Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Means testing State Pension

731 replies

CuriousMariette · 22/01/2022 18:25

Do you think the time has come for this to be introduced? I don’t think the current system is sustainable as many people are living too long. I know it’s not fair and would be political suicide but Pensioner’s didn’t even suffer a 80% furlough during lockdowns. I say this from a place of having “paid in” as people say for 30 years plus already and would likely not receive a State Pension in this scenario.

OP posts:
Whatdramain2022 · 23/01/2022 15:10

I get £663 per calendar month state pension and £113 a month work pension. A grand total of £776 a month. If my husband dies before me, likely because he's older, I won't be able to manage. He was self employed so no private pension for me to inherit as we couldn't afford it. It appears that many people think pensioners are well off. We paid our NI in full all our working lives and every day I worry about money.

Dreamstate · 23/01/2022 15:07

If you think about how much you put in over 35yrs for the state pension and what you get back out us a pretty poor return to be honest. Shockingly bad.

MintJulia · 23/01/2022 15:02

@vancleefarpels Agreed. As a net contributor, that doesn't worry me at all. It is how it should be.

However the state pension was created as a separate contract to provide a pension. If the govt no longer wish to enter in to that contract, then they need to say so and change the whole structure of NI and paye for those entering the system now.

These things take decades to change to allow people to plan. Look at the issues faced by some women when the female state pension age was changed too quickly.

VanCleefArpels · 23/01/2022 14:51

The benefits system does not operate like a piggy bank so you get out what you put in. We contribute to a pot to help people who need it because that’s how we choose to run our society (compare eg with USA where there is far less contribution by all to the benefit of the few). There will always be many who are net contributors (put in more than they take out) - quite rightly so as the burden should fall in those with the broadest shoulders. There are many who don’t need the state Pension and many who need more than they currently get.

MintJulia · 23/01/2022 14:51

Yes, I think I opted out and subsequently back in.

If you look at the history of state pensions, it was created as a contract between govt and worker specifically to provide a pension. That is why it is a separate amount and not just part of paye.
Too many people see it as something old people should be grateful for, when in reality they have paid in to it for their whole working lives.

toconclude · 23/01/2022 14:42

@BigYellowHat

No way. I’m not paying in for 30 plus years just so all the lazy cheapskates who can’t be bothered to work get my contributions. If I’ve paid in, I’m having it thanks very much. And before anyone accuses me of it, yes I’m a Tory voting Daily Mail reader.
Quelle surpriseHmm
100Cause0ftheSauce · 23/01/2022 14:41

In the UK there are already criteria to receive a full state pension, which is 35 years of National Insurance contributions. The Government sets the age that you are eligible to receive the state pension & how much you will receive.

You can obtain National Insurance contributions via; working, receiving certain state benefits like child benefit, unemployment benefit, or by paying yourself.

Anyone can log into the Government Gateway & View their
State pension forecast
National Insurance record per year

The current state retirement age is 66
Therefore people have approx 50 working years to contribute into the system or claim benefits

State pension age due to further increase to 67, 68 & beyond

I've paid into the system

Lockdownbear · 23/01/2022 14:38

@Mintjura the government did have an opt out scheme for a while but private pensions aren't as reliable as they should be it also ade calculating pensions difficult as people move employers far more than they used to so people could end up with multiple years when they were opted out / in for part of the year. Hence they decided to scrap that scheme and have everyone opted in.

MintJulia · 23/01/2022 14:36

Means testing things like winter fuel payments and entitlement to bus passes would make sense though. If someone has £1m in private pension, it is hard to see how they need a winter fuel payment.

Dreamstate · 23/01/2022 14:34

@MintJulia

It is important to remember that the state pension is NOT a benefit. Pensioners have paid NI into a pension for at least 35 years (some up to 50 years) and are entitled to their pension. Pension credit and top up benefits are means tested already. If we means test the state pension then pensioners must also be offered the chance to opt out of paying into a state pension at all, paying rather into a private pension pot as the main pension. That would mean for example, that the govt does not get to use 6% of my income for 40 years to spend on other stuff.
100% this. Infact id love it for then to offer me an option in or out. Cos I'd rather opt out and use the % i put in now to fund my own private pension that over time will compound and give me back more than what state pension would!
DontBlameMe79 · 23/01/2022 14:26

Missing the sarcasm

MintJulia · 23/01/2022 14:26

It is important to remember that the state pension is NOT a benefit. Pensioners have paid NI into a pension for at least 35 years (some up to 50 years) and are entitled to their pension.
Pension credit and top up benefits are means tested already.
If we means test the state pension then pensioners must also be offered the chance to opt out of paying into a state pension at all, paying rather into a private pension pot as the main pension.
That would mean for example, that the govt does not get to use 6% of my income for 40 years to spend on other stuff.

SJFarter · 23/01/2022 14:25

@DontBlameMe79

No they are the Shy Tories. The clue is in the name.
Missing the point of what a shy Tory is there.
DontBlameMe79 · 23/01/2022 14:24

No they are the Shy Tories. The clue is in the name.

SJFarter · 23/01/2022 14:22

@DontBlameMe79

Plus the champagne socialists like me who have higher incomes but also high guilt will also vote for it.
Aren't champagne socialists the shy Tories? Vocal about their left wing credentials but vote Tory secretly when they think about how those left wing policies will actually affect them and their families.
SJFarter · 23/01/2022 14:20

@DontBlameMe79

I’ll explain it with a great deal of charm…
Was it Marx or Engels who said that nothing improves for the lower classes until the middle classes are in side?

Are you going to use your charm to convince those that pay in to continue to fund a system they will see nothing from?

DontBlameMe79 · 23/01/2022 14:18

Plus the champagne socialists like me who have higher incomes but also high guilt will also vote for it.

DontBlameMe79 · 23/01/2022 14:17

I’ll explain it with a great deal of charm…

SJFarter · 23/01/2022 14:16

@DontBlameMe79

Below the 51st percentile. They would be in the majority.
How are you going to get them all to vote and vote in the way that you tell them they should?
DontBlameMe79 · 23/01/2022 14:07

Below the 51st percentile. They would be in the majority.

SJFarter · 23/01/2022 14:03

There are a lot more low earners.

How do you define low earners?

DontBlameMe79 · 23/01/2022 14:01

[quote SJFarter]@DontBlameMe79

The problem is that you think that middle and high earners will continue to pay in at the rate they do now. Or are you planning on means testing voting too, so that only low earners are allowed to vote?[/quote]
There are a lot more low earners.

DontBlameMe79 · 23/01/2022 14:00

[quote SJFarter]@DontBlameMe79

So you're also arguing for a one party state?[/quote]
I’m arguing that means testing allows us to direct limited resources where they are most needed. The system now is inefficient as some do not need the state pension. I’m saying direct that money to those with more need.

This is not a radical concept and much of our state expenditure is directed this way. So why not pensions and health? The arguments against this are either selfish or selfish in disguise - ranting that it won’t work/no one will pay blah blah. The vested interests always say that.

SJFarter · 23/01/2022 13:55

@DontBlameMe79

The problem is that you think that middle and high earners will continue to pay in at the rate they do now. Or are you planning on means testing voting too, so that only low earners are allowed to vote?

MummyWoodentop · 23/01/2022 13:54

Taxing people takes money from the wealthy. I'm a pensioner but I pay tax as I also have other income from a btl property. No need to cut pensions.