Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not tell MIL we want to move abroad?

130 replies

Londonlife123 · 23/01/2022 19:53

My husband and I are currently looking for jobs in Asia to move to this July. We have got 2 young children. We have not told my husbands mother yet as we assume she would be very upset, but we don't want to tell her unless it is a definite yes. She sees them roughly once a week for a few hours with us there. Do you think it is the right thing to not tell her now, or do you think she would be more hurt if we were to tell her last minute?
Yabu- you should tell her now
Yanbu- don't tell her until it is confirmed by
Also, do you think it is really nasty of us to move so far away? It has been a dream of mine and my husbands for a few years now and we thought it is the perfect time before our kids start secondary school.

OP posts:
lifesnotaspectatorsport · 24/01/2022 20:25

We moved abroad, initially to Asia, 6 years ago. MIL was similar age to yours, no other parents living on either side. We didn't have children then but now have 3 (her only grandchildren) and still live abroad though not as far.

You should do what feels right for you and your kids. I agree that living abroad is an incredible experience and only gets more so as the kids grow. Mine are growing up bilingual and are a part of two countries' cultures. I actually don't envisage ever going 'home' and think it would be a loss for them.

MIL visits regularly and has ever since we moved, and admits she's had some amazing experiences as a result. I'm sure she would prefer her grandkids to be down the road but we always lived a minimum of 100 miles away even in the U.K. She understands that they have a better quality of life here.

I would definitely tell her several months in advance so she can come to terms with the idea, and actively plan for lots of visits. If you really only intend it to be temporary and see the U.K. as your eventual home, reassure her of that too. But it is your life to live and I would not let the guilt stop you. We don't have children so that they stay always by our side. You can make this work and be exciting for her too.

Cameleongirl · 24/01/2022 20:05

@HelloFrostyMorning What sometimes happens when two foreign nationals live and work abroad for a while and fall in love?

That's what happened to American DH and I, we were both working in another country and met. We've spent time in both the UK and the US, but our family simply can't be in the same country as all our extended family all the time. It doesn't mean we don't love them. Plus, we have to go where the job opportunities are.

Londonlife123 · 24/01/2022 19:57

Thanks for all your replies...
I am surprised by how many people are really against moving abroad!! Like I have said I have lived in three other countries pre children and absolutely loved the experience of seeing new things, being immersed in different cultures and meeting so many amazing people.
I understand that it is not for some, but I don't see how so many people are so against the idea.
@HelloFrostyMorning thanks for your reply, you are right, you can get those things from England, but why not try a different country? Why not further your career in another country?
So many love abroad and are SO happy with their decision. We are not planning on staying forever, we want to come back within 10 years (when my children start secondary school).
The original question was not about if it is the right or thing to go, but when to tell the mil.
She is a healthy 60 year old, so is capable of visiting if she wanted. Like I said, she is retired so has got quite a lot of flexibility.

OP posts:
HelloFrostyMorning · 24/01/2022 19:47

@exexpat

There is a lot more to living and working overseas than 'sunshine and money' Hmm Career opportunities, culture, languages...

You can get all of this in the UK.

Why do some people think you can only have a full and eventful life by moving to another continent? Confused

You can have a great career in the UK, and a great life, and a great education, AND you can meet and experience other cultures/nationalities in many towns and cities. In addition, you can go travelling if you want to see around other countries.

I would work abroad for a short spell to experience life in another country (like on a cruise ship or in a holiday park etc,) but moving there permanently? Nope. No thanks.

There is absolutely no need to move to another country 'for work' or 'for career opportunities'

Personally, I would only leave the UK if I had no-one here who meant anything to me.

Cameleongirl · 24/01/2022 19:19

Eh? What is the point of educating your kids so the world is their oyster if you plan to emotionally manipulate them into never moving away?

I completely agree @Haveyoubrushedyourteethtoday, I want my children to live the best lives for them, not for me. Of course, it will be great if I can see them/any future grandchildren regularly, but if they're living happy lives elsewhere, that's fine by me. I'm here to give them the confidence to do what they want with their lives - tbh, I'd be more concerned if they always stay close to home, I'd feel that I hadn't given them the tools to spread their wings.

ChubbyMorticia · 24/01/2022 18:43

[quote GrannytoaUnicorn]@Londonlife123 Is this something you both want or something you want, OP?

You asked for opinions on the right or wrong of moving there and so my answer to that is YABU. In my personal opinion, taking children SO FAR away from a grandparent when it's not a requirement for an existing job, is cruel.
Before I get piled on - OP did ask for opinions and that's mine, sorry [/quote]
Isn't it also cruel to expect/demand your children give up their dreams for you?

MargosKaftan · 24/01/2022 18:41

I dont think its horribly selfish to plan your lives for what would be best for you, your dh and your dc , rather than the preferences of a grandparent.

I would wait until you are in the interview stage /negotiation stage for a job. Dont tell her now when it's not definitely a thing that's going to happen. Wait until there's something to tell.

exexpat · 24/01/2022 18:32

There is a lot more to living and working overseas than 'sunshine and money' Hmm. Career opportunities, culture, languages...

From the age of about 15 I was learning multiple languages and working towards a career that involved living and travelling around the world, and although I am sure my mother would have preferred me to stay safely around the corner, my parents were proud of what I did with my life choices. They did not expect my adult life to revolve around my relationship with them - I think it is very unhealthy and unrealistic for any parent to expect that.

I think my children's lives have been enriched by their early exposure to other cultures and languages; both now have partners from an international background and I would be very surprised if one or both of them does not end up living outside the UK temporarily or permanently in future, and I will support them in whatever they want to do. If that means I have to travel and use the internet to get to know any future grandchildren, that is fine by me.

It's a big world and you only get once chance to live your life!

ChubbyMorticia · 24/01/2022 18:10

@Thirtytimesround

Honestly? I do think it’s very selfish, yes. Living abroad can be fun and lucrative but the time for that is before you have kids. What you’re telling her is that you value sunshine and money more than her relationship with her son and grandchildren.

She will, quite rightly, be devasted and very hurt, and it will change your relationship with her forever.

I wouldn’t do it.

I will never understand this.

Why are people obligated to live their lives for others? Why does how MIL feel about their lives matter more than the people living them?

At what point are you allowed to make choices that allow you to live your dreams? Only before and after children? Oh, not after, b/c there may be grandchildren. And then your children are expected to live their lives around you, and on and on it goes...

GrannytoaUnicorn · 24/01/2022 16:13

@Londonlife123 Is this something you both want or something you want, OP?

You asked for opinions on the right or wrong of moving there and so my answer to that is YABU. In my personal opinion, taking children SO FAR away from a grandparent when it's not a requirement for an existing job, is cruel.
Before I get piled on - OP did ask for opinions and that's mine, sorry

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 24/01/2022 15:10

And honestly, if you live abroad, it’s much the same as living in the other side of the country when you tally up actual face time.

I guess if you live somewhere near that could be true, but in many circumstances it's not. I see my sister who's in this country around 6 times a year for an average of 2 days each time.

I see my sister who lives on the other side of the world an average of 1 time every 2.5 years for 2-3 days at a time (she has lots of people she wants to see when she visits and we can't visit her for various reasons. My little sister can't visit her simply as they can't afford it).

I speak to my sister here much more because time zone differences make it harder to talk to the aboard sister.

Ruibies · 24/01/2022 15:05

I would tell her sooner than later, and give her time to come to terms with it. We moved to Asia in our mid-20s and had the best time, living in Shanghai and then HK. What an amazing experience for your kids!

If I were you, I would frame it as an exciting adventure for your family, and not even touch on how much you think it will upset her, just talk about the excitingness of it all. You can also reassure her all the ways you can stay in touch - my mum and I left voice notes for each other on whatsapp when busy and time difference meant we couldn't always call. It was lovely to listen to her chatting on about her day as I walked home from work. We video called whenever we could. I sent her photos all the time and she followed us both on Instagram - and could see what an amazing time we were having. We both downloaded a scrabble app and played each other on an ongoing basis. We sent each other postcards - even if she was just sending one from our hometown, it was lovely to receive written post. There is a drawing app a bit like pictionary - you are given a word to draw and then the other person guesses it. Your MIL could play something like that with your children via your phone or a tablet? There are so many ways to keep in touch nowadays, the world really is very small.

Haveyoubrushedyourteethtoday · 24/01/2022 14:08

@Londonlife123

She is retired but volunteers three days a week. She is 60. I really like the idea of a flight but two things worry me... covid restrictions and isolation periods for her if she visited, and also, I don't know if she would travel that far to visit us in Asia
If she won’t travel that far, that’s on her. She is YOUNG! (I’m assuming in good health?). Dad was well into his 70s. He came for long stays with us while we were in Singapore and Hong Kong.

Unless you are looking at Hong Kong, where 3 week quarantine will be a reality fir a long time I think, the rest of Asia is slowly opening up. Fingers crossed back to normal in another 12 months.

MacaroniCheeseCat · 24/01/2022 13:36

I suppose the question is, which would you regret more on your deathbed? Never moving abroad for a few years in order not to upset anyone, or a few years out of the U.K. and your relatives being upset you didn’t stay down the road? Most people regret the things they didn’t do rather than the things they did.

I’m not sure whether I’d tell her now or when contracts were signed. The latter would be tempting but I think I’d tell her now or then I’d feel guilty for keeping something from her for potentially months.

Play8063 · 24/01/2022 13:33

I'm an expat. You have 1 life. Go for it.

Tell her, with notice, but when it's certain. And provided tou have a good relationship, open your house to her visits and encourage her to come over.

Live your dream and expose your kids to other cultures! Good luck!

Haveyoubrushedyourteethtoday · 24/01/2022 11:14

@Thirtytimesround

Honestly? I do think it’s very selfish, yes. Living abroad can be fun and lucrative but the time for that is before you have kids. What you’re telling her is that you value sunshine and money more than her relationship with her son and grandchildren.

She will, quite rightly, be devasted and very hurt, and it will change your relationship with her forever.

I wouldn’t do it.

Eh? What is the point of educating your kids so the world is their oyster if you plan to emotionally manipulate them into never moving away?

We have lived in 4 different countries and honestly having parents and in-laws come stay/holiday with us was wonderful (they’re all gone now though). And honestly, if you live abroad, it’s much the same as living in the other side of the country when you tally up actual face time.

If and when you tell her, have her first visit planned to soften the blow.

Ulelia · 24/01/2022 11:05

That wasn't a reply to @Thirtytimesround, I was going to write a reply and couldn't find the words to say how dismissive and rude I found that comment.

Ulelia · 24/01/2022 11:03

@Thirtytimesround

Honestly? I do think it’s very selfish, yes. Living abroad can be fun and lucrative but the time for that is before you have kids. What you’re telling her is that you value sunshine and money more than her relationship with her son and grandchildren.

She will, quite rightly, be devasted and very hurt, and it will change your relationship with her forever.

I wouldn’t do it.

I don't understand why the choice is now or last minute? I knew my Dad would be very upset when we moved further away from him (already in a different country but now three times as far) so told him when I'd been offered the job. That way he could be involved in the discussion about if we should take it, and think about the benefits and so on. He's still not thrilled by it, but definitely came to terms with it sooner from knowing how and why we made the decision.
waitingformygirl · 24/01/2022 10:48

I think telling her now would be better. We moved away from my inlaws recently but have been talking about it for a few years. We knew we wouldn't see them much once we'd moved as mil doesn't leave the house much. We kept them in the loop completely, when my dh was applying for further away jobs, we sent them ads for houses and told them when we viewed this one. The move was still difficult of course but they were part of it and we hope we were showing them that they are very important to us all.

Prescottdanni123 · 24/01/2022 10:40

Telling her now would be kinder and it is not a shock. She has time to get her head around it.

Saying to her in a few months time "Oh, by the way, we are moving to Asia next Tuesday," would be unfair.

mandoforever · 24/01/2022 10:36

I'm a devoted grandmother of your mil's age and if be devastated to be told at the last minute.
I would be upset but be pleased you were following your dreams. The advanced warning would give me time to come to terms with it. I'd feel even better if I was reassured I'd always be welcome to stay.

lioncitygirl · 24/01/2022 10:32

Of course you should live and move to where you want to. I did it. Just be prepared for a massive change in your relationship, especially with the kids and her. I had my kids here in Europe as whilst I try and maintain some relationship- it’s very very hard. For context - I’m from Asia. Good luck. She will be heartbroken but you have to do what’s right for your family.

cookiemonster2468 · 24/01/2022 10:26

@Thirtytimesround

Honestly? I do think it’s very selfish, yes. Living abroad can be fun and lucrative but the time for that is before you have kids. What you’re telling her is that you value sunshine and money more than her relationship with her son and grandchildren.

She will, quite rightly, be devasted and very hurt, and it will change your relationship with her forever.

I wouldn’t do it.

This is a small minded comment.

There can be huge differences in quality of life from one place to another, and you have to live in a place that makes you feel whole and suits who you are. It's not just about a certain place being "fun and lucrative".

If I'd have stayed in the place I grew up I would have been utterly miserable. Some of my family members think I moved away to go on a jolly and enjoy myself. The reality is much more complex as I imagine it is for many people.

cookiemonster2468 · 24/01/2022 10:22

Tell her as soon as you reasonably can once you are fairly sure it's happening.

Don't leave it until the last minute. She will need time to prepare emotionally.

alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 · 24/01/2022 10:07

@Thirtytimesround

Honestly? I do think it’s very selfish, yes. Living abroad can be fun and lucrative but the time for that is before you have kids. What you’re telling her is that you value sunshine and money more than her relationship with her son and grandchildren.

She will, quite rightly, be devasted and very hurt, and it will change your relationship with her forever.

I wouldn’t do it.

What small minded rubbish! My folks are extremely proud that I've lived in several countries, they know I would have been utterly miserable to live in the same place as them, I couldn't get out of there quick enough! Yes our families miss us, but its still possible to have a close relationship! Its got absolutely zero to do with valuing money and sunshine over family, how rude!