Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to pay?

555 replies

Pritty · 23/01/2022 16:07

Me and DH have separate finances. I went through a really horrible time in a previous relationship financially, I won't go into all the details here but I can't bear the thought of my finances being tied to someone else ever again or not having access to money when I need it.

I'm a saver, my husband isn't. But with both contribute equally to the household so I don't concern myself with it in the main.

After the last two years with Covid I wanted to treat my son to a holiday this summer. He'd be just 4 by the time it comes around so not in school yet. Found something relatively cheap and have been speaking to DH about it.

Here's the AIBU...

My husband has a child from a previous relationship who is my step child and obviously my son's half sibling.

My husband basically wants to go in the summer holidays all together but the only way to afford this is for me to use the savings I have accumulated to do so.

It wouldn't wipe them out but it would be a big chunk of it, more than I'm comfortable with. DH would be able to contribute some but not all of the additional cost.

Adding two more people and going in the summer holidays makes the holiday triple the price (and admittedly it's a different dynamic than I'd hoped for).

DH argument is that we are a family and it shouldn't matter to me if I have to spend some of my money on his older son.

And yes it's Disney Paris Blush

OP posts:
Croissantly · 23/01/2022 19:13

@Lolamento

If you were a man here the answer would be different about separate finances.
If the thread was about a bloke wanting to go to disneyland without his wife he'd be handed his arse on a platter! Let alone anything about step children.
Gonnagetgoing · 23/01/2022 19:13

If your DH offered eg via a document to borrow the money off you and pay you back I’d agree. Why does he want stepson to go to Disney Paris now? Is it because he’d be jealous (SS) if he couldn’t go and you and your DC and DH did go?

narcdad · 23/01/2022 19:12

Op I don't think you are being unreasonable wanting to go alone with your son (and husband if he wants). Me personally wouldn't want to take a step child with me on every family holiday with my child. Especially as I had to pay the additional cost.

Howshouldibehave · 23/01/2022 19:12

I’d go and just take your son.

Your DH can’t decide to not save himself, but then just dip into your savings for stuff he fancies!

Youcansaythatagainandagain · 23/01/2022 19:12

Everything you've said is relevant to my husband as SS's parent. Not me. I don't have custodial rights over SS.

Yes but why bring the comparison of your SS's mother taking your son on holidays with her family? Your son doesn't spend time living with your DH's ex whereas your SS does spend time living with you and his father?

To me, me going away with DS on my own is no different to my SS's Mum going on her own with him.

You are separating and breaking up a family unit. She isn't as your son doesn't live or stay with her.

I know from many many conversations with my friend who prefers to holiday alone with her son that she sees absolutely nothing wrong with holidaying alone with her son. Her son grew up having a very poor relationship with his father. He's now in his twenties and there is such a lack of respect shown to his father, its actually incredibly sad to see. My friend says this is all due to his father who didn't earn or save enough to accompany them on days out or holidays. To this day, she is blinkered in seeing she played a big part in this by excluding his father from normal family occasions.

Croissantly · 23/01/2022 19:11

I mean if you don't even want to go with your husband of course you aren't arsed about going with your step son. I'm not sure what you're hoping for in this thread other than validation as you've made your mind up anyway !

Lolamento · 23/01/2022 19:11

If you were a man here the answer would be different about separate finances.

Gonnagetgoing · 23/01/2022 19:11

Sorry but your DH is being a bit of an entitled selfish person expecting you to pay for his son’s holiday. As a PP said it should be him paying and his ex wife. If you were feeling generous, had a special scenario (eg staying in relatives holiday home for free, windfall etc and you offered to pay or contribute to your stepson going then lovely but not using your savings when DH can’t be arsed to save himself. In fact though this wouldn’t be a dealbreaker I’d probably think hard for future with him if he didn’t resolve it and made a big deal out of you not paying.

Totalwasteofpaper · 23/01/2022 19:10

@Goldbar

You have separate finances. You both need to pay your way for stuff like this. This is how you've chosen to organise your finances. The trade-off of this is that your DH 'benefits' because you don't regulate how he spends his money. That means he doesn't get to tell you how to spend your money either.

If you all go on this trip:

  • You should pay for you.
  • Your DH should pay for himself and DSS.
  • You and your DH should split the cost of your DC.

If he can't afford to do this, he can save, put it on a credit card or take out a loan.

Or you and your DC go on your own.

Completely agree with this.

I don't get all the hand wringing from others this is the set up her DH chose.

MatronicO6 · 23/01/2022 19:10

YANBU. As you said your finances are separate and you researched and planned a holiday based on what you could afford from your finances. If DH wants to arrange a different holiday he needs to contribute the money for that.

He cannot expect you to wipe out a huge chunk of your savings now if finances have always been separate. If he wants to do a family holiday, tell him you can arrange it for next summer in order for you both to save the money needed.

2DogsOnMySofa · 23/01/2022 19:09

YANBU. You've got separate finances. You should pay for yourself and 50% for your ds. Your dh pays for himself and the other half of your ds. If he wants his other ds to come he pays 100% for him. Simple as.

What people forget is that you have gone without things, luxuries as all the bills are split and you pay for your half, to accumulate your savings. Your dh has spent his, presumably in himself or his dc, so he's already had the benefit of 'his' spare cash. I don't understand why he thinks it's acceptable to spend your 'spare cash' on him and his ds.

If you wanted to and were happy to, then great, but if it comes to a large proportion of your savings, and you're not happy, then tough shit for your dh. He should have saved some of his disposable money.

Pritty · 23/01/2022 19:09

Sorry I didn't realise we had to do everything as a family all the time. Mustn't actually ENJOY time one on one with my child. How awful of me 😳

OP posts:
Shinypog · 23/01/2022 19:08

Yes I do, but I wouldn't do disneyland which is super exciting for a child without DH, we like creating memories like that as a family.

Nat94 · 23/01/2022 19:08

@OneSolitaryCornflake

When you're married you become a unit you don't become so intertwined that you are inseparable or accountable for the others actions.
No but its not normal to go to somewhere like disneyland without one of your other young children and your husband 🤣 that definitely creates a them and us atmosphere in the household.
NorthSouthcatlady · 23/01/2022 19:07

I vote go for it and go with DS. Your husband needs to manage his money better, if he can’t afford it than tough. He earns the same salary as you so he can’t even say you earn more than him

Pritty · 23/01/2022 19:07

@Shinypog

To me, me going away with DS on my own is no different to my SS's Mum going on her own with him

Its odd you don't see yourself as a family unit with DH and his child though, just leave him and be alone all of the time with your son, also wouldn't need to worry about thinking about your step son- sounds like a win.

I don't want to be alone "all of the time" with my son. But I am surely allowed to enjoy some things alone with my son?

Do you never enjoy alone time with your children one on one? How sad.

OP posts:
Shinypog · 23/01/2022 19:06

To me, me going away with DS on my own is no different to my SS's Mum going on her own with him

Its odd you don't see yourself as a family unit with DH and his child though, just leave him and be alone all of the time with your son, also wouldn't need to worry about thinking about your step son- sounds like a win.

Pritty · 23/01/2022 19:05

@Shinypog

Would it fine if SS's mum took him without our son then?

Yes it would because your DS is nothing to do with her.

Why is me going on holiday alone with my son any different?
OP posts:
Shinypog · 23/01/2022 19:04

Would it fine if SS's mum took him without our son then?

Yes it would because your DS is nothing to do with her.

Goldbar · 23/01/2022 19:03

You have separate finances. You both need to pay your way for stuff like this. This is how you've chosen to organise your finances. The trade-off of this is that your DH 'benefits' because you don't regulate how he spends his money. That means he doesn't get to tell you how to spend your money either.

If you all go on this trip:

  • You should pay for you.
  • Your DH should pay for himself and DSS.
  • You and your DH should split the cost of your DC.

If he can't afford to do this, he can save, put it on a credit card or take out a loan.

Or you and your DC go on your own.

Pritty · 23/01/2022 19:03

@Youcansaythatagainandagain

Would it fine if SS's mum took him without our son then?

This is not relevant as presumably SS''s mother doesn't have custodial rights of your son and your son does not spend time or have a bed there in an effort to maintain a relationship with her?

Everything you've said is relevant to my husband as SS's parent. Not me. I don't have custodial rights over SS.

To me, me going away with DS on my own is no different to my SS's Mum going on her own with him.

OP posts:
Lolamento · 23/01/2022 19:02

@Pritty

The stepchild should definitely go

So it would be really unreasonable for me to just want to take DS by myself? Sad

Yes, you should accept the stepson as part of the family. Who does that going to Disney and leaving the stepson behind? Poor child 👦 YABU. Your husband or his mother should pay for him but the point is the callousness of leaving him out the trip.
OneSolitaryCornflake · 23/01/2022 19:01

When you're married you become a unit you don't become so intertwined that you are inseparable or accountable for the others actions.

Youcansaythatagainandagain · 23/01/2022 19:01

Would it fine if SS's mum took him without our son then?

This is not relevant as presumably SS''s mother doesn't have custodial rights of your son and your son does not spend time or have a bed there in an effort to maintain a relationship with her?

luckylavender · 23/01/2022 19:01

@Babyvenusplant

I get what you mean about the money but I think its a bit sad you didn't want your husband to go on this holiday with you originally
I think that too. We have just one DS (young adult now) and DH would have been really upset if I'd taken him to Disney Paris without him at that age. And we did go incidentally.
Swipe left for the next trending thread