs. For more complicated access issues, then the scaffold guy will go out to have a look.

So, the important bit for you - he always speaks to the customer and the next door neighbour himself to ensure everyone knows what's happening.

The big issue at the moment is that a lot of scaffolders (like most decent construction related trades) are really busy. At the moment it's 2 weeks from asking for scaffold to be broken down.

Their property does need checking afterwards to ensure there is no damage, my husband does a walk through generally.

Aderyn21 · 25/01/2022 12:07

I wouldn't give consent for this - unless essential work (which solar panels aren't) the neighbour is under no obligation to risk their property for your benefit. You need to get that scaffolding down now, not done vague point in the future when the scaffolders cba to come back!