Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Means testing State Pension

731 replies

CuriousMariette · 22/01/2022 18:25

Do you think the time has come for this to be introduced? I don’t think the current system is sustainable as many people are living too long. I know it’s not fair and would be political suicide but Pensioner’s didn’t even suffer a 80% furlough during lockdowns. I say this from a place of having “paid in” as people say for 30 years plus already and would likely not receive a State Pension in this scenario.

OP posts:
ancientgran · 24/01/2022 19:12

@onlychildhamster

my FIL had no pension as he didn't work for most of his life. He did however get 100K from my MIL when they divorced (for his share of the house). He was living with his parents for a while but now has moved to Thailand (and has a Thai wife). I have met him once when he flew back to see his dying mum. He is very happy and lives in a large house in Chiang Rai with a rescue duck, pet dogs as well as his wife's family. There are cafes there and beautiful nature and temples. He doesn't speak Thai at all, his wife speaks very basic English. I don't think there is any place in the UK where he could have such a retirement for 100k and zero pension.

Would that be an option for many Brits? As long as you have £17k in your bank account and are over 50, you can qualify for a retirement visa. I get that if you have kids, that would be less of an option. my FIL had 4 kids but most of them aren't on good terms. But perhaps for childless retirees or retirees whose children have emigrated, that may be more common. I think many people in my generation (I am in my 20s) wouldn't have kids and I am only planning on 1 child. I actually think the chance of my child staying in Uk is quite slim...

The Best Marigold Hotel?
echt · 24/01/2022 18:15

@Lockdownbear

Another issue with means testing is how do you value what people have in investments ISAs, and other shares.

Not to mention it becomes a disincentive for people to down size their property. If it means they then loose out on pension because they then have too much money in the bank

This is exactly what happened to a friend of mine here in Australia. In addition to estate agent fees, costs of removals, and inevitable repairs to the new property, she’s had her pension cut.

As an aside, the house is further away from all amenities and her circle of immediate friends. As is often the case in downsizing, it’s hard to stay in the old area.

woodhill · 24/01/2022 17:51

[quote user1497207191]@Lockdownbear

It is also when they had YTS schemes and kids working for two years for a pittance.

I appreciate "some" employers took advantage of cheap labour, but it worked very well for a lot of youngsters who got their first feet on the employment ladder, got valuable work experience, got on the job training, etc.

One of my closest friends left school with barely any qualifications, and got a place on a YTS scheme at the local chamber of commerce doing menial filing, tea making, etc. She impressed and got taken on full time, did various training courses etc and got regular promotions over the years. She's currently the managing director of that same Chamber of Commerce. She often says she owes her career to the YTS scheme![/quote]
The YTS was also beneficial as it got young people into jobs and gave the, opportunities not loads of debt for doing the same job

HootOwl · 24/01/2022 16:49

The other point is that when making pension contributions you have no way of knowing what the tax thresholds and rates will be in several decades when you will be making withdrawals. It seems fairly likely they'll be less favourable than now, for all the reasons discussed in this thread. So if you start taxing people on their contributions to pensions, the incentive to save that way pretty much dissolves: it becomes a very risky bet. People would I expect largely just pay tax on the money now, take it as earnings and invest it in tax efficient non-pension savings, at which point the Government have no future income from it which will make the overall tax position even worse when those people eventually retire.

HootOwl · 24/01/2022 16:20

I don't think people are saying scrapping all tax relief - they're saying to scrap the higher rate relief, so that everyone gets the same basic rate relief regardless of their income levels.

Everyone does get the same in the current system: they can pay into their pension fund tax free from gross earnings. Obviously that means "relief" at a higher rate for taxpayers who pay tax at a higher rate, because they pay more tax in the first place!

Your point re tax on pension payments in retirement in partly valid, but not fully, because a higher earner could be saving 40%/45% or even 60% on their pension contributions whilst working, but then only pay 20% basic rate tax in retirement when it comes to drawing down as income. That's not comparable at all. There'll be few pensioners paying 40/45 or 60% tax on their pension income even those previously higher earners!

And many basic rate taxpayers who received 20% tax relief on contributions will pay nothing on withdrawals because they won't withdraw more than the personal allowance each year. Should we take away their 20% relief on contributions as well? You can't have it both ways.

And as I said, these differences are substantially compensated for by the fact that by taxing at the point of withdrawal, the Government levies tax on a far higher total amount of capital than it would if it taxed contributions instead.

Blossomtoes · 24/01/2022 16:14

@pradavilla

I'd say yes but at a high threshold. Like say anyone who has income of £50k+ per year clearly doesn't need a state pension on top!
It’s not about need. And anyone with an income of £50k will be handing 40% of their state pension straight back anyway.
Lockdownbear · 24/01/2022 16:14

Another issue with means testing is how do you value what people have in investments ISAs, and other shares.

Not to mention it becomes a disincentive for people to down size their property. If it means they then loose out on pension because they then have too much money in the bank

Mountaingoat12 · 24/01/2022 16:12

People with an income of over £50k are often working in the private sector and as a result have a crappy defined contribution pension. The state pension is the only guaranteed income they have in retirement. There’s no gold plated public sector pension for them, unlike the likes of hospital consultants who are retiring early as their pension pots are worth so much and they don’t want to pay the resulting tax bill.

OfstedOffred · 24/01/2022 16:06

I think you can't do this without compensating people part way through a career who havent saved enough with state pension.

They don't have enough time left to make up the missing amount even if they are reasonable earners as the compounding makes a huge difference

Lockdownbear · 24/01/2022 15:55

@pradavilla

I'd say yes but at a high threshold. Like say anyone who has income of £50k+ per year clearly doesn't need a state pension on top!
So how do you then stop people taking a lump sum out their pension pot so it keeps their pension income below the threshold?

Retire early use up their private pot before getting the state pension.

Many ways for people to get round it then throw into the mix the cost of actually means testing. Will cost more than it saves.

pradavilla · 24/01/2022 15:41

I'd say yes but at a high threshold. Like say anyone who has income of £50k+ per year clearly doesn't need a state pension on top!

CuriousaboutSamphire · 24/01/2022 14:57

DGR Smile The Whigs certainly have a certain resonance with politicians these days!

We have actually had two real revolutions: the Civil Wars and Interregnum of 1640-60 and the Glorious Revolution of 1688-89

DGRossetti · 24/01/2022 14:02

The English haven't had a revolution. The civil war was just a lot of posh boys arguing over who gets to stay up after lights out. Unfortunately it dragged in the rest of Britain (sorry about that).

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 24/01/2022 13:55

[quote AuntyBumBum]Hi @daimbarsatemydogsbone

As far as I know, no party has proposed this.

Even the most recent Labour manifesto which proposed 45% tax for earnings over 80K, didn't remove the high rate tax relief - so in fact higher earners would have received more tax relief on pension contributions under a Corbyn government.

The idea has been knocking about for years, at least since George Osborne's time.

Eg
www.unbiased.co.uk/news/financial-adviser/could-higher-rate-pension-tax-relief-be-scrapped[/quote]
Yeah - it's always "could this be next?" and it never happens.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 24/01/2022 13:54

@onlychildhamster

my FIL had no pension as he didn't work for most of his life. He did however get 100K from my MIL when they divorced (for his share of the house). He was living with his parents for a while but now has moved to Thailand (and has a Thai wife). I have met him once when he flew back to see his dying mum. He is very happy and lives in a large house in Chiang Rai with a rescue duck, pet dogs as well as his wife's family. There are cafes there and beautiful nature and temples. He doesn't speak Thai at all, his wife speaks very basic English. I don't think there is any place in the UK where he could have such a retirement for 100k and zero pension.

Would that be an option for many Brits? As long as you have £17k in your bank account and are over 50, you can qualify for a retirement visa. I get that if you have kids, that would be less of an option. my FIL had 4 kids but most of them aren't on good terms. But perhaps for childless retirees or retirees whose children have emigrated, that may be more common. I think many people in my generation (I am in my 20s) wouldn't have kids and I am only planning on 1 child. I actually think the chance of my child staying in Uk is quite slim...

I know someone who plans to retire to the Philippines with his wife who is from there - she has an NHS pension as she has many years of NHS service and family there so they should be fine.
AuntyBumBum · 24/01/2022 13:50

Hi @daimbarsatemydogsbone

As far as I know, no party has proposed this.

Even the most recent Labour manifesto which proposed 45% tax for earnings over 80K, didn't remove the high rate tax relief - so in fact higher earners would have received more tax relief on pension contributions under a Corbyn government.

The idea has been knocking about for years, at least since George Osborne's time.

Eg
www.unbiased.co.uk/news/financial-adviser/could-higher-rate-pension-tax-relief-be-scrapped

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 24/01/2022 13:34

@rookiemere

Yes *@user1497207191* that's what I meant - scrap the higher rate of tax relief on pension contributions, not all of it. I had it in my head that this might have happened already but maybe it was a manifesto pledge instead.
As far as I know, no party has proposed this.

Even the most recent Labour manifesto which proposed 45% tax for earnings over 80K, didn't remove the high rate tax relief - so in fact higher earners would have received more tax relief on pension contributions under a Corbyn government.

onlychildhamster · 24/01/2022 13:31

my FIL had no pension as he didn't work for most of his life. He did however get 100K from my MIL when they divorced (for his share of the house). He was living with his parents for a while but now has moved to Thailand (and has a Thai wife). I have met him once when he flew back to see his dying mum. He is very happy and lives in a large house in Chiang Rai with a rescue duck, pet dogs as well as his wife's family. There are cafes there and beautiful nature and temples. He doesn't speak Thai at all, his wife speaks very basic English. I don't think there is any place in the UK where he could have such a retirement for 100k and zero pension.

Would that be an option for many Brits? As long as you have £17k in your bank account and are over 50, you can qualify for a retirement visa. I get that if you have kids, that would be less of an option. my FIL had 4 kids but most of them aren't on good terms. But perhaps for childless retirees or retirees whose children have emigrated, that may be more common. I think many people in my generation (I am in my 20s) wouldn't have kids and I am only planning on 1 child. I actually think the chance of my child staying in Uk is quite slim...

ancientgran · 24/01/2022 13:22

@monfused

I think the English might be like that laid back person who never loses their temper, until they do and then God help everyone.

Perhaps

Scary when those people lose it, I'm not sure if they are worse when they lost it or if it is the shock element but I used to have a boss like that and the first time I saw it happen I was in shock.
monfused · 24/01/2022 13:09

Thank god (and my Irish grandfather) so do I, my previously outlined retirement plans will mostly be taking place elsewhere :p

Im sure it's the wisest option.

ColletteTheLot · 24/01/2022 13:08

How would my other in law afford her third holiday abroad each year though?

monfused · 24/01/2022 13:07

I think the English might be like that laid back person who never loses their temper, until they do and then God help everyone.

Perhaps

Blossomtoes · 24/01/2022 13:07

@monfused

Get used to it.

Did you mean to be so rude @Blossomtoes?

I'm also not really sure how playing top trumps over how long someone has been unhappy is useful to the conversation but crack on! 😆

No I didn’t actually. I don’t think I was rude. I was just pointing out that whatever government is in power someone will be unhappy. 🤷‍♀️
AuntyBumBum · 24/01/2022 13:07

@monfused

Eventually a demographic tipping point will come when enough of them (a) exist, and (b) start doing something.

I'm not sure we will ever get to the point where there are more young people. Certainly not the way it's going. Fortunately mine have EU passports so they maybe need to escape!

Thank god (and my Irish grandfather) so do I, my previously outlined retirement plans will mostly be taking place elsewhere :p
ancientgran · 24/01/2022 13:06

@monfused

We had a revolution first.

I still don't think it's the English way regardless of who had one first 😆

I think the English might be like that laid back person who never loses their temper, until they do and then God help everyone.