Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

13 year old boy pushed into a river and drowned. No prosecution. AIBU to think this was not a ‘prank’,

178 replies

RopeyRuby · 24/01/2022 21:45

Just seen this and remember the story.

The culprit knew he couldn’t swim and was old enough to understand the consequences IMO. One of the reasons for not prosecuting was it harming his ‘life chances’! What about poor Christopher who lost his? No trial so no closure for his mother.

www.google.com/amp/s/www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-60104439.amp

AIBU to think this is not right or just?

Horrific to think of the fear Christopher went through.

OP posts:
SnowWhitesSM · 26/01/2022 08:21

I think it's unfair to say that this boy (and he is a boy, 13yr olds are still children) should be punished because he would be if he was black. There's huge systematic racism within the police, that's a fact, but surely we should be raising the bar so a black boy who did this would be treated with the same common sense thinking, rather than bringing it down.

My ds is mixed race, I talk to him about what that could mean for him in terms of racism and the police. He will be more likely to be stopped and searched, he will be given harsher treatment if he does something wrong - and so are working class white boys without parents who pay things off to go away. It is unfair, that doesn't mean we should start treating everyone unfairly.

SlidingInto2022sDMs · 26/01/2022 08:17

I see we're victim-blaming now and ready to blame the mum too. "Why did Christopher's parents let him go swimming..." - obviously didn't read the articles on this case but ready to cast blame on anybody but the culprit.

Christopher went to play football, as his mum said. Plans probably changed when his friends decided to go to the river from there. Who knows if the boy who pushed him was his actual friend or just one of the boys in the group or someone he met at the river. There's no evidence to that besides that he knew he wasn't good at swimming. Christopher made that fact obvious, even if he was wearing swimming shorts. Having swimming trunks on isn't a "push me" sign and it's despicable that people keep saying he had his trunks on as if it is. We all know the outrage that victim blaming a woman for wearing a short skirt would cause.

Whether he could swim or not, it's not his fault for drowning anymore than it's a woman's fault for getting killed because she didn't learn self-defence. They're both important life skills. Blame the person who killed him - I'm sure it isn't hard for us to do when a woman/girl is involved.

People learning to swim could be an appropriate conversation to be had here if he went into the water on his own and accidentally drowned because he couldn't swim. He died because he was pushed into the river by someone who knew he was vulnerable.

Even if he knew how to swim, pushing him before he was ready would've still been a dangerous move. People should talk to their children about "boys will be boys" and "teenagers do stupid things". Don't let them raise themselves and think dangerous situations are funny. How about we have that conversation instead.

Who knows? Poor Christopher was so afraid to go in and was dithering so much (according to the articles), he probably wouldn't have gone in at all or he'd have tried to do so at his own pace. The choice was taken away from him when he was pushed.

Heartbreaking stuff. Poor mum!

thevassal · 26/01/2022 08:16

At the end of the day the decision not to prosecute was made by the cps, then reviewed by a different prosecutor, then reviewed again by the high Court. All of whom will have actually seen all the evidence unlike those commenting.

Our justice system isn't based on the family "getting their day in court". It's based on if there's enough evidence for a realistic prospect of conviction. Presumably having had access to all the evidence it's obvious to the cps and high court that no way would a jury convict a crying teenager who explains how guilty he feels about what happened, how he tried to rescue Christopher, how his life's been ruined etc (all factors his legal rep would ramp up). Christopher's family were not witnesses so wouldn't be allowed to give direct evidence about the effect this has had on them (although of course their barrister would summarise this). It doesn't matter how fair or unfair it is, that is our legal process. Campaign to change it if you don't think its right.

I can completely understand why Christopher's mother wants a prosecution. But if it was the other way round and Christopher was the pusher I'm not sure she would be so adamant about it.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 26/01/2022 08:13

To talk abut ‘laughing’ in the context of a child’s death is disgusting. Your alternative scenario is irrelevant and cruel, as he died

I used the word laughing in relation to the example which did not result in death.

I disagree on your second point. If the outcome of death is being referred to as murder, then the outcome where someone survives would be attempted murder. If the second situation is not attempted murder (which of course it wouldn't be), then the actual outcome is not murder

LegoNinjago · 26/01/2022 08:05

@OniferousWasp

Do you know what OP? If not heard the story but as soon as I read your OP, I knew the victim would be from some sort of BAME background and the perpetrator, white. People will come along and justify it in all sorts of ways but it is what it is.

His poor mother.

I agreee OniferousWasp. I thought the same. It reminded me this song by Dave He summed it up very nicely

“The blacker the berry the sweeter the juice
A kid dies, the blacker the killer, the sweeter the news
And if he's white you give him a chance, he's ill and confused
If he's black he's probably armed, you see him and shoot”

m.youtube.com/watch?v=mXLS2IzZSdg

OneTC · 26/01/2022 08:04

Prosecuting this would be compounding the tragedy I think

phishy · 26/01/2022 08:03

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz

I'd also query too, that had the boy who was pushed struggled, but was able to get himself out of the water (even with help), would him claiming attempted murder be acknowledged? Or would it be laughed at.
To talk abut ‘laughing’ in the context of a child’s death is disgusting. Your alternative scenario is irrelevant and cruel, as he died.
phishy · 26/01/2022 08:01

@OniferousWasp

Do you know what OP? If not heard the story but as soon as I read your OP, I knew the victim would be from some sort of BAME background and the perpetrator, white. People will come along and justify it in all sorts of ways but it is what it is.

His poor mother.

Agreed 💯
BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 26/01/2022 07:55

I'd also query too, that had the boy who was pushed struggled, but was able to get himself out of the water (even with help), would him claiming attempted murder be acknowledged? Or would it be laughed at.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 26/01/2022 07:55

Are 13yos actually able to rationalise the outcomes of horseplay? I know they should know "right from wrong" etc, but I didn't think foresight of things like this was locked in until early adulthood

RedHelenB · 26/01/2022 07:53

[quote Grotbag81]Very similar to a case in Bury NW.

www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/uk-news/2019/jul/04/girl-who-drowned-in-bury-river-bullied-at-school-say-family[/quote]
What were rhe details of that case? It only mentioned bullying at school, not what had actually happened?

OhWhyNot · 26/01/2022 07:51

And was it not his choice to take the risk ? It was known he wasn’t a good swimmer.

The question being asked by the family is has this case been treated fairly. No one can surely believe that we are all treated equally. If this was let’s say a white boy who went to private school messing around the local river with some young black boys all friends but not so privileged to go to the same school would we have the outcome. No I don’t believe we would

SnowWhitesSM · 26/01/2022 07:49

Poor Christopher.

I have a 14yr old boy. When he's with his friends they all act like they're in the inbetweeners. I could imagine my ds or any one of his friends giving their friend a push who was dithering.

What I want to know is why did Christophers parents let him go swimming in the river when he couldn't swim? I take my dc our kayaking in rivers in summer and there's older YP 16+ by themselves but 14 seems very young to be going swimming in the river without an adult around. Last year when dd was 15 I still made her wear a life jacket when floating/swimming in the river and she's a strong swimmer!

malificent7 · 26/01/2022 07:24

Very tragic behaviour but kids push each other on water all the time. This time it went wrong.Awful for everyone.

2bunny · 26/01/2022 07:03

I don't think it that clean cut, something similar happen to me on a lodge/fishing area, I was looking over the edge bit and a friend pushed me but was ment to keep hold of me ( as a made you look jump scare) but didn't have a good grip on me and I went in I can't swim and since faster than the titanic rock, luckily some men where fishing and got me out, its some that has stuck with me but I would never blame my friend it was just messing around with each other not realising there own strength at how hard they pushed me and there panic at not being able to keep a good grip on me,

FitAt50 · 26/01/2022 06:46

@OhWhyNot

You don’t think pushing a boy into a river who you know isn’t a good swimmer is boys will be boys silly prank behaviour. This wasn’t a swimming pool he was pushed into that isn’t funny or silly what would you say if you heard your child had done that

At least let this go to court and the evidence is fully heard the poor family deserves that

He had swimming shorts on and was going to jump in himself. This was not a case of some evil boy pushing him fully clothed into a river. They were all going swimming.
GalacticGoddess · 26/01/2022 06:43

That poor boy. And his family

There should have been some consequence to this, maybe not a harsh sentence but some major work done with him, but lack of resources, and a general lack of just outcomes for BAME people as a whole, and society buying into the idea of 'horseplay' adds to the culture of kids behaving dangerously and cruelly with each other.

More education on the dangers of pranks/drowning/extreme horseplay is needed also for our young people. So much daft stuff online and dangerous challenges.

DeeCeeCherry · 26/01/2022 06:25

OniferousWasp
Do you know what OP? If not heard the story but as soon as I read your OP, I knew the victim would be from some sort of BAME background and the perpetrator, white.
People will come along and justify it in all sorts of ways but it is what it is.

His poor mother.

Same. I read this post and immediately tbought I know this is a Black boy, and the perpetrator is White.

Lo and behold

Hont1986 · 26/01/2022 01:51

You still don't understand. The defence of horseplay is a defence against those kinds of charges. There's no point charging people and spending public money on a trial for a charge that there is a clear defence to.

notallpeoplearenice · 25/01/2022 23:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Hont1986 · 25/01/2022 23:34

@notallpeoplearenice

You are wrong.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consent_(criminal_law)#Horseplay

notallpeoplearenice · 25/01/2022 23:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

TokenGinger · 25/01/2022 22:59

This is a helpful article from 2020 on Black people and swimming:

"Black and minority ethnic children and young people are at <a class="break-all" href="https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/drowningwww.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/drowning" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">increased risk of drowningg* – especially among the company of others, and among their white peers. Most drownings in the UK happen in inland areass* – such as rivers, reservoirs and lakes – and according to the most of those who do drown didn’t have any intention of getting into the water in the first place..*"

Full article: gal-dem.com/black-people-cant-swim-is-a-stereotype-but-it-can-also-be-deadly/

nalabae · 25/01/2022 22:12

when i was a teen we were with some other teens who drove onto a train track and the car broke down, we saw the train coming and the car started shortly after, we found it funny at the time, we were 14 and the boys were 17/18

teens do a lot of stupid things

nalabae · 25/01/2022 22:11

that poor mother, i hope shes okay