Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Means testing State Pension

731 replies

CuriousMariette · 22/01/2022 18:25

Do you think the time has come for this to be introduced? I don’t think the current system is sustainable as many people are living too long. I know it’s not fair and would be political suicide but Pensioner’s didn’t even suffer a 80% furlough during lockdowns. I say this from a place of having “paid in” as people say for 30 years plus already and would likely not receive a State Pension in this scenario.

OP posts:
Tealightsandd · 23/01/2022 00:14

@monfuseds

Can't tell people to stop smoking because 'it will shorten your life', but then complain when they stop smoking and live longer.

no one mentioned smoking on this thread though or saying old people should take it up to die sooner

I know. It was me who mentioned smoking - because the anti smoking crusade is very relevant to the 'old people are living too long' narrative, and also the discussion about tax revenue.
silentpool · 23/01/2022 00:14

I'm going to count on that money OP as I won't have quite enough otherwise. You might not need it but others will.

echt · 23/01/2022 00:14

[quote londonmummy1966]@echt - yes but only the levy - I think that they could pay a surcharge/levy equal to NIC not just the extra 1.25%. It is crazy that my DPs have six figure pension income and pay less than many struggling families.[/quote]
Also, there are 8.52 million OAPs in the UK.

The only figures for this who pay tax I could find, and by your argument should be paying NI is 37, 000 at the 45% band and 508, 000 in the 40% band.

That leaves a lot of people not paying your projected NI.

There really really aren't shitloads of OAPs rolling in cash.

monfuseds · 23/01/2022 00:13

The money's there somewhere.

Not with the majority of the public though

SquidMonkey · 23/01/2022 00:12

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

They won't pay it because pensioners don't pay NI Pensioners will be made to pay the levy - not as soon as it’s added to NI, but they will be charged. Check your facts.
They won't be charged anything for over another year yet, if that even happens at all. Not sure if you've noticed but it's hardly as though we have a stable Government and you can put any stock in what they claom to be their longer-term plans actually happening!
Tealightsandd · 23/01/2022 00:12

The UK has one of the lowest pension rates in the developed world.

Yet we're apparently the 5th largest economy.

The money's there somewhere.

monfuseds · 23/01/2022 00:11

Can't tell people to stop smoking because 'it will shorten your life', but then complain when they stop smoking and live longer.

no one mentioned smoking on this thread though or saying old people should take it up to die sooner

FruitMelange · 23/01/2022 00:11

those taxpayers paying for the current pensioners pensions won’t get pensions themselves or will get them much later than those that they have paid for

I've paid in for over 50 years. Still won't get full state pension till I'm 68.
I was promised it at 60 but hey, hang on, they just changed the rules

Lockdownbear · 23/01/2022 00:10

@whatkatydid2013

I know people get really shirty about idea of pensioners losing out but the government just introduced an additional 1.25% for employers & employees NI to help fund health & social care. Imagine these households

Household 1 is a single pensioner who rents a council flat with state plus small private pension. Their current income is ~ £10k/year

Household 2 is a single pensioner who owns their own 4 bed detached home outright & has savings amounting to ~£150k. Their overall pension is £40k/year but net income is more like £34.5k accounting for tax.

Household three is a single parent working 25 hours/week on minimum wage. They rent a 2 bed terrace for £600/month for themselves & 2 children. Income is ~12.5k/year but net income with universal credit/pension contributions/child benefit is around £25k

Household 4 are a couple with two children who earn around £90k between them. They own a 5 bedroom terrace with a mortgage and have ~£70k of savings. Their mortgage is £1,300/month. Their net income including child benefit less private pension contributions is ~£64k/year

If you had to pick out which two of these households ought to start paying a bit more towards health and social care which ones does it seem fairest to tax more?

That seems like House 2.

But House 4 would be House 2 in a few years owning their house outright. With House 3 becoming House 1 in the future still renting.

So if you take pension away from House 2 whats the incentive for House 4 to keep struggling along paying a heavy mortgage and trying to put away some savings for a rainy day?
Why don't they just drop some hours, earn a bit less and enjoy life?

House 3 at the moment are possibly looking at options to increase income, college courses etc with a view to creating a better life for themselves their children won't be dependents forever.

It might be a Scottish government fuckup but there is an issue at the moment with Doctors and the tax thresholds, some Docs are better off working part-time keeping themselves under the threshold or they end up working extra hours for nothing.

You can't tax people to the hilt and then expect them to keep working.
People will leave or go part-time. Dispose of money and assets by passing it to the next generation.

You make the system too difficult People will find and expose the loopholes.

Tealightsandd · 23/01/2022 00:10

@monfuseds

"Our ageing population faces a systematically underfunded NHS, one they've paid into, that is being primed to be sold off to private (US) providers"

If this is happening, who is responsible?

Also, rich people. Of all ages.
Tealightsandd · 23/01/2022 00:09

@monfuseds

"Our ageing population faces a systematically underfunded NHS, one they've paid into, that is being primed to be sold off to private (US) providers"

If this is happening, who is responsible?

Successive governments over the last 30-40 years. Both Labour and Conservative (and Lib Dem).
Tealightsandd · 23/01/2022 00:08

@monfuseds

Tell people off for smoking (a huge source of tax revenue) because 'it shortens your life - but then moan when people stop smoking and...live longer.

You're that poster obsessed with this. Not one person has mentioned smoking on this thread.

Yes I mentioned it, because we can't have it both ways. Can't tell people to stop smoking because 'it will shorten your life', but then complain when they stop smoking and live longer.
monfuseds · 23/01/2022 00:06

@londonmummy1966 i agree

monfuseds · 23/01/2022 00:05

"Our ageing population faces a systematically underfunded NHS, one they've paid into, that is being primed to be sold off to private (US) providers"

If this is happening, who is responsible?

echt · 23/01/2022 00:04

[quote londonmummy1966]@echt - yes but only the levy - I think that they could pay a surcharge/levy equal to NIC not just the extra 1.25%. It is crazy that my DPs have six figure pension income and pay less than many struggling families.[/quote]
I see what you mean. I'm sure it will happen in time.

Tealightsandd · 23/01/2022 00:01

@echt

campaigners and policymakers risk ignoring the real problem that our healthcare system faces: an ageing population

How about: "Our ageing population faces a systematically underfunded NHS, one they've paid into, that is being primed to be sold off to private (US) providers".

That's definitely better worded.
monfuseds · 22/01/2022 23:59

Many is not all. Talking of many, strangely enough many older people want their children and grandchildren to have affordable housing.

And yet the Tories are still in power 🤔

monfuseds · 22/01/2022 23:58

& the levy is only for those working

Tealightsandd · 22/01/2022 23:58

@monfuseds

A mass social housing build would cost upfront but, unlike the billions of recently casually written off furlough fraud, longer term it would save hugely. It would also boost the construction industry.

I agree that housing costs have done extreme damage & we need a huge injection of housing but many people & older ones are more likely to own their home plus other homes likely won't vote for something that penalises them.

Many is not all. Talking of many, strangely enough many older people want their children and grandchildren to have affordable housing.

And, the fastest growing group of private renters is people aged 40+.

monfuseds · 22/01/2022 23:57

Tell people off for smoking (a huge source of tax revenue) because 'it shortens your life - but then moan when people stop smoking and...live longer.

You're that poster obsessed with this. Not one person has mentioned smoking on this thread.

londonmummy1966 · 22/01/2022 23:56

@echt - yes but only the levy - I think that they could pay a surcharge/levy equal to NIC not just the extra 1.25%. It is crazy that my DPs have six figure pension income and pay less than many struggling families.

monfuseds · 22/01/2022 23:56

But we won't in the future. Except the rich.

So we will then...

echt · 22/01/2022 23:56

campaigners and policymakers risk ignoring the real problem that our healthcare system faces: an ageing population

How about: "Our ageing population faces a systematically underfunded NHS, one they've paid into, that is being primed to be sold off to private (US) providers".

monfuseds · 22/01/2022 23:55

@MichelleScarn in my post I was referring to people I know as I said relatives & colleagues.

Posters have said it's a bit shit to pay shit loads in ni and then get told 'actually you're not getting a state pension, that's only for those who've never contributed'.

where have I said it's not shit?

What annoys me is the pious 'oh I'm so happy to not get a state pension, everyone should be like me, and if you don't accept this with glee you're obviously an evil person who wants the vulnerable to suffer' attitude.

Who has said this? I certainly haven't.

As I said I think it's shit that state pensions & the NHS won't exist in X number of years time. It's an absolute travesty but I still think it's inevitable.

Fr0thandBubble · 22/01/2022 23:55

@godmum56 There is a very big difference between “killing” and not providing life-extending treatment. Of course I would never say anyone should be killed.

Swipe left for the next trending thread