Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is a bit unfair and to remove daughter?

61 replies

TheBigPeachy · 23/01/2022 19:40

My dd is 9 she started at a local performaning arts group age 4 she's always really liked it.
There are usually 3 shows a year. In her section there are around 15 children.
Dd has never had a named part since she started. Which is fine other people might be better suited to the roles etc etc.
However it's became more apparent that the children 5 or so of them tend to always get the main roles. These children are the same ones that pay for private singing tutorials with the group leader.
Dd came home heartbroken after auditioning for 2 weeks and again not getting a named role.
She's now saying she doesn't want to go back there (she's really upset bless her). I've let things cool and said we could carry on, find a different hobby maybe but she's said she wants to carry on but not there.
Would you move her? Is it a bit unfair that it's the same few kids every time?

OP posts:
Nancydrawn · 24/01/2022 00:36

Your daughter is 9, and play acting and singing should be fun! I'm sorry you're having such a miserable time. Yes, remove her, and feel free to tell the leader why--not because your daughter can't hack it, but because she shouldn't have to hack it, because she is nine.

wanttomarryamillionaire · 24/01/2022 00:29

My dd had this at school. She loves singing, dancing and acting and had tuition outside of school in all 3. Every single school play and assembly it would be the same 2 or 3 children who had the main parts, they also received lots of awards etc in assemblies. All three of them were also children who's parents were members of staff at the school. It became very disheartening to hear my daughter say at 8 years old that she wasn't going to bother trying anymore because she knew she wouldn't get a part.

skgnome · 24/01/2022 00:07

Just move her
Giving the class the benefit of the doubt, maybe it’s a serious performing school and your daughter it’s not at the level required…
Saying that, she’s 9! Move her to a less serious group… again, she’s 9, having fun and gaining confidence are more important
If they ask do tell them why you’re moving her; but equally, if it’s a very “serious” school be prepared to learn that your DD is just not at the level of the other kids - the entertainment industry is brutal
And find a group where fun is the emphasis

ThirdElephant · 23/01/2022 23:54

She's told you what she wants to do, so do it.

I fail to see the dilemma.

dancinfeet · 23/01/2022 23:50

@WhatICallMyUsername that is shocking behaviour from your former dance teacher, and shows her lack of skill and imagination if she wasn’t able to visualise and reblock a piece of group choreography to accommodate an extra dancer rather than substituting a replacement in your spot and making you feel worthless in the process.

OP- by all means take your child out if the class is no longer a suitable fit for your child.
Before you leave the scathing review that another poster suggested- ask yourself this, is your child honestly at the same standard as those that have private lessons who were cast in main roles? Often in performance type groups there can be favourites who always seem to get the lead, but it’s also easy to call favouritism when sometimes it’s just a case of the other child/children take more classes per week and so have improved at a faster rate. I have students who dance for 2 hrs a week and students who dance for 10 hrs a week, of course the ones who do 3-4 evenings are better than the once a week students and they also do more performances and competitions as they are willing to put in the required amount of time. This may seem unfair on the ones who cannot afford to do these additional things, in the same way that my daughters never got to do horse riding or go skiing- because it’s out of our budget. I don’t resent people who can afford those things. If you can afford to attend the class but not the private lessons then accept that some of the children have an advantage when it comes to auditioning for parts- it’s not an unfair advantage, it’s just an advantage.
If the performance is meant to be a demonstration of class work then all children should have the chance to show what they can do, no matter what their ability level is, if it’s an audition for something then they have that advantage, which their parents are paying for (like any parents who pay for a tutor for GCSEs or the 11+ to give their child an academic advantage).
I’m not saying that your daughter isn’t as able, if she is genuinely of a higher or even the same standard but being overlooked then another group will do her good. BTW I couldn’t afford private singing tuition for my daughter until she was 17 despite knowing that she wanted to follow that career path, so she only had a year of singing lessons to accompany the dance classes that she already took before auditioning for a course in professional musical theatre, she was accepted and now is a professional performer, so please don’t think that there is no hope in continuing. Ultimately it’s a hobby, and if the class is too competitive for your DD find another group that is a bit less full on.

reluctantbrit · 23/01/2022 21:49

@accidentlygothereagain

I did performing arts from 6-18 (I'm 22 now). I've been at different schools and groups. I'd say in general you'll find that everywhere.

It may seem unfair and definitely can be! But generally the stronger students would be suited to the named roles. Throughout all of my years it was always the same people getting cast as the main part.

Moving her could make her shine from the crowd though!

But be prepared that this thing is common in the industry I'm afraid.

In general I agree with you. I doubt DD will ever get a large singing solo as some of the pupils are more talentend than others and nothing is worse than a voice which can't carry.

And DD has some "classmates" who perform on West End level on a regular basis.

But, a good school also ensures that all pupils who want do have an opportunity, it doesn't have to be a large part but having a part gives a boost and also ensures the child enjoys the lesson. We had different main part children for an informal parent only performance to the huge end of Summer show. There are also some who hate the spotlight on stage but would happily sing in front of a small audience.

I would wonder why a child who constantly auditions never get any part and the teacher is not making sure there is progress. Or is open enough to the parent that it is a hopeless case.

I found that in DD's previous school you had the same issue as with school mums on the PTA, the ones who volunteered all the time, the ones who always said yes to whatever the owner said.

Luredbyapomegranate · 23/01/2022 21:32

Move her. There should be a similar group around.

Pamlar · 23/01/2022 21:24

Poor thing.
I would move her and tell them why.
All those years of participation and never being picked seems terribly unfair. If the response is not suitably regretful I would do as @AdultingInTheCountryside suggested and leave a neg review online.

Pythonesque · 23/01/2022 21:21

@Cabbagepie

Unfortunately this seems to be the way these things go in many dance schools. The only time my daughter and her friend got a main part was when an external person who didn't know who the 'stars' were did the auditions. Cue lots of outrage from those who expected the parts and complaints from their mothers. He didn't have any skin in the game and stuck to his guns.
Same thing in music. This comment reminds me of a musician/teacher I knew well telling me she was asked to adjudicate an eisteddfod once. And apparently gave the prizes to all the wrong performers so was not asked back. Similarly, the "pecking order" in my sister's age group on her instrument was established early. When there was a big conference interstate that asked for video auditions for a gala concert - absolute shock that my sister was chosen ahead of several others who "should" have had it.

I hope you can find a group with a better environment for her to participate in and continue to actually enjoy the process.

ginnybag · 23/01/2022 21:21

Move her. I teach kids drama and run an amdram company, and that shouldn't be happening in a 'teaching' group.

I know why it is, though. There is something of a conflict between 'teacher' and 'director'. Teacher absolutely should be ensuring fairness and learning opportunities for all, but Director will naturally tip towards 'bankable' casting. Its hard to igmore a child you know can handle a role and give a solid performance, in favour of an unknown. A 'weak' lead can really limit a whole show and causes stress for the whole cast.

Also, whilst there will be nepotism in force - she needs those kids on her bottom line because they do pay her more - there's also knowing she'll have that extra time with them every week. The other kids don't only need to be as good - they need to be as good in less rehearsal time.

Too, there is pressure on the business for every show to beat expectations, because if it doesn't then parents do pull their kids for somewhere 'better'.

The conflict is why we pulled in an external panel for our show, who knew nothing about the kids. Then stuck to their results.

But, yes, move her and tell the teacher why. A taught class should support all the children fairly.

Pedalpushers · 23/01/2022 21:03

I think it depends how 'serious' the performing arts school is. Not everything in life is fair and it's not school where everyone gets a turn automatically, it's a dedicated performing arts outfit. You could say that it's equally unfair to deprive a more talented child of a part and performing experience that by merit should be theirs. Kids messing around - take turns. Serious performing arts training - those who are most dedicated and talented should get the parts, like they would in the real world.

FortySeven · 23/01/2022 21:02

Obvs move her! And tell them (and the other parents) exactly why

RocketAndAFuckingMelon · 23/01/2022 20:55

I'd move her. My DD is at a similar performing arts class (I wonder whether it is a different branch of the same one, as I've heard they really vary on this according to the personality of the leader) and all the children get a chance to do something, even if that means rotating the "main part" across two or three different children for the performance (confusing as hell for the parents I will admit!) That includes the children with SEN and the children who are not natural performers. I think it's brilliant. So less nepotistic places do exist!

grapewine · 23/01/2022 20:53

@WhereYouLeftIt

"However it's became more apparent that the children 5 or so of them tend to always get the main roles. These children are the same ones that pay for private singing tutorials with the group leader." It's not going to change, is it? So yes, I'd remove my daughter from this group and tell the group leader exactly why.

"she's said she wants to carry on but not there."
Listen to your daughter and find her another group. She doesn't want to be part of this group any more.

All of this. Definitely listen to her.
accidentlygothereagain · 23/01/2022 20:51

I did performing arts from 6-18 (I'm 22 now). I've been at different schools and groups. I'd say in general you'll find that everywhere.

It may seem unfair and definitely can be! But generally the stronger students would be suited to the named roles. Throughout all of my years it was always the same people getting cast as the main part.

Moving her could make her shine from the crowd though!

But be prepared that this thing is common in the industry I'm afraid.

Thirtytimesround · 23/01/2022 20:48

Of course move her!!

If she stays, you’re basically teaching her to put up and shup up with unfairness - a far far more damaging lesson than any benefit she can be getting from the classes.

I’d write a very blunt email to the school leader saying that X has been in your class for years, she has never been allocated a named part despite auditioning constantly, so either the teacher isn’t able to teach her to the required standard or the part allocation is unfair, but either way it is demoralising and harmful for your daughter to accept rejection from her teachers over and over again for years, and therefore you are removing her and looking for a different school that is actually interested in the welfare and development of its students.

Mistressofnone · 23/01/2022 20:46

Yes I'd remove her, especially if that's her wish too. Find a different performing arts school and explain to the new teacher what you found unfair about the previous one.

If she remains there during these important years, her confidence will be shot to bits. Will be such a waste of talent too.

AdultingInTheCountryside · 23/01/2022 20:43

Move her and also leave a scathing review online to as why people shouldn’t join.

WhatICallMyUsername · 23/01/2022 20:41

When I was younger I had dance lessons several times a week. We often had to stay behind to learn group dances for dance competitions. I stayed behind as requested and was informed I was no longer in this dance as someone from another dance school had joined and she'd replaced me.

I fully understand she was obviously better than me but I had already been told I was in it.

I was getting a lift home from one of the other parents so had no choice but to sit and watch trying not to cry

I never went back

Dogdayafternoonz · 23/01/2022 20:41

I'd move her. You aren't paying the place to make her feel bad about herself.

Larryyourwaiter · 23/01/2022 20:37

It’s an educational activity you are paying for, she should be participating fully. I’d move her.
It’s bad enough this goes on in school but when you are paying, ridiculous.

reluctantbrit · 23/01/2022 20:34

That was one reason we moved DD from one performing arts school to another.

AliceMcK · 23/01/2022 20:33

I’d be asking why the children who pay for private lessons are the only ones getting parts, just to put her on the spot.

thepeopleversuswork · 23/01/2022 20:27

I would move her. My DD does a drama club at the weekends and the organisers go out of their way to ensure all children get a chance and not just put the “stars” forward every time.

It’s not the West End, it’s meant to be educational and if they are picking the same kids every time they are failing the others.

It doesn’t have to be like that. Find a better club.

Wineat5isfine · 23/01/2022 20:27

Sadly, we have also experienced this and friends have too. Money talks…and it’s quite despicable to watch and experience this - and it is all down to the group leader.

#bribery

Swipe left for the next trending thread