Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stop plans for her baby shower

130 replies

Beebababadabo · 23/01/2022 22:18

Ok so my sister is having her first and very likely last baby (she is 42) took about 4 years to get pregnant and I understand this is a very much awaited baby, I know how hard it is to get pregnant as it also happened to me. So my daughter has come down with covid last week and now my son has it, tested just today. All the while my dh and I have tested negative so far. Today I stayed home with my ds and my dd and dh went to dinner at my the in-laws. My Bil (sister husband) said he didn't feel comfortable going so didn't go, even though my dh and dd are testing negative for covid. I'm worried because I've organised a surprise baby shower for my sister this Sunday and I'm afraid my Bil is going to put a stop to it.

It's taken me weeks to plan and money obviously spent. It's only a small affair with 8 ladies in all. We are all going to test on the day for covid and if anyone is positive of course they won't go. But I know because my son has it even if I'm testing negative I'm afraid he won't allow it, he wouldn't even go for a walk outside with friends who child had.it but the dad tested negative. I can't speak to my sister as it's a surprise baby shower to know how she feels (but she has said to me he has been a nightmare with his anxiety since her pregnancy and it actually but her off doing it again, not that she thought she had much of a chance anyway.

Would I be unreasonable to tell him he is being unfair. He suffers from anxiety I know, but I don't see why it should stop my sister from experiencing her first and only baby shower. Of course we be as safe as possible and everyone will test but if everyone is negative just because a family member is positive surely it be safe enough?

OP posts:
TheHoptimist · 24/01/2022 03:15

7 people pay for a Pcr to attend (assuming they were all going to do a Pcr like you) is £300 plus

PepInYourStep · 24/01/2022 03:03

I agree with @LittleGwyneth.

Bellyrumble · 24/01/2022 02:14

Glad you came on here to ask OP as there are some realistic comments

Surprise parties and pandemics don’t mix, not least when someone is heavily pregnant. Fortunately my husband told me my friends had done the same thing and I put a stop to it as I was nervous at 35 weeks and thought it daft they had even considered it.

Ironically I ended up in hospital that same day and told to isolate as I’d been exposed to covid whilst there…. So no win really 🤦🏼‍♀️

I was seen as being over the top but don’t care, avoided catching covid so far and my little one has too.

Perhaps she may feel comfortable to do something after the baby is born, on her terms

Zoom might be a nice idea if you think she’d be keen?

PurpleMauve · 24/01/2022 02:13

OP - I won’t be apologising.

You created this thread to garner opinions to your dilemma. PP simply gave them. You need to get over yourself, as this is not about you.
You are clearly upset with yourself, so please don’t take it out on others who do not agree with you. You’ve now realised that your thought processes were wrong, so just own it without attacking the PP who were instrumental in helping you to see this. Tough love/talk sometimes works, like it has in this case. I don’t believe in beating around the bush, so I said what I said.

Superhanz · 24/01/2022 02:13

He's definitely not being OTT, the rules only changed fairly recently about close contacts. I had a baby in November and there's no way I would have wanted a surprise baby shower sprung on me and cases were much lower then and on top of that there is covid in your household. I was very anxious towards the end of my pregnancy and considering this is a much longed for baby and imagine your sister probably feels the same way. Its very thoughtful of you to throw your sister a baby shower but I think you need to think of the bigger picture. The other option would be to tell her what your plans are but otherwise I really don't think you should go ahead.

Aquamarine1029 · 24/01/2022 01:51

I'm incredulous that you even considered putting her at risk. My SIL got covid at 34 weeks and nearly died from it. She was ventilated for nearly two months and wasn't able to meet her baby until he was nearly four months old. She is still, and will probably always, suffer from heart issues because of it. Unbelievable lack of concern for your pregnant family member.

Italiangreyhound · 24/01/2022 01:29

Very sad but surprise parties a d Covid don't mix. Talk to her. Agree with Spilltheteaplease

"I wouldn't socialise with anyone that currently had covid in their household."

Lots and lots to enjoy with sis and baby, maybe even a post-baby baby shower once baby is here, but not a surprise one. Xx Flowers

JustKittenAround · 24/01/2022 01:23

PS so you can send gifts and flowers. Have BIL hide them until the event. She can then Dona virtual thing where you all give your wishes, praise, and support.

There are so many ways to work around it to make it special!

JustKittenAround · 24/01/2022 01:21

Maybe she can attend virtually? Be sent things to be revealed … like set her up so she is very safe.

I think while it is an American import baby showers were a way for women to give support and connection to an expectant mother.

I think ultimately it might be better to clue her in as the surprise is nice, but what really matters is the feeling of love and sisterhood these events are meant to make her feel.

Or retool it to be videos of you all and she then can be surprised with any favorings you give?

The important part is making sure she feels supported, I know you can do that. I know there are also ways to make her feel special!

You’re very kind OP

Beebababadabo · 24/01/2022 01:10

Rely Confused oh dear I'm tired now. Thanks all I think I've got everything I needed and thanks for helping me see out of my own feelings from a different point of view and put my sister and her baby first.

OP posts:
Beebababadabo · 24/01/2022 01:06

@Tilltheend99

I sympathise as chose not to have a baby shower myself due to Covid but I’m not sure your sister would want to take the risk. You are better off postponing or just discussing it with your sister.
I get the impression most people wouldn't want one during covid. I guess because it was small and we had small family gatherings with them there I didn't think. I will definitely talk to her now. I'm just surprised nobody questioned my idea the family even friends I've spoke to about it. Nobody not even my dh. But I have kind have been blown out the water with "who would do it?!" I will ask more on mumsnet because I clearly can't always reply on family or friends to say they don't think it's a good idea.
OP posts:
PurpleMauve · 24/01/2022 01:02

@Yaya26

PurpleMauve
@Yaya26
💐
“Thank you @PurpleMauve xx

I’m so sorry for your losses. They’re hard to carry aren’t they? I have been blessed with three DCs too.

Sometimes with pregnant women I feel like screaming but it is so hard to know how much or little to say.

If only I could turn back time. Instead of living with a lifetime of regret.”

Thank you @Yaya26. I try to be positive as I managed to have 3 healthy pregancies.
You’ll never forget, but please try not to dwell on the regrets. Focus all of your positive energy on your 3 DC that made it through.

Some people do not want to listen. There’s not much anyone can do about that once all is said and done.

Tilltheend99 · 24/01/2022 00:57

I sympathise as chose not to have a baby shower myself due to Covid but I’m not sure your sister would want to take the risk. You are better off postponing or just discussing it with your sister.

Beebababadabo · 24/01/2022 00:53

@Nancydrawn

My apologies, OP. I shouldn't have been so brusque. I watched a dear friend of a friend get enormously sick whilst pregnant with Covid. And while she and the baby survived, thankfully, she came down with it in part because her family had eschewed basic precautions (gatherings, unmasked and unvaccinated) and mocked her and her husband for being cautious--and it's made me a bit touchy.

I know you're arranging this out of love, and perhaps you can consider alternate arrangements another, even better, way of showing her your love.

It's ok..I'm actually really glad I came on here. Sometimes when your in your own circle a bubble you dont think. I was actually going to get a PCR test before going but I'm not going to risk it now. I feel bad on my Bil to he worries about everything and I think I was putting him down because I know his personality, but he is right. I'm just glad I spoke on here first before perhaps talking to him and thinking he was just typical Bil being worried. I do feel stupid but I'm glad it was with internet stranger and not my family who I do love and want to but their needs first.
OP posts:
Frannibananni · 24/01/2022 00:50

Forgo the surprise and ask her.

Nancydrawn · 24/01/2022 00:44

My apologies, OP. I shouldn't have been so brusque. I watched a dear friend of a friend get enormously sick whilst pregnant with Covid. And while she and the baby survived, thankfully, she came down with it in part because her family had eschewed basic precautions (gatherings, unmasked and unvaccinated) and mocked her and her husband for being cautious--and it's made me a bit touchy.

I know you're arranging this out of love, and perhaps you can consider alternate arrangements another, even better, way of showing her your love.

Pantsomime · 24/01/2022 00:43

“I wouldn't thank anyone putting a surprise above me being to make my own decisions about my health.
She might be really angry with you if you just go ahead regardless, or worse still, catch covid.”

This.

Beebababadabo · 24/01/2022 00:41

It's a shame some people are needlessly rude as some people it would put off from making better choices. I don't mind being told I'm wrong of course, I was in this instance and I see that. But those of you who have been insulting after I said I'm wrong and fix my mistake (the party hasn't happened) saying I'm dithering, selfish and the small party I've organised is just ridiculous. Just remember you can get people to see your point of view without tearing them down and I'm thick skinned so it will wash over me and I do get the point and will follow through. Those who gave to the point constructive criticism thanks. People generally respond better without pointless opinions and needless insults though.

OP posts:
Yaya26 · 24/01/2022 00:40

[quote PurpleMauve]@Yaya26
💐[/quote]
Thank you @PurpleMauve xx

I’m so sorry for your losses. They’re hard to carry aren’t they? I have been blessed with three DCs too.

Sometimes with pregnant women I feel like screaming but it is so hard to know how much or little to say.

If only I could turn back time. Instead of living with a lifetime of regret.

ittakes2 · 24/01/2022 00:36

Your 42 year old sister is pregnant with a much wanted baby and you want to take the risk? I would be very upset with you if you were my sister.

Nancydrawn · 24/01/2022 00:34

You are being breathtakingly selfish and shortsighted.

Covid is appallingly dangerous for pregnant women. I'm assuming your sister is vaccinated, which should help, but it's a significant risk factor for what is already a high-risk pregnancy due to her age.

I appreciate and admire that you're being shortsighted because you love your sister and want to celebrate with her. But going to your parents with covid in the house; trying to arrange an intimate get-together with your sister while you still may be infectious; and denigrating your BIL for being considerate of his child and his wife are, well, not particularly broad-minded of you.

I hope you can figure out a way to celebrate without meeting up whilst your household has covid.

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 24/01/2022 00:33

A surprise party for a pregnant women while we are in a pandemic...

Honestly all the issues you're having right now were quite easy to predict.

PurpleMauve · 24/01/2022 00:29

@Yaya26
💐

PurpleMauve · 24/01/2022 00:27

‘I’d definitely cancel the shower. Not trying to be a scaremonger but I know of many cases locally from last summer up until recently where the outcome for pregnant women and babies has been very bad. I have lost babies both late in pregnancy and after birth and I probably will get slated for this but if she my sister I’d be wrapping her up in cotton wool and keeping her safe at home until after the baby is safely here. A shower is one day a stupid party - it’s really not important.’

You definitely should not get slated. I totally agree with you. I have 3 DC along with both early and late MC in between.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 24/01/2022 00:26

If you've arranged it as a surprise, what if SHE tests positive a couple of days before? I just don't think surprise parties are at all practical at the moment. But it was a nice idea. Tell her and let her make her own mind up.