Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mil moving an hour away!

60 replies

Username3092997 · 23/01/2022 17:01

Mil is planning to move just over an hour away to a different area (38 miles ish on crappy a&b roads). The area is slightly cheaper and she wants to free up some £££ selling her house and also to be closer to to her partners place of work which is a bit mad in itself as he's been doing the same job for years and he's close to retirement age now. He drives for a living, so it's just close to his depot so to me makes little difference as he's often in Scotland hundreds of miles away. Entirely their choice of course. I wish them well.

But she's expecting us to visit all the time, I just don't think we can go every week or two like she expects. Why can't she come here?! We could visit maybe once a month. She thinks we will love to visit all the time as it's a nice area but so is the area we live!

I appreciate many families live much further than an hour away and an hour doesn't seem that far but we aren't used to it. Currently she lives 10 minutes away. We don't see them more than once a week now, she and her partner work full time, dp works long hours, I am a sahp/carer to both children who have sen and have busy lifestyles. We don't see her that much really. . Maybe once every 1-2 weeks. Sometimes dc will go their for dinner after school. Often Dp will pop in to see her after work for a cuppa as she lives just down the road from his place of work, I think he will struggle with that more than anything. We don't rely on her for anything like childcare etc so her move isn't going to cause us any issues like that.

After a conversation today, she's fully expecting us to visit every week. Aibu to think hell no? We don't always see her every week now.

I just don't think it will work. Dp works Monday - Saturday. That only leaves sundays. Do we want to travel 2 hours on a Sunday plus a couple hours there? I'm not sure I do! Sunday is our only day as a family. Living close by we can see her during the week after school or on a Sunday for an hour (not every Sunday). I just don't think We can commit.

Dp doesn't want to do it either. He doesn't want to be travelling for 2 hours out of county on his only day off!! I don't really like driving.

Plus both dc both have sen. Sometimes even the shortest journeys are stressful! They need frequent stops etc. We really don't travel far as a family and tend to stay local.

Our lives are pretty local. My family live 15 miles away and we don't even get chance to see them much!! Once a month max usually!

Aibu to think that she can't move and expect us to still see her all the time? She could come here? Or will have to be once every month or so?

I just don't think I'll look forward to sundays if I feel like we have to get up and travel! Dp can't take the kids alone due to their sen, neither of us would manage a long trip like that with them on our own. 10 minutes max we are alone with them 😅 so we would all have to go!!

How often do you visit your relatives who live quite far away?!

OP posts:
Username3092997 · 23/01/2022 17:50

she is early sixties. It's her own house so her choice to make. She is a widow after her younger dc's dad died. Dp's dad lives many miles away which ain't overly relevant here though...

OP posts:
toomuchlaundry · 23/01/2022 17:49

Do you think she has a choice about moving? Who will have ownership of the new house, if they are not married?

Username3092997 · 23/01/2022 17:49

@Chocolateis1ofyour5aday

If she's moving an hour away and her DP is away 3 or 4 nights a week she'll be on her own a lot. Maybe that's why she's suggesting you visit weekly? Is she saying that to all her own DCs? You should show her your current schedule and how the weekly travelling doesn't work for your family and reset her expectations before she puts her house on the market and regrets the move!
2 live quite far away. I'm sure dp's brother will visit all the time, he relies on his mum quite a lot and has a car, he just doesn't want to move there! We would love to see her all the time but it's just not achievable. We won't be able to visit during the week, dc are both school age. Saturdays are a no. Sundays maybe. The only option is maybe Dp taking the dc there and staying on a Saturday night and coming back early Sunday with dc but I feel it's too much for him to do on his own. I can't nor do I want to stay over (which she's mentioned). We have a dog, she has 2 that don't get on with my dog so not an option!
OP posts:
guardiansofthegalaxychocs · 23/01/2022 17:46

Realistically once relatives are more than half an hour away it’s unlikely to be more than once a month visit for a busy family with kids at school.

Username3092997 · 23/01/2022 17:45

@toomuchlaundry

How old is she?

Where do her DP’s family live?

You do need to manage her expectations.

Mil's partner has nothing to do with his children (I think he has 6 kids!) and hasn't got anyone else around. I do fear he is very controlling of mil, she was a vulnerable widow when they met and he's took advantage I think. They've been together for several years though! It's entirely her house to sell though, they aren't married. I feel he is taking advantage, somewhere to live. He seems to get agitated when the kids go round there. They can be full on but I feel he doesn't like kids at all, as never had much to do with his own.

But I feel this is going way off topic and too personal now. I doubt any of dp's family is on here though 👀

It's not that I don't want to see her. Mil is okay really, hard work at times but hearts in the right place. But I just can't see how we can go visit all the time!!

The only other option is finding somewhere halfway. A pub or cafe or even a play park. There doesn't seem to be a huge deal though!

OP posts:
Chocolateis1ofyour5aday · 23/01/2022 17:44

If she's moving an hour away and her DP is away 3 or 4 nights a week she'll be on her own a lot. Maybe that's why she's suggesting you visit weekly? Is she saying that to all her own DCs? You should show her your current schedule and how the weekly travelling doesn't work for your family and reset her expectations before she puts her house on the market and regrets the move!

tara66 · 23/01/2022 17:41

You need to make it clear you will not be visiting her very often if she moves so she can decide whether to go or not. Maybe she can find a smaller (cheaper) property nearby instead?

Username3092997 · 23/01/2022 17:40

@twominutesmore

I think you need to tell her that you're worried about her ending up isolated, that you just don't know how often you'll be able to visit. I think she needs to know that before she makes any irreversible decisions.

Personally, I think she's crazy to leave her two children and their families to live closer to her DP's job as he approaches retirement.

Is it entirely about money and releasing equity? If so that's understandable but such a shame. I think she'll regret it.

It does seem crazy but it's their choice to make. Dp is 40 and has his own life. Hsi sisters live hours away! But Dp's brother is much younger (early twenties) and lives with them (her partner is not his dad either) Dp'a brother has got a settled job and friends here, grew up here too and he doesn't want to move so has to find somewhere to live now too - would be a 3 hour round commute for him. We don't have the room for him here sadly but would if he had nowhere to go. They are hoping if the current house is sold, they will be able to give him money for a deposit to buy somewhere, but it's not going to be quick for him! House prices are really high in our area, but there are cheaper places that are much closer. But again, their choice. They've spoke about moving for a while!
OP posts:
toomuchlaundry · 23/01/2022 17:39

How old is she?

Where do her DP’s family live?

You do need to manage her expectations.

Chloemol · 23/01/2022 17:39

Normal posts on here are that it’s the people moving who do the travelling

I would just say weekly visits are not going to work, she is more than welcome to visit for a day if she wants to and you can fit it in to your schedule. Otherwise it’s will be 4/6 weekly visits to see her

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 23/01/2022 17:38

so you all have to go through massive upheaval because some bloke is more important than her family. id tell her that and youll be visiting when it suits you.

Speakuptomakeyourselfheard · 23/01/2022 17:37

Having moved 200 miles away from my family, after them reassuring us that they would visit frequently, it hasn't proved to be the case, as there are always reasons why it's easier for them not to come, which in all honesty, I've found quite hurtful, as I wouldn't have moved if they'd been honest and said that it was too far for them. You at least have better reason with your children's difficulties, so please OP, be truthful with your MIL, tell her exactly what you've said here, and point out about it being daft to move closer to her partner's work at this stage. Maybe then she'll realise that it's not such a good move. Plus, what she releases in capital, is likely to be spent on travelling to see you, if you can't get to see them. It does sound like she hasn't thought this through properly.

MananaTomorrow · 23/01/2022 17:34

My parents and PIL are about 1 hour away.
We don’t go and see then every two weeks because each visit means more or less a full day.

Have you mentioned that to her?

twominutesmore · 23/01/2022 17:33

I think you need to tell her that you're worried about her ending up isolated, that you just don't know how often you'll be able to visit. I think she needs to know that before she makes any irreversible decisions.

Personally, I think she's crazy to leave her two children and their families to live closer to her DP's job as he approaches retirement.

Is it entirely about money and releasing equity? If so that's understandable but such a shame. I think she'll regret it.

Username3092997 · 23/01/2022 17:32

She can drive quite far as she wants to, she often bombs up the motorway to see her other dc who lives hours away (only Dp and his brother around here now). But she doesn't like the minor roads! I'm the opposite, I don't like motorways 😅

OP posts:
Nutrigrainygoodness · 23/01/2022 17:29

MIL used to live about half an hour away, down nice easy roads- dual carriageway etc.
Now she lives an hour away. The roads go from being typical country windy roads to super fast back to narrow roads.

They never come to us. We either meet them half way for lunch or we go to them maybe once every 3 months now whereas before they moved DW would see them every weekend or every other depending on plans.

codexa · 23/01/2022 17:29

"Oh that sounds lovely MIL, but will you be able to be with us as often as before"?

See what she says, and cut her off at the breach if she says you need to do all the visiting. 50/50 at least which would be once a fortnight for her to see you, and once a month for the opposite journey for you. Is that doable for you?

Might be a reasonable compromise, but do NOT do all the travelling, and I am sure she will understand. If she doesn't, well stick to your reasonable guns. Do not lose your cool, just sound positive and reasonable.. It is her choice to move after all, and if necessary remind her of this.

Best of luck.

PurplePikachu · 23/01/2022 17:29

Only thing you can do is be clear about it now, before she moves. Then she can make her own decisions.

Birdles52 · 23/01/2022 17:28

Yanbu

Username3092997 · 23/01/2022 17:28

@VickyEadieofThigh because he usually drives when they go out. If he's away, she will be stuck where she is as worn drive far! 😃

OP posts:
Hunkydory99 · 23/01/2022 17:27

Make it clear now - she may well abandon plans if you do. Happened to a friend of mine when her parents retired, suddenly had grand plans of moving ‘up North’ and to help with the kids who ironically were reaching a more independent age. She made it clear they had a life of their own and whilst them being closer would be lovely it would be a once a month visit. Like a previous poster she showed them their weekly diaries with work, school, swimming, football, dance etc and it wasn’t possible to see each other several times a week. They quickly changed their plans and instead moved to Spain. Everyone’s happy!

Davros · 23/01/2022 17:22

Do not offer even once a month, wait and see

VickyEadieofThigh · 23/01/2022 17:20

@Username3092997

She does drive but won't drive too far a distance on her own and her partner works away 3-4 nights a week. She'll be leaving behind her other ds too so I am also worried that she'll be isolated with her partner working away but I guess he'll be retiring in a year or two!

We have no issue driving in itself, but my kids are nightmares and it's tiring driving far with them! Sometimes a half an hour journey is more than enough! We tend to stay local as in op.

She needs to build her confidence driving for an hour to visit, therefore.

Not sure I understand what the partner working away 3-4 nights a week has to do with it...?

Santahasjoinedww · 23/01/2022 17:20

Haven't seen my mil for 7 years!! Your mil is being ridiculous. But maybe it's up to your dh to spell that out. Does she acknowledge your dc have SN?

Username3092997 · 23/01/2022 17:17

She does drive but won't drive too far a distance on her own and her partner works away 3-4 nights a week. She'll be leaving behind her other ds too so I am also worried that she'll be isolated with her partner working away but I guess he'll be retiring in a year or two!

We have no issue driving in itself, but my kids are nightmares and it's tiring driving far with them! Sometimes a half an hour journey is more than enough! We tend to stay local as in op.

OP posts: