Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not ask for money from scratchcard win

160 replies

Geauxtigers · 23/01/2022 01:15

OK this is pretty simple.

I always buy a £1 scratchcard to put in people's birthday cards. I've been doing this for over a decade. Last month a good friend won a decent 4 figure sum on the scratchcard I put in their card.
My husband thinks I should ask for half of it because I bought it for them.
But in my opinion I bought the scratchcard as a gift and in doing so was opening myself up to the possibility of them winning a lot of money.

If I hadn't been buying it as a gift I wouldn't habe bought the scratchcard so it's not like I bought a roll of 5 and gave them the winning one. My husband and I never argue but he's really pushing me to ask on this one. We aren't rich but we also aren't struggling so I don't know why he's so insistent that I ask for some of it.

If it was me I would offer half to the person who bought me the card, but this is because I'm fairly financially stable and I don't know the financial status of this friend but I'd suspect its not as good as ours.

So am I being unreasonable to just celebrate the win with my friend and not ask her for some of the money?

*she did say when she told me she'd won "We'll have to go put for a meal, babysitter and dinner on us" which I personally thought was lovely

OP posts:
Bobonelove · 23/01/2022 18:45

You sound lovely as your friend offering meal ect , i wouldnt want to take your husband on the night out , how akward!! See if she fances a girlie night instead 😊

GrannytoaUnicorn · 23/01/2022 18:43

I hope she's not a Mumsnetter!

@Geauxtigers Show your DH this thread & the unanimous verdict!

RoseSays · 23/01/2022 18:39

Yes, I wouldn't want your dh to be at the dinner either - can you suggest to your friend dinner for 2 and leave the husbands looking after the dc?

Geauxtigers · 23/01/2022 18:31

Thanks for all the messages and reassuring me that I'm not completely losing the plot!

We've had another chat about it and I've said I won't put scratchcards in cards anymore. I asked why he was so insistent I ask for the money and he just kept saying "well if it was the other way around you would have given her half" which is probably true but not the point at all.
I asked if he was having secret money trouble and he showed me his bank account, very healthy and all our money is still in our joint account so I don't think it's that.

I don't think he will mention it again, but I now have to dread him saying something at said meal if it ever happens. Think I might just make it a girls night one weekend he's working nights

OP posts:
Geauxtigers · 23/01/2022 18:22

@StrangerThanSpring

I agree that a scratch card might seem a fun present to give but money really does cause a lot of problems. What if she had won millions? It would cause so many issues.
It was a scratchcard with a £100,000 top prize so no millions could have been won.
OP posts:
JackieWeaversZoomAc · 23/01/2022 13:30

Surely the who idea of giving someone a small piece of cardboard as a gift is the idea that they might actually win something- otherwise why would you put it in a card?

Your DH is being a dick.

Ipadflowers · 23/01/2022 12:57

@Toanewstart22

I would lose all respect for my dh if he ever made a suggestion like this
Me too, I actually said to my husband about this thread, just the synopsis to see his reaction on what he’d do and he immediately said what, no way, they can’t ask them for money, how embarrassing for them, it was a gift.

Thankfully. I’d have lost respect if he said he’d put his hand out.

It’s just so entitled grabby and full of jealousy. I’d go out for dinner with them to celebrate but I’d pay my half and certainly not take cash to pay for my babysitter. It was a gift, you don’t put your hand out try to snatch some of it back.

Frozenlikeablockofmarble · 23/01/2022 12:13

One thing - why does your husband even know what you gave your friend? DH and I were out yesterday buying a small gift as part of our shopping, but he wouldn’t normally even know, think to enquire, remember or be fussed by what I gave to my family or friends unless I’m stumped or we’re out together. We do discuss gifts, yes, especially to immediate family and mutual friends, but we don’t drill down to the level of detail whereby we keep tabs on each other’s gifts to relevant folk with exactitude - that seems to me a deeply unattractive trait. We might share - oh so-and-so was delighted, or is still wearing that thing we gave them 10 years ago. If it was a scratchcard we’d both be pleased that the gift had had benefits to the recipient beyond what we’d spent on them. And neither of us would ever think to recall the gift in whole or in part, as that’s effectively what your DP is doing. Offering your friend a loan as a gift, to be repaid at an exorbitant rate of interest, is effectively how he’s seeing it.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 23/01/2022 12:03

Your DH is completely wrong. As pps have said, it was a gift ! You don’t ask for half of a gift back.

givemepiece · 23/01/2022 12:00

Show your husband this thread

Agapornis · 23/01/2022 11:57

If your husband feels friendship is only worth £1-5k, I bet he doesn't have many friends!

TreeLawney · 23/01/2022 11:46

I really don’t understand those people saying she could give half back. When I give a gift to someone, I don’t expect them to give me half of it back. This was a gift.

The meal sounds like a lovely offer.

ChargingBuck · 23/01/2022 11:33

I really don't know what he is thinking I've tried to ask why he's so upset about it, but he just keeps saying "she should at least offer"

He says that OP, but he doesn't mean it.
He's just covering his arse & making out your pal is committing the social faux pas, rather than himself with his embarrassing entitlement.

Because if friend DID offer, he wouldn't turn it down, would he?
Manipulative bullshit.

ChargingBuck · 23/01/2022 11:26

My husband and I never argue but he's really pushing me to ask on this one.

Sorry he is being so unattractively venal.
I would find this very hard. Not the friend bit - of course she should keep her winnings! - but the uncomfortable realisation that not only was my DH being a twat, he was urging me to do his dirty work for him ...

If he refuses to STFU about it OP, tell him he can do his own dirty work, go round your mate's house & demand her money himself. Won't that make him a big man in everyone's eyes?
That should cool his jets.

(Obviously, if he was blind & stupid enough to take it seriously, I'd stop him, tell the pal etc).

DoctorManhattan · 23/01/2022 11:24

Not often that Mn threads are fairly unanimous but it appears on this occasion that your hubby needs to have a moment of clarity

amusedbush · 23/01/2022 11:24

I will admit that I can understand the jealousy. I'm not massively well-off (I'm not skint, but I'm not well-off) and I feel that pang when I hear people winning thousands of pounds on the radio or similar. A "decent 4-figure sum" would be a massive deal to me. If I had given a winning scratch card as a gift I would definitely be envious and wish that I had kept it. Hindsight is a bitch in that sense!

BUT I would not voice that to anyone and I certainly wouldn't feel entitled to a share! As you said, OP, you wouldn't have bought the scratch card had you not been giving it as a gift so it's not like you missed out. The money was never yours (or rather his) either way.

Luredbyapomegranate · 23/01/2022 11:21

Of course!
It was a gift
Tell your husband he’s being appalling

InvalidCrumb · 23/01/2022 11:21

@LimeSegment

Oh god this has reminded me of something an ex bf did. He gave a scratch card to his friend in a birthday card, but he scratched it first, "in case it's a winner". I was ShockConfused and tried to explain it doesn't work like that. He said his friend wouldn't mind Confused. Maybe if his friend was OPs DH he was right!
This is one of the funniest things I've read on MN! Imagine getting a used losing scratchcard in your card!
DishwashDogsDickens · 23/01/2022 11:16

It is lovely of your friend to ask Offer to take you out

Would your husband behave ? Or would he spoil it ?

I hope not
Please tell him it was a gift YOU gave and it is up to YOU what happens now and you don’t appreciate his attitude
I would also tell him how hard up they are and how generous with others - so he sees the bigger picture

MegaClutterSlut · 23/01/2022 11:13

No I wouldn't ask for half the money Shock that's the chance you take when buying someone a scratch card. Your friend taking you out for a meal as a thanks is more than enough imo

Faevern · 23/01/2022 11:11

Genuinely wondering how many scratch cards have bought over the decade and how many have won? I would be interested to know what the win ratio is.

I can see how it’s a bit of fun putting one in a card, until someone wins Grin

TheNoodlesIncident · 23/01/2022 11:07

I bet you're regretting telling him about your friend's win now... His behaviour is appalling. There is no expectation for your friend to share any of it if she doesn't want to, although I can understand the bigger the sum the stronger the feeling that some should be shared with the person who enabled it.

When you give something away, you are no longer entitled to it, come what may. If your DH can't grasp that, I'd consider leaving him at home for any get-together with the lucky friend, in case he says something you'll regret.

I'd be so pleased if I bought something that went on to bring positive things to a friend, it's a win in itself!

buckeejit · 23/01/2022 11:07

So rude to ask for their money. Your dh is well wrong. Nice they offered to shout you a meal, would only take your dh if he promised to behave & not mention the money

grapewine · 23/01/2022 10:58

I don't understand why she should offer, either. I wouldn’t, although I'd do what she has done and pay for a meal.

Notajogger · 23/01/2022 10:56

He sounds barmy. Of course you can't ask! Even if she offered, I would decline - it would be very strange to accept back half of a gift, I think.
It's nice of her to take you out for a meal but if it were me I'd make sure it was a "girly" meal or some such- I.e. he doesn't come. He'll make it super awkward otherwise and that could sour things somewhat.

Swipe left for the next trending thread