Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Means testing State Pension

731 replies

CuriousMariette · 22/01/2022 18:25

Do you think the time has come for this to be introduced? I don’t think the current system is sustainable as many people are living too long. I know it’s not fair and would be political suicide but Pensioner’s didn’t even suffer a 80% furlough during lockdowns. I say this from a place of having “paid in” as people say for 30 years plus already and would likely not receive a State Pension in this scenario.

OP posts:
DontBlameMe79 · 23/01/2022 13:50

@SJFarter

The higher earners will be funding it. That’s why it’s called progressive. Pretty logical.

😂😂😂

And that sums up the problem.
SJFarter · 23/01/2022 13:50

@DontBlameMe79

So you're also arguing for a one party state?

SJFarter · 23/01/2022 13:48

The higher earners will be funding it. That’s why it’s called progressive. Pretty logical.

😂😂😂

DontBlameMe79 · 23/01/2022 13:44

And I’m not saying the higher earners will like it. That’s why it’s called progressive.

irregularegular · 23/01/2022 13:44

It is means tested. Those that get the full state pension pay NI in for 35 years!

That's not means tested. It's the opposite. People who receive it are also more likely to also have other income in retirement.

Blossomtoes · 23/01/2022 13:44

Unless you earn very significantly over the national average salary if you have a family, or have no children and still earn a decent salary, then statistically you are very, very unlikely to be even covering your own expenses

Exactly what I said @SquidMonkey, before you remarked on my bizarre posts that showed I had no grasp of economics. 🤷‍♀️

DontBlameMe79 · 23/01/2022 13:44

@SJFarter

Logic goes out the window.

Given that you have no idea who is going to be finding your new means tested system, I'd agree 😂

The higher earners will be funding it. That’s why it’s called progressive. Pretty logical.
Lockdownbear · 23/01/2022 13:43

Yes there was no right to any money, just not allowed to return to the factory. I guess for it to have been put into legislation so early there must have been mills or something with nursery provision that encouraged / forced women back to work. Grim days
But yes maternity pay / allowance would have been much later.

irregularegular · 23/01/2022 13:42

If the maximum state pension was increased, and the withdrawal rate as you earn was sufficiently low, then I would support it.

irregularegular · 23/01/2022 13:41

I'm not sure. Means testing it would have a massive disincentive effect on people saving for pensions, so might not end up saving much anyway. It is taxed, so in some sense high income pensioners receive less anyway.

SJFarter · 23/01/2022 13:40

We need to be more progressive

By progressive do you mean like the Scandinavian systems?

SJFarter · 23/01/2022 13:38

Logic goes out the window.

Given that you have no idea who is going to be finding your new means tested system, I'd agree 😂

DontBlameMe79 · 23/01/2022 13:37

@Lockdownbear

You really are missing the point, you means test stuff the quality goes down, not up.

The people who vote and pay the heaviest tax will not vote for investment in something they don't benefit from.

Opposite is true. People don’t value what is “free”. Just look at the missed appointment problem in NHS. The UK model has become too entrenched and scaremongering that making reasonable changes will make us the US overnight are symptomatic of the problem - people just don’t think rationally. And it’s all about “I want my contributions back”. We need to be more progressive and direct limited resources where they are most needed and not to middle class welfare. Which is what the state pension is to middle/high income earners.
ancientgran · 23/01/2022 13:35

[quote Lockdownbear]@ancientgran I'll agree with most of what your saying but the first maternity legislation is about 140 years earlier under one of the first factories acts in 1830 something.
It's still illegal to employ a woman in a factory with in 4 weeks of giving birth. I think for other work it's 2 weeks but factories is 4 weeks dating back to 1830 something.[/quote]
Yes they couldn't work but did they have a guarantee of a job or any income? I was talking specifically about maternity leave legislation so we are both right in what we say but we are talking about different things. I can assure you we had no automatic rights to maternity leave, obviously some people will have had contractual rights.

The UK introduced its first maternity leave legislation through the Employment Protection Act 1975, which was extended through further legislation, such as The Employment Act 1980. From here www.striking-women.org/module/workplace-issues-past-and-present/maternity-and-paternity-leave-and-pay

I had a baby in January 1975 and missed out so I remember it well. I had six months off work and then had to find another job. It was very difficult to find work, part time work more so but a manager at my then husband's firm gave me a job where he really needed a fulltimer but I could only manage 30 hrs due to childcare. I'm not sure how we'd had survived without it.

Of course one of the things we did have was a maternity grant, it was £25 and it bought me a pram. A big pram was useful back then as we had no car so a pram that accommodated a baby, a toddler with a basket underneath for your shopping was very useful. Also with a second child I now got family allowance (like child benefit) but you didn't get it for the first child. I think I got under a pound for my 2nd child but it was increased either later that year or the next year and I think that was £1.50.

SJFarter · 23/01/2022 13:33

@DontBlameMe79

SJ - lots of putting words in my mouth there but that’s par for the course with this debate I find. Logic goes out the window. I’d make the means tested pension more generous, just going to fewer people. I’d have the health system higher quality but only free to those who are means tested. The “NHS” model of everything free won’t last and we need to face reality.
And who is paying for this?

It won't be the people who are currently funding the universal system.

Lockdownbear · 23/01/2022 13:33

You really are missing the point, you means test stuff the quality goes down, not up.

The people who vote and pay the heaviest tax will not vote for investment in something they don't benefit from.

SJFarter · 23/01/2022 13:32

[quote Lockdownbear]@SJFarter Well done you managed to put what I was trying to say into something more readable.[/quote]
Those that argue against a universal welfare system should look at the US to see what that means.

Take healthcare and the state pension away from those who contribute enough to pay for their own and others services and we will have our very own Republican Party in a flash, one that most net contributors will vote for. That means low tax, low universal services. Individuals pay privately for what they need and want. If you can't afford to pay privately then tough.

DontBlameMe79 · 23/01/2022 13:29

SJ - lots of putting words in my mouth there but that’s par for the course with this debate I find. Logic goes out the window. I’d make the means tested pension more generous, just going to fewer people. I’d have the health system higher quality but only free to those who are means tested. The “NHS” model of everything free won’t last and we need to face reality.

Lockdownbear · 23/01/2022 13:25

@SJFarter Well done you managed to put what I was trying to say into something more readable.

SJFarter · 23/01/2022 13:21

@DontBlameMe79

Many things are already means tested. Welfare, the dole. I can’t see why pensions and the NHS should be different, especially when we have an unsustainable funding model for both (which everyone agrees is the case). I never hear any solutions for that offered, just “I’ve paid in and deserve to get paid out”. A very selfish approach really.
As other posters have already pointed out to you, middle earners and above don't give a shit about means tested benefits being cut. Did they care about the temporary UC uplift being removed? No because it didn't affect them. Do middle earners care about the state of social housing? Nope because it doesn't affect them.

What you are arguing for is a pittance of a state pension being paid to those who can't afford private pension provision and that pittance not being paid until the age of 80. You also seem to be arguing for a very basic healthcare system for those that can't afford private provision. Who would care about waiting lists. Do you think the middle income voters, who wouldn't be entitled to free healthcare, would care if low earners were waiting 2 years for treatment. Nope, those middle income earners would be retiring in their 60s on a privately funded pension and paying for private healthcare - which they'd be paying for with the tax they'd saved on not funding a universal welfare system.

Lockdownbear · 23/01/2022 13:15

@camperqueen54

It is means tested. Those that get the full state pension pay NI in for 35 years!
Or have NI Credits, you get credits while claiming JSA, MA and if you are SAHP with child under 5. Might be others but those are ones I know about.
camperqueen54 · 23/01/2022 12:52

It is means tested. Those that get the full state pension pay NI in for 35 years!

Lockdownbear · 23/01/2022 12:51

@woodhill

Trouble is the means testing will be ridiculously low as per usual penalising the thrifty low income pensioners with a modest property Confused
Yip, and then people will moan when the MPs who'll be means tested out of it decide to keep raising the age and reduce the increases it gets. Think what your asking for
woodhill · 23/01/2022 12:48

Trouble is the means testing will be ridiculously low as per usual penalising the thrifty low income pensioners with a modest property Confused

Lockdownbear · 23/01/2022 12:47

@ancientgran I'll agree with most of what your saying but the first maternity legislation is about 140 years earlier under one of the first factories acts in 1830 something.
It's still illegal to employ a woman in a factory with in 4 weeks of giving birth. I think for other work it's 2 weeks but factories is 4 weeks dating back to 1830 something.