Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be angry that social services not investigating how my DC ate clinical waste at school?

95 replies

Weemammy21 · 24/01/2022 18:24

Got phone call from school to say my DC ate clinical waste at school and had to be taken to hospital. For context my DC has severe Sen and has a very detailed and EHCP giving school funding for 1 to 1 support to be provided through mouth the school day. Many education specialist report detailed need for constant 1 to 1 supervison and never to be left alone or unsupervised and yet DC was left alone at clinical waste bin and ate some of the contents. DC attends a private “specialist autism” school that charges an excessive amount of money for the placement. When school took DC to hospital they withheld information from the hospital that he consumed items from clinical waste bin and downplayed it to the hospital by saying he ate from a domestic bin and also refused to disclose to me or hospital what the other contents of the bin was. A day later the school disclosed that one of the items in the clinical waste bin was a used incontinence pad. When all this information was sent to LADO for school area social services have stated that they are not going to investigate it as a child protection incident as “thresholds have not been met”. I can’t understand how s child eating clinical waste at school can be dismissed as not being of sufficient concern to conduct a child protection investigation! AIBU to be super angry that
a) this happened my DC who was supposed to have constant 1/1 support
(b) the school did not take sufficient action to protect my DC whilst in their care
(c) social services LADO doesn’t think it is serious enough to instigate a child protection investigation? I removed my DC from school immediately but as no CP investigation is occurring I am very concerned for the other Sen children and their parents not knowing what occurred. Also witnessed other distressing incidents when I arrived early to collect DC from school and did notify LA of my concerns for DC safety months before it happened.

OP posts:
mycatisannoying · 26/01/2022 00:15

I work in a primary school, with SEN children, and we are on our fucking knees at the moment! Staff absence is through the roof, and children getting 1:1 support can't be watched every minute of the day due to staff breaks.
It's unfortunate but if your child is ok, and school ensures this never ever happens again, then I'd leave it. What good will a witch-hunt do ...

Soontobe60 · 26/01/2022 00:12

@Weemammy21

IMO the school and the chair of governors is only interested in covering it up. The fact that the school staff lied to the hospital about what happened to my severely Sen child put my DC safety and life st risk as hospital was denied the opportunity to make informed decisions about what medical care orctests DC needed. It is this and them waiting another 24 hours to confirm a used incontinence pad was in the bin that makes it clear they can not be trusted to care for Sen children as their first and only priority was to conceal what occurred to medical professionals at the hospital and cover it up. This is every parents nightmare and a change of policy is not enough. I contacted the chair of governors and he didn’t even bother to respond.
Could it be the case that the person who escorted your child to the hospital wasn’t the person who found him by the bin, and had only been told that ‘he’s eaten something from a bin’? I’m assuming you went to the hospital as soon as school phoned you? If so, surely you would have told the doctor that school told you he’d eaten a used incontinence pad? Or did they not tell you this? Did no-one at the hospital notice faeces on him? The school may well have not joined all the dots together initially whereby everyone realised what he’d eaten, at which point I’m assuming they notified the hospital? Was your child kept in hospital?
Kickers567 · 26/01/2022 00:12

Hmm. Clinical waste bins with pads in them will be easily accessible, like in every bathroom just with a swing lid. I don't think they mean a medical waste bin or sharps bin which would be locked away.

The 1:1 could have been turned away from the child to wash their hands (but still right there, so still supervising) and the child could have quickly reached in and pulled out a pad and put it to their mouth before the 1:1 can turn round, take 2 steps towards the child and take the pad off them.

Dogdayafternoonz · 25/01/2022 23:58

I wouldn't try to destroy your relationship with the school if you want your child to continue to go there. Presumably they are aware mistakes have been made. I would concentrate on finding out how they mean to make sure they don't make the same mistakes again.

Cocopogo · 25/01/2022 23:53

@Spikeyball in my school children are supervised 3 adults to 1 child and still they are entitled to privacy and risk behaviours. I understand this is not a good situation, as with a neurotypical child who falls off the climbing frame but children should still be allowed to climb. It’s about managing risk and balancing learning risks and quality of life.

ecoanxiety · 25/01/2022 22:39

Not surprised at all! Hope your DC are OK

Idontbelieveit14 · 25/01/2022 22:23

@JenniferAlisonPhilippaSue

Am I the only one so far who can see the schools pov on this? Eating wee/poo soaked incontinence pads from a bin is pretty extreme behaviour. It can’t be feasible to literally monitor your child every second. If you push this then I think the most likely outcome would be that they decide that they cannot accommodate the child’s needs and they’re better off leaving until a space becomes available at a more suitable school.
I work in a special school - can’t see how this would happen if the child was being properly supervised. I’m assuming the bin was in the bathroom? Pad should be secured in a bag in the bin too! It’s really bad!
x2boys · 25/01/2022 22:07

@Cocopogo

Who took the child to hospital? Sounds like a massive over reaction. Obviously not great but kids with PICA eat all sorts and their digestive system becomes pretty robust. I would be very wary of removing child from school in the current climate. Lots of schools aren’t taking on as there’s a massive shortage of staff so you might need to be prepared to come at home for a long time. In relation to the incident, I missed whether you said how old your child is but there has to be a balance between supervision and independence/quality of life. Your child is entitled to privacy too. Depending on how long he’s been at the school perhaps they are still learning to balance this and sometimes things happen.
Age is irrelevant here ,my nearly 12 year old is at a special school ,with a 1'1 ,he wouldn't do this although I have caught him trying to eat dog food etc ,but he does have equally risky behaviour because he has no awareness of danger etc .
Spikeyball · 25/01/2022 21:46

"In relation to the incident, I missed whether you said how old your child is but there has to be a balance between supervision and independence/quality of life. Your child is entitled to privacy too"

A child with this level of support at this type of school is a child that needs constant supervision. The expectation would be that the child is never left alone.

Knackeredmommy · 25/01/2022 21:42

That's terrible! It is a health and safety issue. There should be a risk assessment in place, how did he manage to access a clinical waste bin? They will now have to review risk assessment to ensure this cannot happen again. I'd request a meeting to discuss the risk assessment they have in place for him.

Spagoot224 · 25/01/2022 21:32

Child Protection Social Worker - definitely not under the remit of a mash team to investigate this - a Social Worker couldn’t be expected to investigate a school, professionals or failings of either. Child Protection investigations and work, in its true form is around risks and abuses from within a child’s family or home network. Not to say support couldn’t have been offered but it isn’t a child protection (in its true form!) issue

Cocopogo · 25/01/2022 21:21

Who took the child to hospital? Sounds like a massive over reaction. Obviously not great but kids with PICA eat all sorts and their digestive system becomes pretty robust.
I would be very wary of removing child from school in the current climate. Lots of schools aren’t taking on as there’s a massive shortage of staff so you might need to be prepared to come at home for a long time.
In relation to the incident, I missed whether you said how old your child is but there has to be a balance between supervision and independence/quality of life. Your child is entitled to privacy too. Depending on how long he’s been at the school perhaps they are still learning to balance this and sometimes things happen.

ldontWanna · 25/01/2022 21:08

@neverbeenskiing

Surely that meets the threshold for safeguarding and warrants an investigation at least.

There is a lot of misunderstanding and misinformation on MN about what comes under the umbrella of "safeguarding". What has happened to OP's DC is not a Child Protection issue, it is a Health and Safety issue. That doesn't mean it's not serious, or that it doesn't warrant investigation but it's not the role of Children's Services to investigate. I agree with previous posters that Ofsted would be the more appropriate body to contact regarding this.

I can admit I'm wrong, i just need more info you're willing please.

I understand the bin situation is a health and safety issue.

However, as far as I know lying to HCPs about what happened to a child to end up in hospital and withholding information that can interfere with their treatment is safeguarding, not health and safety. Do you mind explaining to me why that isn't the case? Is it because it's a school and not the parent/legal guardian? Something else?

I'm genuinely trying to understand.

Kindnessandcourage · 25/01/2022 19:01

Op go to the school website and make a formal complaint. In their required format. Make sure you still write to the chair of the governors with the staff names and all the details. It might feel repetitive giving out the details over and over but don't let this one go. You mentioned that you moved dc out of this school is it right? I am asking coz some schools have a process where they close all complaints of a child changes school or nursery.

neverbeenskiing · 25/01/2022 18:21

Surely that meets the threshold for safeguarding and warrants an investigation at least.

There is a lot of misunderstanding and misinformation on MN about what comes under the umbrella of "safeguarding". What has happened to OP's DC is not a Child Protection issue, it is a Health and Safety issue. That doesn't mean it's not serious, or that it doesn't warrant investigation but it's not the role of Children's Services to investigate. I agree with previous posters that Ofsted would be the more appropriate body to contact regarding this.

Weemammy21 · 25/01/2022 17:59

@IdontWanna Thanks for your response. I have bee contacted by the Safeguarding manager but she did not apologise. I also contacted the chair of governors and the chief executive of the school group who has an OBE and neither of them have responded to my contact never mind apologise. They don’t care. DC is just a number.

OP posts:
rebeccachoc · 25/01/2022 17:30

Absolutely disgusting level of neglect and then lying at the hospital to cover it up. Definitely go to the press, name and shame.

BungleandGeorge · 24/01/2022 21:58

As well as being disgusting if he had eaten the gel inside the pad it could be dangerous if it swelled inside his body. Do you know where the bin was? An incontinence pad wouldn’t be in the highest category of clinical waste so wouldn’t need a closed bin I don’t think.
Your poor child what a horrible thing to happen.

ldontWanna · 24/01/2022 21:44

The fact that it happened is bad. But I do think that if they were honest,apologetic,explained what happened and why and took steps to prevent it in the future then it would've been sorted.

The worst issue here is that they lied and withheld information from hospital staff that were trying to help your child and treat him as needed. Surely that meets the threshold for safeguarding and warrants an investigation at least.

Have you tried talking to someone at the hospital? What do they think? Do they have a different avenue of reporting that might help?

Weemammy21 · 24/01/2022 21:35

@JenniferAlisonPhilippaSue The school were very aware of DC severe Sen and the need for constant 1 to 1 supervision and never to be left unsupervised. That is why they charged and were paid such a huge amount of funding. The school were also provided with many independent and LA professional reports detailing DC severe SEN and emphasising the need that DC never be left unsupervised. School response was that definitely they could keep DC safe but would need extra funding for DC to get 2 to 1 support if DC was outside the school building. The school also got this extra provision and it is also stated in the EHCP that 2 to 1 support was needed outside. Nothing was withheld from the school about the extent and severity of DC needs so no excuses can be provided for what occurred. It is an independent and very well known expensive School so lack of funding or knowledge is not a defence.

OP posts:
JeffThePilot · 24/01/2022 21:21

Sorry I should have written “lead the investigation into complaints made against named individuals in the course of their employment”.

JeffThePilot · 24/01/2022 21:18

@Weemammy21

The official response from the Social Services LADO regarding the thresholds not being met stated:

“- Behaved in a way that has harmed or may have harmed, a child

  • Possibly committed a criminal offence against or related to the child
  • Behaved towards a child or children in a way that indicates they pose a risk of harm to children
  • Behaved in a way or may behave in a way that indicates that they may be unsuitable to work with children (Working together to safeguard children, 2018)”

That was the LADO’s response word for word. Well if:

  1. not providing a severely Sen DC with their 1 to 1 supervison when they knew it was unsafe to leave DC unsupervised and
  2. allowing DC to eat clinical waste
  3. lying to the hospital about the type of bin DC ate from and withholding information on what was contained in the clinical waste bin does not meet the above thresholds then no child is safe there.
While the LADO will be a qualified and experienced social worker, they are not “social services” and do not undertake child protection investigations (those who do do not investigate schools/professionals). The LADO role is separate from children's social care, and is to lead the investigation into complaints made against named individuals who are alleged to have acted in a way which causes harm or risk of harm to a child. I wonder if in this case it’s a structural failing in school rather than an individual’s actions. Hence in this case, Ofsted would be the appropriate body, or formal complaint procedures.
Kindnessandcourage · 24/01/2022 21:18

This must be so distressing for you and your child. Hope he is feeling better now. Contact the school chair of governors and complain. Also go to local council and even ofsted. This has to be investigated. Its unfortunate but Schools really downplay their mistakes and its so unfair. This needs to be investigated so that it doesn't happen again with you child or any other child.

Weemammy21 · 24/01/2022 21:17

IMO the school and the chair of governors is only interested in covering it up. The fact that the school staff lied to the hospital about what happened to my severely Sen child put my DC safety and life st risk as hospital was denied the opportunity to make informed decisions about what medical care orctests DC needed. It is this and them waiting another 24 hours to confirm a used incontinence pad was in the bin that makes it clear they can not be trusted to care for Sen children as their first and only priority was to conceal what occurred to medical professionals at the hospital and cover it up. This is every parents nightmare and a change of policy is not enough. I contacted the chair of governors and he didn’t even bother to respond.

OP posts:
sprite25 · 24/01/2022 21:13

@JenniferAlisonPhilippaSue

Am I the only one so far who can see the schools pov on this? Eating wee/poo soaked incontinence pads from a bin is pretty extreme behaviour. It can’t be feasible to literally monitor your child every second. If you push this then I think the most likely outcome would be that they decide that they cannot accommodate the child’s needs and they’re better off leaving until a space becomes available at a more suitable school.
Sorry but this comment has really angered me. Did you not read the part that not only had the child been left alone long enough to reach into the bin bit also retrieve and place something in their mouth, when they were supposed to have one to one supervision but when taken to the hospital they actually withheld information AND lied about what type of contents were in the bin! Yes accidents can happen in the blink of an eye but be honest and find a way forward to ensure it doesn't happen again, instead they lied to try and cover their own arses!
Swipe left for the next trending thread