Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Means testing State Pension

731 replies

CuriousMariette · 22/01/2022 18:25

Do you think the time has come for this to be introduced? I don’t think the current system is sustainable as many people are living too long. I know it’s not fair and would be political suicide but Pensioner’s didn’t even suffer a 80% furlough during lockdowns. I say this from a place of having “paid in” as people say for 30 years plus already and would likely not receive a State Pension in this scenario.

OP posts:
SJFarter · 23/01/2022 11:19

@Soontobe60

In a round about way, it already is means tested! My earnings are double that of my dh, and as a result my National Insurance contributions, on which my state pension is based, is also double his. Yet we will receive the same state pension. I have also paid into a private pension, so will not need to claim further benefits in retirement.
It's also already means tested in that those who have made private provision pay tax on their state pension. So, someone who has 12.5k a year private pension income, plus the state pension will be giving 20% of their state pension back in tax. Someone on the state pension plus benefits (pensioners are entitled to housing benefit, for example) won't be paying any tax.
Soontobe60 · 23/01/2022 11:14

In a round about way, it already is means tested! My earnings are double that of my dh, and as a result my National Insurance contributions, on which my state pension is based, is also double his. Yet we will receive the same state pension. I have also paid into a private pension, so will not need to claim further benefits in retirement.

SJFarter · 23/01/2022 11:04

@CityMumma78

No!!! Those that have contributed have as much right (if not more) to the pension pot! Those that don’t work still get a state pension. I keep seeing idiotic suggestions on MN where the working MC get penalised for owning their homes and working!! Madness.
Yep and these suggestions come from people who are already consuming more than they are paying for. They are already being heavily subsidised by others, although this is something they don't seem to grasp. A poster on minimum wage claimed that she was paying for others to be on furlough. This poster is a single parent and claims various tax credits, child benefit etc which offsets the small amount she contributes in IT and NI. As a higher earner, I have no issue with contributing to others but I think that those who are being heavily subsidised should be educated on how much they are already getting before they shout for more.
SJFarter · 23/01/2022 10:59

@DontBlameMe79

I would means test it. Other countries do and pensions still take up much of the budget. The money will be needed for NHS, which I think will end up constituting the bulk of Govt expenditure in the longer term. In general EVERYTHING should be means tested.
But then the people who pay in (net contributors) will vote for the lower tax / low public services parties. Why should they pay into a system that they get nothing from? I would expect to be paying a much lower level of income tax if I had to fund my own pension, healthcare etc. Means testing the few things that net contributors get would end up with a US style system where individuals pay privately for services and get what they can afford. That would mean lower earners also only getting what they could afford to pay for privately too.
HollowTalk · 23/01/2022 10:58

@whatkatydid2013

I think what would be better is to rework national insurance/tax and slowly make NI lower/increase tax so that unearned income (whether belonging to pensioners or others) eventually attracts same tax as earned income.
I don't know what you mean here. National insurance isn't paid by state pensioners but the normal tax rate applies.
DontBlameMe79 · 23/01/2022 10:52

I would means test it. Other countries do and pensions still take up much of the budget. The money will be needed for NHS, which I think will end up constituting the bulk of Govt expenditure in the longer term. In general EVERYTHING should be means tested.

Loopyloulou007 · 23/01/2022 10:32

I honestly believe by the time our current primary school children become working age, it won't be within reach of claiming. They are already extending the age to claim it, that will again be extended and then extended, so will probably have to work until they are 80. On top of that Uni fees if they are fortunate to go, will increase, increase and increase through time, so will be so in debt, throughout their life, the stress that Debt brings, also makes you age. I see it, that everyone pays in, yet at this current time, the workers are having to pay in their tax & NI contribution and pension contribution and an extra thrown in on both council tax and NI, increasing shortly. So in reality a double tax to top up the social care that currently doesn't cover what the people have already paid in. Which is only going to be increasing year on year. So what will it be like in the future. People dying before they reach pension age, never actually benefitting from it at all, but paying in for the people before them.

CityMumma78 · 23/01/2022 10:29

No!!! Those that have contributed have as much right (if not more) to the pension pot! Those that don’t work still get a state pension.
I keep seeing idiotic suggestions on MN where the working MC get penalised for owning their homes and working!! Madness.

AutumnAlmanack · 23/01/2022 10:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

sashh · 23/01/2022 07:54

I'm sure they will, they have already done it with disability benefits.

Because I'm disabled I claim ESA, because when I was working I paid into a pension I started to receive it early.

My ESA, which is contribution based, not income based, is reduced by the amount of my pension.

So I paid into a pension, I paid NI and now I'm penalised for doing the 'right' thing.

monfuseds · 23/01/2022 07:54

How many people are currently unemployed?
What I'm really saying is we can train people or but do we have enough people

I'm not sure we do, loads left the care industry & went into retail/delivery work. Why wouldn't you?

Oldsu · 23/01/2022 07:15

@londonmummy1966 I DO pay extra as a working pensioner my state pension is deducted from my tax free allowance so I pay more tax on my wages - no-one on working age benefits tax credits or UC has to pay more tax on their wages as their benefits are tax free, yes (after nearly 51 years of paying it) I no longer pay NI (until the levy kicks in) but I pay far more in tax alone than I did tax and NI combined when I was working age, tax that pays towards the NHS - how much more do you want me to pay?

DockOTheBay · 23/01/2022 06:46

@TheHateIsNotGood

Anything above State Pension is 'means-tested' eg Pension Credits. I say lets really start Means-Testing, not just randomly here and there.

Pensioner Winter Fuel Allowance, Means Test.
Any Pension-aged Benefit. Means Test.
Nothing automatically given because of Age. Means Test.

Any Child-related Benefits. Means Test
Cut off £35k - no entitlement to anything above that
CTS - Means Test. Max 10% Deduction from any Award.

Shall I go on? There's loads more.....

I am sure I read somewhere that for certain benefits it is actually more expensive to make them means tested, due to the admin and workforce required to carry out the means testing process. I think it was the fuel allowance? Because its not as straightforward as "what's your salary?".
DockOTheBay · 23/01/2022 06:40

@echt

I don't know what they can do about it apart from hugely drastic measures such as DNR for anyone over a certain age

And that age would be? if you're up for putting forward such a disgusting scenario you, it would be more honest to put a number on it.

While you're there, why not DNR those with terminal illnesses? There doing fuck all.

Hmm

I'm not up for it, obviously Hmm. Thats why I'm calling it "hugely drastic measures". I don't know what they can or will do about it - do you? But they will have to do something.
SquidMonkey · 23/01/2022 02:45

Mods must be asleep @FruitMelange but I am sure they'll fix it tomorrow.

SquidMonkey · 23/01/2022 02:41

@FruitMelange

Yus, now struggling to get it deleted🙄
Lol! 😂
SquidMonkey · 23/01/2022 02:40

You can be damn sure if you're buying a house alone you're still expected to pay 100% stamp duty. And the same VAT on all the goods you buy as well. You get a measly 25% Council Tax discount. Wow. That will make up for supporting a household financially and doing all childcare etc alone. Not!?

I really can't believe a poster has come on here pretending that the idea of assessing individually not by household is detrimental to women when it's so obviously the case that the opposite is true and this is one of the main causes of poverty for women and children who've been treated appallingly by men.

FruitMelange · 23/01/2022 02:39

Yus, now struggling to get it deleted🙄

SquidMonkey · 23/01/2022 02:36

@FruitMelange

Hi. Just wanted to share. My daughter married at 35, now 38 and still not pregnant. She is really gutted. Just sharing
Sorry to hear this but presume this was not the thread you meant to post on?
SquidMonkey · 23/01/2022 02:33

@Swonderful

This would hit women the hardest because presumably it would be means tested by household. That means women missing out if their husbands are wealthy.

Women are already massively disadvantaged in terms of pension wealth. The average women has a much lower private pension than the average man.

Lol! This is ab absolutely ridiculous post.

90% of single parents are women.

60% of the children who grow up in poverty grow up in those households.

Setting tax/ benefit thresholds per person rather than per household directly causes a large amount of that poverty.

Why should a couple with kids, two people to work and share childcare, get to earn £25k tax free when a single parent (almost always the mother) can earn only £12.5k tax free?

Why can a couple each earning £49k and having two people to share childcare get child benefit and a single mother on £60k gets none?

Same thing with 30 hrs funding, tax free childcare etc. Single mothers are both villified and discriminated against financially at every turn by the fact that the tax system doesn't set allowances by household, but "per adult", and women and children suffer immensely as a result.

If the price of rectifying that is that some women who haven't bothered to build their own career and financial security but have a wealthy husband funding them feel hard done by then I'll go and try to find the tiniest violin in the world. Honestly, are you for real??

nokidshere · 23/01/2022 02:29

Then you'd get all the Mumsnet posters in 20+yrs time moaning that 'my pension is means tested and it's not fair because other generations got it anyway' 🙄

No, it should be universal. But perhaps pensioners should continue to pay pay national insurance (or some other sort of tax). pension is taxed already.

FruitMelange · 23/01/2022 02:24

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

SquidMonkey · 23/01/2022 02:17

I'm not sure what you thought was patronising but sorry it seemed that way.

SquidMonkey · 23/01/2022 02:16

Nah sorry, I am not going to spend ages searching for it.

echt · 23/01/2022 02:13

@SquidMonkey

Sorry I am on the app so not going to be able to find something on a specific page. If you want to post it again I will watch it if you think it actually moves the discussion forward in a useful way.
Your sentence was good. Your second pissed me off; fucking patronising.

Just keep scrolling back, it's the only video posted.

Swipe left for the next trending thread