Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Means testing State Pension

731 replies

CuriousMariette · 22/01/2022 18:25

Do you think the time has come for this to be introduced? I don’t think the current system is sustainable as many people are living too long. I know it’s not fair and would be political suicide but Pensioner’s didn’t even suffer a 80% furlough during lockdowns. I say this from a place of having “paid in” as people say for 30 years plus already and would likely not receive a State Pension in this scenario.

OP posts:
monfuseds · 23/01/2022 01:00

The social care levy; that's what it's for.

You think that will touch the sides? 😆

Tealightsandd · 23/01/2022 00:59

There are finite resources. We can't have everything.

So why not let people smoke without massive crusade against it. Plus, legalise (and tax) all drugs. It's not as if living a long life is prized. Why not give people the option to exercise their personal responsibility and freedom and individual risk assessments (as they've been told to do for Covid) - to choose whichever source of pleasure or comfort they prefer during their (shorter) life?

echt · 23/01/2022 00:58

And of course it wouldn't be popular but there is a huge social care crisis so again where do people think the money is going to come from

The social care levy; that's what it's for.

Blossomtoes · 23/01/2022 00:58

@monfuseds

It’s not logical, people can’t sell their home while they’re still living it.

of course. they would put a charge on it reclaimed after death.

And of course it wouldn't be popular but there is a huge social care crisis so again where do people think the money is going to come from?

Given the reception it was given in 2017 I can’t see it happening any time soon. It certainly won’t happen under a Tory government.
monfuseds · 23/01/2022 00:56

They've paid their share.

The point is it doesn't matter if there isn't any money

Fr0thandBubble · 23/01/2022 00:55

@SquidMonkey

Oof unconscious bias right there *@FruitMelange*. I’m a woman. And I work this hard to provide for my children, one of whom needs additional support because he has ASD.

Sorry @Fr0thandBubble I didn't see you'd already responded to that post just dripping with misogyny. It's pathetic isn't it, how so many people still assume that only a man can earn a good salary. 🙄😆

Yes it’s depressing!
monfuseds · 23/01/2022 00:55

It’s not logical, people can’t sell their home while they’re still living it.

of course. they would put a charge on it reclaimed after death.

And of course it wouldn't be popular but there is a huge social care crisis so again where do people think the money is going to come from?

Blossomtoes · 23/01/2022 00:52

@monfuseds

I also expect care in the home will move to a similar model for care out of the home (since most don't end up in care homes) with house value being included in the means testing.
That proposal helped lose May lose the 2017 general election. It’s not logical, people can’t sell their home while they’re still living it. It’s absolutely right to take it into account for residential care because it’s no longer needed.
Tealightsandd · 23/01/2022 00:51

@monfuseds

I also expect care in the home will move to a similar model for care out of the home (since most don't end up in care homes) with house value being included in the means testing.
Care for who? The Long Covid disabled? There will be fewer older people in the future because of increasing ill health. Long Covid, plus poverty.

But also, perhaps some people will decide to keep on smoking - rather than live longer to become one of the "financial burdens".

The majority of the current generation of pensioners left school at 16 to start working and paying into the system. No university. 50 years of income tax. Add in VAT. They've paid their share.

SquidMonkey · 23/01/2022 00:50

Oof unconscious bias right there @FruitMelange. I’m a woman. And I work this hard to provide for my children, one of whom needs additional support because he has ASD.

Sorry @Fr0thandBubble I didn't see you'd already responded to that post just dripping with misogyny. It's pathetic isn't it, how so many people still assume that only a man can earn a good salary. 🙄😆

FruitMelange · 23/01/2022 00:49

So basically many of those taxpayers paying for the current pensioners pensions won’t get pensions themselves or will get them much later than those that they have paid for. That’s pretty unfair

I started work in 1969 with the promise that I would have a state pension at 60. Now it's been put back till I'm 66
It's a huge blow to my financial plans. I now don't have the money I was promised so I'm stuffed. It's not just a young person thing.

echt · 23/01/2022 00:49

@monfuseds

As I'm sure you know, people can be asset-rich and money poor, so their wealth is theoretical for the purposes of discussing pensions, which is what this thread is about.

of course but far better to be asset rich & money poor then asset poor & money poor as at least you have options with the former.

The thread is about whether the current state pension system is sustainable & should be means tested or not. I don't know what the answer is but don't think it's crazy to take into account assets when means testing.

I'm not arguing about which is the the better position, it's, as they say here, bleeding obvious.

They assets test for the state pension in Australia (where I am) , though the home is not part of it. That's why I don't get the pension: income. It's also why my friend, who sold her home, downsizing to free up some money, had her state pension reduced.

monfuseds · 23/01/2022 00:48

argue with you!

monfuseds · 23/01/2022 00:48

@Tealightsandd I don't think anyone would agree with you that the state pension is crap.

Tealightsandd · 23/01/2022 00:47

Work until you drop is coming back rapidly to the UK. Rewind 150 years progress.

www.express.co.uk/finance/personalfinance/1548684/state-pension-age-increase-retirement-uk

monfuseds · 23/01/2022 00:47

I also expect care in the home will move to a similar model for care out of the home (since most don't end up in care homes) with house value being included in the means testing.

SquidMonkey · 23/01/2022 00:45

@FruitMelange

Why the hell should I live this kind of life flogging myself to death only to fund other people who don’t make these sacrifices?

Well don't then. Spend more time with your wife and children. Money alone can't make you happy.

Jesus. Why the assumption that the poster is either a man or a lesbian? Did they say that??
monfuseds · 23/01/2022 00:44

As I'm sure you know, people can be asset-rich and money poor, so their wealth is theoretical for the purposes of discussing pensions, which is what this thread is about.

of course but far better to be asset rich & money poor then asset poor & money poor as at least you have options with the former.

The thread is about whether the current state pension system is sustainable & should be means tested or not. I don't know what the answer is but don't think it's crazy to take into account assets when means testing.

echt · 23/01/2022 00:43

But they don’t. If they’ve got a six figure income, they’re paying 40% tax on most of it

Londonmummy was making a proposal about NI being levied on high earning OAPs, not income tax. I pointed out that this would lead 8 million OAPS not paying. So the levy, whether right or not, would not generate a lot of money.

Swonderful · 23/01/2022 00:41

This would hit women the hardest because presumably it would be means tested by household. That means women missing out if their husbands are wealthy.

Women are already massively disadvantaged in terms of pension wealth. The average women has a much lower private pension than the average man.

echt · 23/01/2022 00:40

@monfuseds

It has to do with wealth though
Yes, but londonmummy's specific proposal was about NI and higher-earning pensioners. Hooking my comment, which was about the 8 million pensioners who don't qualify for tax is beside the point.

As I'm sure you know, people can be asset-rich and money poor, so their wealth is theoretical for the purposes of discussing pensions, which is what this thread is about.

Blossomtoes · 23/01/2022 00:39

[quote londonmummy1966]@echt - yes but only the levy - I think that they could pay a surcharge/levy equal to NIC not just the extra 1.25%. It is crazy that my DPs have six figure pension income and pay less than many struggling families.[/quote]
But they don’t. If they’ve got a six figure income, they’re paying 40% tax on most of it.

FruitMelange · 23/01/2022 00:38

As for many people are living too long you can fuck right off. Tell me that when you're in your 70s. So ignorant

My mil is 93 and still drawing her pension. My own parents died in their 60s, and also my recently passed brother was 63. I have several friends pass away (die) in their late 50s, early 60s. A couple of them still working and paying their NI and taxes.

Well, they never got their money's worth, did they?

monfuseds · 23/01/2022 00:38

Politicians don't want to do this because they would have to stop the discrimination in terms of tax in favour of business owners/ self-employed people, and then also the general population might realise how much tax they actually pay

yes

Swipe left for the next trending thread