Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is a bit unfair and to remove daughter?

61 replies

TheBigPeachy · 23/01/2022 19:40

My dd is 9 she started at a local performaning arts group age 4 she's always really liked it.
There are usually 3 shows a year. In her section there are around 15 children.
Dd has never had a named part since she started. Which is fine other people might be better suited to the roles etc etc.
However it's became more apparent that the children 5 or so of them tend to always get the main roles. These children are the same ones that pay for private singing tutorials with the group leader.
Dd came home heartbroken after auditioning for 2 weeks and again not getting a named role.
She's now saying she doesn't want to go back there (she's really upset bless her). I've let things cool and said we could carry on, find a different hobby maybe but she's said she wants to carry on but not there.
Would you move her? Is it a bit unfair that it's the same few kids every time?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MargaretThursday · 24/01/2022 19:08

I've had children in various performing arts.
In a lot of way the teachers can be caught between a rock and a hard place.
They pick the same kids, then everyone says it's favourites and unfair.
They give everyone the chance and they may end up with a poor production and then parents pull their children out because the show was "rubbish". Yes, that does happen, seen it several times.

The extra singing = parts can be one of several reasons:

  1. Those who are good tend to have extra lessons
  2. Those who have singing lessons are better because... they have singing lessons, and possibly teach them for the audition
  3. The children who have singing lessons have pushy parents who will make a fuss if they don't get the main part
  4. They give main parts to the children who have extra lessons because they want them to keep paying.

I've seen all of those happening at various places.

It isn't just talent going into the auditions. It's also how well a child listens to instructions, are they likely to panic on the day, are they unreliable (I've been at a dress rehearsal where the main part didn't turn up with no warning), how well do they work with their opposite number etc.
There can with a known group also be a bit of history-she did particularly well with her small part last year, let's give her a big part this time; he refused to wear the costume last year because he didn't like the hat, let's avoid the part with a major costume.
You can also have the situation that they're very keen to give new people the chance to see what they can do (and keep them coming back :D) so the regulars get bumped down each year.
With one of mine I was fairly sure she was given some of the parts because she was very good at herding/encouraging the younger ones and they wanted her off stage to do that at certain points.

Yes, I would pull her out and look for another if she's asking. But don't get your hopes up it necessarily will change.

What I would look for is:
Camaraderie: When they're encouraging each other and cheering for each other. Fingers crossed all watching in the wings because their friend finds this bit difficult is lovely. Yes there might be a bit of rivalry too, you'll never eliminate that, but when they work together and want to see each other that's good. Ds came out from his first session back saying "it was brilliant except X wasn't there." Not that X is his best friend, but he missed them because they are part of the group/

Fun: A great show is one thing, but how did they get there? You want to see the children going in running and calling to friends, and coming out laughing and full of adrenalin.

Control: A theatre can be dangerous. You want the leaders to be in control. I've chaperoned when the leaders are not in control and it's not fun for the children or anyone else. You want so that if they say "lights down, stand still" that one doesn't decide to see what happens if they jump off the stage, knocking the others in the way."

Performances: Some places go for lots of performances, drama festivals etc. Some don't. I don't think it really matters, but your child may love or hate them.

So look at a few and decide what you want from it. Give her the chance of picking from some, but sometimes the little independent ones can be better than big franchise-and sometimes the franchise ones are great! Give them both a chance.

Ffsmakeitstop · 24/01/2022 18:53

Not quite the same but at school my ds1 was desperate to do after school rugby. I asked the teacher if he could join and he said only if we bought the boots and kit beforehand. We spent s fortune and the poor kid never got a game only ever practice games. I asked the teacher why he was never picked and was told it was because he wasn't very good and they wanted to win whatever trophy it was.
I told him it should be the taking part that mattered not winning. Ds1 never went back and wouldn't do any sport after that.

TrainingToBeFun · 24/01/2022 18:32

Move her, we had the same with our branch of Stagecoach. The hilarious things is the enthusiastic sales pitch the organiser gave me when dd was in reception, how great for her confidence it will be and isn't that what we want as parents for our dc, fast forward 3 years and £££££ paid and hours wasted dd who is naturally confident and able and who was getting good parts at school had max. 1-2 line if any during all plays. When I realised, way too late I instantly removed her.

itsgettingweird · 24/01/2022 18:03

It's sadly often how things go in a lot of competitive situations.

I agree it's sad.

You have your "go to" people because they are a safe bet. Others then never get a chance yet could prove to be the better bet.

That's why you hear about someone's "break". As in they get a chance and prove themselves rather than they suddenly become amazing and weren't before.

It can happen in employment as well. We recently had an internal opportunity for promotion for a new role. It was also external. No one internal would go for it as they felt X was a shoe in.

I'm senior to all these staff who refused to go for it and felt one had an opportunity to prove they actually had equal skills (arguably more) but they definitely has more practical experience of doing the bits of the job as have stepped in and up before when staff absent.

I'm neither of their line managers so couldn't get more involved.

No one went for it and this person got the job. They definitely are suited to it. But there were others who would have been just as good but are less "flirty" with management iyswim?

So I think remove your dd and find somewhere else. But perhaps have a trial at a few other places before finally deciding on which one you'll join. It's important your dd follows her hobbies and equally important she enjoys it and feels equal within the setting.

Headteacher415 · 24/01/2022 17:12

It's meant to be fun & enriching. If your daughter doesn't want to be there, and this is not a passing whim, then take her out. Not because you are annoyed that they give the parts to the best (most will do that), but because this just isn't what she wants to spend her free time doing. Can she join a choir instead where there is less individual pressure & selection?

HappyDays40 · 24/01/2022 16:29

Isn't this par for the course with these things. I'm not saying it's fair but there are always favourites in school plays and in theatre groups. The children who have the additional tuition often have the more enhanced abilities or are better known to the staff so they will get picked.
I'm not sure I've known it any differently elsewhere. I went to drama and dance school as a child. I had no shining personality or talent and it was hard but sort of taught me to go my own way a bit. By all means try somewhere else but be prepared for the same again. I thinks it'd so important to do things that hey enjoy and there are ways of enjoying without needing to be always front and centre. If her self esteem is being shot to bits it isn't worth it but if she generally enjoys it it could be that jut thinks oh well its just a hobby and sees it for just that.
Hope she is okay OP, kids mental health is so important Smile

SpiderinaWingMirror · 24/01/2022 16:19

Just to add, I have had 3 daughters. Now my mantra is that anything needs to be supportive, fun, and broaden outlook and experience. My kids were unlikely to go on to the West End but I wanted them to explore their skills and talents and gain some experience.
I would move if they weren't getting that.

IntermittentParps · 24/01/2022 11:53

@SD1978

Have you asked for feedback? Openly asked why after 5 years, and 15 performances, she has never had a main part, and if there is a reason, or what would need to be worked on? Chances are you won't get an answer, or an answer you like, but at least you'd maybe get a bit of closure regarding it.
I think this. And I'd not be scared to raise the subject of the correlation between main roles and private tutorials. Approach it in a 'my DD loves the group but I'm sure you understand she's a little disheartened, and I may need to look at other groups' way. If the group leader is decent they'll respond well. If not, move her.
poetryandwine · 24/01/2022 11:33

@ginnybag has brilliantly described the conflict of interest. If the teachers are any good, those taking private lessons are likely to have a competitive edge. But it is dead wrong for their own teacher to be making the judgments, hence external panels are the proper way forward.

We can’t know how your DD would fare under that system. Given her wishes I would by all means be looking to move her to a supportive, welcoming PA group. In light of what @ginnybag has said, perhaps one with more emphasis on inclusivity and therefore less emphasis on the box office.

Whatwhywhenwhere · 24/01/2022 11:29

Have you mentioned this to management? Regardless of whether there are some more talented performers, everyone should have the chance to shine. Many parents go to this type of class to make their kids more confident and performing in lead roles does do that. That feeling of never being picked really affects people too!

I would speak to management and tell them how you feel. It’s tough because you are not trying to blackmail them into giving dd a part but they aren’t being fair.

TheBigPeachy · 24/01/2022 11:24

Thanks all another mum has msg me this morning out of the blue to say she's taking her dd out and I said I was thinking the same so obvious other people must have noticed too

OP posts:
SpiderinaWingMirror · 24/01/2022 06:57

You won't find that everywhere in my opinion. My dd14 goes to a local performing arts place that is inclusive, supportive and helps develop confidence.

ImustLearn2Cook · 24/01/2022 04:56

Before you join your daughter up to another group can you use the money you would normally pay for the group drama class to give your daughter some private lessons elsewhere? This might boost her confidence and give her a good head start before joining a new group.

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 24/01/2022 03:49

I would move her, pref to a school where they DON'T offer private tuition.
I can see why the kids having private tutorials are given the parts, from the school/club's perspective, because otherwise the parents will say "what's the point of paying extra, if they don't get the star roles?" and pull them out of the private classes.

But that's still not fair on other kids who don't have the private tuition. It's such a pain dealing with the "money talks" situations, it really is. :(

PepInYourStep · 24/01/2022 03:05

Too many dancing and performing arts schools seem to be like this. I'd move her to a similar hobby elsewhere if I were you.

halloweenie13 · 24/01/2022 02:28

Yes regardless of those who 'are the best', at that age and the fact you are all paying for the same group it should be about nurturing the talents of all the children equally to promote confidence and an understanding of working together. Remove her, state exactly why, that you feel the ethos of the school isn't in line with what you want for your child and that those who can afford private lessons are be favourited, significantly increasing the disadvantage average children already have at the school. Then look for a couple of alternative schools within the area and send you daughter for a trial session or two to pick which one she likes!

expat101 · 24/01/2022 02:22

This sort of thing stays with you. I'm in my 50's and I clearly remember at school winning a major part, I was so chuffed!

However, when I turned up for practice, I was sent out several times on errands for the teacher. Turns out another classmate, the daughter of the school librarian, was given the part instead.

I was gutted and I don't remember Mum saying anything to the school either. So make sure you have your say on how your DD has been treated.

SD1978 · 24/01/2022 02:15

Have you asked for feedback? Openly asked why after 5 years, and 15 performances, she has never had a main part, and if there is a reason, or what would need to be worked on? Chances are you won't get an answer, or an answer you like, but at least you'd maybe get a bit of closure regarding it.

Bussinbussin · 24/01/2022 01:46

@m00rfarm

So organise your own drama group. Be the director of the show. Make your kid the lead for every performance. Easy. Having been involved in this type of thing before, I can say that anyone getting private coaching will be MORE likely to get a part and their lessons will revolve around practicing to make sure their songs/speaking parts are perfect. Life isn't fair. Take her somewhere else but be prepared for the same outcome. Or find an adult group who are performing something like "Oliver" and need a ton of kids.
Yes, I was thinking it would be very easy for the teacher to argue (if challenged) that the parts were given on merit, to kids who are taking extra steps to improve themselves and who've put the extra hours in to practise and prepare. Whether that's the whole truth or not.

But you can tell her your DD wants to move to a group where she might get more opportunities, it doesn't have to be said in an accusatory way.

kittensinthekitchen · 24/01/2022 01:46

Apologies, it was a drama club.

Anyway, you might get some helpful advice on here

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4454381-Another-bloody-school-play-one-sorry

kittensinthekitchen · 24/01/2022 01:41

Didn't you post this a couple weeks ago?

I recognise the bit about private lessons.

AmyandPhilipfan · 24/01/2022 01:35

I would move her if you have another nearby group you could go to. My son went to a drama group that only ever seemed to do shows involving the kids who also paid for private singing lessons. I pulled him out the week I picked him up and he was sitting on the side while the private lesson kids practised for their show - during the main drama group time that I was paying several pounds a week for. He also came out upset because the leaders had told him off when they asked him why he hadn’t bought tickets for the show and he repeated what I’d said to him - that I was saving my money for shows he was in. I asked him that day if he wanted me to ask about a place at another group. He did so I did, he joined and was in a show with them a few weeks later.

I hate it when the same kids are always given parts. As a long term supply teacher I was once told to give my best readers lines for a school assembly. I asked if I could break up the lines so all the children could say something but was told ‘no, at this school the parents understand that the best readers need to read in assemblies.’ Of course at parents evening I had a number of parents quite upset that their kids had never been chosen for any roles at school events. I made damned sure that at our next class assembly all the children had extensive parts!

Blanketpolicy · 24/01/2022 01:07

Take her to another group or pull her out. It will slowly chip away at her confidence and self esteem and you will have a big job building them back up. It happens at a lot of activities and sports and tbh, those that run them would be ashamed of themselves, they are 9 year old children at a local group not auditioning for the west end.

VivX · 24/01/2022 01:06

I'd move your dd, too. These things don't tend to get better.

When I was little I was in a similar-ish sort of thing. It was run by an extended family. Every year they had an annual prize-giving where they awarded eachother most of the prizes. It was both hilarious and cringey.

m00rfarm · 24/01/2022 00:47

So organise your own drama group. Be the director of the show. Make your kid the lead for every performance. Easy. Having been involved in this type of thing before, I can say that anyone getting private coaching will be MORE likely to get a part and their lessons will revolve around practicing to make sure their songs/speaking parts are perfect. Life isn't fair. Take her somewhere else but be prepared for the same outcome. Or find an adult group who are performing something like "Oliver" and need a ton of kids.