Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Means testing State Pension

731 replies

CuriousMariette · 22/01/2022 18:25

Do you think the time has come for this to be introduced? I don’t think the current system is sustainable as many people are living too long. I know it’s not fair and would be political suicide but Pensioner’s didn’t even suffer a 80% furlough during lockdowns. I say this from a place of having “paid in” as people say for 30 years plus already and would likely not receive a State Pension in this scenario.

OP posts:
Tealightsandd · 22/01/2022 23:23

But anyway don't worry OP.

More people are for now living longer...after dutifully doing what they were told by anti smoking crusaders, eg. not smoking because 'it shortens your life". And just like that - massive loss of tax revenue.

But, it won't go on. Life expectancy even before the pandemic had stagnated. Poverty and lifelong stress is a deadlier (and more unpleasant) killer than smoking.

Add in Long Covid - the organ and other damage it can cause, long term poorer health and the growing numbers hit by the public health housing and homelessness emergency - and in the future, life expectancy will be falling (except for the rich - of all ages).

Many will die without ever having a pension. We're going backwards.

And on the slippery slope of seeing human beings only value in how much money they can make (for somebody else) and a race to the bottom....after the pensioners, who next? Obviously the disabled. It's already been happening to them. It was so bad that some years ago the United Nations condemned how the UK was treating disabled people.

Who next? Refugees? Single mums.

First they came....

Meanwhile the billionaires got richer over the last two years. The money's there somewhere.

CuriousMariette · 22/01/2022 23:23

Can I just clarify I meant many people are now living too long for the current system to be sustainable. At no point did I say living longer was a bad thing - it’s a great thing - but brings issues we can’t ignore. I apologise to anyone I unintentionally offended I could have structured that sentence much better.

OP posts:
whatkatydid2013 · 22/01/2022 23:21

[quote monfuseds]@whatkatydid2013 the argument will be household 2 has been prudent & not wasted money on coffees 😆[/quote]
@monfuseds - Household 2 is basically my FIL. My parents are similar. They all think it’s stupid they don’t pay more tax & don’t have to pay the new levy. I tend to agree with them. We will likely be in a similar position to them when we retire and if more money needs to be found (even if it doesn’t and we just want to be more equitable) then we can pay more and so can they a hell of a lot more easily than someone grafting away on minimum wage raising a family. I roll my eyes a great deal at the comments on working hard & being deserving etc. I mean I do work hard but I’m darn sure I haven’t worked any harder or have any more stress than a career has had in the past couple of years and I earn a massive amount more money while working for what is likely a much more understanding employer with great sick leave, maternity leave, pension etc. I wish people could accept that working hard isn’t the only factor in achieving higher earnings.

Blossomtoes · 22/01/2022 23:20

Yes, I think a young person’s life is more important than an 89 year old’s

You need to be really careful where you go with that @Fr0thandBubble. It’s a slippery slope. Once you start weighing the value of lives, where do you stop? When my parents were 89 their lives were of massive importance to me. Your child means nothing to me, they mean everything to you.

TheHateIsNotGood · 22/01/2022 23:20

And the answer is...there isn't one; things will be/are getting increasingly tough for nearly all of us.

The last thing any of us should be doing is 'turning on' others.

Best see ourselves and our nearest and dearest are getting through rather than wasting our energy trying to reduce what others might get.

whatkatydid2013 · 22/01/2022 23:14

If you moved NI out of been a separate charge & handled it with tax (applying the same thresholds) then the people with the smallest earnings (including pensioners on really low incomes) would see no change or a decrease in tax overall and those with largest unearned/pension incomes would see the biggest change. You could put in plans now to make changes over next 20-30 years to slowly move away from ring fenced NI to give people a chance to plan for it

monfuseds · 22/01/2022 23:14

I don't think we should stop treating 80 year olds or whatever but we need to increase taxation That burden should fall on everyone.

echt · 22/01/2022 23:12

Yes, I think a young person’s life is more important than an 89 year old’s

No it isn't. An 89 year-old has a short time left. so good luck to them,. the young have many more years before them.

ancientgran · 22/01/2022 23:10

[quote CayrolBaaaskin]@ancientgran but if you are above state pension age you don’t pay NI which is a huge saving on tax on your income compared to a younger person[/quote]
It isn't a huge saving for me because my income isn't that high. Adding together my SRP my private pension and my part time job I pay a small amount of tax, if I give up my part time job I wouldn't pay any just like a younger person who is living on that level of income.

The point is the post I was replying to was saying pensioners should be paying NI or some other sort of tax. Well we do pay tax if our income is high enough, to imply we don't pay tax is wrong.

Maybe stop the upper limit on NI so it isn't regressive. I don't suppose high earners would be happy with that.

Tealightsandd · 22/01/2022 23:08

many people are living too long.

?!?

TheHateIsNotGood · 22/01/2022 23:05

Yes Blossom I agree it does, my local Council spends more on constantly re-assessing CTS Claims than it really could. Means Test them but not me....

My suggestion of let's totally Means Test is more to provoke some brain cells into thinking; if you take Means Testing far enough beforer you know it we're all on a National Income.

Unless you've got an Uncle calle Snowball or Napoleon :).

monfuseds · 22/01/2022 23:04

blanket free prescriptions for over 60s needs to go

iwantareindeer · 22/01/2022 23:04

I'm mid 40's I'm fortunate to have a job with a pension and afford to pay into it myself each month - I'm expecting the state pension to be means tested by the time I retire. I pay tax towards nhs funding but use private health- I'm expecting pensions to go the same way - a tax I won't personally benefit from but contribute towards.

monfuseds · 22/01/2022 23:03

child benefit is means tested

whatkatydid2013 · 22/01/2022 23:02

I believe some research claimed moving child benefit to being means tested would cost more in admin of more people doing tax returns, checks to ensure people hadn’t claimed when they shouldn’t have etc than it would gain. I’ve seen same on winter fuel allowance. It’s likely true for some benefits that are small & less so for those that are significant.

echt · 22/01/2022 23:02

£2.2 b annually in unclaimed means-tested benefits for OAPs in the UK:

www.ageuk.org.uk/globalassets/age-uk/documents/reports-and-publications/reports-and-briefings/money-matters/benefit_take-up_and_older_people_may-2021.pdf

I know it's peanuts compared to friends' benefits being spaffed away by the current government, but still.

CareBear50 · 22/01/2022 23:00

What about enforced euthanasia at say??? 65???

That would fix the problem and then its fair for everyone GrinHmmConfused

CayrolBaaaskin · 22/01/2022 22:59

@ancientgran but if you are above state pension age you don’t pay NI which is a huge saving on tax on your income compared to a younger person

SquirrelG · 22/01/2022 22:58

I don't know what they can do about it apart from hugely drastic measures such as DNR for anyone over a certain age

Wow, aren't you a charmer. What is this "certain age" btw? Should I start worrying because I'm 62?

My 88 year old DF had an expensive heart procedure done last year, which has given him a new lease of life, and hopefullly a few more good years on this earth. Perhaps he should just have been left to suffer and die?

CayrolBaaaskin · 22/01/2022 22:57

Also means testing doesn’t cost more than it saves at all! Why else is pretty much ever other benefit means tested?

Fr0thandBubble · 22/01/2022 22:56

[quote mellicauli]@Fr0thandBubble My Mother is 89. She had cancer treatment earlier this year but up til then she's been very fit and healthy. It's taken 6 months but now she's in remission.

She has been contributing tax to this country for 61 years, had a fine career, raised a family and did voluntary work until 2 years ago. Yet you are saying that her point of need she should have just be left in pain and untreated?

And that you seriously think your life is worth more than hers? She developed the software for one of 1st microchips, a technology that underlies every device around your house. What exactly have you contributed?

I think it would be just be a fairer idea to ask the 4.5 million self employed people to pay the same rates of national insurance as people who are employed? I also think that working retired people should pay national insurance.[/quote]
Yes, I think a young person’s life is more important than an 89 year old’s. We can’t afford pension payments and health and social care for the elderly at projected rates without it seriously impacting what the state is able to provide for children and the young - which is where I think it should be focused.

ancientgran · 22/01/2022 22:55

@80sMum

No, it should be universal. But perhaps pensioners should continue to pay pay national insurance (or some other sort of tax). I would go further and say that everyone should be on benefits, ie that should be universal too. Means testing of benefits creates poverty traps and inequality and discourages saving and working.
We do pay tax if our income is high enough. I've been working for 52 years and my main income is my SRP and I've paid for it. I'm still working part time.
monfuseds · 22/01/2022 22:55

I think we should just move NI into income tax so people don’t have this misconception it’s some sort of fund.

good point, I didn't realise so many see it as a personal pot.

CayrolBaaaskin · 22/01/2022 22:54

Again - no one is promised anything at 16 or any other age. State pension are benefits- paid for by general taxation. That means generally working age people are paying for pensioners pensions. Even if ni contributions were to be invested, it would be nothing like enough to pay the average state pension.

You have to be at least a higher rate taxpayer (40%) to pay for the benefits and services you use. That’s over your lifetime- so you are paying for your schooling etc( so irrelevant if you have children or not,). What is actually happening is a few people at the top are paying a hugely disproportionate share.

I think we should just move NI into income tax so people don’t have this misconception it’s some sort of fund. It’s not, it’s just a tax. Also no reason pensioners shouldn’t pay it. Generally pensioners take most out of the system (due to healthcare needs, care and universal pensions). The wealthier ones should at least be paying in fairly.

monfuseds · 22/01/2022 22:53

@whatkatydid2013 the argument will be household 2 has been prudent & not wasted money on coffees 😆