Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Means testing State Pension

731 replies

CuriousMariette · 22/01/2022 18:25

Do you think the time has come for this to be introduced? I don’t think the current system is sustainable as many people are living too long. I know it’s not fair and would be political suicide but Pensioner’s didn’t even suffer a 80% furlough during lockdowns. I say this from a place of having “paid in” as people say for 30 years plus already and would likely not receive a State Pension in this scenario.

OP posts:
RockingMyFiftiesNot · 22/01/2022 20:38

Pensioner’s didn’t even suffer a 80% furlough during lockdowns.
Not everyone who isn't a pensioner was furloughed.

AnneKipankitoo · 22/01/2022 20:38

No.
It costs more to means test .

woodhill · 22/01/2022 20:37

I think it was originally set up that way and you do make contributions during your working life, that is how it is presented to you

Fr0thandBubble · 22/01/2022 20:36

@monfuseds

I pay well into 6 figures tax a year - why should I be paying for everyone else’s pension and not get one myself

you are paying 6 figs in just tax & you are worried about not getting your state pension?

Why shouldn’t I get it? People seem to think high earners get high pay from luck or something - I get it because I work ridiculous hours in a highly stressful job that I had to train for 3 years for after university. I barely get to see my children, I barely get to see my friends, I am never home before 10:30pm at night, I regularly work on weekends. Why the hell should I live this kind of life flogging myself to death only to fund other people who don’t make these sacrifices? Honestly the sense of entitlement some people have to other people’s hard-earned money blows my mind.
CayrolBaaaskin · 22/01/2022 20:34

Many people on this thread seem to think paying NI is some sort of fund that you get back as a pensioner. It isn’t. It’s just a tax. Pensions are benefits which are being paid for by today’s taxpayers. It’s likely given how expensive universal state pensions are that they won’t exist for many working age people.

So basically many of those taxpayers paying for the current pensioners pensions won’t get pensions themselves or will get them much later than those that they have paid for. That’s pretty unfair.

As for paying in to the system and not getting anything out - that’s how tax works. You get out in accordance with need and pay in in accordance with means.

JustBkind · 22/01/2022 20:33

No, state pension MUST stay. The majority of people have worked bloody hard for it! Start making everyone pay for prescriptions, even if in differing levels like dentistry. It fails to amaze me how someone with thyroid problems for instance, gets all medicine free no matter what it’s for…okay get your thyroid medicine free but not other medicine for unrelated conditions!

FFSFFSFFS · 22/01/2022 20:29

Again the Australian system works very well. People in need get a pension and others privately save for the event of old age for which they have had their entire lives to prepare for.

I do think though that of course this should not be imposed on people already in the system. So it’s a big ship
To turn around

onlychildhamster · 22/01/2022 20:29

@JanuaryBluehoo Lots of poorer older Londoners have million pound houses but no private pension as they weren't rich at all, just bought when it was cheap. A terrace house where I live is £1 million and it is not large at all!

Yes I could sell my flat and move to the north after I retire but that is probably not good for the northerners...also I don't think I would ever be able to afford more than a 3 bed flat so there isn't much to downsize to in the same area....in numbers terms, the number of crazy rich pensioners driving Porsches is probably not huge.

FruitMelange · 22/01/2022 20:29

My gran receives a little over 1400 a month in her pension and whenever she mentions that I experience a little fury each time (not for her obliviously)

She doesn't get that from a state pension. Perhaps her husband had a pension that benefited her when he died. That's fairly common in her age group I imagine.

We own our house, which we've lived in for 40 years. If my husband dies, I can't afford to keep it. I don't have a personal pension because we have a disabled child and I have had to stay home and care for her. Didn't have the forethought to pay into a pension scheme for me.
So if he dies I'll have to up sticks and move from my home of 40 years.
I'm willing to bet that this new idea of means testing would cut my income even further. Even though I've saved the state millions of squids by caring for my disabled child at home unaided, for all these years.

It would be too complicated to means test all these complicated situations, so for today, Curious Mariette, I'm out.

bigbluebus · 22/01/2022 20:28

Having only been able to work for 16 years before needing to give up work to become a full time carer on the pittance that is carers allowance, I have been looking forward to receiving my state pension as the only perk to the 22 years I worked day and night for very little whilst saving the Government thousands. So forgive me if I don't wish to forfeit my pension just because DH managed to keep working in a half decent job - albeit it not as advanced in his career as he could have been due to our caring commitments. So no I don't want pensions to be means tested - I've missed out on years of paying into a private pension because I couldn't afford to due to having to give up my job.

caringcarer · 22/01/2022 20:28

Onion patch you are right, pensioners still pay income tax if total income above tax threshold.

Lolamento · 22/01/2022 20:28

I despair when reading this. So much wrong with it. I know of some people leaving in council houses and having saved for houses back home abroad whilst never downsizing their council houses when their children leave. Getting benefits and working for wages in cash and sending the money to their families in other countries. In short there many people that while they are based here and never contribute much.pretty sure they would be in line to get their pensions. While other for paying taxes could not save for a private pension and top of that would be at risk of not getting a state pension.

caringcarer · 22/01/2022 20:27

I paid into state system.for 35 years do when I am 67 I will get full state pension. I also paid into Teachers Pension scheme for almost 30 years although some part time when children.small. I paid into a third pension and have £63k sitting in there and have already drawn down 25 per Percent of that. When I am 67 I will only get about £20k so will have to make it stretch. Without state pension I would be screwed. No point being in retirement if you cannot afford to have nice holidays, finally in term time, and pay for your activities. Luckily my dh has a much better personal pension than me.

Chloemol · 22/01/2022 20:26

Nope. I have worked all my life to get a pension at the end of it

Why should I continue to work to get nothing at the end of it when some, who have never worked through choice, will get one

monfuseds · 22/01/2022 20:23

You’d be giving people absolutely no incentive to pay into their private pensions, what would be the point, paying the pensions of those who didn’t save

It would make me save more into my private pension. I already do as assume I won't see the state one.

Alexandra2001 · 22/01/2022 20:22

@Fr0thandBubble

That wouldn’t be fair. I pay well into 6 figures tax a year - why should I be paying for everyone else’s pension and not get one myself Confused?
Good point and sounds like you really need that 8k p.a. too.
elbea · 22/01/2022 20:20

You’d be giving people absolutely no incentive to pay into their private pensions, what would be the point, paying the pensions of those who didn’t save

Alexandra2001 · 22/01/2022 20:20

Get rid of it entirely?

Give people the option to take the monies saved and pay that into a private pension, those that don't will end up destitute but thats a price worth paying, it will also encourage a spirit of independence.

Similar is already happening with the NHS, anyone needing an op for urgent personal reasons e.g. their job, has to pay '000s to get it done.

We've voted Tory for the last 12 years and will doubtless do it again in 2024/5 so its clearly what we want.

monfuseds · 22/01/2022 20:17

I pay well into 6 figures tax a year - why should I be paying for everyone else’s pension and not get one myself

you are paying 6 figs in just tax & you are worried about not getting your state pension?

Fr0thandBubble · 22/01/2022 20:14

That wouldn’t be fair. I pay well into 6 figures tax a year - why should I be paying for everyone else’s pension and not get one myself Confused?

HeatonGrove · 22/01/2022 20:13

Cost of means testing is very high and would not make economic sense in this context. There are too many pensioners and the tax system already balances things out.

Wealthy pensioners still pay income tax and many continue to pay far more into the system than they take out.

monfuseds · 22/01/2022 20:11

@Ylvamoon I will check it out.

RuthTopp · 22/01/2022 20:11

It’s just young workers subsidizing a generation that designed a system to benefit themselves

Bollocks is it ! You pay until you retire , plenty of 60+ still paying.
Also you don't stop paying once you've reached your 35 years of contributions , you carry on until you retire.

monfuseds · 22/01/2022 20:10

There are only liabilities paid out of tax income and borrowing.

yep

user1497207191 · 22/01/2022 20:10

I think there should be means testing but at a VERY high level such as £100k.

Swipe left for the next trending thread