Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boris Johnson’s birthday party

862 replies

Cheekypeach · 24/01/2022 18:34

Here we go again…

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
DePfeffoff · 26/01/2022 11:59

@Clavinova

In people not in your bubble, banned. No singing in church for instance

It takes 20 seconds to sing Happy Birthday - I'm not convinced it was banned at all. Boris Johnson wasn't in the bubble when those school children sang Happy Birthday to him.

The law was perfectly clear. No indoor gatherings unless reasonably needed for work purposes. Even no. 10 isn't trying to say that the birthday do was reasonably needed for work.
Roussette · 26/01/2022 11:56

No, I haven't - have any of the prominent lawyers on Twitter said singing 'happy birthday' was actually banned? You haven't provided any links to back up your claim

Your links proved it. Sorry.
Singing is singing whatever the song.

Clavinova · 26/01/2022 11:55

ancientgran
But you quoted an explanation from George Eustice, did you understand what he said?

I understood perfectly what George Eustice said - perhaps you are mixing up your ministers?

Clavinova · 26/01/2022 11:51

Roussette
You've proved the point even if you don't like the word 'banned'

No, I haven't - have any of the prominent lawyers on Twitter said singing 'happy birthday' was actually banned? You haven't provided any links to back up your claim.

DGRossetti · 26/01/2022 11:49

Are they having a party or are they at work?

I guess, very much like the squirrels here, they're working.

ancientgran · 26/01/2022 11:49

@Clavinova

ancientgran Doesn't add up for me but maybe you can explain it

I haven't read Sue Gray's report.

But you quoted an explanation from George Eustice, did you understand what he said?
Clavinova · 26/01/2022 11:47

ancientgran
Doesn't add up for me but maybe you can explain it

I haven't read Sue Gray's report.

ancientgran · 26/01/2022 11:44

@Peregrina

Not just losing though in 1997, but absolutely thrashed. Blair had set out to make Labour electable though, and was maintaining tight discipline in the party. He also had the ear of Murdoch.

As for Labour MPs taking their areas for granted and losing - I hope this time this happens in those Tory areas with the proverbial pigs in blue rosettes getting elected.

I've lived in my house for 25 years, I've never seen any of our 3 Conservative MPs on my doorstep or any other doorstep. I have met one, the first one, when I went to his surgery about a problem we were having at work, he was helpful but I still feel we have been taken for granted.

I have sent two emails to my current, 2019 elected MP, about how I felt about this govt, the first was a few months ago and he was very positive about BJ and co but the one last week was very different. He seems to have a bit of a conversion.

Roussette · 26/01/2022 11:44

Exactly Clavinova

No singing.
No choirs
No singing in church

You've proved the point even if you don't like the word 'banned'

Clavinova · 26/01/2022 11:42

Singing was banned

Several reports have avoided using the word "banned" -

singing near others was cautioned against...

www.theguardian.com/politics/2022/jan/24/what-were-the-covid-rules-at-the-time-of-boris-johnsons-2020-birthday

At the time there was also intense concern about the potential for singing to spread Covid-19, with choirs unable to meet to rehearse

www.itv.com/news/2022-01-24/boris-johnson-had-birthday-bash-during-lockdown-itv-news-understands

jgw1 · 26/01/2022 11:38

@DGRossetti

Two squirrels !!

I'm sure they're friendly with the magpies, as they often seem to run around the lawn (well magpies more hop Grin) together.

There could be a childrens story in that.

Are they having a party or are they at work? The squirrels and rooks in my garden are at work, I can tell this because they are eating and have a bottle of wine.
ancientgran · 26/01/2022 11:38

@Clavinova

I can remember Late May 2020 v clearly - it was my son’s 18th. . He didn’t get a party and wasn’t ambushed by a cake.

Boris Johnson's 'birthday gathering' was the 19th June.

oh, he just had a birthday cake with the people he worked with. 30 of them?

George Eustice said "closer to 10" people yesterday - Grant Shapps also denied as many as 30 had been present, telling BBC Breakfast the group had been working together all day.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-60121572

Singing? (banned)

Was singing 'Happy Birthday' banned? I thought we were supposed to wash our hands for 20 seconds to the tune of 'Happy Birthday'?

19 June 2020: Schoolchildren sing Happy Birthday to Boris Johnson

news.sky.com/video/19-june-2020-schoolchildren-sing-happy-birthday-to-boris-johnson-12524667

I felt bad for the littlies I taught; no birthday parties, no food (cake) could be brought in, no singing of happy birthday allowed.

October 2020
Some schools in England have reportedly banned singing in the classroom due to fears it could accelerate the spread of coronavirus.

Children in some schools in England are being told not to sing ‘Happy Birthday’ to their classmates, over fears their vocalisations could accelerate the spread of COVID-19.

Some schools are reportedly telling pupils to listen to the song online or hum the tune instead. Others are also said to be discouraging children from bringing in birthday cakes from home to reduce contact points for the virus.

Parent campaign group UsForThem said the ban has been self-imposed by certain schools.

www.classicfm.com/music-news/coronavirus/schools-ban-children-singing-happy-birthday-transmission-fears/

Staffrooms were closed across the country as people weren’t allowed to all eat together.

Hospital staffroom here -

www.imperial.ac.uk/news/196613/imperial-students-provide-over-350-free/

I remember Chris Whitty being a bit like..even at BBQs be careful and use separate utensils

Yes - you could hold a barbecue (or small party) for 6 people from different households in your back garden from the 1st of June 2020.

So if Boris was at his birthday bash, his wife, interior designer and Rishi Sunak were all there then is George Eustice saying there were fewer than 6 people who work in No 10 there?

If the "closer to 10" people had been working together all day then
How come we have seen video of BJ visiting a school, he wasn't even in No 10 all day.
Why was Carrie Johnson working all day with staff at No 10, she doesn't have a job there?
Why was the interior designer working all day with staff at No 10, she doesn't have a job there?
How was Rishi Sunak just passing through if he was working there all day?

Doesn't add up for me but maybe you can explain it.

MooSakah · 26/01/2022 11:24

@Clavinova

Yes they tweeted about the kids singing happy birthday to the PM - the kids were social distanced outside in their playground whilst queuing to wash their hands!

Children go out to play/wash their hands in all weathers - it's a pity then that some enterprising teachers couldn't arrange to sing 'happy birthday' to pupils outside as well!! Although I'm still not convinced that singing 'happy birthday' was actually banned.

Singing was banned and playing certain musical instruments I think
Roussette · 26/01/2022 11:12

Singing inside was banned. For much longer than spring 2020. In churches, in schools, no choirs. No singing at funerals

I'm sure schools could have lined children up outside SD and sang happy birthday to a pupil. Not really the point though is it? The rules prevented them doing what the PM and his friends did

^^ This.

Clavinova knows it really but would rather focus on the song Happy Birthday than the actual singing indoors with up to 30 people. And cake. And buffet. And wife and interior designer there. And being in the Cabinet office
(I am surprised that wives and interior designers are allowed in there in the first place to be honest)

Roussette · 26/01/2022 11:10

lthough I'm still not convinced that singing 'happy birthday' was actually banned.

Oh, don't be so obtuse. It's not the song, it's the singing!

I know you know that, you're just being deliberately provocative

Clavinova · 26/01/2022 11:04

lborgia
I read a lot of this post 13 hours ago and Clavinova was pumping out the quotes, and the links, like her job depended on it

That's funny because I didn't post anything yesterday and I was out all weekend - so didn't post on Sat/Sun. Yes, I posted on Monday evening - but that's because other posters kept quoting my username before I joined the thread.

I hope you can hand over to a colleague soon

No - I'm enjoying myself - I do it for love. Grin

itsgettingweird · 26/01/2022 11:01

@Clavinova

Yes they tweeted about the kids singing happy birthday to the PM - the kids were social distanced outside in their playground whilst queuing to wash their hands!

Children go out to play/wash their hands in all weathers - it's a pity then that some enterprising teachers couldn't arrange to sing 'happy birthday' to pupils outside as well!! Although I'm still not convinced that singing 'happy birthday' was actually banned.

Singing inside was banned. For much longer than spring 2020. In churches, in schools, no choirs. No singing at funerals.

I'm sure schools could have lined children up outside SD and sang happy birthday to a pupil. Not really the point though is it? The rules prevented them doing what the PM and his friends did.

itsgettingweird · 26/01/2022 10:58

I think some people have forgotten the sorts of restrictions we were under in spring 2020

Totally!

We were in school. Our guidance was not to go into staff room. Not even with people you shared a classroom with. You were meant to stay in your own classroom bubble. Eat in there, drink in there. We even had certain toilets we could use over bubble.

Surely if what they did was ok we could all gone to the staff room at lunchtime for a cuppa and slt could have ambushed us with cake?

Clavinova · 26/01/2022 10:55

Yes they tweeted about the kids singing happy birthday to the PM - the kids were social distanced outside in their playground whilst queuing to wash their hands!

Children go out to play/wash their hands in all weathers - it's a pity then that some enterprising teachers couldn't arrange to sing 'happy birthday' to pupils outside as well!! Although I'm still not convinced that singing 'happy birthday' was actually banned.

lborgia · 26/01/2022 10:51

Well, Feck me.

I read a lot of this post 13 hours ago and Clavinova was pumping out the quotes, and the links, like her job depended on it (Hmm).

13 hours later I'm back and cut right to the last page, and she doesn't seem to have slowed down.

@Clavinova - you must be knackered mate - I hope you can hand over to a colleague soon. Zero hours contract, no doubt. Tough gig. Sad

Notonthestairs · 26/01/2022 10:48

Yes they tweeted about the kids singing happy birthday to the PM - the kids were social distanced outside in their playground whilst queuing to wash their hands!

Funny they didn't tweet about the cabinet room party. That would have cheered the nation up.

Clavinova · 26/01/2022 10:47

Very clear rules set by the council

Set by the council, but not by the government?

Clavinova · 26/01/2022 10:46

Little different from 6 socially distanced in a garden, wouldn't you say?

Yes - the 6 socially distanced people in a garden could be people who don't normally meet or work together.

thelittlestrhino · 26/01/2022 10:42

Not a self imposed ban Hmm on singing in class. Very clear rules set by the council.

Clavinova · 26/01/2022 10:41

In people not in your bubble, banned. No singing in church for instance

It takes 20 seconds to sing Happy Birthday - I'm not convinced it was banned at all. Boris Johnson wasn't in the bubble when those school children sang Happy Birthday to him.