Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to share food

190 replies

Whohashiddenthebiscuits · 23/01/2022 12:30

Just that really! If anyone has seen the Gavin and Stacey episode where they are ordering a takeaway and James Corden goes off on a rant about not wanting to share his order, I completely got that!

The last two Saturdays, I’ve seen friends.I’m middle aged, a pescatarian and really fussy about food. I’ve tried a lot over the years and know what I like and what I don’t. I’ve just got to the point where I just want to eat food I know I actually like. I know it’s good to try new things and I have for many years.. but Ive got to the point I just want to eat what I want to eat.

Last Saturday we were over friends and they ordered a Chinese (we split the bill). DH and our friends were discussing ordering a whole load of stuff and I just asked if I could have 2 dishes instead to myself I liked. Last night out at a Thai with friends, same scenario. All friends were really nice about it.. but I felt like the request was being a bit petulant and odd (even though I expressed it both times nicely!) not to want to share my food!

Anyone else feel the same way or is it really a bit anti social?!

OP posts:
Whohashiddenthebiscuits · 23/01/2022 17:54

@MasterBeth, what an odd example!

When have you ever been to the cinema where you just rock up without looking at what’s on and when?? As an adult that is. If one friend didn’t fancy going to see a film I wanted to see, I wouldn’t have a problem and would go with others who did. But that would all have been agreed before anyone arrived at the cinema!

Pretty sure I didn’t ruin anyone’s enjoyment last night or spoil the mood - I did feel a bit anti social for asking if they minded if I had my own dishes as it’s not the usual thing to do in my experience. These are friends I’ve known at least 20 years - would take a hell of a lot more than me wanting not to share food with them to create a sour atmosphere!

OP posts:
sadpapercourtesan · 23/01/2022 17:44

It's nothing like the fifth person sitting in a different screen room, where you wouldn't see each other for the duration of the film Confused

Are you this intolerant about people who don't drink? Don't fancy dessert?

If you think one person making a different food choice spoils the experience for you, then I think the problem is with you and your control issues.

TimBoothseyes · 23/01/2022 17:44

@MasterBeth

It’s like if five people go to the cinema. Four agree on something they all don’t mind seeing, but the fifth fussy person goes and sits in one screen on their own. The four can’t actually talk to each other during the film, but the fifth one has still spoiled the communal experience.
How is it spoiled? Everyone is seeing the film they want to. Surely the only person missing out is the person sat on their own and if they're not bothered then why should anyone else be?
MasterBeth · 23/01/2022 17:39

It’s like if five people go to the cinema. Four agree on something they all don’t mind seeing, but the fifth fussy person goes and sits in one screen on their own. The four can’t actually talk to each other during the film, but the fifth one has still spoiled the communal experience.

FrangipaniBlue · 23/01/2022 17:33

@MasterBeth

I love sharing plates, tapas, meze, Chinese or Indian food with a group of like-minded easy-going diners. The minute the fussy eaters get involved, it becomes too much admin and stress.
I don't understand the hassle?

If there are say 5 of you and the place recommends 3 small plates per person surely the fussy person orders 3 things for them self and the rest of you choose 12 to share between you in exactly the same way you would if there were only the 4 of you at the meal?

MasterBeth · 23/01/2022 17:31

@Simonjt

Not mixing meats” and “wanting a proper portion” are exactly the sort of comments that define fussy eating.

@MasterBeth I take it you always take a portion smaller than you actually want to avoid being a fussy eater?

No, I am an adult who takes joy in the social situation, understands that trying/eating a variety of tapas/meze/Chinese food is part of the joy of eating this way - and knows that ordering more of the food want more of, is part of the custom. Fussy eaters ordering their one thing for themselves spoil the occasion.
caringcarer · 23/01/2022 17:01

I'm with Joey and you OP. I am a very fussy eater and know what I like for takeaway. My dh, D's and foster son order about 5 things and share. I order my chicken wings and chips and want to eat them myself as I don't want to eat any of theirs. Occasionally I offer them a few of my chips if portion is too large. Luckily they don't mind. My son even says Mum is like Joey and does not like to share her food. If anyone even tries taking something off my plate I would stab them with my fork. Don't even think of going near my egg yolk.

sadpapercourtesan · 23/01/2022 17:01

Personally I like sharing food with DH and my sons, but am a bit iffy about it with others unless I know them very well. Not because of anything to do with the food itself, or hygiene, but just because the etiquette and unspoken conventions wigs me out (how much dip is too much, and what's a Mmmmm face?!? Shock)

I wouldn't find it rude if someone turned down a request to "order lots and share" because they're more comfortable having their own food. I think generally, as a society, we need to start being more tolerant of other people's pecadilloes around eating, and make more effort to understand one another. We all have our frailties and differences. Life is too short to get upset because someone else is perceived as fussy or greedy or weird for wanting/not wanting to share.

2Rebecca · 23/01/2022 17:01

There is no reason why Indian or Chinese dishes should be shared. Fair enough share veg side dishes but the portions are designed for 1 person. Different with tapas. If sharing with my husband we sort out the food before we start eating eg we often order scampi and chips and burger and chips and halve and transfer the scampi and burger before we start eating. I hate people who take stuff from other people's plates especially without asking. That's just rude and greedy

NinaProudman2022 · 23/01/2022 16:59

I’m with you OP. I don’t say sharing a garlic bread, rice or say popadoms.

But if we are ordering say an Indian, Chinese or Thai say I don’t want someone ordering one of these, one of them, two of those and this and that for everyone and we will all just sharing everything as SIL and MIL have tried to do on occasion. DH and I now just say well fine you can do that but we are like Smithy and Nessa and we will just order what we like and eat that. Don’t mind sharing rice or popadoms but other than that we don’t want to share mains.

Similarly I love tapas but hate seafood, red onion and mushrooms so I would much prefer to order three dishes I fancied and stick to those.

violetbunny · 23/01/2022 16:53

I wouldn't think twice if someone said they did not want to share. Especially if they were on a restricted diet, otherwise I'd be worrying the rest of us were going to hoover up the only dishes they could actually eat!

WondrousAcorn · 23/01/2022 16:47

@Lesperance - I have a friend like this. She is the sort of person who is always thinking of other people and worrying about if they’re ok. When I suggested a tapas restaurant for a group meal recently I was surprised at how vehemently she said no. She then explained she finds sharing far too stressful, which makes sense knowing her - she’d probably not end up eating anything.

Lesperance · 23/01/2022 16:43

My husband is like this. He is not in any way a fussy eater, but he gets a little anxious in this type of situation, and never feels like he has had enough to eat because he is wanting to be polite and not take too much. It causes him actual stress so he just orders separately now in a group situation, it's just not worth it.

Mumshappy · 23/01/2022 16:43

Agree re the dessert. They dont want one but say they will have some of mine. NO YOU WONT.
I just tell people I dont share food. Order your own bloody sticky toffee pudding or fries coz I need the calories. The closer the friend or relative they more they assume

burnoutbabe · 23/01/2022 16:41

I am happy to go for tapas with friends but I won't be eating octopus or fish.

So I want to order one dish that is 100% mine to ensure I actually get to feel I had a fair share.

Then we can share other bits.

BennysBingoBonanza · 23/01/2022 16:40

I’m not sure what the problem is. You told your friends that you didn’t want to share and that’s what happened. Totally up to you. If you felt a bit awkward, it’s probably because the norm is to share for those cuisines. Not sure what anyone else can do about that.

gobbledygoook · 23/01/2022 16:38

Oh my god yes. My DH jokes that I'm smithy in this scenario - I love my MIL normally, but anytime we go for a meal she's "just not that hungry" "only wants something small" then looks in my direction, and I'm expected to share my meal with her (ladies have small appetites I guess). I put a stop to that very quickly 😂 now she doesn't even try to stick a fork in my food!!

WondrousAcorn · 23/01/2022 16:35

@BreadInCaptivity - you make a great point. I’ve been to meals in Italy where everything is shared (yes, I’m thinking of Ferragosto for any Italians or anyone living there!) and I’ve actually been thankful for being vegetarian and latterly pescatarian because the quantity of food is such that I can at least politely decline some courses. There is an abundance of everything.

Here, it’s many different small-medium-sized dishes that individually don’t go far. Guaranteed to see you lose out if you’re overly polite or there’s anything you can’t or don’t want to eat. It doesn’t work well.

I don’t get posters who are actively annoyed by friends who want their own drink or meal. Yes, it’s nice to share, but only when everyone actually wants to. Who cares if some choose a different drink? For me, the communal element in eating is about being together and everyone enjoying themselves.

irregularegular · 23/01/2022 16:28

Exactly what ontopofthesunset said. Some cuisines (tapas, mezze, many Asian cuisines are intended to be eaten as a collection of different dishes that are shared. Most people will agree that you get a much nicer, more interesting, balanced, and authentic meal that way and will expect it. When we go out for those meals, we will always order as a group to make sure we get a good mix of dishes. I would consider someone who asked just to have their own dish to be a bit odd and a minor nuisance to be honest! Though I would be polite about it.

On the other hand at eg a French restaurant I would not expect people to share. Though DH and I do often swap dishes part way through, or or friends might offer a taste or share a pudding, but we shouldn't just all share, obviously.

MrsFezziwig · 23/01/2022 16:25

“I’ll eat mine in the car!” Grin

Definitely Team Smithy and if I’m with a group of my friends someone will always pipe up with “MrsFezziwig doesn’t share food!” (fortunately they love me dearly)

I just don’t see the logic in being forced to eat someone else’s choice of food rather than my own. Added to which, I don’t like very hot curries (my friends do) and I’m a relatively slow eater (my friends aren’t). So I would be lucky to get a reasonable amount of food that I like before the gannets had been in action.

And for the accusatory posters upthread, not liking Vindaloo doesn’t make me a “picky eater”.

ECLT · 23/01/2022 16:18

@LoseLooseLucy

JOEY DOESN'T SHARE FOOD!

I'm confused, did you have to tell them you wouldn't give them some of yours, or do you just feel awkward ordering your own? I don't really like to share when I've requested something specifically, but will do.

Damn, I really wanted to say that!

But I am with Joey mind, I don't like sharing food.

singlenamestar · 23/01/2022 16:10

Are you looking at my bhunas?!

Marmelace · 23/01/2022 16:03

@coop36

No it's fine. I am funny around FOOD TOO AND HAVE AN Acquired taste. What I hate is people dipping into my plate when I eat, I was out friends recently and mates gf stuck her fork she'd eaten with into my cheesecake without my permission. I didn't say anything but was secretly yukkk. I would only share forks/food with an intimidate partner. I even stopped eating burgers in fast food places because they don't wear gloves. It's a psychological thing, I CAN NEVER EAT SANDWICHES OTHERS HAVE MADE KNOWING THEIR HANDS HAVE Being all over it.

Reminds me of a group of colleagues I worked with who'd share Meals and be double dipping etc. It made me sqiurm.

I'd of been tempted to prod her back with my fork.
OnceUponAMidnightBeery · 23/01/2022 15:58

YANBU- team Smithy & Nessa all the way. Tapas bars possibly excepted

I chose what I wanted to eat, paid for it, and I want to eat it! I don’t want to eat what you ordered or I would’ve chosen it myself. Makes me stabby!

BreadInCaptivity · 23/01/2022 15:57

[quote erinaceus]@BreadInCaptivity You make an excellent point, I totally agree. I used to love going to the good Chinese restaurant with my Chinese friends because they knew how to put together the dishes.

If you are in a big group and the restaurant is a good one, one option is to ask the waiter/waitress to choose the dishes. It sounds a bit daft, but it really works! They know what goes with what, so you get a balance of flavours, they can accommodate requests like whether or not you like spicy dishes, the quantity is spot-on. I've done this a few times. Not everyone likes the idea and it doesn't suit every situation, but it has worked for me a few times. (Not one for the OP though.)[/quote]

I've done similar with Chinese friends from Uni and it's brilliant isn't it! Lovely food, all complimentary (tastes/textures/spice/vegetables/meat).

The best analogy I can come up with is as follows.

A group of 10 all go to a restaurant well known for its Sunday Beef Roast.

You sit down and everyone orders the same and when it's brought to the table to be shared there is plenary of food for everyone to have a good portion of everything.

Yes some people might have mustard instead of horseradish, some might have fewer carrots and more cauliflower cheese but there is no danger of anyone not having a portion of everything they want and no fights need break out over the roast potato's, beef or Yorkshire puddings. Everyone is happy.

In contrast another group go to the same place but only 6 order the beef. 2 order poached salmon with a salad, one sausage and mash and one fish and chips.

As above it's all put in the centre of the table.

Some people are really happy. They got their roast dinner plus a few extras/changes. One got a sausage as well as the beef. One swapped their roasts for mash. Another decided to have a few extra chips and two decide they might like some salad as a palate cleanser in place of the carrots they didn't fancy quite as much.

That left some at the table a bit miffed. Yes they got a sausage (but had to supplement it with beef they didn't want) and ended up with roast potatoes and not mash. Not great, but ok ish.

The person ordering fish and chips ended up with fish and salad and decided to forgo their mushy peas.

And then there were two people left with the unappealing prospect of salmon with some beef gravy, mushy peas and carrots.

Essentially this is what we do when ordering "communal" meals.

Order a lot of dishes that are not designed to be eaten together resulting in some people eating food that's very unappetising and far from what they ordered/wanted.

That's why it so often doesn't work. It's just a load of random food that doesn't compliment each other with portions that mean not everyone can have everything.

As such I'd rather do it properly or not at all and seeing as few people want to do it properly then I'm out and will simply order my own food.

Swipe left for the next trending thread