Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To forward face my carsick toddler?

105 replies

carseatnightmare · 22/01/2022 20:40

DC1 is 2.5. A few months ago we forked out for an expensive rear facing car seat that we were hoping would keep him safe for a long time (axkid minikid). He's always been rear facing, but a month ago he suddenly developed awful travel sickness. Even the 5 minute drive to nursery has on several occasions caused him to be sick, especially when in stop start traffic.

Is there anything I can do? We chose a rear facing seat as I'm fully aware of how much safer it is, but I can't face him throwing up for every small car journey we make. He's still so young he doesn't even understand to be sick in a bag etc so just ends up throwing up all over himself and the car, and I just feel so bad for him.

OP posts:
110APiccadilly · 22/01/2022 22:02

There are, on average, about 10 fatalities of 0-15 year olds who are travelling as passengers in a car per year in the UK. So when you're taking about rear-facing being safer, you're taking about reducing an already tiny risk. It's fine to do that, but IMO it's also fine to decide that the distress of the child, which has a very high probability (pretty much certain), is in this case more important than reducing the already very small risk of a serious accident.

ContadoraExplorer · 22/01/2022 21:59

DD went through a phase of vomiting in the car at around 14/15months. It was just after the first lockdown and I think if happened because she hadn't been in the car for so long. It was OK if the two of us were in the car and one could be sitting in the back with her but when it was only one driving and we couldn't see her (we removed the mirror to see if that helped) it was awful because she would vomit and then go silent when we couldn't pull over and wouldn't respond when we said her name so we'd start freaking out that she had choked.

Thankfully she grew out of it and at 2.5years she rear faces but if it had continued I'd have seriously considered forward facing.

I don't think there is any harm in trying it to see if the sickness improves, if it doesn't you can always revert back.

carseatnightmare · 22/01/2022 21:56

@PlayerOneReady

Honestly, imagine it was you in that car seat. You were forced to sit in a position that made you vomit even for a short and safe journey. Every time you got in a car in fact. Would you want to do it? I wouldn’t. Absolutely grim.
I know. It is grim, and I feel awful for him. As I've said already, I get carsick too and so I know how horrible it is.

But I also want to make him as safe as humanly possible, and rear facing is without question safer. I do take on board other posters' comments about him being/feeling sick causing a distraction to my driving though. Definitely food for thought.

OP posts:
carseatnightmare · 22/01/2022 21:53

@nothingcanhurtmewithmyeyesshut

My niece and nephew have forward faced since about 8 months as they got so carsick. My sister made the decision to turn them round so she could see them after niece choked when vomiting and if it wasn't for my older nephew (7) sitting next to her she wouldn't even have known it was happening. It was completely silent which is what scared her so much.

Luckily her eldest was next to the baby, saw it and immediately unstrapped her, pulled her upright and slapped her on the back a few times until she started coughing.

That is terrifying!
OP posts:
PlayerOneReady · 22/01/2022 21:52

Honestly, imagine it was you in that car seat. You were forced to sit in a position that made you vomit even for a short and safe journey. Every time you got in a car in fact. Would you want to do it? I wouldn’t. Absolutely grim.

nothingcanhurtmewithmyeyesshut · 22/01/2022 21:51

My niece and nephew have forward faced since about 8 months as they got so carsick. My sister made the decision to turn them round so she could see them after niece choked when vomiting and if it wasn't for my older nephew (7) sitting next to her she wouldn't even have known it was happening. It was completely silent which is what scared her so much.

Luckily her eldest was next to the baby, saw it and immediately unstrapped her, pulled her upright and slapped her on the back a few times until she started coughing.

RobinPenguins · 22/01/2022 21:48

We did this at the same age for the same reason. No regrets.

Ickle37 · 22/01/2022 21:47

My dd was forward facing from 2 yrs. I am really at peace with this decision. My nephews at 3 were in boosters! ( 10 yrs ago). I am all for keeping children safe, but risk assess your own trips and child. If i was moving forward but facing the wrong way i would be sick as well. I think these were eu mandates, which are thoroughly ignored in the eu country i live in! Here they can be and often are on boosters at the height of my daughter ( but everyone is tiny here!) . Turn your kid around so no more puke. Poor wee soul.

TickTickTock · 22/01/2022 21:38

This was the exact same situation which forced us to change DD to forward facing after forking out for a rear facing seat. So much sick, nearly every car journey. It was horrible for her, and for us, so we had to clean and sell the seat. She was so much better when facing forwards. :)

KnobJockey · 22/01/2022 21:36

Yes, according to the experts on the extended rear facing Facebook group- there are a few actual experts on there ☺️
I use this one, posts are published immediately. There are a lot of RF fanatics who will jump you for suggesting FF though.
www.facebook.com/groups/1376541652674823/?ref=share

Mossstitch · 22/01/2022 21:35

As an adult who is carsick unless driving....... You can't put the poor kid through feeling that bad every time he gets in a car!
Two of mine were carsick rearward facing or if they were looking down at something as they got older, like a hand held games console. I know it's not the done thing now but my first was forward facing from 4 months or sick but in those days rearward facing seats only went up to 9 months. If possible in the middle seat seemed to work best so they can look through front window but my first had to go in front seat as he got older or he would be sick. If you don't do something to stop it he will develop a real fear of going in the car. I do think it became psychological with my eldest who insisted he had to sit in the front to stop it.

WhenTheyComeForYou · 22/01/2022 21:30

@carSeatnightmare

Yes, as long as the passenger airbag is switched OFF x

carseatnightmare · 22/01/2022 21:28

@KnobJockey

Could you try moving the mini kid tomthe front seat to see if it helps?
Possibly! Is a rear facing seat in the front still safer than a front facing seat in the back though?
OP posts:
KnobJockey · 22/01/2022 21:27

Could you try moving the mini kid tomthe front seat to see if it helps?

carseatnightmare · 22/01/2022 21:27

@SouthOfFrance

If its only happened in the last month or so could it be something else? Are you giving him a book he's getting engrossed in, or an ipad? Only because reading/not looking out of the window often makes people car sick

Just a thought!

No he doesn't have an iPad and I'm careful never to give him a book in the car either as I know first hand how triggering that is for me to this day!
OP posts:
Thirtytimesround · 22/01/2022 21:26

I get horribly travel sick.

Definitely do forward facing!!!

WhenTheyComeForYou · 22/01/2022 21:25

@UnbeatenMum

I decided to FF my DS at a similar age after he learnt to silently undo his strap. I felt it was safer being FF and strapped in than RF unstrapped.
Just out of interest, no judgement, but if he could unbuckle himself rear facing, why not forward facing?
SouthOfFrance · 22/01/2022 21:23

If its only happened in the last month or so could it be something else? Are you giving him a book he's getting engrossed in, or an ipad? Only because reading/not looking out of the window often makes people car sick

Just a thought!

Tiredoftiers · 22/01/2022 21:22

Mine only vomited when we started forward facing them. Just need to try it and see I guess.

UnbeatenMum · 22/01/2022 21:21

I decided to FF my DS at a similar age after he learnt to silently undo his strap. I felt it was safer being FF and strapped in than RF unstrapped.

autienotnaughty · 22/01/2022 21:21

We rear faced til 4. But you have to say up risk/discomfort. Also risk of choking. I think I'd forward face.

winter12345 · 22/01/2022 21:21

Instead of towels, stick them in a bibado bib for car journeys. I put them in DD (18 months) when she has sickness bugs!

I am pro extended rear facing, but would absolutely try FF OP. Have you got any friends with seats that FF that you could try (bibbed or towelled up obviously!)?

user2908143823142536475859708 · 22/01/2022 21:20

My dd went forward facing at 1 because of car sickness.

She choked on her sick and I never put her rear facing again so it's not as simple as "I would rather have a child covered in puke" I couldn't drive 5 minutes down the road without her vomiting everywhere.

Haribo16 · 22/01/2022 21:19

My just turned 3 year old has been forward facing since he was around 2 years old. He doesn't suffer with travel sickness but is very large for his age probably the size of a 4 year old and although I was adamant that I would make sure both my ds's were rear facing for the correct amount of time to keep them safe I had to relent as his legs were up to his ears and very uncomfortable. Also as someone that still suffers woth travel sickness going backwards makes it so much worse so I would 100 % change to forward facing.

carseatnightmare · 22/01/2022 21:18

@DonnatellaLyman

Do you have a bike? 20 min walk would be 5 mins by bike which is definitely faster than I can clean up sick? Or leaving car at nursery then walking to/from with buggy so you can go on to work?

Have you tried taking head rest off the back seat so he can see out. People also say sea bands and sitting on newspaper.

Borrowing a FF seat to see if it helps sounds like a good idea.

I also have a young baby DC2 so a bike wouldn't work sadly, and there's no long term parking near the nursery.

Will try taking the headrest off so he has a better view though- very good suggestion thanks!

OP posts: