Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Means testing State Pension

731 replies

CuriousMariette · 22/01/2022 18:25

Do you think the time has come for this to be introduced? I don’t think the current system is sustainable as many people are living too long. I know it’s not fair and would be political suicide but Pensioner’s didn’t even suffer a 80% furlough during lockdowns. I say this from a place of having “paid in” as people say for 30 years plus already and would likely not receive a State Pension in this scenario.

OP posts:
monfused · 23/01/2022 19:09

Again picking the bits that fit the story will paint a certain picture.

You keep saying this. Are you saying it's not harder to buy a house these days?

monfused · 23/01/2022 19:08

I literally said it’s never been easy.

I didn't say that either though did I?

I replied to a comment that said We will soon be back to 70s inflation and a whole new generation will find out what fun we had back then.

saying don't forget that current generations have the fun of soaring house costs & wage stagnation.
That poster replied to my point talking about high interest rates & free nursery places etc.
You then decided to interject to tell me that " It may be inconvenient for you but that was the reality". The only point I was making it that's it's harder to buy a house today which somehow triggered you that I was implying they gave them away in the past. 😆

ancientgran · 23/01/2022 19:08

[quote 1dayatatime]@Blossomtoes

" And if you’re paying 35% tax and NI at 9% on your earnings. It may be inconvenient for you but that was the reality."

++++

So the UK average full time salary in 2021 is £31k. On this you would pay a top rate tax of 20% plus 9% graduate loan tax plus NI of 13.2% from April.

This totals 42.2 % for an average salary which is comparable to the 44% you quote for the 1970s(35% income tax plus 9% NI.

Yes the key difference is the addition of the 9% graduate loan tax and that is because university education was not only free in the 1970s but you actually got a grant of free money to go to university.[/quote]
Not everyone is paying student loans back, lots didn't go to uni and lots went before tuition fees or when they were low and are still paying mortgages now. Or are you saying people in their 30s who paid lower tuition fees are at a great advantage now?

You do realise that you don't pay tax and NI on your total earnings so you need to check how the starting points have changed for them. You don't pay 9% of your income for your student loan, only once it goes above a certain level.

Again picking the bits that fit the story will paint a certain picture.

Do you know how many, or should I say how few, went to uni in the 70s?

Blossomtoes · 23/01/2022 19:01

Yes the key difference is the addition of the 9% graduate loan tax and that is because university education was not only free in the 1970s but you actually got a grant of free money to go to university.

Only if you were one of the most academic 5%.

ancientgran · 23/01/2022 19:01

It isn't easy to compare, for example my then husband and I were saving like mad to get a deposit in 1970/71 for the mortgage we could get we could afford a nice 3 bed semi (£5k where we lived) but we didn't have the deposit. We bought a house in 1973, our money now bought us a rundown 2 bed terrace, it needed rewiring, new windows as the frames were rotten and new floorboards as they were rotten as well. There was no central heating. So we bought a £5,200 house, someone else could have bought the nice 3 bed semi for £5,000 18 months before us. They had a much easier time than we did.

Just to give a flavour of the value of money then my husband couldn't get the mortgage on his salary, 3 times was usual then, but with my earnings we just managed it. They didn't look at affordability then just income which was just as well as what I earned was wiped out by childcare.

Fast forward 2 years, house prices had slumped a few months after we bought the house, we spent alot of money on it and alot of blood sweat and tears and we sold it for £7k, if we had added up what we spent on it we probably made a loss. We were sensible enough not to do that.

The next house we bought was £9k, it crippled us and there were months when we didn't know if we would be able to buy food but in the long run we made money on it. Ten years later we got 4 times what we paid for it.

You could do the same thing now, people who bought a house 18 months ago have made money, people buying now might be at the top of the market and losing money in six months time.

So if you compare us buying a house at the top of the market in 73 with someone buying a house 18 months ago it would give a different result to us buying our second house when prices had dropped to someone buying now with prices high.

Go back to the banking crisis, about 14 years ago, people who bought just before the crisis were in negative equity for years in many cases, the people who bought after the crisis probably got a bargain.

It really isn't as easy as pick "the 70s" v "the 20s" because there are big variation within those time frames.

1dayatatime · 23/01/2022 19:00

@Blossomtoes

" And if you’re paying 35% tax and NI at 9% on your earnings. It may be inconvenient for you but that was the reality."

++++

So the UK average full time salary in 2021 is £31k. On this you would pay a top rate tax of 20% plus 9% graduate loan tax plus NI of 13.2% from April.

This totals 42.2 % for an average salary which is comparable to the 44% you quote for the 1970s(35% income tax plus 9% NI.

Yes the key difference is the addition of the 9% graduate loan tax and that is because university education was not only free in the 1970s but you actually got a grant of free money to go to university.

Blossomtoes · 23/01/2022 18:57

You literally attempted to correct my post where I said it was harder

I literally didn’t. I literally said it’s never been easy.

Blossomtoes · 23/01/2022 18:55

Also although you mention 15% interest rates you fail to mention MIRAS where the interest on your mortgage was tax deductible from your income (before tax).

Lastly the average house in March 2021 cost more than 65 times the average UK home in January 1970, but average weekly wages were only 35.8 times higher.

You’re conflating different time periods. MIRAS wasn’t introduced until 1983 so very few people benefited from it and high inflation rates - which were of little benefit to anyone when the cost of everything you bought was shooting up like a rocket. What with that and an effective tax rate of 44%, saving a deposit was hard, not least because high inflation eroded it as fast as you saved it.

monfused · 23/01/2022 18:53

That’s why people used to buy doer uppers, do all the work themselves and live with their relatives’ cast off furniture for years.

You may need to sit down for this but people do this nowadays too. I know mind blowing!!

monfused · 23/01/2022 18:51

I didn’t say you’re wrong.

You literally attempted to correct my post where I said it was harder.

I am saying don’t belittle people who say it wasn’t easy in the past.

Who did that? I certainly didn't! 😆

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 23/01/2022 18:49

You seem to forget that with inflation running between 20 and 26% at n the 1970s that the real value of your mortgage debt was being inflated away 20 to 26% per year.

Ridiculous exaggeration - the 26% was a single peak and those levels were only for a couple of years.

Lincslady53 · 23/01/2022 18:49

@monfuseds

Many is not all. Talking of many, strangely enough many older people want their children and grandchildren to have affordable housing.

And yet the Tories are still in power 🤔

Look at how much house prices rose during the labour years, 97 to 2010 and compare that to the increase in the following 10 years. We live in Lancashire and our house more than doubled in value in the Labour years. It has increase a fair bit in the last couple of years, but only reached its 2008 value by 2018.
Blossomtoes · 23/01/2022 18:45

@monfuseds

All the data says it's harder but *@Blossomtoes* you're welcome to post stats that show I'm wrong.
I didn’t say you’re wrong. I am saying don’t belittle people who say it wasn’t easy in the past. It’s never been easy to buy a house. That’s why people used to buy doer uppers, do all the work themselves and live with their relatives’ cast off furniture for years.
1dayatatime · 23/01/2022 18:42

@Blossomtoes

Not this again

Yes, this again. Because it’s spot on. A house isn’t cheap, however low its asking price, if the money you borrow is at 15% interest. It was like buying a house on a credit card now. And if you’re paying 35% tax and NI at 9% on your earnings. It may be inconvenient for you but that was the reality.

You seem to forget that with inflation running between 20 and 26% at n the 1970s that the real value of your mortgage debt was being inflated away 20 to 26% per year.

Also although you mention 15% interest rates you fail to mention MIRAS where the interest on your mortgage was tax deductible from your income (before tax).

Lastly the average house in March 2021 cost more than 65 times the average UK home in January 1970, but average weekly wages were only 35.8 times higher.

Means testing State Pension
monfuseds · 23/01/2022 18:31

All the data says it's harder but @Blossomtoes you're welcome to post stats that show I'm wrong.

monfuseds · 23/01/2022 18:30

It's harder to buy a house today eg save the deposit then it was in the past. The gap in affordability is much greater. This doesn't mean it wasn't hard in the past

Blossomtoes · 23/01/2022 18:25

Not this again

Yes, this again. Because it’s spot on. A house isn’t cheap, however low its asking price, if the money you borrow is at 15% interest. It was like buying a house on a credit card now. And if you’re paying 35% tax and NI at 9% on your earnings. It may be inconvenient for you but that was the reality.

1dayatatime · 23/01/2022 18:14

@AnotherSillawithanS

I think the government could look after its elderly if it didn't have to look after the young so much.
And the baby boomers look aghast when they are called the selfish generation.
monfuseds · 23/01/2022 18:09

And you think we didn't have that in the 70s? The 70s house prices did soar, they will seem low to you but have a look at what people were earning and what a 15% interest rate on your mortgage looked like. We also had 35% income tax rate as previously mentioned.

Not this again 🙄

We didn't have free nursery places either so it was really hard to work and actually generate an income if you had young children.

Who gets free nursery places?

Are things the same? No. Is everything better? No. Is everything harder? No.

Buying a house is harder

user1497207191 · 23/01/2022 17:09

@ancientgran

You also have to remember it isn't just what you put in, there is also what the employer puts in for you. Of course some big employers have cottoned on to that and they know they can save money by hiring part timers or zero contract people and keep them under £170 a week and they won't be paying the employers part.

To balance that NI isn't just for a pension.

Complicated isn't it.

Likewise many people deliberately choose to work 2 or more part time jobs to avoid paying NIC, or refuse to work more hours so they don't breach the threshold for paying it.
user1497207191 · 23/01/2022 17:08

@Dreamstate

If you think about how much you put in over 35yrs for the state pension and what you get back out us a pretty poor return to be honest. Shockingly bad.
That really depends on how much NIC you've paid. Plenty of people pay little or nothing but still accumulate "credits" and get full state pension.

For a start, two part time jobs instead of a full time job and you pay a shed load less (if any) NIC than someone earning the same on a single job, but still get "credits".

NIC needs scrapping - it's a historic anomaly that has no place in the modern world.

worriedatthemoment · 23/01/2022 17:00

No as it is many who never paid in get paid or get top ups
Its not even that much either
What should happen is the money paid in should go in a pot towards it and mot be touched for other spending

Blossomtoes · 23/01/2022 16:57

The system now is inefficient as some do not need the state pension

So who decides who “needs” the pension they’ve been making contributions to, in some cases, for 50 years? The vote against any party putting this in their manifesto would be the biggest landslide ever. .

ancientgran · 23/01/2022 16:26

You also have to remember it isn't just what you put in, there is also what the employer puts in for you. Of course some big employers have cottoned on to that and they know they can save money by hiring part timers or zero contract people and keep them under £170 a week and they won't be paying the employers part.

To balance that NI isn't just for a pension.

Complicated isn't it.

FanGirlX · 23/01/2022 15:44

@Dreamstate

If you think about how much you put in over 35yrs for the state pension and what you get back out us a pretty poor return to be honest. Shockingly bad.
It's a good return for low earners though. Low earners put very little in (none if their stamp is being paid for them).