Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Family staying after new baby

164 replies

Carey55 · 24/01/2022 13:44

Just had DD (3 weeks old) DS is 3. In laws coming to stay for two weeks, I think this is too long and would prefer a week or at most 10 days. My hormones are all over the place so quite prepared to be told I’m being unreasonable.

OP posts:
DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 24/01/2022 16:06

I've noticed in a lot of threads like these, the DH has decided in their wisdom to invite people to stay and thinks that because the invitation has already been issued, it can't be withdrawn or altered in any way.

It most certainly can and by you if DH is mealy mouthed about it.

There may be wittering about how offended everyone will be and so now you have to just put up with it. But consider how offended you are by them deciding they can just come and do this without even asking you.

Tell them unapologetically that you've thought about this proposal and it doesn't suit you, but they are welcome to do xyz (what ever compromise you think you can live with) I say this as someone who had difficult births and difficult inconsiderate relatives and wished there was someone to tell me this.

I0NA · 24/01/2022 16:06

@Carey55

Thanks. DD will be 6 weeks when they arrive. Hubby thinks it will be great. I’m feeling very emotional about it all. My parents stayed for a few days but they were looking after our toddler whilst I was having DD. My parents are local, hubby’s are 6 hours away.
Is your hubby taking the two weeks off to look after them , since he thinks it’s great ?

And He will be doing the shopping / cooking / washing / cleaning for that two weeks ?

And he won’t complain if you are up in your bedroom / in the bath / visiting your mum etc for some of that time? Because he doesn’t get to decide what’s “ great “ for you.

pussycatunpickingcrossesagain · 24/01/2022 16:03

My parents are local

Well that's lucky - you can go there to get some peace and quiet. Grin

Is your DH having 2 wks off work to entertain his family?

WouldBeGood · 24/01/2022 16:00

YANBU. A couple of nights at most.

Marcipex · 24/01/2022 15:59

Hotel.

And ring before they rock up on any given day.

And take your toddler to the park/dog walk/anywhere every afternoon.

And organise a takeaway for dinner.

Purplecatshopaholic · 24/01/2022 15:58

Jeezo, no way. Even a week is too long. If they are coming from far away and must make it worth it, they can get a hotel. Put your foot down on this one right now

RisingSunn · 24/01/2022 15:56

YANBU. In between recovering, feeding, health visitor/checks. It will be all too much.

Absolutely not on.

Rightsraptor · 24/01/2022 15:53

Only permit this if your inlaws will be extremely helpful and don't have to be asked to do stuff. And if you are happy to be looking far from your best around them and are also happy to have your breasts out (assuming breastfeeding) in front of them. Otherwise, no they have to stay elsewhere and that will be a shorter stay most likely, because they'll be paying for their accommodation.

Helocariad · 24/01/2022 15:52

YANBU. Like PP say, it depends how they make you feel and how much they muck in.
Having said that, my parents and in-laws live hrs away too but always stayed in B&Bs when the DC were born. They would come over during the day. MIL was brilliant at helping out, shopping, housework, minding older DC.

You need to speak to your partner and get him on board. Good luck!

Chasingaftermidnight · 24/01/2022 15:51

You couldn’t be being less unreasonable!

I credit - at least in part - the visit we had from my in-laws when my oldest was three weeks old for the fact I developed crushing PND and PNA. I had serious birth injuries and was struggling with BFing and bonding - and we were taking them out to National Trust properties so they were entertained, my DH was cooking three course meals for them, I couldn’t breastfeed in the same room as them, my MIL kept giving unwanted and plain stupid advice (like telling me the safe sleep guidelines were nonsense and I should put the baby to sleep on his front)… it was horrendous.

If you aren’t comfortable with it, stand your ground.

CharityDingle · 24/01/2022 15:50

I genuinely don't understand people who think it's a good idea, to stay for two weeks, when there's a new baby. Who will be doing the preparation for their stay? Will they be sitting back, expecting everything done for them?
If 'hubby' thinks it's great, is he going to be there with them?

Regardless, it's not a good idea. Surely it's a time when you need to be able to rest and relax, insofar as possible, with a new baby and an older child.

MarbleQueen · 24/01/2022 15:49

This is a recipe for disaster.

SafferUpNorth · 24/01/2022 15:47

YANBU - as the person who's just given birth, it's entirely YOUR call who comes to stay, and for how long. Your DH has to respect your wishes on this.

Whether or not women want family staying so soon after the birth is an entirely personal preference that;s so dependent on circumstances - mainly, how well you get on with them and whether they'll be helpful (or a liability).

My mum and dad cam to stay for 3 weeks not long after my son was born - but they live a 12 hour flight away, and were incredibly helpful and supportive... took care of the cooking, cleaning and washing. DH had just returned to work after paternity leave and I was very grateful to have company in the house and be waited on hand and foot.

Anyone less helpful would not have been welcome!

OnTheBenchOfDoom · 24/01/2022 15:45

My PIL stayed for weekends every 5 weeks or so but in a B&B as we were always treated like guests at their house. My Mum on the other hand would come and stay at ours but she was a roll her sleeves up, make you a cup of tea, put your laundry on, take the toddler to the park type of person. Huge difference.

weegiemum · 24/01/2022 15:44

When our kids were born we lived on one of the Scottish islands. Quickest way is to fly, for mu mum and mil it was 2 flights.

When I had dd1, we got home from hospital on Wednesday and my parents (dad and stepmum) arrived on Friday night for the weekend. I wanted my dad to be the first to meet baby as he brought me up, and my lovely stepmum. They could only stay 3 nights due to work, and they were awesome when they were there.

My mum came for a week after that and cleaned the house top to bottom (which made me feel a bit inadequate but hey, the house was clean!). I didn't even have to make a drink. Dh went to work while she was with us. Then mil came for a week (we genuinely had no gaps!) and she did prioritise holding dd1 "for me" over other things, but she did cook and she took dd in the night for a bit so o could sleep (I was ebf but baby was snuffling in her cot and keeping me awake!).

I think if people are coming to help - and really are going to muck in and really help - then it's ok. We were lucky with our parents, though mil was a bit miffed she was last to come. She came first 2 years later when ds was born.

blyn72 · 24/01/2022 15:44

I wouldn't like it but if they are coming to help you, ie housework, shopping, cooking, it might be worth it to give you a break.

crimblecrumbles · 24/01/2022 15:41

You YANBU. They are!! Totally and utterly unreasonable for anyone to expect to stay for one night without your wholehearted blessing but 2 weeks!! I'm angry FOR you! Your DH should recognise what you have been through and nip this in the bud. You need time to recover physically and emotionally. The last thing you need if houseguests. Unbelievably selfish and inconsiderate. Sending hugs Thanks

Nanny0gg · 24/01/2022 15:40

@Carey55

Thanks. DD will be 6 weeks when they arrive. Hubby thinks it will be great. I’m feeling very emotional about it all. My parents stayed for a few days but they were looking after our toddler whilst I was having DD. My parents are local, hubby’s are 6 hours away.
Will he be entertaining them?

Will they be any help at all?

PufferFish · 24/01/2022 15:35

My PIL's arrived to stay within 24 hours of 2 of my 3 being born. It didn't bother me. They were excited and I get on well enough with them. It was nice for the other children to have some attention too, as I was rather preoccupied with the baby. I have never understood babymoons and the like. I've always agreed with the philosophy that it takes a village etc.

However, if you aren't comfortable with it, or if you just feel it's too long, it is entirely your prerogative to speak out now. Far better to be honest than to feel resentful and invaded at such a vulnerable and emotional time. Perhaps the arrangement could be flexible, depending on how the birth goes and how you feel?

Wnkingawalrus · 24/01/2022 15:34

Threads like this make me realise how lucky I am to have both a DM and a MIL who waited on me hand and foot after my kids were born. Both live some distance away and it wouldn’t have crossed my mind to tell them they couldn’t visit when the babies were born. Thankfully they made themselves useful!

OP context is everything. If you think they will help look after you, keep your toddler entertained, keep you fed and watered, etc and generally make life easier then say yes. If not, then say no.

I disagree about people staying in a hotel, for me it makes things harder. Always wondering what time guests will appear, are they staying for dinner or not, they feel like a guest rather than family so make themselves less at home and therefore more hard work for hosting. But I appreciate others feel differently and it’s so dependent on the characters of the individuals.

RoseGoldEagle · 24/01/2022 15:31

That’s too long even without a baby in the picture in my view! I wouldn’t have coped with this when I had a new baby, let alone a toddler and a new baby. I actually can’t believe anyone would be so clueless as to even suggest staying with someone who’s just had a baby. Just so bizarre.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 24/01/2022 15:30

Will your DP be at home all the time they are visiting?

Willhe be cooking, cleaning, making cups of tea, amusing them while they are visiting?

Will he make sure you get uninterupted time to feed, sleep, chill out with your new child while they are visiting?

Will he make sure you don't feel as though your home has been intruded upon whilst they are visiting?

Will he put your comfort, your newborn child, first whilst they are visiting?

If the answer to any of those is no, then he needs to have a rethink and quickly!

diddl · 24/01/2022 15:28

"Hubby thinks it will be great."

Course he does!

They are only 6hrs away-2/3 nights would be fine.

2weeks-I thought that they must be flying in from somewhere!

Pipsquiggle · 24/01/2022 15:25

No bloody way. You need to say 'NO' very firmly. Your DH has no clue whatsoever. I would be apoplectic with rage if my DH did this to me.

When I had my 2nd DC, my DP (who live 4 hours away) stayed in a B&B around the corner for about 4 days.
They usually stay with us when they come down but even they had the emotional intelligence to stay in a B&B with a young baby.

Strokethefurrywall · 24/01/2022 15:21

It totally depends on the type of people they are surely?

We live overseas so had a stream of visitors for 2 weeks at a time after DSs were born but my parents and in laws are magic.
Helpful, kind, did everything around the house I didn't know I wanted them to do, made me endless cups of tea and toast, cakes, walked the dogs, bought the shopping and made dinners, kept us stocked in wine/beer, cooed at the baby whilst I showered, and so on.

I never felt like they were intruding but then they are kind helpful people (and we had the space).

If they're not like that then they should definitely stay in a local premier inn and give you the space you need. You definitely SHOULD NOT be rushing to be the "host". Youre recovering from birthing a human and should be relaxing and recovering, not dicking around trying to accommodate them and their daily requirements.