Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Means testing State Pension

731 replies

CuriousMariette · 22/01/2022 18:25

Do you think the time has come for this to be introduced? I don’t think the current system is sustainable as many people are living too long. I know it’s not fair and would be political suicide but Pensioner’s didn’t even suffer a 80% furlough during lockdowns. I say this from a place of having “paid in” as people say for 30 years plus already and would likely not receive a State Pension in this scenario.

OP posts:
VanCleefArpels · 23/01/2022 12:42

Yes I think it should be means tested - my parents gave private pension income that puts them in the top tax bracket. They do not need the state pension and they joke about what fripperies they will spend it on. On the other hand there are so many pensioners who are scraping an existence as the state pension is their only source of income

ancientgran · 23/01/2022 12:40

@monfuseds

We will soon be back to 70s inflation and a whole new generation will find out what fun we had back then.

You're ignoring that current generations have the fun of soaring housing costs & wage stagnation.

And you think we didn't have that in the 70s? The 70s house prices did soar, they will seem low to you but have a look at what people were earning and what a 15% interest rate on your mortgage looked like. We also had 35% income tax rate as previously mentioned.

You can't pick and choose the bits that fit your story, either look at the whole picture or don't reference it. We didn't have free nursery places either so it was really hard to work and actually generate an income if you had young children. People now budget for a couple of expensive child care years between the end of maternity leave and 3, we didn't get any free educational places until a child was 5 or almost 5, varied by LA but where I lived you got a place at school for the term after the 5th birthday so some children missed a whole year at school.

The first maternity leave legislation in the UK was introduced in 1975, SMP wasn't introduced until 1987. When I had my first two children it was just accepted that when you lost your job when you had a baby, they might have you back but unemployment was so high that the chances of them keeping a job open for you was small for most women and of course women didn't have equal pay. In my first job I worked in an office of 12 people, six men and six women and the men all earned double what the women did.

Also look at unemployment rates.

Are things the same? No. Is everything better? No. Is everything harder? No.

woodhill · 23/01/2022 12:31

Yep mil made sure she paid extra NI to qualify for her own pension which she received at 60. She never worked full time after having dc anyway but still

Lockdownbear · 23/01/2022 12:29

Go back further and you have women who paid the 'wee stamp' who'd only get a pension based on their husbands contributions.
Verses women who paid the 'big stamp' so they'd get a pension in their own right.

I think they were officially known as A&B but still it's a contributions based on thinking you'd get something out the system later.

Lockdownbear · 23/01/2022 12:23

Can I also add the various tax NI changes over the years SERPs paying extra in to get more out.
Opting Out reducing NI to divert into a private pension. Many private pensions were under funded and the government decided opting out was a bad idea.

You cannot move the goal posts for people who've paid in.

woodhill · 23/01/2022 12:22

Remember SERPS in the 80s

It's always been implied you are paying in NI contributions to receive a pension even if it a total lie

Therefore I would like my pension at age 67

woodhill · 23/01/2022 12:20

@GoldenBlue

Yes, and I have been asked if I want to make extra contributions in the past.

Plus I remember in the early 00s that the stamp wouldn't be paid once my youngest dc was 6 so a good reason to work

I get frustrated about the people who don't seem to work at all and pay any NI in the first place unless they are disabled. Do they receive a pension

whywouldntyou · 23/01/2022 12:15

Piss off. By the time I retire I will have worked for over 50 years. When I started work (aged 16) you weren't allowed to put into a pension until you were 25, by which time I was married with a mortgage and interest rates were 18%. I have fucking earned my pension and despite me now having a private one it will be nowhere near enough to live on. Also I used to work for the NHS. A few years ago I got a letter saying basically 'we don't want you to have a pension with us anymore, here's your money' - no asking me, just a cheque. That was weird, but true.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 23/01/2022 12:09

@monfuseds

You have to have 35 years of national insurance contributions for full state pension, that is qualification enough.

Young people who are looking at a state pension age of 68 (despite unlikely to live longer) will end up paying far more than 35 years.

It's a minimum. I have 11 years the go and already have 40 year's worth of payments in. DH is in a very similar position. As is almost everyone I know.

It isn't just the current young generation that will have put in many more years than the minimum required.

CrazyCatLover · 23/01/2022 12:08

Nope. I’ve paid a lot of NI throughout my working life so far so why shouldn’t I get some of it back when my time comes?

monfuseds · 23/01/2022 12:07

We will soon be back to 70s inflation and a whole new generation will find out what fun we had back then.

You're ignoring that current generations have the fun of soaring housing costs & wage stagnation.

ThreeFeetTall · 23/01/2022 12:06

@AuntyBumBum
Yes you're right it's not means testing but taxing people (the state collecting the money afterwards) is pretty similar to means testing which is the state keeping the money back from being paid in the first place?

LibrariesGiveUsPower · 23/01/2022 12:06

No way.

I don’t begrudge the rich or very getting a whopping £9000 a year state pension. If they are entitled to it they’ve paid their taxes.

Or would you rather push the richest earners even more towards tax evasion?

monfuseds · 23/01/2022 12:05

The state pension isn't a benefit, like the other things you mentioned. People pay for their future pension, it is delayed pay in effect.

That's really not how it works. Today we are paying for those above us, when we are pensioners those working will be paying for us. Hence why with an ageing population the model isn't sustainable.

Do you think people who die before retirement get a refund?

ancientgran · 23/01/2022 12:00

@SquidMonkey

You can be damn sure if you're buying a house alone you're still expected to pay 100% stamp duty. And the same VAT on all the goods you buy as well. You get a measly 25% Council Tax discount. Wow. That will make up for supporting a household financially and doing all childcare etc alone. Not!?

I really can't believe a poster has come on here pretending that the idea of assessing individually not by household is detrimental to women when it's so obviously the case that the opposite is true and this is one of the main causes of poverty for women and children who've been treated appallingly by men.

Well Margaret Thatcher attempted to address that with the poll tax and look where that got her. At the time I had an elderly couple as neighbours on one side, he was chronically ill and she had been his carer for years. On the otherside I had neighbours who both worked and had 3 adult working children still living at home. They paid the same rates (council tax) and I never understood why it was apparently so dreadful that each adult was supposed to pay their share. My sister was a lone parent living just round the corner with two young children, I honestly can't remember if she got a single person reduction back then.

We were two adults so we probably didn't gain or lose on the deal but those two households did demonstrate the unfairness.

anniegun · 23/01/2022 11:59

@BigYellowHat

No way. I’m not paying in for 30 plus years just so all the lazy cheapskates who can’t be bothered to work get my contributions. If I’ve paid in, I’m having it thanks very much. And before anyone accuses me of it, yes I’m a Tory voting Daily Mail reader.
You have not paid in. There is no state pension fund. You will be a welfare beneficiary when you get the state pension- just like the rest of us.
GoldenBlue · 23/01/2022 11:59

@DontBlameMe79

Many things are already means tested. Welfare, the dole. I can’t see why pensions and the NHS should be different, especially when we have an unsustainable funding model for both (which everyone agrees is the case). I never hear any solutions for that offered, just “I’ve paid in and deserve to get paid out”. A very selfish approach really.
The state pension isn't a benefit, like the other things you mentioned. People pay for their future pension, it is delayed pay in effect. You can't remove a right that has been paid for without reimbursing the payments.

How would you feel if you paid into a Christmas savings fund and then someone decided you had enough money after all and didn't need the money you had set aside?

Whilst successive uk governments haven't saved our pension contributions they have to honour the commitment.

You could change the rules going forwards but not the historic rights. But I think it runs the risk of reducing pension savings from low snd middle earners.

It is not selfish to want to receive something you have paid for.

It is selfish to expect someone to give up what they have paid for in order to reduce your own taxes.

Lockdownbear · 23/01/2022 11:58

Middle earners don't give a shit about UC how well does that work for those who need it?
Same with disability payments.

Do the same to state pension and you'll be back to the days if your cold inside put a hat on.

OnGoldenPond · 23/01/2022 11:56

No to this. I'm a relatively high earner but the state pension is an integral part of my pension planning and without it I would struggle to pay the bills in retirement. At this stage in my life I would not be able to save enough in a private pension to replace the income. I'm certainly not alone in this.

Private pensions are poor value for money when compared to the state pension as they are invested in private companies which exist primarily to pay out dividends to their shareholders. Far better idea for everyone to pay more tax and NI to invest properly in a state pension for all (and good quality healthcare and education provision for that matter)

If you introduce the principle of means testing to the state pension you can be sure that pretty soon access to it will be limited to only the poorest in society and then will be subsumed into universal credit. We must fight to preserve the principle of a basic state pension that we all earn and which cannot be taken away.

DontBlameMe79 · 23/01/2022 11:54

The big earners who are rich enough to leave the country don’t care about not getting the state pension - they won’t even notice. So no problem with stopping it for them.

Middle earners would pay a bit less tax because fewer people would need the pension if it was means tested. Overall they would be a bit worse off though as they would not get the pension, but that’s necessary to fix the funding problem. This is the Australian system I understand.

The entitlement and lack of economic reality on this thread is quite breathtaking.

ancientgran · 23/01/2022 11:52

@ThreeFeetTall

Haven't read the whole thread but surely it IS means tested as state pension is taxable income?? If you think rich pensioners need to pay more then increase taxes.
Yes we could all go back to the 70s and pay 35% on basic rate income tax, wouldn't that be great. We will soon be back to 70s inflation and a whole new generation will find out what fun we had back then.
Lockdownbear · 23/01/2022 11:46

@DontBlameMe79

Many things are already means tested. Welfare, the dole. I can’t see why pensions and the NHS should be different, especially when we have an unsustainable funding model for both (which everyone agrees is the case). I never hear any solutions for that offered, just “I’ve paid in and deserve to get paid out”. A very selfish approach really.
So what are you going to use to encourage the big earners to stay in the country?

And how are you going to stop the Tory voters raising the pension age again and again?
At the moment the middle earners the people who's votes count have a vested interest in the state pension.
Means test them out they won't give a shit. Lower tax rise the pension age yeah!

AuntyBumBum · 23/01/2022 11:44

@ThreeFeetTall

Haven't read the whole thread but surely it IS means tested as state pension is taxable income?? If you think rich pensioners need to pay more then increase taxes.
I think you haven't understood what means-tested means!
DontBlameMe79 · 23/01/2022 11:34

Many things are already means tested. Welfare, the dole. I can’t see why pensions and the NHS should be different, especially when we have an unsustainable funding model for both (which everyone agrees is the case). I never hear any solutions for that offered, just “I’ve paid in and deserve to get paid out”. A very selfish approach really.

ThreeFeetTall · 23/01/2022 11:22

Haven't read the whole thread but surely it IS means tested as state pension is taxable income??
If you think rich pensioners need to pay more then increase taxes.