Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Means testing State Pension

731 replies

CuriousMariette · 22/01/2022 18:25

Do you think the time has come for this to be introduced? I don’t think the current system is sustainable as many people are living too long. I know it’s not fair and would be political suicide but Pensioner’s didn’t even suffer a 80% furlough during lockdowns. I say this from a place of having “paid in” as people say for 30 years plus already and would likely not receive a State Pension in this scenario.

OP posts:
Tealightsandd · 22/01/2022 23:54

[quote monfuseds]@Tealightsandd what's not true? that we don't have an ageing population? we do already. [/quote]
But we won't in the future. Except the rich.

Tealightsandd · 22/01/2022 23:53

[quote monfuseds]@Tealightsandd I don't understand what point you are trying to make[/quote]
The point is posters are complaining about people 'living too long'. Well, people can't have it both ways. Tell people off for smoking (a huge source of tax revenue) because 'it shortens your life - but then moan when people stop smoking and...live longer.

monfuseds · 22/01/2022 23:52

@Tealightsandd what's not true? that we don't have an ageing population? we do already.

monfuseds · 22/01/2022 23:50

A mass social housing build would cost upfront but, unlike the billions of recently casually written off furlough fraud, longer term it would save hugely. It would also boost the construction industry.

I agree that housing costs have done extreme damage & we need a huge injection of housing but many people & older ones are more likely to own their home plus other homes likely won't vote for something that penalises them.

whatkatydid2013 · 22/01/2022 23:49

@MichelleScarn I don’t think the state pension should be means tested but I think a possible fair solution would be changing the way we manage taxation so the wealthiest pensioners/those with unearned income have to pay a tax rate that incorporates what is now ring fenced as national insurance and the poorest working don’t have to start paying National Insurance at a low threshold (I can’t recall exact amount but it’s on income above ~£6.5k).

Tealightsandd · 22/01/2022 23:49

@monfuseds

although your link highlights the point I made re financial impact of the changing demographics

"campaigners and policymakers risk ignoring the real problem that our healthcare system faces: an ageing population.”"

Well that's not true is it.

Covid is being allowed to kill loads and loads off (in the UK).

And Long Covid, plus growing poverty, will see to it that life expectancy will continue to stagnate and then fall.

We're going back to the 19th century. If you're not rich, literally work until you drop.

Next up, workhouse revival.

MichelleScarn · 22/01/2022 23:49

@monfuseds I can't see any poster stating they think they've earned the right to not want to pay a penny towards care have they? Posters have said it's a bit shit to pay shit loads in ni and then get told 'actually you're not getting a state pension, that's only for those who've never contributed'.
What annoys me is the pious 'oh I'm so happy to not get a state pension, everyone should be like me, and if you don't accept this with glee you're obviously an evil person who wants the vulnerable to suffer' attitude.

Lockdownbear · 22/01/2022 23:49

@monfuseds

I think we should just move NI into income tax so people don’t have this misconception it’s some sort of fund.

good point, I didn't realise so many see it as a personal pot.

I do agree there, the tax system could do with being simplified. Another one that should be rolled into general taxation is TV licence. Many argue against TV licence but BBC and Bitesize came into its own during lockdown. Nobody can guarantee us that we'll never have another reason to close schools.

I bet many people don't realise this Each month Companies calculate the NI due to be paid, then deducts any SSP, Mat Pay or Paternity pay they've had to pay out and then pays the balance to IR.

The benefits to keeping NI separate are they calculate the number of payments made for certain benefits like the contributions based element of Job Seekers Allowance, Maternity Allowance for those who've moved jobs and not entitled to SMP.
Pension if you have x years of NI payments you get the 'full' pension. Although some people may have had periods of being a SAHM where you still get you NI credits if you have a child under 5.
Not sure if there are any other times when you get NI credits when you aren't paying it.

But I'm sure they could still simplify the system making it easier for small employers too.

monfuseds · 22/01/2022 23:47
  • First they came for the elderly. Then they came for the disabled. Next they came for the refugees. Then they came for the single mums. By the time they came for me, there was nobody left to speak out for me...*

slightly dramatic plus they came for the refugees, disabled & single mums long ago. I think older wealthier people should contribute to the h&s levy, that's not coming for the elderly.

echt · 22/01/2022 23:45

@londonmummy1966

No but I think that there should be an income surcharge on higher rate pensioners that is at a similar level to NI contributions - to help fund the NHS as their age group are the ones that cost it the most and I don't see why the better off amongst them can't cough up given the rest of us will have to pay extra now.
Higher paid pensioners will pay the levy from 2023 ( 2, second paragraph)

www.gov.uk/government/publications/health-and-social-care-levy/health-and-social-care-levy

Higher-paid pensioners are already taxed at the same rate as the general population.

TheHateIsNotGood · 22/01/2022 23:45

OP really does have a point though - it is true that we have 'expectations' of keeping ourselves 'alive for as long as possible, no matter what the cost.

My 74 year old Mum had Level 4 Cancer but rather than helping her to accept her final stages in the life cycle, many thousands of £s were wasted in the painful and unnecessary chemo that killed her before the cancer did.

monfuseds · 22/01/2022 23:45

Meanwhile the billionaires get richer

well that's not going to change

monfuseds · 22/01/2022 23:44

@MichelleScarn They've benefited from hugely inflated property gains, cheap lending to buy btls, good private pensions etc. I don't think they've earned the right to not want to pay a penny towards care & wrap everything up in trusts to limit tax grabs & sit in million pound plus homes moaning that A&E is too busy & too many people arriving on boats are milking the system.

I would be very unhappy to not receive a state pension that doesn't mean logically I can't see how the system is unsustainable.

Tealightsandd · 22/01/2022 23:44

Race to the bottom and Othering.

Meanwhile the billionaires get richer.

Tealightsandd · 22/01/2022 23:42

First they came for the elderly.
Then they came for the disabled.
Next they came for the refugees.
Then they came for the single mums.
By the time they came for me, there was nobody left to speak out for me...

londonmummy1966 · 22/01/2022 23:40

No but I think that there should be an income surcharge on higher rate pensioners that is at a similar level to NI contributions - to help fund the NHS as their age group are the ones that cost it the most and I don't see why the better off amongst them can't cough up given the rest of us will have to pay extra now.

FruitMelange · 22/01/2022 23:38

So it’s a big ship
To turn around

I've not heard that phrase before, but it's spot on here.

I hope I get chance to use it in the future.

monfuseds · 22/01/2022 23:38

although your link highlights the point I made re financial impact of the changing demographics

"campaigners and policymakers risk ignoring the real problem that our healthcare system faces: an ageing population.”"

MichelleScarn · 22/01/2022 23:36

[quote monfuseds]@whatkatydid2013 I have lots of similar people in family as colleagues however they buy into the "I've earned it" narrative. [/quote]
Do you think they haven't 'earned it' all those saying how happy and pleased they'd be not to accept a state pension, how much charity giving do you do now?
For those who think there should be a cut off for income for state pension, do you not think that's a bit arrogant to state what should be done with others income?

Tealightsandd · 22/01/2022 23:36

There was an interesting report the other day. A major issue is not longer life expectancy. It's that growing numbers of people are becoming too unwell to work years before retirement age (this will worsen with Long Covid).

Dealing with the public health housing and homelessness emergency would significantly improve the situation.

The poverty, destination, and stress associated with insecure or no housing is a major cause of ill health.

It also, whilst we're talking of tax money, is hugely costly to the taxpayer. Billions and billions and billions.

Billions to house homeless families and vulnerable individuals in expensive temporary accommodation. Billions in housing benefits to pay high private rents. And billions and billions on the knock on impact of the housing emergency - NHS (including mental health), social services, criminal justice system, and more.

A mass social housing build would cost upfront but, unlike the billions of recently casually written off furlough fraud, longer term it would save hugely. It would also boost the construction industry.

It's the moral thing to do - but also financially prudent for the national economy.

monfuseds · 22/01/2022 23:36

@Tealightsandd I don't understand what point you are trying to make

Tealightsandd · 22/01/2022 23:35

we need to increase taxation

www.publicfinance.co.uk/news/2017/08/smoking-and-drinking-save-public-purse-money

monfuseds · 22/01/2022 23:28

@whatkatydid2013 I have lots of similar people in family as colleagues however they buy into the "I've earned it" narrative.

coronafiona · 22/01/2022 23:24

No. I've paid into it since I was 16, I'm entitled to it thanks. Sorry but just.. no.

godmum56 · 22/01/2022 23:23

@Fr0thandBubble
"godmum56
@Fr0thandBubblethan
"Honestly I think the issue is that we try far too hard to keep people alive for as long as possible in this country. I’d happily pay more tax to fund better education for children, better services for disabled children (being a parent of one, I know just how dire the state provision is), generally better provision for children, etc. But taxpayers spending hundreds of thousands eking out the age of people in their 80s and 90s, I’ve got no interest in."

go on then, who shall we kill and how shall we kill them? I have worked in the NHS and by and large, its my experience that the older population who are receiving a high level of care are given only treatments to keep them comfortable because that is what is best for them....or should we leave them in pain and fighting for breath?"

"I’m not talking about killing anyone. If you’re old and you can afford your own healthcare, crack on. If you can’t, I don’t think the taxpayer should be paying to eke out every last year of life of someone in their 80s/90s. As I said before, I’d rather the money I pay in tax goes on provision for children. And these are choices we have to make, because we have the means of keeping people alive for a long time, at vast expense, but that needs to be paid for somehow, and there is a great many more people taking out of the pot than putting into it."

well actually you are talking about killing people if you are suggesting, as you seem to be, no NHS care for people over 80? As I said in my original post, when people get seriously frail and unwell at any age then health care in the NHS is limited to what is in their best interests....no one strives "officiously to keep alive" unless circumstances are very unusual...wasn't it one of the big issues during the early stages of covid that people from care homes were not given intubated oxygen? My experience in care of older people in the NHS is that realtives fight for their loved ones to be given more aggressive life prolongation treatments but that this is usually not done because it amounts to cruelty to the patient. I have no idea where you got the idea that the life of older frail people is "eked out" at vast expense by the NHS? Yes some peoples lives do carry on beyond the point where they are cognitively aware or physically able in any real sense but what should we do with these people who won't die?
I used to work with older poeple who had been badly affected by stroke. Sometimes relatives, loving distressed people, would ask why their loved one hadn't been allowed to die. the answer was always the same and absolutely true: that while the person had been kept comfortable, nothing had been done to prolong their life, the fact was that they hadn't died. So again i ask, who should die and how shall we kill them?