Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Still feeding 2 year old “baby” food

61 replies

Disneymagic321 · 24/01/2022 14:58

Such as cereal bars or Ella’s kitchen biscuits or even crisps . At what point did you switch to “grown up” food (e.g wotsits) that has a lot more sugar, salt etc? So far he doesn’t know any different and is happy. I give small exposure here and there, so he’s not completely sheltered and try to keep snacks healthy ish e.g, fruits, raisins , rice cakes with hummus, dates. Someone said to me why are you still giving them baby versions, he’s big now! So I’m interested in your experiences to help me get a good balance 😊

OP posts:
busyeatingbiscuits · 24/01/2022 16:39

@Babdoc

When did "snacks" for babies/toddlers become a thing? I had my DC thirty years ago, and simply mashed or gave small portions of my own meals to them. None of us were eating stuff between meals.
30 years ago I had hula hoops and chocolate buttons as snacks!

OP, if your child is happy to have the low sugar/salt baby snacks and you don’t mind the cost, then no need to switch to adult versions.

elbea · 24/01/2022 16:35

You should hold off of sugar until two as much as possible, salt is reduce as much as possible but can have more after one.

Sugar - solidstarts.com/foods/sugar/

Salt - solidstarts.com/starting-solids/sodium-and-babies/

This is info backed up by peer reviewed studies referenced at the end of the article.

Caspianberg · 24/01/2022 16:30

@Babdoc - there’s been ‘kids’ snacks around for ages. I was born 30 odd years ago and I’m sure we lived of those sugary rusk biscuits for years. And snacked on whatever, even adults.

MajesticallyAwkward · 24/01/2022 16:28

Dc1 switched to non- baby stuff by about 18 months, although we'd stopped the pouches by 10 or 11 months. dc2 never had any of the things marketed as 'baby'. He's always just had what we have and I keep an eye on salt/sugar intake.

I realised with dc1 that we were paying a fair bit more for less when buying the baby stuff and she was happy to ditch them.

I don't see the problem with giving these snacks at 2 though.

MaryShelley1818 · 24/01/2022 16:28

My children have always eaten what we have, just regular normal food. The baby is 11mths and for snacks eats, fruit, vegetable sticks, yogurt, bread sticks, cheese, crumpet, plain Biscuit, Crackers and yes occasional few Quavers or some flapjack. Baby snacks are just ridiculously expensive and unnecessary for the most part (mine do like the occasional fruit pouch! Lol)

T00Ts · 24/01/2022 16:23

@Babdoc

When did "snacks" for babies/toddlers become a thing? I had my DC thirty years ago, and simply mashed or gave small portions of my own meals to them. None of us were eating stuff between meals.
I don’t regularly give snacks. My kid doesn’t need it. He’s a bloody good eater and scarfs down his meals, which are generally whatever we’re having. But the occasional biscuit or packet of crisps feature in his life and on those occasions, I give him miserable baby ones because why not, if he doesn’t know any better?
Disneymagic321 · 24/01/2022 16:21

Thanks guys ! Good to see I’m not alone , I am just mindful of the amount of sugar and salt in the grown up versions ! I’ll keep it going for now and see how we go 😊

OP posts:
caringcarer · 24/01/2022 16:19

My first born dd used to think grapes and sultanas were sweeties until she started school. By third child they knew what a KitKat was from about 18 months. Keep them on low salt and low sugar as long as you can.

shouldistop · 24/01/2022 16:16

@Babdoc

When did "snacks" for babies/toddlers become a thing? I had my DC thirty years ago, and simply mashed or gave small portions of my own meals to them. None of us were eating stuff between meals.
The nhs suggests that toddlers need 2 snacks a day and 3 meals. I'd hazard a guess that they know more than the average joe.
bluebeau · 24/01/2022 16:10

my 2 and a half year old eats anything ! after she turned 1 we started giving her more '''our food'' than the ellas stuff for dinner/lunches etc. my meals are tastier and healthier than them so it mad sense.

In regards to snacks IIRC that just naturally progressed. She doesn't have a lot of that stuff generally being at nursery all day. Grandparents certainly don't help with the no sweets agenda but the rare occasion she has them it's not an issue.

I think because she doesnt have them much but we dont say no when she does we dont get the sugar highs and lows or the tantrums. she knows she can't have crackers for dinner and cheekily smiles when we say no lol

mynameiscalypso · 24/01/2022 16:08

DS is 2.5 and I generally have a pouch of baby yoghurt and a baby cereal bar somewhere about my person. He has plenty of normal food but they're so useful when they get hangry or need to be bribed into doing something. I don't know that there's a massive difference between a box of Aldi baby cereal bars and a box of adult cereal bars and as he's the only one who will eat them, it doesn't make much difference. Plus as PP said, some of the yoghurt pouches are long life and don't need to be kept in the fridge so they're handy to have around.

Babdoc · 24/01/2022 16:07

When did "snacks" for babies/toddlers become a thing?
I had my DC thirty years ago, and simply mashed or gave small portions of my own meals to them. None of us were eating stuff between meals.

T00Ts · 24/01/2022 16:05

By the way, I quite like the lentil veggie tube crisps from Aldi. They’re not terrible.

I mean, they’re not Flamin’ Hot Monster Munch, but still.

T00Ts · 24/01/2022 16:04

I’ll avoid giving my toddler added salt and sugar for as long as I can. I’m not particularly precious about it but I equally don’t see the point in him having it, he has his whole life to eat what he likes.

And all the time he doesn’t mind the occasional tasteless baby snacks and he has low standards when it comes to snacking, I’ll give them to him.

PotatoGoblins · 24/01/2022 16:04

DC3 is 2, and I still buy “baby” crisps, like the Organix gruffalo claws etc because she likes them!
She also loves most of the Kiddilicious snack range which are almost always on a special Clubcard price at tescos.
Buy what your kids like and what you know they will eat!

Guineapigssweak · 24/01/2022 16:00

I never really bought baby food. I gave my children what.i cooked but mashed it up. Having 3 kids I never had extra money for separate food so did what my mother and grandmother would have done. It's all a gimmick anyway. Normal yogurts, porridge, toast, meat and veg, fruit, Pasta and sauce etc all suitable for any age. Just don't add or cook with salt. I used raisins for cooking so a large bag was always in my cupboard so just put a handfall in a bowl along with a sandwich for their lunch. (Tiny raisin boxes are silly money )Eggs were used loads as made lots of different meals but dippy eggs were their favourite. I also gave cow's milk/goats milk/soya milk before.they were a year old and they had no issues. Save your.money.

HerculesMulligan · 24/01/2022 15:58

My 7yo's favourite snack is still the flavoured rice cakes you buy in the baby aisle. I think he'll be taking a few bags to university with him.

RestingPandaFace · 24/01/2022 15:54

We still use pouch yogurts with DS as they seem to be lower sugar and he can’t spill them down his school jumper dicking about in the morning

I used ‘baby’ snacks pretty much until he went to school, they are lower salt and sugar versions of the same thing, and generally better nutritionally than the grown up equivalent.

shouldistop · 24/01/2022 15:54

My 5yo still eats oaty bars and baby crisps sometimes.

devildeepbluesea · 24/01/2022 15:52

DD was about 5 when I stopped buying the baby snacks. She had other stuff too, and never had a jar but the snack stuff, I’d say buy for as long as possible

gogohm · 24/01/2022 15:51

Mine ate ordinary food from the start. I obviously didn't give them wotsits then as babies don't need crisps - they had whatever I was eating mashed up/cut up small. From around a year they started to eat convenience foods but I always limited it. I don't understand why they even make baby biscuits or crisps, they don't need them.

grey12 · 24/01/2022 15:49

I used to eat the Ella's kitchen squeezy fruit pouches at uni Grin

My kids always ate what we ate. And those were snacks. They are good as snacks, no matter the age.

Do you mean your child is struggling with food that requires chewing and whatnot?

8dpwoah · 24/01/2022 15:49

We still use the pouch yoghurts sometimes as she likes them, and she (DD 2.5) also still likes the baby crisps, although she likes wotsits and quavers too. The only downside to carrying in with the baby stuff is that it's comparatively expensive but I can't see any issues other than that. I like them too!

Grandparents give her fruit shoots which I'm less keen on but it turns out it's the bottle more than the drink that she likes so I bought a few bottles of water with the same style and she's quite happy with them with tap water in!

Caspianberg · 24/01/2022 15:48

I think most are marketed as 1-5 year ‘toddler’ snacks. So I guess roughly school age before portions too small.

We mainly give Ds regular stuff such as only buy large pot of Greek yogurt everyone eats, not special ‘kids’ versions.

But I like the childrens oat bar type things. They last ages so handy to keep some in car, hand bag, pram as back up if we need when I wasn’t planning to be out longer.

FelicityBob · 24/01/2022 15:40

I give my 5 year old the mamia oaty bars in his lunch box