Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL unreasonable?

60 replies

strawhatblonde · 24/01/2022 18:48

I posted here before about the decision of moving to the states to be with my fiance or him moving here.

OH has firmly said he will move here. He knows it will be indefinite (kids, their ages/schools and elderly cat) and he is happy with that. He has considered what he is losing vs what I would lose, and feels he would be happy here. The idea being he rents somewhere initially then moves in with me later on down the line.

MIL not happy at all - understandably - wants her son to stay in the states. He was on the phone with her and told her he wants to move here. I then get a message saying "you know I love you but it would crush me if my son moved to England, just being honest I wouldn't tell him though. Marry there but live here"

I told my best friend and her reaction matched mine - WTAF. Is that not emotionally manipulative? And also a bit controlling? This is NOT what she is saying to OH obviously.

To OH she says she'll get a passport (he thinks she means to visit... what I think she actually means is "ok you have the wedding where you want but live where I want")

Her and OH are going to see an immigration lawyer (her idea) to "see where is best to marry and best to live" so OH thinks she is considering England.. she's not.

OH told her to back off pressuring me because she's then messaging me saying how medication is "only" $200 per month and without a discount would be a lot more.... I'm saying well it's £10 here!!

I am being adult about it and explaining to her I have done my research. My kids could end up doing another year at school as the grades have different brackets (eldest is yr 7 here but would be 6th grade there for example). My cat would not be insured as she's too old (she's 16, been insured here since kitten), she also has a heart murmur that she is medicated for, so we would be paying for that. Other cat's insurance is more in 1 month there than it is all year here. And then there's health insurance, cheapest quote I could find doesn't include everything and was hundreds of dollars (vs free) because welfare/medicaid doesn't kick in until we're citizens. Also the cost of rent, car insurance etc etc... figured it all out and sent it to her.

I am getting really irritated with things, OH is insistent he will move here and doesn't care what anyone else thinks, he can rent a room here for minimal cost compared to what he pays over there. He's able to get a work visa. It's cheaper, quicker and easier for him to move here in comparison. He says it's his choice as he's a grown man and his mum will get over it.

Now I feel like she is being unreasonable but at the same time I feel guilty for taking her only son away.

I'm a very non-confrontational person, I don't like drama, so I'd rather walk away than deal with bs like this, AIBU here?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Beachhuts90 · 25/01/2022 18:24

Is he hoping to come in on a fiance (marriage) visa? Be warned they require you to sponsor him and part of that is living together. Also the NHS surcharge is something like £500 or so per year which I see you're aware of but you have to pay the whole thing for the whole validity of the visa up front. Also, if you are here on a marriage visa, you cannot work until after the wedding and the switch to spouse visa.

I think you are wise to spend as much time together before marriage as possible. Quite frankly it is none of his mother's business. I say this as the one who left America to make a life with my UK spouse. And yes I am close to my parents despite the distance.

nixon1976 · 25/01/2022 12:13

I'm not going to comment on your relationship, but if you do consider moving to the States, we moved here last year (I am a US citizen, husband and children are not). It took about 18 months to get green cards for him and our kids; then the kids applied for and received US passports as soon as we landed. It was a stressful process, but it is perfectly do-able and people do it all the time!

It is also perfectly possible for your children to move here up to junior year of high school/11th grade (going into sixth form). Any 'credits' gained from GCSEs will transfer and there is time to get a decent GPA in order to apply to college here. Private schools rarely take pupils into grades higher than 10th (year 11) but public schools do and will. The school system here has to allow for frequent pupil transfers as every time you move house to a different school district you have to move schools.

IncompleteSenten · 25/01/2022 11:28

Forward her messages to him and ask him to reply. Every time she messages, forward it straight on.
This is for him to deal with.

Can you imagine what a pain she'd be if you did live near her?!

felulageller · 25/01/2022 11:25

You've made a good decision from previously.

Lots of rels have mil issues- at least yours will be thousands of miles away.

Her not wanting her Ds so far away is human. Give her time to adjust.

2DogsOnMySofa · 25/01/2022 07:45

You've both made a decision, your mil can have an opinion on it, but why is she so involved. Wtf are they going to see an immigration officer about which is the best place to live. You've already made a decision.

Tbh she's one of the reasons I would stay in the uk. If she's interfering now, wait until you have the wedding and kids. Better to put a plane ride inbetween you and her

CloudPop · 25/01/2022 07:35

Moving to the UK From the US really isn't a big deal. People do this kind of thing all the time (or did pre pandemic). If it doesn't work out he goes home. People are reacting like he's buying a one way ticket to Siberia.

KatyRebecca84 · 25/01/2022 07:25

He’s old enough to make his own choice. She has no control over that. A kind mother would want him to be happy. She sounds hard work.

Foxglovers · 25/01/2022 06:53

I feel for you OP.
So many negative comments here when you are just after some advice.
I read your previous thread too and think you have made a great decision in having him come here to you and rent for a bit. You can see how things go and I hope that everything works out for you! You seem very much in love and sounds like you deserve a happy relationship and great your kids like him! So far it sounds like you have really thought about things and decided on the best course of action!
As for his mother, that sounds very annoying! As others have said, I wouldn’t send her the info and financial stuff. She’s a mother so (should!) understand. I think you need to be firm and keep reiterating that you love your partner and want the relationship to work but you have to think of your kids and right now uprooting them halfway around the world (when they have also lost their father) just isn’t the right decision for you now. You can stay positive with her but keep your reasons brief. Really it’s for her son to explain and she has to accept his decision really! Good luck.
I’ve followed from your previous thread. I’d love to know how things go for you and really hope it works out! 😊 must’ve been very hard this far and with children too!

violetbunny · 24/01/2022 23:39

I think you just need to ignore any messages from her and direct her back to your DP.

For what it's worth, DP and I moved to my home country on the other side of the world some years ago. He is an only child, his mum lives alone and doesn't fly due to fear (realistically this is the only way to travel her unless you want to spend months on a boat). So you can imagine how she reacted. DP ended up telling her that he was here on a 2 year visa as a trial (in reality he was on a permanent visa), which I don't agree with but it did calm her down a bit. He calls her several times a week and makes all the visits back home as she won't travel here.

Anyway as upset as she was initially she has come around to it over time. I think the fact that he makes such an effort to stay in touch really helps. He speaks to his mum far more than I speak to my own, and my mum's a lot closer geographically!

whenwillthemadnessend · 24/01/2022 23:00

Not read the other thread but from the posts on this one I think you sound perfectly grounded and sensible. Don't why everyone is up in arms
Good luck.

Hanooooooo · 24/01/2022 22:08

@strawhatblonde please ignore all the negative, spiteful comments on the thread about your relationship and your children. I think your course of action sounds wise.

Heartofglass12345 · 24/01/2022 22:06

Don't discuss it with her anymore. I wouldn't even reply to her messages about it.

AlternativePerspective · 24/01/2022 22:01

And sorry, but I consider calling someone your fiancé after 9 weeks just as bad as calling a boyfriend a partner.

Engagement means 0 in these circumstances. He’s a boyfriend at best. Maybe marriage will become a serious thing one day but you can’t possibly know that at this point since you barely even know each other.

AlternativePerspective · 24/01/2022 21:59

Well given you’ve only actually known him in person for 9 weeks, I’d hardly say they’ve met him multiple times.

Seriously I agree that it would be a bad idea for you to move in the circumstances, but if it was my son I’d be advising him the same and advising him to stay in the US for another couple of years at least until you’ve got to know each other.

Clearly this is an infatuation which you hope will last the distance, but you’re seriously rushing into this. You don’t know each other at all. Slow down. If he’s genuinely the one then he’ll still be around in a year or two.

Motnight · 24/01/2022 21:55

Op is staying. Her fiancee is joining her. Please read her posts!

Willyoujustbequiet · 24/01/2022 21:51

Hell would freeze over before I uprooted my kids.

Get your priorities straight. Dont justify anything. It makes far more sense for him to move here.

TokyoTen · 24/01/2022 21:50

Why on earth are you sending MIL your costs and financial workings? You need to withdraw from her, ignore her, let your BF deal with her. It's just generating drama.to keep talking with her.

strawhatblonde · 24/01/2022 21:49

Their father is deceased, they met OH multiple times before we went to the states.

OP posts:
AlternativePerspective · 24/01/2022 21:45

You say you’re doing this because you’re thinking of your kids.

So how is taking your kids abroad to stay with a stranger who you’ve only known for 5 minutes putting their interests first?

And have you already told them you plan to marry this bloke even though you don’t really know each other at all?

Jesus. It’s bad enough when people introduce the kids to their dates too soon when it’s done on neutral ground, to take them to another country to stay with a stranger or at best share their hotel room with a stranger is beyond comprehension. I despair.

Is their father in the picture? Because if so he could easily prevent you from taking the kids to the US.

ElleGettingBetter · 24/01/2022 21:19

[quote TheHoptimist]enjoy

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4453015-Giving-it-all-up[/quote]
Dick move.

The OP is staying here, he’s renting before moving in - she took the advice on board clearly.

wordler · 24/01/2022 21:19

[quote strawhatblonde]@GeorgiaGirl52 no it’s not because of my cat. I’m not moving there because I have two kids who’d have to move, I can’t afford to live there, not giving up free healthcare, not giving up my financial independence, the house I own or my career … and the cat.

My kids come with me when I go to the US. That’s why I’m saying it’s a lot because even though he pays it all, we are the ones travelling.

thank you for the other posts.

A lot to think about and take in.

Thank you also for explaining the grades I didn’t realise that!

I still think he should move here, in a few years time my eldest will be too old to move (year 10). When the eldest is 18 or heck when the youngest is 18, (5 year age gap) it will be up to them if they want to move. If they say no, I won’t move. So really it does have a time limit on it for me to be moving, another reason why I won’t be.[/quote]
You have a time limit for moving to the US to if you want both kids to have the chance to come and live with you.

If you marry your fiance before the oldest turns 18, she could immigrate with you to the USA in the same time frame as you and younger child if the application is processed before she turns 21.

If you want until she is over 21 it will take seven years to get the same visa if she stays unmarried during all that time and longer if she gets married.

Something to consider if you want both children to have the same opportunity to live and work in the USA.

Ponoka7 · 24/01/2022 21:13

Posters called you delusional because you seem to believe that she loves you and your kids. She's love bombed you to get you to go there. They'll all quite happily throw you and your kids under the bus to keep him in the US. Things would have changed when you got there and were both competing for his attention.
Stop pandering to her. He comes here and you see if it would work once he's here. You need to be on the same page financially and how you parent. Your eldest is going into their teenage years and that's always testing.

strawhatblonde · 24/01/2022 21:12

@GeorgiaGirl52 no it’s not because of my cat. I’m not moving there because I have two kids who’d have to move, I can’t afford to live there, not giving up free healthcare, not giving up my financial independence, the house I own or my career … and the cat.

My kids come with me when I go to the US. That’s why I’m saying it’s a lot because even though he pays it all, we are the ones travelling.

thank you for the other posts.

A lot to think about and take in.

Thank you also for explaining the grades I didn’t realise that!

I still think he should move here, in a few years time my eldest will be too old to move (year 10). When the eldest is 18 or heck when the youngest is 18, (5 year age gap) it will be up to them if they want to move. If they say no, I won’t move. So really it does have a time limit on it for me to be moving, another reason why I won’t be.

OP posts:
wordler · 24/01/2022 21:11

Alright - this is how I'd do it in your position - to give everyone the best opportunities and chances to experience both countries. I'm in a UK/USA couple and we've done immigration one way and have researched the other way too.

First, no one moves until you are both sure you want to get married.

Then get married (doesn't matter in which country but UK needs a marriage visa which is an annoying extra step)

Apply for UK spousal visa for him. Takes about 6-8 weeks to process. He moves over and starts the process towards citizenship (will take at least 5 years) - which starts with being granted indefinite leave to remain and you have visa renewals every 2 years. About a year before he gets his citizenship - you put in applications for you and the kids to move to the USA (spouse and stepchildren visa) - you want to time this so that it will be processed just after he gets his UK citizenship so check processing times.

By this time your oldest will have finished secondary school. You all move over to the USA - you and kids will have green cards. Oldest can either go to university in the USA or can go in the UK (as long as her home base is the USA and she comes back on holidays she won't lose her greencard.

After living there for three years you can apply for American citizenship - it's a lot easier than the UK version. Child under 18 will automatically become US citizen at same time as you. Older child can apply for citizenship after 5 years of holding green card.

At this point all four of you have citizenship of both countries - can freely travel and live in both countries depending on preferences.

AlternativePerspective · 24/01/2022 20:47

I very much doubt that she wants you to move over there because she loves you. I suspect in fact that she wants you to move over there because, as people have pointed out to you on here, you’re both rushing things, and giving up everything to pursue something with someone you’ve only ever spent 9 weeks with is incredibly unwise.

So as his mother it’s not unreasonable for her to suggest to him that you should be the one doing the moving, just as it’s not unreasonable for people close to you to suggest that he should.

The thing with long distance relationships is that you can’t rush them. You shouldn’t take things any quicker just because you’re living apart, and that should be something which you should always consider going in. Are you prepared to wait for years to be together? If not then I’d say that it’s a bad idea to get involved in the first place.

3 weeks at a time is like a holiday, and now you want him to come over here and live? You don’t even know what his bad points are. And what’s happening to your children when you’re flitting backwards and forwards to the states?

Seriously OP this has disaster written all over it, and even on the remote off chance that things work out it will cost you tens of thousands of pounds in costs before he can live here permanently, and even then there are no guarantees that he’ll be granted citizenship. Someone I know’s wife was refused citizenship at the last minute and was deported. Even though they’d been together for around 5 years by then.