Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Means testing State Pension

731 replies

CuriousMariette · 22/01/2022 18:25

Do you think the time has come for this to be introduced? I don’t think the current system is sustainable as many people are living too long. I know it’s not fair and would be political suicide but Pensioner’s didn’t even suffer a 80% furlough during lockdowns. I say this from a place of having “paid in” as people say for 30 years plus already and would likely not receive a State Pension in this scenario.

OP posts:
FruitMelange · 22/01/2022 19:32

I thought pensioners still paid income tax if there income was over the tax free allowance anyway

Yes, they do.

SJFarter · 22/01/2022 19:31

@CuriousMariette

Do you think the time has come for this to be introduced? I don’t think the current system is sustainable as many people are living too long. I know it’s not fair and would be political suicide but Pensioner’s didn’t even suffer a 80% furlough during lockdowns. I say this from a place of having “paid in” as people say for 30 years plus already and would likely not receive a State Pension in this scenario.
The net contributors have to get something back from the system they pay into, otherwise they'll stop paying in. The architects of the post war welfare state understood this.

That's why removing child benefit from high earners was wrong / calculated to start the dismantling of the system.

Wineisoverrated · 22/01/2022 19:31

My gran receives a little over 1400 a month in her pension and whenever she mentions that I experience a little fury each time (not for her obliviously).

The welfare state was experienced in its golden years by one generation. We taste only the dregs. I’m 30 and DH and I are ploughing as much money as we possibly can into savings for us to have a little nest egg for our retirement. Even though we both have private pensions they’re meagre in comparison to what we’ll need.

The pension system is broken. The nhs is failing. Welfare and housing are completely substandard. There’s no ‘welfare state’ left.

monfuseds · 22/01/2022 19:29

The 'ridiculously rich' have probably contributed millions in tax and NI over the years.

Unlikely, the majority of the ridiculously rich pay far less tax then they should.

Crabwoman · 22/01/2022 19:28

@Crabwoman

No for most of the reasons mentioned above.

Also, wouldn't it be a huge cost to implement?

Pendioners would have to submit accounts regularly which could be very stressful and whole new branch of the DWP and associated software would be needed surely?

Not sure of the figures but maybe (like winter fuel allowance) it's not worth the cost of administration and upheaval.

Pensioners, not pendioners 🙈
Lincslady53 · 22/01/2022 19:28

@puffyisgood

I'd support it for ludicrously rich pensioners, but realistically there are probably only a few hundred thousand of these.
Where do you draw the line? The 'ridiculously rich' have probably contributed millions in tax and NI over the years. The pension should be a universal as it is at the moment. I would change the way NI contributions are calculated though. If you are self employed, you can set yourself up as a limited company. You can then pay yourself just enough to pay the minimum in NI, but not enough to pay income tax. You will pay just a few pence per week in NI. You will then get the full state pension. Any additional income you take will be in dividends which you do not pay NI on.
Tal45 · 22/01/2022 19:27

That would make it incredibly complicated and so expensive. Terrible idea.

SapatSea · 22/01/2022 19:27

Most pensioners who have some sort of private / work pension in addition to the state pension pay INCOME TAX.

A lot of pensioners DO pay tax. The state pension is added to income from private pensions and investments, employment, savings interest etc and if it is above the personal tax allowance then you pay tax (some of the private pension might be tax free) at the lower or higher rate depending on your total income. So it is kind of "means tested" already.

monfuseds · 22/01/2022 19:27

How is universal basic income supposed to be funded?

AlDanvers · 22/01/2022 19:27

Absolutely no. For all the reason stated above.

But this comment made no sense at all

Pensioner’s didn’t even suffer a 80% furlough during lockdowns. I say this from a place of having “paid in” as people say for 30 years plus already and would likely not receive a State Pension in this scenario.

So you want it means tested for only people claiming now? Because those people that were furloughed, will eventually be at a pensionable age. Those that were furloughed shouldnt be means tested?

What about the people who werenr furloughed but held companies together while others were furloughed? Care workers? Postal workers etc. You want to remove pension from people who are too old to change their financial position and everyone else. Because people were furloughed?

ChiefInspectorParker · 22/01/2022 19:26

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Toomuch2019 · 22/01/2022 19:25

No. I remember some research from when I was back doing my masters which generally showed that socially once any type of benefit becomes means tested overall society support declines over time leading to further cuts for those who need and benefit from it the most. Can't quote where it was from but it stuck in my head for a long time

winter12345 · 22/01/2022 19:24

That's terrible @FruitMelange Sad

DoTheMerengue · 22/01/2022 19:24

Fine, but I want a proportion of the contributions I’ve made to date to be refunded so I can put them in my private pension.

FruitMelange · 22/01/2022 19:23

What about those who die before reaching pension age ? It's not given back to the family !

Precisely this. My Dad died two years after his retirement age, after paying in for 50 years. That goes for many other people I know who died too young. My mother struggled on a single pension. No private pension to fall back on. Good job she had 3 kids to top her up.

Crabwoman · 22/01/2022 19:20

No for most of the reasons mentioned above.

Also, wouldn't it be a huge cost to implement?

Pendioners would have to submit accounts regularly which could be very stressful and whole new branch of the DWP and associated software would be needed surely?

Not sure of the figures but maybe (like winter fuel allowance) it's not worth the cost of administration and upheaval.

BungleandGeorge · 22/01/2022 19:19

The figures are showing that average life expectancy isn’t actually increasing as projected and could well decrease. Unhealthy lifestyles and reducing living standards will achieve what you suggest without doing anything!

129orbust · 22/01/2022 19:17

By the time I receive my pension, if I live that long, I will have paid 48 years of contributions.
I really hope the system will not be changed so I receive nothing at all.

DGRossetti · 22/01/2022 19:15

You don't need to means test the pension.Just not raise it in line with inflation. That'll claw it back automatically.

Obviously it will disproportionately affect the less well off. But as that's official government policy, then it seems the fairest way.

SquirrelG · 22/01/2022 19:15

It’s just young workers subsidizing a generation that designed a system to benefit themselves

So the state pension has only been around as long as the current generation receiving it? Don't think so.

monfuseds · 22/01/2022 19:14

Do people think today's 20 & 30 yrs old will receive a state pension? The way things are going I don't even see the NHS existing in its current form in the next 5 yrs.

TheHateIsNotGood · 22/01/2022 19:11

Well so many late 50s/early 60s women are being sliced and diced from every direction at the moment, maybe there could be other areas that could be looked at to save money - the State Pension is all some of us have to look forward to when we can get it.

Whilst many of my age might well have benefitted from being a 'baby boomer' or whatever, not all of us were, count the ones that remained fiercely indepenent and unwilling to embrace the shackles of our sex in the 1970s amongst them; not all of us were writers or journalists, just young women who broke through various
barriers at a grassroots level.

Making it real just by doing it, rather than declaring any right to do it. And some of us remained single and unsupported, etc, etc - most didn't though.

Hack away at something - just not the State Pension - I've just got to keep scraping by whilst caring for my autistic adult ds for another 8 years, I''m 59.

Unless, like Yosser Hughes, you'll "Gissa Job", but so far, it seems I'm on the Scrapheap too.

MichelleScarn · 22/01/2022 19:09

I've worked since 14, paid ni since I was 16, won't get state pension till 68 (at present, will prob be older!) So I'll have paid in for over 50 years, and will get nothing? Absolutely no! Even less of an incentive to save and have a private pension.

monfuseds · 22/01/2022 19:09

CGT should also increase in my opinion.

Alexandra2001 · 22/01/2022 19:08

Most people have SFA, means testing the pension wouldn't rise muchas you might think, unless set very low.

But a better idea would be to remove the tax free status of ISA's now used by the wealthy to avoid paying any tax on investments.... each year take 20k from your investments & its income, put in iSA, than draw down from ISA... all tax free 0% its called a wrapper.

1000s have become ISA millionaires over the last few years, using S&S isa's.

This would effect me but everyone should pay tax on income.