Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to pay?

555 replies

Pritty · 23/01/2022 16:07

Me and DH have separate finances. I went through a really horrible time in a previous relationship financially, I won't go into all the details here but I can't bear the thought of my finances being tied to someone else ever again or not having access to money when I need it.

I'm a saver, my husband isn't. But with both contribute equally to the household so I don't concern myself with it in the main.

After the last two years with Covid I wanted to treat my son to a holiday this summer. He'd be just 4 by the time it comes around so not in school yet. Found something relatively cheap and have been speaking to DH about it.

Here's the AIBU...

My husband has a child from a previous relationship who is my step child and obviously my son's half sibling.

My husband basically wants to go in the summer holidays all together but the only way to afford this is for me to use the savings I have accumulated to do so.

It wouldn't wipe them out but it would be a big chunk of it, more than I'm comfortable with. DH would be able to contribute some but not all of the additional cost.

Adding two more people and going in the summer holidays makes the holiday triple the price (and admittedly it's a different dynamic than I'd hoped for).

DH argument is that we are a family and it shouldn't matter to me if I have to spend some of my money on his older son.

And yes it's Disney Paris Blush

OP posts:
Isntitironic1 · 23/01/2022 19:51

@Blue09

I think you’re being incredibly selfish tbh. You have two children in your family regardless of whether you like it or not. The holiday you have planned is a dream holiday for children, why on earth would you opt to leave a child in your family out of that?? Yes it will cost more but that’s your husbands responsibility, and as others have said he can get a loan or a credit card to pay his sons contribution.

You’re hiding behind the not to pay question when really you don’t want your stepchild to go with you. That’s what this is really about.

Your son is also not your possession, I’m sure he would love the holiday but why wouldn’t you want to share those precious moments with his dad as well??

I was a stepchild and being left out is not a nice feeling. Stop being selfish and be the adult here. Don’t leave children in your family out.

Wow you’ve completely misread the whole situation 😂
DysmalRadius · 23/01/2022 19:50

I am taking my two kids on holiday without their dad in a few weeks and we're married with no step/half/blended family issues. It just worked out that way as I was able to book a cheap term-time holiday around my more flexible working pattern and the fact the kids don't go to school.

It seems a shame to limit fun activities because one parent can't come - are stay at home parents expected not to do anything fun with their pre-schoolers during the day because their partners/older children/step or half siblings can't come?

WildFlowerBees · 23/01/2022 19:49

There's absolutely nothing wrong with you taking your ds away. If your dh wants to join you with his son then he and your dss mum should be paying.

I know several families that holiday with their kids alone for various reasons. It's fine. Go and enjoy yourself!

Bywayofanupdate · 23/01/2022 19:48

I also think step child should go, but you definitely shouldn't have to pay extra for them. Dh will have to fork out and in future I probably wouldn't tell Dh how much you have in savings.

Shiteshow100 · 23/01/2022 19:48

No take your son unless your husband pays for himself and older kid. Don't see why your saving and he's not but expects you to pay for the extras.

D0lphine · 23/01/2022 19:47

Is it common for parents who are together to go away on their own with their kids without the other partner?

I've never come across this before. Not necessarily saying it's a bad thing!

HTH1 · 23/01/2022 19:47

Just do it OP and tell DH you can go again as a family another time but he needs to save towards it.

WingingItEveryDay7 · 23/01/2022 19:46

If it was you, DH and your shared child I would definitely say it's not fair on the step child but your DH should pay the extra cost if he wanted to include him. As you just want to go yourself and your DS I would say just go! If you're paying for the trip it's not really up for discussion is it. I'm sure your step child gets to enjoy trips to places with his mother that your son doesn't go too...... x

surreygirl1987 · 23/01/2022 19:46

I think the main issue here is that your savings are entirely separate to be honest. I've not read the entire thread but surely some sort of shared pot (even if you want to keep the bulk to yourself) would make things easier?!

NoMoreFries · 23/01/2022 19:45

Can you take DSS out of school and all go together for a third of the price?

Seems like an easy win to me. Just call in sick for the week for DSS.

however, long-term there's a fundamental problem between you and your DH. Not sure why you married a man who has such a big difference in attitude to money. This is only the start of many many conversations around this topic which will end, probably in divorce.

Dear oh dear OP. You need a better match.

If he's a spender and can't save, then how can you possibly be compatible? You won't ever be on the same page, will you?

Hagpie · 23/01/2022 19:44

You knew you had a bonus child when you met him and I think it is a bit outrageous to take one child and not your other tbh. Dad can come or not but that’s your kid too wtf?? If I was bio mum I’d give half plus money for extras or keep my kid away from you as much as possible so I knew dad and his mrs weren’t playing weird favourites.

Cornishclio · 23/01/2022 19:44

I would go by yourself with your DS. If your DH wants to go and take your DSS then he needs to pay for 50 % minimum if you have separate finances.

Goldbar · 23/01/2022 19:44

@funinthesun19

How would you feel if your husband took the step child away and left your son behind.

Well that would be wrong of him seeing as he’s dad to both children.

Since there's a 6 year age gap, I think it's fine for him to do things separately with his DC sometimes so long as there's no overt favouritism. For example, 10yo is unlikely to enjoy Peppa Pig world and 4yo will be too young for lots of stuff. Neither should miss out.
TameDucksAtChatsworth · 23/01/2022 19:44

I must be an old fart but I think it is truly bizarre that you want to take your son on a holiday without your husband.

Your money, his money, separate holidays.

It doesn't sound like a comfortable home and, using my magic crystal ball, it won't be long before you both go your own ways. That said, there doesn't seem as if there'll be a lot to disentangle so that's a positive I suppose!

treesarebeautiful · 23/01/2022 19:43

I never understand the mumsnet approach to step children. They have their separate lives with their other parent, so it's entirely reasonable not to include them in everything you want to do with your shared child.

Go on your holiday with your ds and have a wonderful time. If your DH wants to come, then he can pay for himself. He should really pay half of your joint child's costs too, but that's a separate issue. You don't have to take DSS if you'd rather enjoy the time with just your shared child, but if you are happy for him to come, then DH can pay.

thegirlwiththelongblackhair · 23/01/2022 19:43

@OwlinaTree

I think if the dad went without his older child that would be awful.

If just the op and her son go that's ok.

I'm very curious.

Does the step child's mother include her child's half sibling? Would she even think twice about taking her child abroad.

I don't understand why the OP can't go on holiday with her partner and child without the stepchild tbh.

But I think you should go by yourself with your child OP.

XingMing · 23/01/2022 19:43

@Haus1234

It’s highly unreasonable to expect you to pay for your DSS when you have separate finances. I do think it’s reasonable to make it a family trip though I’m afraid, any child would be gutted to miss out on Disney (much more than any other holiday) when their sibling got to go.
I disagree a bit. We moved heaven and earth to go to Disney in California, and DS was, at 8, a bit too old to be taken in by the fakery. The rest of us could have been perfectly happy not going.
Cameleongirl · 23/01/2022 19:42

@funinthesun19. Why would it be “wrong”? My DH is father to both our children and he took DD on an amazing trip in Asia pre-pandemic. DS and I were absolutely fine with it. He’s now discussing taking DS on a trip when travel finally gets back to normal.
I have no idea where they’ll decide to go, DS isn’t as interested in travel as DD so it might be a couple of weeks domestically. It’s what suits them.

Cryalot2 · 23/01/2022 19:42

I would stick to your original plan op.You are a traveller who wants to give your child some wonderful experiences.

If your partner wants to take his son then tell him to start saving and fund it. You cannot be expected to change dates or fund your stepson.

Hoping you go and enjoy

Tobchette · 23/01/2022 19:41

We have a similar setup op. Separate finances because I am a saver, dh is a spender. It works perfectly for us. However dh always has a bit of money tucked away for a family holiday so we do go away together.

I have more holidays than dh which is a perk of my job. So rather than sit at home twiddling my thumbs, I have taken dd away on my own quite a few times while dh had to work. And he paid half towards dds airfare etc.

The only thing I think you are bu for is not asking dh to cough up half of the money for ds ticket. He's going to get time at home child free and then some quality time with just him and his other son. So I have no idea what he's complaining about. He's onto a right winner and is absolutely daft for looking this gift horse in the mouth. If I were him I'd stop questioning the arrangement before you realize he actually should be contributing toward your shared ds' fare for the trip and owing you in time for all the solo child care you will be doing!!

MatronicO6 · 23/01/2022 19:41

I feel a lot of posters are attacking OP as they are judging the situation according to their relationship and their family dynamic.

OP has clearly stated that they have separate finances. She has also said that she has gone on holiday without husband and presumably stepson. The precedent has been set in their family, so the judgement should be based on the context of their family set up, not yours.

Goldbar · 23/01/2022 19:39

@AnotherSillawithanS

How would you feel if your husband took the step child away and left your son behind.

That's your answer.

I have a stepson that lives with me so gets treated the same as my three. I never refer to him as a step son so feels weird to do it here.

Given the age difference, it makes some sense for the OP's husband to take the children away separately sometimes.
funinthesun19 · 23/01/2022 19:39

How would you feel if your husband took the step child away and left your son behind.

Well that would be wrong of him seeing as he’s dad to both children.

angelikacpickles · 23/01/2022 19:39

Your husband has two children. I don't see the difference between the mother of one child taking her son away on her own without his father, and the mother of the other child taking her son away without his father. If your DH was going, then I could see how the SS and his mother might be upset, but if your DH isn't going then I don't see how they can have a problem.

The issue of whether you should or shouldn't want your DH to come with you is entirely separate IMO.

Needacuppanow · 23/01/2022 19:38

Don't feel obliged to pay for your step son. All this blending the family nonsense is silly.