Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to pay?

555 replies

Pritty · 23/01/2022 16:07

Me and DH have separate finances. I went through a really horrible time in a previous relationship financially, I won't go into all the details here but I can't bear the thought of my finances being tied to someone else ever again or not having access to money when I need it.

I'm a saver, my husband isn't. But with both contribute equally to the household so I don't concern myself with it in the main.

After the last two years with Covid I wanted to treat my son to a holiday this summer. He'd be just 4 by the time it comes around so not in school yet. Found something relatively cheap and have been speaking to DH about it.

Here's the AIBU...

My husband has a child from a previous relationship who is my step child and obviously my son's half sibling.

My husband basically wants to go in the summer holidays all together but the only way to afford this is for me to use the savings I have accumulated to do so.

It wouldn't wipe them out but it would be a big chunk of it, more than I'm comfortable with. DH would be able to contribute some but not all of the additional cost.

Adding two more people and going in the summer holidays makes the holiday triple the price (and admittedly it's a different dynamic than I'd hoped for).

DH argument is that we are a family and it shouldn't matter to me if I have to spend some of my money on his older son.

And yes it's Disney Paris Blush

OP posts:
AcrossthePond55 · 23/01/2022 19:00

I guess my feeling is if a couple is going to have separate finances, then each pays for or saves what they want (after agreed upon 'regular' expenses are paid) according to their own priorities. Isn't that the point of separate finances in the first place? Because a couple has different priorities and/or can't agree on what to do with the 'leftover' money? If A wants to save up for holidays and B doesn't, then B doesn't go on the holidays. They didn't contribute to them, why should they benefit from them?

If A wishes to 'gift' B with a holiday (or any extra expense) and then it's up to A to decide how much they choose to spend. If B isn't happy with A's budget they need to contribute the difference. It's not up to B to dictate what or how much A spends, not even for a stepchild.

In this situation, I'd just go with my child on my own since DH can't afford to pay for himself and his child.

user1471604848 · 23/01/2022 18:59

If someone ever told me I couldn't take my child on holiday, unless I also took theirs, they'd get short-shrift from me.
I'm sure his ex can take her (their) child on holiday without consulting you.

Just go without him. It might motivate him to save for potential future family holidays.

Nat94 · 23/01/2022 18:59

When you're married you become a unit. If my partner was short on money or needed help financially I'm their to help and vice versa. If i had the money i would have no problem contributing more to the holiday than my partner as they would do the same for me. Its not exactly good for family relations leaving behind your husband and the other child. Although, with respect i have no idea why your husband would not be able to save enough money to go to Disneyland Paris in 6/7 months time if he's working?

OneSolitaryCornflake · 23/01/2022 18:59

Until you die, you both own the money in savings together no you don't. Not unless it's in a joint savings account.

Pritty · 23/01/2022 18:59

@Shinypog

It sounds like an odd set up all round to be honest, regardless of what others think it seems to be in line with what you do as a family anyway- separate finances and separate holidays. Sounds a pretty miserable way to live though, would it not be more appealing if it was always just you and your son?
It's not miserable at all. I've never even said we've never holiday'd together. We have! Including with SS, before and after DS was born.

I just like to go away for weekends etc.. quite a bit and have done so many a time without DH. I've been with my parents, with my friends, alone. I love it! And I love the time with my son.

He's not really a big holiday person so it's what works for us 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
Pritty · 23/01/2022 18:56

@Willyoujustbequiet

I wouldn't personally. I think Disney is a massive deal for kids and it's unfair for one child of the family to go but not the other.

It just smacks of a them and us scenario. Not what a family is really about in my view.

Would it fine if SS's mum took him without our son then?
OP posts:
D0lphine · 23/01/2022 18:55

@OneSolitaryCornflake

Firstly the idea of "separate finances" in a marriage is so baffling. When you get married you own everything together. So he owns your savings just as much as you do. You hold all assets together- that's literally what marriage means. no it's not. You can have a savings account in your own name and leave it to someone else when you die.
Great, well OP when you die you can leave your savings to who you want if you haven't given it to Mickey Mouse before then 🤣🤣😂

Until you die, you both own the money in savings together.

Pritty · 23/01/2022 18:55

@QuitMoaning

My exH took his young children away on holiday without our son. He actually told our son, he couldn’t afford to take him as it would have to be during school holidays so more expensive.

So our son was left behind.
He was devastated and neither of us have forgotten it. I had to spend a lot of time telling our son that he was lucky as he got to go away with me and his half brothers couldn’t.

However I don’t know how to address the financial disparity in your relationship and holiday contribution as that wasn’t relevant in my scenario.

My husband isn't going without SS. The original plan was me and DS ALONE.

Like if you took your son away by himself without his half siblings. What's the difference?

OP posts:
Unsure33 · 23/01/2022 18:54

I think you going with your son on his own , no problem..

And to me it’s simple if your Dh and ss want to go then he pays for it .

Simples.

BreakingGood45 · 23/01/2022 18:53

I love the idea of you and your son having holidays just the 2 of you. I need to do more of that. Enjoy Disneyland with your son. Your OH can save up and you all can go as a family during the summer holidays next time.

OneSolitaryCornflake · 23/01/2022 18:50

Firstly the idea of "separate finances" in a marriage is so baffling. When you get married you own everything together. So he owns your savings just as much as you do. You hold all assets together- that's literally what marriage means. no it's not. You can have a savings account in your own name and leave it to someone else when you die.

D0lphine · 23/01/2022 18:48

Firstly the idea of "separate finances" in a marriage is so baffling. When you get married you own everything together. So he owns your savings just as much as you do. You hold all assets together- that's literally what marriage means.

I'm lecturing now but I think people focus on the romance / wedding too much and don't think of the financial side of things!

If you are going to have separate finances, I still think you should go with you, your Husband, your child and your step child.

I think you should pay for you and 1/2 your child.

I think your husband should pay for himself, his step child and 1/2 your child. (The idea being the step child his 100% his financial responsibility in this situation.)

This seems fair.

caringcarer · 23/01/2022 18:48

Just you and DS go. Don't let DP spoil it for you noth. Let DP know he and SC's Mum need to pay for DSC. If he starts saving now perhaps DSC can be taken at a later date. He literally can't expect to spend his own money on himself then make you spend hours on him and DSC. He is trying to control how you spend your own money.

Youcansaythatagainandagain · 23/01/2022 18:46

Go with your DS alone. If your DH goes, then your stepson should definitely go too.

FWIW I wouldn't make a habit of this though. A friend of mine refused to pay for her husband to go on holidays as he was out of work and later didn't earn enough or save enough. She went on two holidays a year alone with their son. Her son grew up having a very poor relationship with his Dad. They have no shared memories and her son has very little respect for his father.

cheekychaplin · 23/01/2022 18:42

@MalbecandToast

I'll get flamed for this but if you have children with a man who already had kids, you should accept that you all become a family and should take the sibling.

Take, yes. Pay for? No. That's the SC parents responsibility, no one else's.

Mummyoflittledragon · 23/01/2022 18:41

I’m sure your ds will love Disneyland and even more when he gets older. Perhaps suggest to your dh you go alone this year and he saves for future holidays to do together.

Willyoujustbequiet · 23/01/2022 18:40

I wouldn't personally. I think Disney is a massive deal for kids and it's unfair for one child of the family to go but not the other.

It just smacks of a them and us scenario. Not what a family is really about in my view.

Daleksatemyshed · 23/01/2022 18:39

Your money, you choose how to spend it. If your DH can't be bothered to save money to take his DC away, then that's his problem, no way should you be paying for him and the DSC just because he can't be asked.

mummykel16 · 23/01/2022 18:37

@MalbecandToast

I'll get flamed for this but if you have children with a man who already had kids, you should accept that you all become a family and should take the sibling.
Agreed, it seems like punishing the child , strange marriage
KatharinaRosalie · 23/01/2022 18:35

He can't have it both ways - happily spending all his money and then having his eye on your savings.

soundsystem · 23/01/2022 18:35

You and DS going is absolutely fine. You, DH and DS going and leaving DSS out would be mean, but that's what not what you're suggesting.

(I have 3DC and have taken them individually for overnights/weekends so not a step-family issue I don't think.)

Shinypog · 23/01/2022 18:35

It sounds like an odd set up all round to be honest, regardless of what others think it seems to be in line with what you do as a family anyway- separate finances and separate holidays. Sounds a pretty miserable way to live though, would it not be more appealing if it was always just you and your son?

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 23/01/2022 18:34

Why did you marry him? Thats the quickest way to lose all your money.

stingofthebutterfly · 23/01/2022 18:33

A just turned 4 year old won't give a toss whether you're at Disney or 10 minutes down the road. Seems a lot of money for something that will be underappreciated. Book something cheaper and go as a family, stepchild and all.

Octopi · 23/01/2022 18:33

Would DS not want his dad there? I find going on any holiday weird but each to their own, but disneyland is a special one, does he have chance to save?

Swipe left for the next trending thread