Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Means testing State Pension

731 replies

CuriousMariette · 22/01/2022 18:25

Do you think the time has come for this to be introduced? I don’t think the current system is sustainable as many people are living too long. I know it’s not fair and would be political suicide but Pensioner’s didn’t even suffer a 80% furlough during lockdowns. I say this from a place of having “paid in” as people say for 30 years plus already and would likely not receive a State Pension in this scenario.

OP posts:
Tealightsandd · 23/01/2022 00:38

[quote Fr0thandBubble]@Tealightsandd Oh come on! The rich are the ones paying for it all! The problem is that there are too many people taking more from the pot than they put in! Exactly how much more do you want the rich to pay? Because at a 45% tax rate (plus NI, SDLT, VAT and council tax), I certainly feel like I do my bit - and then some.[/quote]
I'm talking about the likes of Tony Blair and co. who use various tax avoidance schemes (see Pandora papers). Legal, yes. Moral? Not so much.

As for the stuff about home ownership. average is indeed the word. There are many pensioners living room in poverty. And plenty of super wealthy 30 somethings.

And like I said, things will soon change.

  1. Long Covid will lower life expectancies.
  1. The fastest growing group of private renters (note - private rent, not the more secure social rent) is the 40+ age group.
monfuseds · 23/01/2022 00:38

There are finite resources. We can't have everything.

and if we want everything we need far higher taxation that has to be spread across all.

Fr0thandBubble · 23/01/2022 00:36

@FruitMelange

Why the hell should I live this kind of life flogging myself to death only to fund other people who don’t make these sacrifices?

Well don't then. Spend more time with your wife and children. Money alone can't make you happy.

Oof unconscious bias right there @FruitMelange. I’m a woman. And I work this hard to provide for my children, one of whom needs additional support because he has ASD.
SquidMonkey · 23/01/2022 00:35

@Blossomtoes

Yes, I think a young person’s life is more important than an 89 year old’s

You need to be really careful where you go with that @Fr0thandBubble. It’s a slippery slope. Once you start weighing the value of lives, where do you stop? When my parents were 89 their lives were of massive importance to me. Your child means nothing to me, they mean everything to you.

The NHS does this every single day already!

There are finite resources. We can't have everything. When NICE authorise new treatments they do a cost/ benefit analysis based on healthy expected life years and the difference the treatment will likely make to that.

It's naive in the extreme to pretend these judgements don't have to be made in a world without infinite resources. Yes, they are unpleasant to think about. But pretending to be outraged and that there is some other alternative is ridiculous.

Lockdownbear · 23/01/2022 00:35

@SquidMonkey
Exactly it's very difficult to make things 'fair' even if you can define 'fair'.

Two couples both retired both own their own house.

Couple A, the woman never worked outside the house since she married. The man big earner retired at 55, excluding an afternoon a week.

Couple B Woman returned to work when LO started school, relying on family help for childcare, both of them then worked to state retirement 60 & 65. Both with small company pension but need state pension to make ends meet.

I should they both get pension or just one couple, and where do you draw the line?

monfuseds · 23/01/2022 00:34

& intergenerational inequality.

monfuseds · 23/01/2022 00:34

It has to do with wealth though

echt · 23/01/2022 00:34

@monfuseds

There really really aren't shitloads of OAPs rolling in cash.

"Average wealth varied most by age, with median total wealth amongst respondents aged in their early 60s almost nine times as high as those aged in their early 30s."
"Home ownership and preparations for retirement play significant roles in this divide, with median property wealth rising across all age groups and pension wealth peaking as individuals approach State Pension age."
"Today's younger generations are less likely to own their own home than their predecessorss_. This is noteworthy since living in a rented home was associated with lower wealth than mortgaged homes when controlling for age and other factors"

That was not the question posed by londonmummy, and has nothing to do with pensions.
SquidMonkey · 23/01/2022 00:33

@whatkatydid2013

If you moved NI out of been a separate charge & handled it with tax (applying the same thresholds) then the people with the smallest earnings (including pensioners on really low incomes) would see no change or a decrease in tax overall and those with largest unearned/pension incomes would see the biggest change. You could put in plans now to make changes over next 20-30 years to slowly move away from ring fenced NI to give people a chance to plan for it
It isn't ringfenced!
monfuseds · 23/01/2022 00:33

@Fr0thandBubble the truly rich don't always pay their fair share though.

"Using anonymised data from personal tax returns, we show that in 2015-16 the average rate of tax paid by people who received one million pounds in taxable income and gains was just 35 per cent: the same as someone earning £100,000. But one in four of these paid 45 per cent – close to the top rate – whilst another quarter paid less than 30 per cent overall. One in ten paid just 11 per cent—the same as someone earning £15,000. The rich, it seems, are not all in it together."

echt · 23/01/2022 00:32

[quote Fr0thandBubble]@Tealightsandd Oh come on! The rich are the ones paying for it all! The problem is that there are too many people taking more from the pot than they put in! Exactly how much more do you want the rich to pay? Because at a 45% tax rate (plus NI, SDLT, VAT and council tax), I certainly feel like I do my bit - and then some.[/quote]
Any real evidence for that?

SquidMonkey · 23/01/2022 00:31

@whatkatydid2013

I believe some research claimed moving child benefit to being means tested would cost more in admin of more people doing tax returns, checks to ensure people hadn’t claimed when they shouldn’t have etc than it would gain. I’ve seen same on winter fuel allowance. It’s likely true for some benefits that are small & less so for those that are significant.
Yes. Subsequent studies showed doing that to child benefit did in fact cost the state more than just paying it universally. They have to process all of the additional tax returns, take enforcement action to recoup wrongful payments etc etc. That money would have been better spent on children than extra Civil Service paperwork.
monfuseds · 23/01/2022 00:30

There really really aren't shitloads of OAPs rolling in cash.

"Average wealth varied most by age, with median total wealth amongst respondents aged in their early 60s almost nine times as high as those aged in their early 30s."
"Home ownership and preparations for retirement play significant roles in this divide, with median property wealth rising across all age groups and pension wealth peaking as individuals approach State Pension age."
"Today's younger generations are less likely to own their own home than their predecessorss_. This is noteworthy since living in a rented home was associated with lower wealth than mortgaged homes when controlling for age and other factors"

Fr0thandBubble · 23/01/2022 00:29

@Tealightsandd Oh come on! The rich are the ones paying for it all! The problem is that there are too many people taking more from the pot than they put in! Exactly how much more do you want the rich to pay? Because at a 45% tax rate (plus NI, SDLT, VAT and council tax), I certainly feel like I do my bit - and then some.

SquidMonkey · 23/01/2022 00:29

Yes, I think a young person’s life is more important than an 89 year old’s. We can’t afford pension payments and health and social care for the elderly at projected rates without it seriously impacting what the state is able to provide for children and the young - which is where I think it should be focused.

I totally agree. And I know my children's grandparents do as well.

SquidMonkey · 23/01/2022 00:28

@monfuseds

I think we should just move NI into income tax so people don’t have this misconception it’s some sort of fund.

good point, I didn't realise so many see it as a personal pot.

Politicians don't want to do this because they would have to stop the discrimination in terms of tax in favour of business owners/ self-employed people, and then also the general population might realise how much tax they actually pay. It is all the same, so the basic tax rate is 32%. People wouldn't like to hear this, it's not a vote winner. Successive Governments of all stripes have promised to overhaul and simplify the tax system and then realised that whatever they did towards that would obviously disadvantage some people and make them angry so the project has been abandoned again and again. Every single Government makes the tax code longer and more complex, not shorter. Yet again it's political expediency winning out over good governance, logic and any kind of long-term vision.
monfuseds · 23/01/2022 00:25

@mellicauli but in the 90s the deficit wasn't so high & birth rates were never predicted to get this low. They can make any change they like.

Crankley · 23/01/2022 00:24

I worked non stop for 45 years and am entitled to receive my pension.

As for many people are living too long you can fuck right off. Tell me that when you're in your 70s. So ignorant.

FruitMelange · 23/01/2022 00:24

Why the hell should I live this kind of life flogging myself to death only to fund other people who don’t make these sacrifices?

Well don't then. Spend more time with your wife and children. Money alone can't make you happy.

monfuseds · 23/01/2022 00:24

Too many jobs are undervalued and underpaid.

yep & it's a vicious circle with many people themselves don't want to pay the "correct" price for goods or services.

People complain about Amazon but don't stop using them.

SquidMonkey · 23/01/2022 00:23

@whatkatydid2013

I know people get really shirty about idea of pensioners losing out but the government just introduced an additional 1.25% for employers & employees NI to help fund health & social care. Imagine these households

Household 1 is a single pensioner who rents a council flat with state plus small private pension. Their current income is ~ £10k/year

Household 2 is a single pensioner who owns their own 4 bed detached home outright & has savings amounting to ~£150k. Their overall pension is £40k/year but net income is more like £34.5k accounting for tax.

Household three is a single parent working 25 hours/week on minimum wage. They rent a 2 bed terrace for £600/month for themselves & 2 children. Income is ~12.5k/year but net income with universal credit/pension contributions/child benefit is around £25k

Household 4 are a couple with two children who earn around £90k between them. They own a 5 bedroom terrace with a mortgage and have ~£70k of savings. Their mortgage is £1,300/month. Their net income including child benefit less private pension contributions is ~£64k/year

If you had to pick out which two of these households ought to start paying a bit more towards health and social care which ones does it seem fairest to tax more?

It isn't that simple in reality though, is it?

How about the elderly couple who own their house outright but have no private pension?

What about the renter with no assets but some private pension income?

A couple who rent and have a £50k income between them but spend 50% of their net income on rent and are struggling?

A single mother who earns £101k but therefore gets no help with childcare costs of £2.5k per month and has commuting costs and housing costs of another £2.5k per month?

How would you actually define the criteria to make it "fair". It can't be done.

mellicauli · 23/01/2022 00:23

@monfuseds

Do people think today's 20 & 30 yrs old will receive a state pension? The way things are going I don't even see the NHS existing in its current form in the next 5 yrs.
This is what everyone said when I started work in the early 90s. But 30 years later, I can't see how they can make this change. (We also paid 25% basic tax rate back.)
monfuseds · 23/01/2022 00:21

I think that's a bit simplistic, our population is growing because people are living longer. That's not a reason to take up smoking though.

Lockdownbear · 23/01/2022 00:21

The money's there somewhere

But where?

Big companies rather than small buisness or individuals.

We need better paying jobs that come with manufacturing. Currently to get a well paid job people either seem to need a degree or have a construction trade. Too many jobs are undervalued and underpaid.

Tealightsandd · 23/01/2022 00:17

The point is that over the past 30 years, many people have been persuaded or coerced into giving up smoking. Told to do so 'because it shortens your life'. So what happens when they give it up and don't die younger? They face a barrage of 'old people are living too long'...