Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to make 8.5YO DD anything else for dinner?

136 replies

user1488481370 · 24/01/2022 19:33

I spent over an hour making dinner tonight in a freezing cold kitchen with no heating.

DD didn’t touch hers, didn’t even try it. Demanded I make her some super noodles instead and then hit me because I wasn’t getting up to do it straight away. I told her she can go into the kitchen herself and make some toast if she’s hungry with that attitude. She’s sat sobbing and I feel awful now 😫

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Embracelife · 26/01/2022 09:02

*dcs have had their toys damaged"...

Agree with pp who said serve food they like
Make home a safe place
Do not yell
Everyone is reacting to stressful situation
But op is the adult
Seek help and support
Don't stop soft play but use the opportunity to listen and engage

granny24 · 26/01/2022 09:02

Listen to user. Much the best advice.

Embracelife · 26/01/2022 08:57

@user1488481370

We’ve recently had to move house thanks to violent and aggressive behaviour from our in-laws. The DC’s didn’t witness any of the violence as such but they’ve been glared at, shouted and sworn at and had their toys damaged/defaced. BIL also has a criminal record for GBH against DP (DD’s dad) which happened before DD was born but was fetched into conversation recently when BIL was confrontational with DP and said ‘I only hit you because you gave our mother a black eye,’ which was completely false. DD was very upset by this and asked me if it was true to which i told her it wasn’t, otherwise daddy would’ve had the conviction not her uncle.

I can honestly say DP has never raised a hand to myself or our children and if he ever did we’d be gone the same hour!

The attitude from DD isn’t new, the hitting out is. She’s always been strong willed but up until last year I’d have always said she wouldn’t hurt a fly.
I’ll be honest and say I don’t always deal with things in the best way with her. We have two other very young children, I’m often rather fraught, still haven’t properly unpacked and have a tendency to yell when I’m overwhelmed (this is usually after several attempts of being calm and trying to explain things nicely) but I definitely don’t help the situation at times.

The school DD attends has also had a major change round (they’ve changed buildings completely) and she’s really struggled with this, usually she wouldn’t bat an eye about it.

There is clearly a lot going on This was behaviour as communication This was not about food She is 8 Stay calm Listen , go for a walk with her let her talk Read "how to talk so kids will listen" Say "We do not hit" calmly

She s heard adults talk about hitting people

Take her to soft play and engage try to listen to the bigger picture of her feelings and life
See family therapist with her

NoOtherShadeOfBlue · 26/01/2022 08:49

Your parents were unkind to you and you want to be the opposite for your daughter. But ut isn't kindness to let children have all the control - choosing dinner, giving commands and hitting when they don't get their way. It's kind to enforce boundaries, teach empathy and gratitude and have rules. Sometimes we think we are being kind, loving parents because we give in instead of being inflexible and angry like our parents were. It really isn't. There has to be a middle ground. It does kids no favours going into school when they're the ones used to giving the orders at home. For her own sake, she needs to know better.

Mummyoflittledragon · 26/01/2022 08:31

In regards to putting things on her plate she doesn’t like, that’s how I parent, I always put a little bit of everything on their plates… I’m not going to stop doing that.

This worked as long as your dd felt safe. She doesn’t feel safe right now and you admit that yourself:

she’s gone from a very happy, well-behaved little girl to angry, sulky and short-tempered within a matter of months

She has had a lot of change and witnessed nasty abuse. This means she needs extra loving care, not a mum, who is doing what she’s always done.

She’s already struggling and have taken something away she was really looking forward to you. It would have been far better to have discussed the hitting and attitude with her. And looked at your behaviour as well. Not adapting to her suffering is punishing her for being abused.

You said yourself your parents were very harsh. Not adapting your parenting when your child is crying out is also very harsh. Do you want your kids to grow up believing their mum is harsh?

I’ve always said I’ll cook one meal and one meal only. I just hate the idea of sending her to bed hungry.

Right now you need to parent differently. I don’t think you should 100% have red lines right now. At the very least, the meal should be something familiar, which makes her feel safe.

My mother had the ungrateful child, you had it so much better than me attitude toward me. Except I didn’t have it better than her. She learned the concept of unconditional love, which I never had. Don’t be that mother comparing their childhood to yours and setting your benchmark as better than your mother so all fine.

RobertSmithsLipstick · 26/01/2022 08:16

Yelling?
The op said she had told her daughter she wouldn't be cooking anything else for her.

RantyAunty · 26/01/2022 08:09

She's witnessed a lot of abuse.

I don't understand the concept of repeatedly making something you know she doesn't like. Why would you keep putting the bits she doesn't like on her plate when you know she doesn't like them?

Do you make things you and your DH don't like and keep serving it up?

Can you make things that everyone reasonably likes? or just not put the parts she doesn't like on her plate?

And try to stop yelling at her so much. It's really scary.

Aspergirl77 · 26/01/2022 07:11

I cook one dinner for the family, if our 2 sons (13 &10) turn their noses up at dinner time and either pick about with it or leave it (which is extremely rare tbh), they’re asked to get down from the table and not offered an alternative. I’m not a monster though as I’d never let them go hungry, I usually wait a reasonable period of time e.g. after all the tidying up is done and I’ve had a cuppa, and I offer a light snack like fruit and yoghurt, toast or some cereals. We’ve always had this approach and it’s worked well for us, as it has allowed us to be firm about the ‘consequences’ of not trying/refusing foods whilst not starving them! Smile. As they’ve got older I’ve also got them involved in meal planning for the week and this has helped them think about the reasons why we have various dinners (each of us has meal preferences and we have to be considerate of that). They think it’s great when it’s their choice served up for dinner!

PinkSyCo · 26/01/2022 04:26

Agree with this. Poor kid is lashing out because she's stressed and 'hangry'. Just give her noodles or toast or whatever you know she'll eat for a quiet life.

Fucking hell. 🤦🏽‍♀️

PinkSyCo · 26/01/2022 04:24

Did she have a snack after school, or has she waited since school to eat?

I know my DC is a different person when tired & hungry like me

The kid’s 8. Kids of that age are allowed, nope scrub that, SUPPOSED to be hungry before dinner ffs.

anotherbloodyyearofcovid · 26/01/2022 03:02

@sadpapercourtesan

It sounds like there is more going on than just a poorly-received meal. You're cooking in a freezing kitchen with no heating, you must be stressed out and it sounds as though she might be as well. I would make her some toast, then sit down with her for a proper talk about how she's feeling and what led to the outburst - as part of that of course she would be sternly reminded that hitting out is never the right answer. I would probably not punish her, though. I'd be more interested in helping her understand and manage her feelings, because she's struggling to.
Agree with this. Poor kid is lashing out because she's stressed and 'hangry'. Just give her noodles or toast or whatever you know she'll eat for a quiet life.
Fromthebirdsnest · 26/01/2022 01:34

You seem like a fab mum so I won't talk about how to deal with the hitting etc as you seem to have it under control and understand that it's not right , sorry you had a shi t evening ... We do a vegetable soup starter with part baked rolls every day it takes no no time at all and I make enough for 2 days I make then change the soup , it's incredibly cheap to do and it means you need less of the main which also saves money , we have 4 children so pleasing everyone is hard so as we have a starter if someone isn't keen on the main then they can have extra soup and a n extra roll .. We also let our children choose a meal a week (except the baby )and they usually help cook it too , for example my older daughter (11 ) chose moussaka and we cooked the "meat" sauce the day before and did the bechimal and aubergine and baked it on the night so she could help after school , maybe if you involve her the meal planning and occasionally prep will be less resistance , even my 6 year old peels the soup vegetables for me and helps make his chosen meal x

BikiniB0tt0m · 25/01/2022 23:47

I hate the idea of sending my child to bed hungry but it doesn't happen very often when you stick to it, especially the next day at dinner. So it doesn't do them any harm. I tend to serve a small portion when I know they fuss over a meal I plan, so they don't get over faced and I know they can manage it.

user1488481370 · 25/01/2022 15:46

In regards to putting things on her plate that she doesn’t like, that’s how I parent, I always put a little bit of everything onto their plates. I’d like to know that they at least tried it. I’m not going to stop doing that.

I hardly think I neglect my DD nor did I wind her up. Does it ever make it ok for one person to hit another person because they were ‘wound up?’ I don’t think so.

School know about the situation at home, I’ve been very transparent about everything. She has spoken to teachers about it (we told her that if she ever felt the need to speak about it, a teacher would be there to listen) she’s gone from being a very happy, well behaved little girl to angry, sulky and short tempered within a matter of months. She was always head strong but there was never any nastiness or violence.

I do think that it’s a mixture of things, the home situation that we dealt with for so long and her age. I’m just sad that it’s come to this. She definitely needs boundaries which we do have in place. I offered toast because it was something that she could do herself. I’ve always said that I’ll cook one meal and one meal only. I just hate the idea of sending her to bed hungry.

OP posts:
G5000 · 25/01/2022 14:16

wants to get back at her daughter rather than being caring and loving and understanding over the fact that she doesnt like the food that much

WTF, an 8-year old hits her mother because the dinner served is not her favourite and mum does not scurry back to the kitchen fast enough to make another meal, and according to some posters, the mother is in the wrong?
Next Xmas, the child will throw her new iPhone in mum's face because it wasn't the Plus model she wanted, and mum should be loving and caring and run to the shop to get the right one?

JudgeJ · 25/01/2022 12:34

@Holothane

We had no choice growing up it eat what your given.
My Dad would always say, if we were wanting to be too choosey, This is a home, not a transport caff!
JudgeJ · 25/01/2022 12:24

[quote user1488481370]@Krakenchorus would you rather I hit her back?[/quote]
No, because children know that they have the upper hand in situations like this!

Notcontent · 25/01/2022 09:25

I agree with a previous poster who said that children don’t hit at that age for no reason. It sounds like your dd has gone through quite a traumatic time and things are still difficult. She might be suffering from anxiety, which in children that age can manifest itself in behaviours such as hitting. I would not punish her but try to get to the bottom of what is going on.

Sartre · 25/01/2022 09:05

Crikey, she hit you?! You shouldn’t feel bad at all, she acted like a toddler.

mogsrus · 25/01/2022 08:52

So she sits sobbing, hoping mum will give in to her demands, it’s child psychology ,,,, if I do this, I get that , our child did it, soon realised it wasn’t going to work.. you eat what we eat or go hungry, they won’t go hungry by the very nature,

Brieandcamembert · 25/01/2022 07:55

Super Noodles are absolute junk. Just don't buy them. Feed her a decent meal each evening which she either ways or she doesn't with no back up plan.

Have you done any patenting courses to look at behaviour management?

MumWithYOPD · 25/01/2022 07:42

This may sound harsh but in my home with dinner it’s a case of take it or leave it, there is no option b. If they don’t want to eat it fine but there’s nothing else, and I mean nothing until the next mealtime. Nothing terrible happened from a child missing one meal. Obviously this is in the context of meals that we have had before and know DC like/eat. If it was a completely new meal then there would be other options available but that rarely was needed.
The hitting is another issue that I don’t feel qualified to deal with as that was nipped in the bud when mine were toddlers as I’ve always said it might not seem like a big deal when a 3 year old hits you or an 8 year old but when they’re 15 you’ll wish you’d stopped it sooner because it will be a big deal then.
There’s nothing you’ve dealt with that can’t be rectified, we’re all trying our best as parents. Good luck.

EarringsandLipstick · 25/01/2022 07:37

@Howareyouflower

Sorry, you are raising a very badly behaved child. She would not have been offered anything else in my house!
No, she has a child who had behaved badly and needs support & boundaries

Enough of your judgment.

EarringsandLipstick · 25/01/2022 07:36

[quote DreamTheMoors]@EarringsandLipstick

Stop overreacting. You don’t know me. I posted something about MY MUM.

If you’re different, well, good for you. You’ve got no business criticizing ANYBODY else. In particular, strangers on the internet, whose one post you’ve read.
Criminy. Lighten up.[/quote]
You should probably re-read your own posts so where you stated that your view & your mum's approach was 'normal' and can't see any one else's point of view)

It's not.

My point remains - all humans are capable of being wrong. Including mums. Including your mum.

Suzi888 · 25/01/2022 03:36

“YABU to be feeling awful if by that you mean guilty. I’d have sent the little madam to bed with no dinner if she’d hit me. “ - I agree with this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread