Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Means testing State Pension

731 replies

CuriousMariette · 22/01/2022 18:25

Do you think the time has come for this to be introduced? I don’t think the current system is sustainable as many people are living too long. I know it’s not fair and would be political suicide but Pensioner’s didn’t even suffer a 80% furlough during lockdowns. I say this from a place of having “paid in” as people say for 30 years plus already and would likely not receive a State Pension in this scenario.

OP posts:
Giraffeaftergiraffe · 23/01/2022 23:45

[quote Blossomtoes]But the mortgage interest was tax deductible! That makes a huge difference

MIRAS was introduced in 1983 and after the first five years only applied to one income. It wasn’t nearly as generous as you might think and made very little difference as shown when it was removed.

www.theguardian.com/uk/1999/mar/10/budget1999.budget3[/quote]
As would not having to pay a £500k mortgage in the first place because house prices have been so ridiculously inflated.

Giraffeaftergiraffe · 23/01/2022 23:44

[quote Blossomtoes]But the mortgage interest was tax deductible! That makes a huge difference

MIRAS was introduced in 1983 and after the first five years only applied to one income. It wasn’t nearly as generous as you might think and made very little difference as shown when it was removed.

www.theguardian.com/uk/1999/mar/10/budget1999.budget3[/quote]
Well I am a single parent and it would make an enormous difference to me if it existed now.

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 23/01/2022 23:33

I am aware of how it worked. Tax-deductible mortgage interest would offset a massive amount of the higher interest rate effect.

It really didn't. I wish I'd kept my old payslips and bank statements so I could give you exact figures. I do know our mortgage repayments on an £85k mortgage went up to £800 a month and even almost crippled us. Luckily we could hold onto it but many couldn't

Blossomtoes · 23/01/2022 23:32

But the mortgage interest was tax deductible! That makes a huge difference

MIRAS was introduced in 1983 and after the first five years only applied to one income. It wasn’t nearly as generous as you might think and made very little difference as shown when it was removed.

www.theguardian.com/uk/1999/mar/10/budget1999.budget3

Tealightsandd · 23/01/2022 23:29

It will also be hugely costly. Although, I suppose, it's a way of reducing the unemployment figures. Perhaps they could focus their recruitment on the un and underemployed over 50s - a group full of people able and willing to work but facing the major barrier of widespread employer age discrimination.

Giraffeaftergiraffe · 23/01/2022 23:28

@RockingMyFiftiesNot

But the mortgage interest was tax deductible! That makes a huge difference. You got tax relief (you didn't get the interest deducted off your tax as some people think) - but on massive mortgages because of the explosion in house prices I described and the sharp hike in interest rates. That tax relief didn't prevent the mass of reposessions and people going into negative equity. I saw so many people who were desperate at that time, please don't dismiss the situation.
I am aware of how it worked. Tax-deductible mortgage interest would offset a massive amount of the higher interest rate effect. And means that - combined with the far, far lower salary to house price multiples at the time - that houses was far more affordable than they are now.
Tealightsandd · 23/01/2022 23:26

With means testing, it hits the people just above the generally too low threshold. Hard. They'll struggle. It will also hurt those below it - unless it doesn't get affected by the many admin errors, delays, confusion, and mistakes that so blight the working age benefits.

1dayatatime · 23/01/2022 23:23

@Blossomtoes

" Because. More. People. Have. Degrees

And.why.do.you.think.that.is? 

You tell me what you think.

This should be good.

++++

More than happy to explain.

In essence more people have degrees today than in 1970 because more jobs today require degrees in order to perform them than in 1970.

For example:
Jobs that existed in both 1970 and 2021 such as say teachers or nurses are significantly more complex and technical with more specialist knowledge required than they were in 1970 which means that teachers and nurses often very much need a higher level of education (degrees) to perform these roles.

Jobs that existed in 1970 and today such as doctors or lawyers needed degrees both in 1970 and today.

Jobs that didn't exist in 1970 but do in 2022 such as say a search engine optimisation specialist or a genetic counsellor need the knowledge and expertise from higher level of education (degrees) in order to do their complex jobs.

Jobs that did exist in 1970 that were viewed as skilled but not requiring a degree such as steel manufacturing workers or production line workers are now viewed as relatively lower skilled and outsourced to countries with lower labour costs.

Jobs that existed in both 1970 and in 2021 and that in both times are viewed as relatively low skilled such as fruit pickers is usually outsourced to lower cost migrant workers.

Now I am sure that there are many graduates with degrees that find themselves in jobs such as retail or hospitality that do not require a degree to do them, but this is usually because they have been unable to find the job they wish to do and are admirably working hard in a job they could find until they secure the job they actually want to do.

I think part of your misunderstanding is the assumption that a nursing job today is the same as it was in 1970 when the reality is that it is incredibly more technical and complex even if the basic tenets of patient care is the same.

You also fail to grasp that many jobs that existed in 1970 no longer exist in 2022 or have been offshored to countries with lower labour costs.

Lastly you are probably unaware that a very high proportion of jobs that people do today never existed 50 years ago.

And that's why more people need degrees today. Hope this helped...

DontBlameMe79 · 23/01/2022 23:12

@Blossomtoes

The system now is inefficient as some do not need the state pension

So who decides who “needs” the pension they’ve been making contributions to, in some cases, for 50 years? The vote against any party putting this in their manifesto would be the biggest landslide ever. .

Deciding that is the very definition of “means testing”
RockingMyFiftiesNot · 23/01/2022 23:11

But the mortgage interest was tax deductible! That makes a huge difference.
You got tax relief (you didn't get the interest deducted off your tax as some people think) - but on massive mortgages because of the explosion in house prices I described and the sharp hike in interest rates. That tax relief didn't prevent the mass of reposessions and people going into negative equity. I saw so many people who were desperate at that time, please don't dismiss the situation.

Giraffeaftergiraffe · 23/01/2022 22:55

@RockingMyFiftiesNot

You are proving my point, you parents bought in the 80s when there was a price crash. Timing is everything but you don't know till it's too late.

There was a massive property boom late 80s. When we bought our first home together., it cost 2.5 times what the vendors paid for it 3 years earlier. And 4 times what our neighbours had paid for their's 5 years earlier. We'd not been in it long when interest rates went up to 13%. A lot of negative equity and repossessions. Wasn't all great news propertywise in the 80s.

But the mortgage interest was tax deductible! That makes a huge difference.
RockingMyFiftiesNot · 23/01/2022 22:53

You are proving my point, you parents bought in the 80s when there was a price crash. Timing is everything but you don't know till it's too late.

There was a massive property boom late 80s. When we bought our first home together., it cost 2.5 times what the vendors paid for it 3 years earlier. And 4 times what our neighbours had paid for their's 5 years earlier. We'd not been in it long when interest rates went up to 13%. A lot of negative equity and repossessions. Wasn't all great news propertywise in the 80s.

gogohm · 23/01/2022 22:48

No because people have factored receiving a state pension into their retirement plan. Higher rate tax payers contribute more than they will every receive back

Tealightsandd · 23/01/2022 22:45

Also often ignored, when people talk of a growing elderly population, is that is partly because we have a growing population full stop.

www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/populationandmigration/populationestimates/articles/overviewoftheukpopulation/january2021#migration-to-the-uk-has-been-the-main-driver-of-population-growth-since-the-1990s

More people = more elderly. Migrants grow old - just like anybody else. Many of today's elderly are the Windrush generation.

It is absolutely not ok to use and exploit migrant labour when they are young...only to then resent them a decent pension and social care when they're older.

Meanwhile, the likes of multi millionaire Blair (young and old) use legal but not so moral tax avoidance schemes.

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10054929/Secret-offshore-wealth-world-leaders-revealed-leak-14-MILLION-files-dubbed-Pandora-Papers.html

Tealightsandd · 23/01/2022 22:40

@monfused

& dont forgot the disparity with regards to multiple home ownership.

"Half (52%) of all the assets held in additional properties is held by the baby boomers, born 1946-65, and a further quarter (25%) by generation X, born 1966-80."

I would favour higher SD on additional properties & higher CGT personally.

Thing with averages and generalisations. It's that huge and varied and very much not homogenous groups are lumped in together - and it's always the less fortunate of each cohort (including groups by age) who suffer.

And also like I said yesterday, the fact of Covid (including Long Covid ill health), and long term poverty, means that for many the already stagnated life expectancy will fall.

And also what can't, or at least, shouldn't, be ignored and dismissed is the role of smoking.

People are living longer because they were told to live longer.

We can't push people to give up smoking (a massive source of tax income) and then moan about pension and social care costs.

No point giving up smoking and living longer - if that means ending your days in poverty and/or without the dignity of decent and safe care.

FanGirlX · 23/01/2022 22:03

They probably saved the 20% on transport, buying lunches out and childcare.

More than 20% if you include nursery.

Lockdownbear · 23/01/2022 21:58

I actually don't know why people who were furloughed aren't counting their blessings. They probably saved the 20% on transport, buying lunches out and childcare.

Think about the poor sods trying to work, educate and child mind. I was knackered, physically and emotionally exhausted meanwhile I kept getting told what a great time my SIL in the country was having, going for walks and bike rides.

FanGirlX · 23/01/2022 21:20

Nobody got their state benefits "furloughed " during lockdown. Why would pensioners be singled out?

UC actually went up.

Onionpatch · 23/01/2022 21:16

It isnt unexpected that people who have lived longer and therefore worked longer have had more time to build up assets.

FanGirlX · 23/01/2022 21:16

[quote worriedatthemoment]@BorgQueen isn't there a country thats trialling a universal payment ? Or one thinking of it[/quote]
Was it Finland?

Lockdownbear · 23/01/2022 21:03

Something else to remember many 'working class' trades people hourly paid weren't eligible to get a mortgage regardless of the money they earned because it wasn't salaried.

I know a few couples who were denied mortgages in the 60s and 70s they were the people who then ended up buying their council houses in the 80s and 90s but not before they spent years renting.

It's very difficult to compare but they were less of the current pensioners who went to Uni, a vocational college HND / HNC was actually worth something. They were down valued with the get 50% of people to have a degree, which also led to many degrees being worthless and a huge amount of student debt.

woodhill · 23/01/2022 20:14

It's definitely harder now for young people to buy homes

Working class could afford housing in yester year on 1 salary

monfused · 23/01/2022 20:05

& dont forgot the disparity with regards to multiple home ownership.

"Half (52%) of all the assets held in additional properties is held by the baby boomers, born 1946-65, and a further quarter (25%) by generation X, born 1966-80."

I would favour higher SD on additional properties & higher CGT personally.

worriedatthemoment · 23/01/2022 19:59

@Somanyquestions1984 thing is if it happens companies just put up prices etc as people have more income etc
There is no easy answer

monfused · 23/01/2022 19:59

Please don’t be so rude, it’s completely unnecessary

😆 are you actually ok?

I mean this was you posting the below....

"You tell me what you think."

"This should be good."

I mean you might think the above is polite but....