Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don't think I should pay for this...AIBU?

211 replies

Wenjie · 24/01/2022 06:41

DD is at a university in the United States getting a four year degree in Art & Design: Games and Playable Media. She just found out she almost has enough credits to get a two year degree in Business Administration. It would be around 800 USD, which converts to about 590 GBP. She doesn't think that's much, but I don't even know that employers would care about a two year degree. I know this might not be the right place to post something about schools in the states, but it's caused friction. Am I being too unaccommodating?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Wenjie · 08/02/2022 21:31

She had the meeting with a counselor to draw up a student education plan, but she's still restricted from registering for the courses and they commence in a week, so it may not matter.

OP posts:
Darkstar4855 · 31/01/2022 11:29

I’d pay it, if only so she has something to fall back on if the gaming doesn’t work out. I wouldn’t have paid £55.5K for a gaming degree though. She is very lucky.

NoLongerTroels · 31/01/2022 11:17

55k for a four year degree in California is good.
My Ds did a 4 year degree there in a private Uni. In business and accounting, cost 120k 10 years ago. (included accommodation) Thank god for scholarships, grants and school loans.

HTH1 · 31/01/2022 10:42

Not sure the £55k for a gaming degree is such good value though Shock

HTH1 · 31/01/2022 10:41

It’s a drop in the ocean compared to what you’re already paying, I wouldn’t think twice about it (could add value, in which case it’s a bargain).

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 31/01/2022 10:00

[quote Wenjie]@ThumbWitchesAbroad She has a meeting in four days with a counselor at the community college to get a student education plan updated so she can register for classes. I'm definitely feeling more open-minded after reading the replies on this post. But I'm waiting until after the meeting to decide whether I'll pay for it.[/quote]
Glad the thread seems to have helped you with a wider perspective on the situation - hope that your DD does well.

Wenjie · 31/01/2022 07:28

@LannieDuck I want to thank you, too! Wow, someone whose husband works in the games industry and teaches. That's really interesting. "The games industry doesn't value games degrees." Maybe I should have made a post asking "AIBU to fund a game degree" instead of fretting about the business courses.

OP posts:
Wenjie · 31/01/2022 07:24

@Thethuthinang Thank you for your reply. It was especially interesting to see you husband's perspective on games-related degree programs.

OP posts:
Wenjie · 31/01/2022 06:55

@ThumbWitchesAbroad She has a meeting in four days with a counselor at the community college to get a student education plan updated so she can register for classes. I'm definitely feeling more open-minded after reading the replies on this post. But I'm waiting until after the meeting to decide whether I'll pay for it.

OP posts:
Thethuthinang · 26/01/2022 19:21

I would add that I think your daughter is going to do well. She's bravely come to a new part of the world that is an important center for the games and entertainment industry. My spouse has the same degree and skill set that he had when we lived elsewhere; it wasn't until we moved to California that things took off because the size of the community of like-minded people with similar goals meant so many more oppoy. She'll meet and talk to people and adjust her training as needed. I wouldn't be surprised if that is what has led to her mention of the business degree. Getting into games is highly competitive. It is also constantly changing in terms of markets and tech. Maybe this why a specialized degree doesn't get one "in" the same way a law degree let's you enter the legal business, or a plumbing certification gets you in to plumbing. With games, local connections and mentors are invaluable. For producers and designers, strong fundamentals (writing, familiarity with agile teams and other funky management stuff, data analysis) are really important because the need for these is a constant as one moves from one platform to another. She'll do great.

Suzanne999 · 26/01/2022 09:56

I think if you’re already paying out £55k an additional £600 is a drop in the ocean. I think she and you may regret it in the future if she doesn’t do it.
Any chance of a p/t job to pay you back?

LannieDuck · 26/01/2022 09:37

@Thethuthinang

My spouse is a game designer with about 20 years of experience, and is in charge of hiring for his large team. The Business Admin degree would be somewhat useful, because they have a lot of need for people with general production and management skills. It might even be more useful than the games degree; in my husband's experience classes for games degrees are taught by people who have failed in the industry and they do not hire from those programs. It does sound like she is design/production track rather than coding or art? If she wants coding, the best degree would be from the highest ranked CS program she can get into, avoiding any specialization. If she wants art, some gaming specialization might be okay, but it isn't as valuable as one might think. The degrees of designers are much more eclectic. Spouse's degree is in economics and philosophy. For new designers, he mainly looks for an obsessive level of interest with games, including board games, and ability to see complex projects through to completion.
Agree with all of this. My husband is a computer games designer, he's lectured on games degree courses and regularly interviews for new hires in his company.

The games industry really doesn't value games degrees. They're generally taught by people who used to work in the industry, but are 3-5 years out of date (DH was unusual in doing it alongside a current job). DH would much prefer to see a CV with a good degree in a traditional subject from a good uni (DH did science), and a passion for gaming in their spare time - all types of gaming, incl board games.

Also, as Velvet says, once you get in the pay isn't great because so many people want to do it (I think programmers are an exception here - they do tend to be paid well). And at crunch time, you have to work very long hours.

In your DD's situation, I would pay for the business admin qualification.

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 26/01/2022 09:15

@Wenjie - have you decided to help her out with the funds for this extra qualification now?

CaribouCarafe · 26/01/2022 07:09

I'd definitely fund this or at least loan her the money if I were you - I work as a data analyst and work with lots of programmers and data engineers and can tell you that whilst technical types are 10 a penny its much rarer to come across someone who is both technical and business-headed.

The business qualification (even though it is not a full degree) would set her apart from other candidates who don't have anything to prove that they understand wider company goals and vision and the importance of being able to communicate on a business level.

Furthermore, if she later decides to change career path, the business qualification may be useful to prove her competency in areas beyond art and design.

Thethuthinang · 25/01/2022 14:18

My spouse is a game designer with about 20 years of experience, and is in charge of hiring for his large team. The Business Admin degree would be somewhat useful, because they have a lot of need for people with general production and management skills. It might even be more useful than the games degree; in my husband's experience classes for games degrees are taught by people who have failed in the industry and they do not hire from those programs. It does sound like she is design/production track rather than coding or art? If she wants coding, the best degree would be from the highest ranked CS program she can get into, avoiding any specialization. If she wants art, some gaming specialization might be okay, but it isn't as valuable as one might think. The degrees of designers are much more eclectic. Spouse's degree is in economics and philosophy. For new designers, he mainly looks for an obsessive level of interest with games, including board games, and ability to see complex projects through to completion.

Wenjie · 25/01/2022 08:16

@VelvetChairGirl Thank you so much for replying in such depth. It was really enlightening. You've given me a lot to think about.

OP posts:
NeverEndingFireworks · 24/01/2022 14:11

@ineedsun

Wow, that’s really different to the UK. So you can use your credits twice in the USA?

Is her paying an option?

No - you can in the uk too - so I have a BSC, but along the way I picked up one certificate and one diploma in two different, specific, disciplines - using the credits that finally counted towards my degree (but with no overlap between the lower awards). A certificate or diploma is often available part way through a degree as it's saying you have achieved that, lower, threshold of achievement.
dreamingbohemian · 24/01/2022 13:50

@MinestroneMini yes it's amazing isn't it

California community colleges are highly regarded as well I think

President Biden's wife, Dr Jill, teaches at a community college in Northern Virginia which is also very good

MinestroneMini · 24/01/2022 13:35

@SenecaFallsRedux

Quite a few states in the US have programs that offer free community college tuition.
Just looked this up, it’s a program that has developed since I was in the USA and sounds like a very positive social improvement.
VelvetChairGirl · 24/01/2022 13:30

I was a tester for 5 years, I also did script editing on one game that wiped its face, which was considered a success at the time as on average only about 4 games a year were expected to turn a profit and they propped up the other games, I think the thing cost about 16mill to make.

being a tester is a minimum wage job, with long hours (6 to 7 day weeks during crunch time and shifts upto 48 hours long, yes thats right a single shift with a couple of lunch breaks lasting upto 48 hours).

nitsandwormsdodger · 24/01/2022 13:29

You are paying 55k and quibbling over £600 for an extra qualification!
Maybe let her pay it back to you in her wages if she thinks it’s nothing ?
Curious ... why are you paying for a USA education that definitely won’t be looked at favourably over here ( or anywhere) ?

ancientgran · 24/01/2022 13:20

@VelvetChairGirl

Art & Design: Games and Playable Media.

do you mean she wants to work in the games industry? if so she needs programming languages and lots of them, if she wants to be a character designer she needs a big portfollio of art and to be very very good and very fast at drawing.

she also wants to have no social life as she will be working long hours and weekends for shit pay and being an alcoholic helps because if your not one before you start work you soon will be Grin

Wow, you are really selling it as a career. Are you speaking from experience?
VelvetChairGirl · 24/01/2022 13:13

We did have a tester then ended up a producer, TBH someone in management took a shine to that person and they had a degree in web development.

I dont think it was the degree alone that did it, TBH there was alot of brown nosing the right people and bedding your way up in that company.

Mummyoflittledragon · 24/01/2022 13:11

You would be bonkers not to pay for it. People are at work for many many years. Your dd may change career direction in a couple of decades. Even if not, the degree will stand her in good stead for managerial roles and shows she is more of an all rounder, confident in business and so forth.

As for your desire that she does an internship in game production. Can she do this as well or in addition eg in her spare time?

VelvetChairGirl · 24/01/2022 13:07

I didnt know really what to say this morning as 55k already spent is more money then I have ever had in my life, but as someone else has said about it, I feel emboldened.

I would pay the small amount for the extra, frankly because I think it would give her something to fall back on to perhaps work in HR or Admin in a games company. otherwise she needs to work more on learning programming languages and using them so she has work to show off. and I dont mean 1 group project as part of the course I mean off her own back showing enthusiasm stuff.

I googled the course the OP said and I found one I assume its THE one in america and the only thing it offered was Python the rest of the course seemed to be things like the history of games and the mechanics of games etc.

TBH I worked for a massive Dev/publisher who makes games for sony, nintendo and MS we didnt have people from specific "video games" uni or college courses, management didnt rate them they dont care that you have done a course about the history of games or game mechanics etc, they care that you leaned CAD, programming, web design etc in as many different languages as possible and that if you wanted to be an artist you had a portfolio, if you wanted to do SFX etc portfolio of work, wanted to program have a portfolio of work.

we had a guy who was a tester who went onto be a character artists for another company, he never went to higher education he just had a massive portfolio of his art and was amazingly good, he wanted to be a manga artist and had always loved drawing.

we had someone who went on to be a scriptwriter for games, they did fan fiction stuff and ended up doing a kickstarter campaign with a artist to release their own fantasy comic book series and did do a few volumes, got a writer job off the back of that having already been a tester for years at multiple companies.